Message Boards

Topic : 06/04 In-Laws’ Dirty Secrets Exposed

Number of Replies: 336
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 10, 2006, 09:23:21 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/17/06) It's often said that parents find true happiness when their child finds true love. But what happens when a mother suspects that her child may be sleeping with the enemy? Gerri fears that her son-in-law, Alan, is such a danger to her daughter, Melissa, and her grandchildren, that he may kill them. She claims Alan is molesting his 3-year-old daughter, and that Melissa is in denial. Gerri says she had no choice but to call Family Services. Alan and Melissa are outraged by the accusations and say Gerri is out to destroy their marriage. Alan maintains his innocence, and Melissa stands by his side. Could Gerri's guilt as a parent be causing her to make these serious allegations? Alan takes a grueling three-hour lie detector test to prove his innocence. Who will be the one apologizing when Dr. Phil reveals the results? Is Alan a monster or the victim of a malicious mother-in-law? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More June 2007 Show Boards

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:15 pm PST

Everyone Pays

Quote From: afraid

and i must admit its better to report and find out nothing is going on than to not report and something Reilly be happening to the children,and i Reilly don't think her dislike for her daughters husband had much to do with her turning him in, i think it had more to do with her not reporting what happened to her daughter by a family member,maybe she saw the error of her ways and didn't want to make the same mistake two times, however i Reilly do think she has problems only Dr Phil can help her with, it Reilly looked like she was reaching out for help,
I don't get the program until tonight, but I've seen enough from people who have watched it to feel that the mother was probably compounding one mistake with another.  The sad fact is that a number of people will always look at the husband and think he just got away with it.  Many will always judge him as guilty and will not be confused by the facts.  It is a sad situation for all.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:20 pm PST

wacky mother

Quote From: purplepenny

I'm glad that there are people who recognize this. Accusing someone of molestation does effect them for the rest of their lives. It can ruin the relationship with their child and their spouse, it can effect their jobs.

It's ridiculous how easily people want to jump on a band wagon to accuse people.
you know, this is ridiculous. My mother did the very same thing to me. She accused my boys of molesting my daughter. Oh my God!! 2 weeks after she pulled some psycho phone call on me, she called 911 saying she had a hurt leg. Then when the ambulance got there, she wouldn't answer the door. All she said was "in the name of Jesus get away from the door..... well, it ended up she was in the psychiatric ward for 2 weeks. She is a little better but not much and I don't trust her. She was diagnosed with paranoia and schizophrenia. I think she went down hill after my father divorced her. She was also raised by an alcoholic father and I think she was molested herself. I'm just trying to put the pieces together and figure out why she would ever do such a thing. I've seen alot of older women go down hill over some trauma in their life. It upsets me. I know what this couple is going through and I sympathize with them. I don't know what the answer is for these type of mom's.  My relationship with my mom is distant but I do call her and check on her. Just realize there are Mom's out there that need help.   The mother may think she is exactly right in her own mind doing what she did and she needs a different way of thinking. My mother twists things around all the time and looks for an opportunity to start her mischieviousness. All of us sisters have figured her out by now.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:33 pm PST

Gerri is a real piece of work.

She does nothing when her daughter says she was molested.

Later on, she allows her daughter to be alone with the same man.

Today, she's making accusations against an innocent man with absolutely no evidence.

You know who seems like they might "snap and murder someone"?   Gerri.

 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:41 pm PST

She needs to get help, big time.

This was a three hour polygraph test....he passed. Going on what the mother in law herself said, she's a malicious vile woman, imo. Her use of 'buzz words' and phrases makes me think she's watched a LOT of TV shows or read a lot of books on this subject. I think she's a bit psychotic--her affect is so flat and she's so callous. She certainly never said she was sorry for putting that guy through hell. ESPECIALLY when it was second hand information.

Thank you she's not MY mother or my mother in law. Good Lord.

 

K

 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:42 pm PST

11/17 In-Laws’ Dirty Secrets Exposed

Quote From: fluffyfat

She does nothing when her daughter says she was molested.

Later on, she allows her daughter to be alone with the same man.

Today, she's making accusations against an innocent man with absolutely no evidence.

You know who seems like they might "snap and murder someone"?   Gerri.

Oh, YOU KNOW IT! I just said the same thing! She seems psychotic, doesn't she? or heavily medicated. One of the two!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 12:44 pm PST

Gerri needs the help

There is just a crazy look in Gerri's eye! She seems psychotic and determined, like Alan said, to control here daughter. I think that Gerri is mentally ill and needs to seek help. I know that polygraph tests aren't admissable in court in my state, but it's enough for me. If Melissa didn't feel that she was endangering her children by staying with her husband, Mom should let it go!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
November 17, 2006, 12:56 pm PST

What a difference!!

