Message Boards

Topic : 03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Number of Replies: 437
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 17, 2006, 12:52:01 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/21/06) Contemporary weddings have turned into five-star productions, with couples pulling out all the stops to shine on their special day. But what happens when the bride- or groom-to-be starts making diva-like demands? Mike and Jamie agreed to a small Vegas wedding, but that went out the window when Jamie switched her gown three times, rented a limo to drive her one block and upgraded her engagement ring. Mike says that Jamie also made him un-invite all of his friends and cancel his bachelor party! Are Jamie’s antics a hint of what’s to come in their marriage? Then, Nastassia complains that her husband-to-be, Richard, is cheap. She says he wants her to buy bridal flowers from the grocery store, have her mom sew her gown and even schedule the wedding before year's end so he can get a tax write-off! Will Richard’s tightwad ways force Nastassia to call off the wedding?  Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More March 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 4:25 pm PDT

Wow, Sad

Quote From: bettyboop1996

Nastassia you do not even look HAPPY on the show.  You look very sad sweatie.  If your not happy now do you think your ever really going to be happy with Richard??  Go with what's in your heart.  If you can't agree on things now, your headed down a LOOOONG road.  You're a very beautiful girl (and a beautiful name, I might add) and surely can find someone who will treat you right and give you what you need (and your big wedding).

 

And $150 for a wedding...WOW.....and did you get your dream wedding?  Are you truly happy with the wedding you got?  We spent $50 on ours and after 10 years of marriage I still miss the wedding I never had.  As Dr. Phil says a REAL wedding & reception costs  an average of $20K.  I think you could do a reasonable wedding between $5-10K.

 

Best wishes Nastassia!  I hope the counseling helps Richard.  If not, things tend to work out the way they're suppose to.  Take Care!

Very true about how sad she looked on the show....
It's been a long time since I've been so shocked by a show. I couldn't believe the reaction from Richard after Dr Phil's offer for conseling. I'm also a little amused by some of the comments I've read from people on this thread. It was very clear to me that the main problem wasn't even the wedding planning. This is just a way for their issues to manifest. From my perspective, he was controlling, manipulative, and self centered. I'm sure they are both "in love", but that doesn't keep a marriage going. I would hope she sticks to her guns and doesn't go through with the wedding until they either get counseling or she finds a better mate!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 5:01 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: jamie7280

 

                            This is Jamie from the show that was showed today.  I just wanted to post something on here and give everyone an update. As you may know the show originally aired in November and I must admit when I read the message boards then I realized how things must have came across because of some of the things posted on here.  First Mike and I were getting married because we were at the time and still are very in love.  I will admit I got carried away in the planning and wanting everything so perfect. I knew I was marrying my prince and I really wanted everything to be beautiful. We never really sat down and negotiated the cost and Mike really did not like wedding planning so yes I took it upon my self and now realize that a lot of that stuff that was purchased was not needed.  As far as the bachelor party goes I did cancel that because I seen clips from the show they were going and maybe I am old fashioned but I really did not want my future husband around a lot of half naked women. This does not mean I do not trust him because I trust him with all my heart and I told him I felt uncomfortable if he went.  I did not care if they had a guys night and went out somewhere else.  I know how things may have came across but Mike and I really get along great and are bestfriends and lovers.  He is a good person and believe it or not I also put others before myself and maybe not at that time.  I think wedding planning is stressful and you can easily get caught up into "Making it your day" . We are doing great and our communication is better than ever and we make decisions "Together" instead of separate.  We are happy and enjoying our marriage.   I know some of you were probably wondering if the couples on the show have split up but I know we are going strong and I believe the other couple are doing great as well.

I'm sorry but the idea that you told Dr. Phil that your husband was a "hindrance to a perfect wedding. "I had a vision. I wanted everything to be right, but he’s cheap,"  is just outragious.  You told him he couldn't go to his bachelor party because you didn't want him around half naked women & is that because it would be humiliating to you?  Imagine how humiliating it is to be called cheap & a "hindrence to your perfect wedding?  On top of that it wasn't your place TO cancel the party.  To ask him not to do it & express how upsetting it is to you I can see but for you to cancel it is controling.  You're not his mother & he's not your child.

 

You had a "low key" Vegas wedding planned & marrying your best friend & lover shouldn't have been "stressful" that's the whole point of having a low key wedding.  Mean while back at the ranch you spent over $6,000. & asked him to uninvite friends?  That's the most self centered thing I've ever heard & certainly mad "your day" anything but perfect.  I'm glad to hear that your communication is much better now & I hop that that communication started with you apologizing for all the pain you cause on a day that was really suppose to be his too. 

