Message Boards

Topic : 11/14 Sisters at War

Number of Replies: 152
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 10, 2006, 09:18:47 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
You’ve heard the old saying, “Blood is thicker than water.” Dr. Phil’s guests are putting that adage to the test! Colleen says her sister, April, committed the ultimate betrayal by trying to fix up her boyfriend and father of her children with another woman. April says her sibling is no angel, and claims Colleen dragged her out of bed and punched her in the face! After spending time on stage with the women, Dr. Phil sends them home with a special assignment: to watch their bad behavior on tape. Now, one month later, Colleen and April join him in the studio again. Does one sister owe the other an apology, or are they both to blame for their ongoing feud? Will the women find a way to move on and become sisters again, or is this relationship beyond repair? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More November 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
November 14, 2006, 11:52 pm PST

sisters who will never get along, sad but reality

Quote From: ss4real

My mother and her sister have hated each other since, well since they were kids. When they'd walk to school together as kids my aunt would make my mom walk on the other side of the road. She told my mom she wasn't pretty enough, smart enough and good enough to walk on her side. My mom spent half of her life feeling insecure and had to handle a great deal of depression.  Well, my family endured many disappointing holidays because the two of them had to be in the same room together. My brother and I grew up,  with the blame that it was my mom's fault for ruining the holidays again! It finally took my grandfather's passing for me to realize and to see what kind of an abuser my aunt really is. What hatefulness she has in her heart that for some reason we as kids thought it to be our mom's fault. I am guilty that I ever thought for a moment that my mom was embarrassing us, or ruining our holidays. My aunt doesn't call anyone in her family. She hates all the relatives, yet she seems to think that calling me once in awhile is acceptable. I wish I could stick up for my family and give my mother the true respect that she deserves. I say nothing but I think its because I know my aunt is sick.  I see now that 90 % of what my family has had to go through with each other stems from one person. My mom's sister. The good news is that although my mom and dad are divorced, us kids will always have a good relationship with our parents and each other. The cycle has broke so to speak (at least for us). I think its wonderful if family can restore their love for each other but in some cases it isn't so. My grandparents are gone now and my mother finally has a chance at some peace. She will never have to deal with her sister again and this is truly a good thing. After all these years (58 to be exact) she finally has a chance to move forward in her life. I'm 33 years old and it has taken me this long to get here, but I finally see the pain that my mom has gone through in her hole life. I wouldn't wish this kind of pain on my worst enemy. And I hate the fact that my mom was robed of having a "normal" childhood.   My aunt and her family might have all the money and material things today  but my mom has more than her sister will ever know. And for that I feel really sorry for her.

Hi,

Your story was refreshing.  I can relate to it.  However, in my case, it is with my brother.  He was either nice to me at times, or, verbally abusive at times.  Then, he married a woman who was mean to me.  He and I didn't talk for a few years until recently when my mom got sick.    He and I hugged, and, my daughter was able to finally meet him.  I miss him, and, would do anything to get together and try it again with he and his wife, am scared of rejection.  Have any advice? 

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 12:54 am PST

Imature Sibling Rivalry

These two got on my last nerve with all of the pointless bickering.  Everytime Dr. Phil tried to make them aware of how toxic the pettiness was, it just didn't click with them.  The blonde one was especially annoying.  She is a whiny manipulator and tries to get people to side with her by fake crying and saying how much she loves her sister....it made me ill.

 

If they truly loved each other as much as they say they do then they would put the past in the past and quit the pointless bickering.  Dr. Phil was right.....they're more interested in being right than salvaging their relationship. 

 

Personally, I don't think they are going to be able to mend their relationship.  If they do then it will be very short lived.  These two have some major issues to deal with that go way beyond the petty bickering between the two of them.  The even have totally different recollections of their childhood.  I think the blonde sister is narcissistic.  I also think that she is jealous of the other one. 

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 1:51 am PST

Amen!

Quote From: pritytexan

Wow, today's show was just awful.  I could bearly stand watching it.  Colleen and April are the worst two-year-olds I've ever seen!  They're really pathetic.  I don't believe they'll ever have any kind of civil relationship.

 

Today's show was a big waste of my time.  It made me want to scream!

I am so feelin' you on this one. 
 

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 4:29 am PST

I have to agree totally!!

Quote From: pritytexan

Wow, today's show was just awful.  I could bearly stand watching it.  Colleen and April are the worst two-year-olds I've ever seen!  They're really pathetic.  I don't believe they'll ever have any kind of civil relationship.

 

Today's show was a big waste of my time.  It made me want to scream!

Huge waste of my time also.  I hope Dr. Phil understands that there are just some people who don't want his expertise or help.  These two are getting something out of it and they love what it's doing to them.  I don't completely understand, but that's them.  They are who they are and that's it.  End of sentence.  I hope he doesn't continue down this road with these types of shows. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
November 15, 2006, 5:53 am PST

im happy you saved the picture i put it there for you hoping you would save it

Quote From: yvls123

I did try to celibrate Chirstmas at our house for 5 years after our mom passed away but after that I just gave up.  It's only me husband & I here now & we have other things that we're trying to get done.  I tried again 2 years ago to put up a tree & all it did was make me sad.  I don't like the fact that I spend most of Nov. & Dec. depressed so have decided to move on.  There's more to the story but right now at this time I really don't want to talk about it.  Thanksgiving is coming soon as well as Christmas & I'd rather stay happy instead of dwelling on things that upset me.  That is a GREAT pic!  I see what you're saying about it.  Hope you don't mind but I saved it.  Maybe it'll remind me of what you said when I get blue.  Thank you.
i also hope it gives you as much pleasure looking at it as it has given me,and i am also glad to hear you are in good cheers about the holidays,sounds like you already know hoe to brighten the holidays for the ones you love, and thats what counts being happy and at peace with your self, have a great thanksgiving and a merry christmas as well,<>
 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 6:05 am PST