 I watched this father of this little girl and compared him to the father of Kaylee from last week. What a difference in attitude. This man was calm, cool, and confident. Kaylee's dad was angry and yelling trying to cover his butt.  That was sure proof (plus the polygraph) that Kaylee's dad is guilty. Looking forward to hearing more from that episode. As far as this mother, SHE definitly needs the help here!
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 1:01 pm PST

Oh Boy

Quote From: jwiz512

It has been over 5 decades since everything happened. Me and my brothers have suffered so bad for what our parents and family did to us. I am waiting for a 96 year old woman to die to tell what 5 out of 8 of her sons did to us when we were babies and small toddlers. Also what she did to us was almost as bad if not worse. We were rapped by her sons and she beat us and abused us so bad it sent us running to the streets. She is going to be 96 now and with her health and age I am finding it hard to come forward with all that happened. I have recorded my story but I don't know what to do. If I don't tell what happened back then my brother may end up dying in prison waiting for the truth and proof to come out. Yet I know she can't stand in court and it would upset her when he five sons go to jail for rapping us with a weapon. Please someone help me. I have suffered along with my brothers all these years and the abuse never stopped after we left her home. My first husband beat me so bad every day because I was not a virgin when he married me. When I told him what happened and why I didn't bleed when we had sex on our wedding night he never let me live it down and it was the cause of me loosing my children to him because I didn't want the public to know. The beatings from him were so bad and at times he would point a gun at me. I didn't want to have sex and never dreamed when I married him that I would have to take my clothes off. Oh my God this whole thing is such a mess and I need help bad. Please someone help me before my brother dies with this in prison and what they did to us. Our parents and our family destroyed our lives and my brother has been in prison for 37 years. I tried to speak to the Governor but he doesn't have time for people like us who have nothing.
I am ashamed of the responses you have received.  No one has the right to judge you based on this small amount of information.  It shows their ignorance that they can't even see that if you were trying to get on the program, there is direct access to send that to the show.  I wish you the best.  Hang in there and try to remember people love to prejudge others.
 

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 1:10 pm PST

Wizard of Oz

 

What a Wicked Witch.

 

I'm glad Dr. Phil pointed out the error of her ways and why she hadn't said anything to him.  She said something to her daughter, "I'm sorry you aren't in a situation of ..." which is so far to being a left-handed compliment -- to the point of making any reference to her SIL with her daughter she's gone more than three sides around the barn.

 

"Dad" was exceptional in the way he conducted himself, both before and after the lie detector test and didn't jump around and have a victory dance after the results were read.. He wasn't emphatic, as it would have looked suspicious like another "Dad" we saw recently.

 

What the MIL might find herself in is a situation where even her daughter will not look at her for visits. She's already been told is if her daughter has to make a choice, he's first, as it should be.  Grandma or not, I don't know I'd be so forgiving and invite her to stay at a local hotel (at their expense) so she wouldn't be "overrun" with all of the family activities.  I'm guessing he's bigger than I am about that and he'd allow her there but not provoke her.

 

On a good note, we're headed out to celebrate my wife's birthday (it's tomorrow) and we'll be celebrating our 20th anniversary Dec. 10th.  Not bad for only dating six weeks. (I knew I was out of her league and I'd be moving up. There was *no* way I was going to miss a chance. I didn't even have to beg.  My FIL and I were talking a few months ago and we were talking about "family stuff" (my wife is an only child of an only child, so I'm the son they didn't have) and somehow the question was "what will be the last thing I say to either of them on their deathbed?"  "Don't worry, he|she will always be taken care of, not matter what the circumstances are". I dread the day.  But as I said when I hosted their 50th anniversary last year, "some guys end up with a MIL, others a mother, but I've got another Mom (with my other Mom's hearty approval".  (side note:  I wasn't sure what I was going to say when I was waiting for everyone in until I pulled out my calculator and mashed some numbers.  "Today's society places a premium on certain things. When Mom & Dad got married, millionaires were a premium. Today, it's billionaires.  Poets liken people in love as sharing their hearts (and heartbeats). Tonight, we're celebrating two billionaires in our midst.  From my calculations, they've shared their hears for 1 billion, ....Dad, I was unleashed and inflicted  on the world from an abusive household.  I know it's been tough for you at times, but you still remain my model for what a man and a husband are supposed to be. Perhaps without realizing it, you've given me a lot of therapy and I can't imagine a better gift, other than your daughter. Happy Father's Day, Dad." (it was the day before Father's Day).  I had to sit down because I was starting to cry and I'd have to stop talking. I'm a bit steamy typing it right now.

 

Anyway, when it comes to in-laws, it's a two-way street, like all relationships. 

 

p

 

p.s.

 

If someone wants to make use of the material above, be my guest. It's a gift to anyone who can refine it. I was only thinking a couple of words at a time as I spoke. Time & effort should improve it.

 

 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 1:16 pm PST

11/17 In-Laws’ Dirty Secrets Exposed

 I really think Gerri should have been asked to take a polygraph test to determine if she was truely concerned for her grandchild....or if she were just a meddling mom-in-law who cannot stand her daughter being happily married and making false accusations for control / attention.

Watching her on the show really made me doubt her sincerity

 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next | Last