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 5:41 pm PDT

I've seen this guy before!

My ex-stepson is so much like Richard that it's scary. They even have the same grin that he

had when Dr. Phil offered them counseling. The difference is that he is already married and

they already have children. In the last 10 or so years, he's broken her nose, beaten her up,

threatened to kill family members and thrown temper tantrums a 2 year old would be proud

of, just to get his way. He does control through intimidation if he can't control through

charisma. He believes he is always right, he has to always be in control and if you don't

do things his way then it's the highway. He seems at times to be bi-polar and refuses to

get help because he's afraid of what people might think. Nastassia, take it from someone

who has seen this type of behavior in the family.......RUN!!!!! You are too sweet, beautiful and

intelligent to be manipulated by a self-centered, egotistical man with an anal-retentive

personality.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 6:18 pm PDT

selfish bride

the first woman that would not "allow" her husband and best friend a bachelor party of their choice, I'm like Wow! Your future husband wasn't going out and hiring prostitutes or something he was going to a public place to watch a show, and enjoy his last night as a bachelor with his buddy. He was celebrating with a close friend an ending and a new beginning.

You got  mad at him for not telling you of the "surprise" honeymoon, because you spent the money on a ,crappy looking, purse. I laughed when I seen you proudly presenting that piece of junk  that you paid "650 dollars!" for.

Maybe I'm being rough but gee the way that poor man was treated I felt so angry that you were so intent on meeting your wants that you were totally oblivious to his needs =(.

just like women men need the support of their family and friends especially when going through something that will change their lives forever. gee .

I do think you really do feel bad about the fiasco, and you know what I feel bad for you too.

I guess just take this as an emotionally expensive learning lesson, and put to use what you learned. For me I think the learning would be "I am not the only one who needs to be considered here".

You said you were going to make it up to your husband and his friend, i believe you will, but for Pete's sake  if you plan something special for them, make sure it is for them not what you think you would like for them to do lol.

A little  saying my mom used to say was BUTS are for sitting on period. LOL good luck with your future =)

 

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 6:34 pm PDT

Nastassia

Yes Dr.Phil had got this one right on the money Hun =(. Thats a tough thing to hear the truth does not always turn out to be what one hopes it will be, but Dr.Phil told you the truth.

when i seen the list of your hopes and wishes being so callously crossed of like that my heart broke.

It brought an image of a little girl dreaming of white fluff and sweetness and being told she will have burlap and lemons =(.

Callous. insensitive, and uncaring, thats the words that came to my mind when I listened to your story and the story of your fiancee.

I don't believe in breaking the bank, but i sure as heck don't believe in breaking hearts either!!!

Every Bride and their family and the groom and their family deserve to make a special day really memorable within their means. It sounded to me like you family was more than willing to put up more that a 350 dollars to make that day special for every one.

but you know what it wasn't really the money that mad me so angry with that young fella it was his cavalier attitude to how breaking your spirit was such a triviality in the face of how much he would save.

Not worth the pain Hun not worth one penny of that 350 dollars!

Take the counseling for yourself and work on your own self worth which cant be estimated by dollars but how you are treated by your "significant" other.

Hopefully you will come to realize that you are worth being treated with respect, dignity, and above all else Love.

Good luck in your future and it is my hopes for you is that if not all your wishes and dreams come true, that the ones that do are so memorable the rest just don't matter =) hugs.

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 6:59 pm PDT

defenisve richard?

Quote From: airassault71

We are still happy together we have finished our counseling and I (Richard) have learned alot through this experience. We did the show 6 months ago and a day has not gone by that I have not continued working to make our relationship better. It is alot better now compared to then. I cant help how they portrayed me this mean, awful, controlling monster that is to cheap for my own good. We do have a wonderful time together I just needed a wake up call to reality that a relationship takes work alot of work. For every bad thing they portrayed theres many other things that I do right and with love. People please stop comparing me to your men in your life because I don't see them telling the world they were wrong and want the chance to make it right. I value our relationship and have made big strides in making us happy as a couple. A relationship takes work more work and then more work and I am working hard on my relationship are you?

why so defensive Richard?

Everything they showed was what you said and even when you watched it on the screen you were aghast. Count your lucky starts young man that the woman you love didn't throw in the tea towel.If I am raising your hackles ask your self why. Accepting the help that Dr.Phil offered you is huge and for that young lady's sake I am thrilled that you choose to try to save something worth saving.

I don't doubt for a minute that you have quality's that are endearing and kind. I don't think Natassia would love a man that is "Bad to the Bone".