Immature

How can these women watch the tape of themselves and NOT see how immaturely they are behaving. It was the most ridiculous thing I have seen in a long time!  I thought this sort of interaction was reserved for pre-teens.  Geez!  And to think, they are each rearing children of their own!  Nice!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
sad
November 15, 2006, 6:55 am PST

sisters at war

I have a brother whom I have had very little contact with for about 6 years. This brother has caused a lot of problems for my family, especially my parents who both passed away this year. It all started when my parents signed over their house to him with agreements that he was suppose to pay them when he sold his own house. We then put a mobile home on their property that they had turned over to him, for them to live in. My husband and I live next door, so we had it planned that between my brother and I, we could take care of my parents as they were in there late 70's and early 80's. What my brother failed to let any of us know was that when we were at the lawyers and getting this all arranged, he was cheating on his wife with a crack using prostitute, and leading a life style none of us knew about. After about a year of seeing a change in him and knowing something wasn't right, my sister-in-law went to my mother and told her what was going on and that she was getting a divorce. At this point my brother had yet to pay my parents for the house. My mother came to me and wanted to know what she should do. She was worried as to what would happen to them if my brother got a divorce and the judge decided that they had to sell the house in the divorce settlement. So I took my mother to a lawyer and my parents sued my brother to get the house back. Well, when my brother got the papers he went crazy. Then he more or less stopped his life style, became the happy husband and my sister-in-law just forgot about everything and my brother now made it his lifestyle to make my parents life miserable. The court suit dragged on for 2 years. The judge finally ruled that my brother had to pay for the house and that if my parents weren't happy living where they were, they could just move. My parents felt that they were prisoners in there home. Every time they went outside he would harass them. My father had the beginnings of Alzheimer's and didn't really understand what was going on. My brother had my husband arrested by lying about an incident that happened and put a restraining order on him, so then my husband couldn't even go over to see my parents as they were living on his property. I went over to my parents one day to take care of my dad (he was sick from a reaction to a new medicine and could hardly walk)  so my mother could go out for lunch and my brother got on his high horse that day and started to fight with me and then called the cops to have me arrested for trespassing. I had to take my sick father out of his house and bring him to my house. After the judges ruling we sold my parents mobile home and my husband and I moved them in with us. My dad lived with us for 8 months and then we had to put him in a nursing home where he lived for almost 3 years before he passed away March 21st. My mom lived with us that whole time until she passed away in our home on May 29th.I have 2 other brothers and they don't speak to my brother either. I did go over about 2 years ago to his house right before Christmas and apologized to him. We did have very limited contact for a while after that. I really did it for my mom. My brother is also a pathalogical liar and that causes problems in the family also. Just last week, my husband and him encountered each other and shook hands. I suppose it's a step in the right direction, but I just don't know if I can ever have the relationship I had with him before. We were very close. Since my husband and him shook hands, my brother saw my daughter and told her of their encounter and he thinks things are just peachy now. Also the story he told her was not quite the same as what really happened.  I don't know why he has to lie. I just don't trust him. My other sister-in-law calls him a wolf in sheeps clothing. Sorry this is so long. I could go on and on about all of the things that he has done to my family especailly over a 2 year period, but that would take up about 3 pages on the message board!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
November 15, 2006, 7:28 am PST

disappointed in Dr. Phil

Quote From: lflegs

Huge waste of my time also.  I hope Dr. Phil understands that there are just some people who don't want his expertise or help.  These two are getting something out of it and they love what it's doing to them.  I don't completely understand, but that's them.  They are who they are and that's it.  End of sentence.  I hope he doesn't continue down this road with these types of shows. 
WOW! I was very surprised that Dr. Phil allowed them to interrupt HIM. He was extremely tolerable of their behaviors. I actually expected him to eventually say "hey, this is my show and I've had enough of you two not letting me get a word in". I completely agree about not letting other guests appear on the show that act as badly and disrespectful of him as they did. Again...WOW!
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 9:07 am PST

Mirrors

Quote From: atresia

How can these women watch the tape of themselves and NOT see how immaturely they are behaving. It was the most ridiculous thing I have seen in a long time!  I thought this sort of interaction was reserved for pre-teens.  Geez!  And to think, they are each rearing children of their own!  Nice!
The really sad thing is that both of them probably left the show thinking "NOW maybe she will see how immature she is!".  This relationship has two chances: little and none.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 9:11 am PST

Just A Note

Quote From: rubyharris

Hi,

Your story was refreshing.  I can relate to it.  However, in my case, it is with my brother.  He was either nice to me at times, or, verbally abusive at times.  Then, he married a woman who was mean to me.  He and I didn't talk for a few years until recently when my mom got sick.    He and I hugged, and, my daughter was able to finally meet him.  I miss him, and, would do anything to get together and try it again with he and his wife, am scared of rejection.  Have any advice? 

I have only one piece of advice.  Send your message to your brother and ask him to help in the fence mending.  Yoou probably can't do this without his help.  Good luck.
 
First | Prev | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | Next | Last