However, pointing fingers at people that choose to voice their opinions and attack their relationships is immature. You know what you have a choice take what is useful to you and leave the rest.

I like the Dr.Phil show and even if i don't like all the guests I can be grateful that they choose to speak on his show. I then in turn can be grateful that Dr.Phil has allowed us to make a community were we can discuss our opinions and views, right or wrong, and in turn learn something about ourselves and humanity in general.

I don't really think "you" are as self important as you would like to believe lol. Many people probably post just to present their views, and opinions for the community possibly for feed back or to see how close it is the the moral climate, simple as that young man.

Good luck to you and your wonderful young wife, I wish a happy and content future for both of you . Richard one last thing, I really do appreciate you posting what has become of you and you young wife thank you for posting.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 8:18 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: lynnlea

Very true about how sad she looked on the show....
It's been a long time since I've been so shocked by a show. I couldn't believe the reaction from Richard after Dr Phil's offer for conseling. I'm also a little amused by some of the comments I've read from people on this thread. It was very clear to me that the main problem wasn't even the wedding planning. This is just a way for their issues to manifest. From my perspective, he was controlling, manipulative, and self centered. I'm sure they are both "in love", but that doesn't keep a marriage going. I would hope she sticks to her guns and doesn't go through with the wedding until they either get counseling or she finds a better mate!

I agree with you but you know some times when someone like this gets their grip on someone they're got them so convinced that they're "really trying" & all the while they just keep turning it around to what everyone is doing to them.   "they made me look like a monster on the show, "please ladies don't compare me to the men in your lives" & "I've worked so hard" blah blah blah.  Not one word of how grateful he is that his fiance has stood by him or how lucky it was that is was her that he was engaged to.  Never once on the show did he say he felt bad or didn't really mean it when he gave her ultimatums & then after he did say "it's my way or we're done" he's got the nerve to say he'd lost a bit of respect because she didn't stand up to him?  So no matter *what* she does she's done it wrong.  When Dr. Phil addressed her and asked "This has given you reason for pause"  She wasn't even allowed to finsh speaking without Richard interupting her, because he had to make sure she knows that "he's had reason for pause too" The abuser always paints themselves as the victim.   You're right he's controlling, manipulative, and self centered and these are signs of an abuser............. They always start on breaking the spirit & convincing the victim that they're not worth much, no one else will want them & that them marrying them is this huge sacrifice.  And they NEVER trust their spouse/partner & that's why he was checking emails etc.  I had a BIL just like him & he use to check the mileage and gas gage in my sisters car.  They don't trust because they can't be trusted & think everyone else is just like them.  Notice how he'd come here to "defend" himself even after all this time & yet this poor woman still isn't allowed to speak?  

 

You're right this has nothing to do with the plans for the wedding & the fact that her parents were going to pay for it & I thought it was her father that said they don't have their blessings to marry to me is a HUGE flag that he's at the place where he's starting to tear her away from family & friends.  This is classic for an abuser & he'll start to tell her that they're just trying to break them up & he'll play the victim once again "they just don't like me & they've got it in for me" etc. etc.  & this way when they break away from her in frustration he's then got her isolated from family & friend & now stuck with him & of course he's holding the purse strings because "she's not as good at handling money".   You see she said that "she's paying for the wedding" & he replied "well everything that comes from you comes from us"?  That so that when she comes home with a pay check he can take it for "their" bills & he'll handle it for her & she'll be working & STILL not allowed any of the money.  And as for counseling if you go to any board where there are abused women they'll tell you that these abusers are *masters* at manipulating counslers.   I think in the name of not wanting to humiliat anyone Dr. Phil didn't say it on air but that's why he was so adimant about them not marrying in Dec. & until they've gotten a LOT of counseling, so maybe someone else would see it.  There were 2 other posts that I'd seen from this show today that have seen (I'm sure they'll be many more going back through the posts) & recognize this as abuse & I hope that this fiance reads here & heads these warnings because as hard as it is to get away now it'll be so much harder later on.

 

Run away honey & RUN as fast as you can................ 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 8:51 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: care_bear1st

Honey, I don't know if you will ever see this, but for others that might be in your position, I plead with you.  Do not marry a man who displays this kind of behavior.  If you do no know what narcissist means, please look it up, you can use your computer to get a definition.  I married a young boy when we were both 19, knowing I was making a terrible mistake.  All of my family pleaded with me to break it off, but being 19 and knowing everything, I was going to prove them wrong.  I was way smarter than they were!  Nine years later, I had my first daughter, and I say I because he wasn't involved except for "look what I need" mentality.  When my first daughter was 5 months old, she developed an ear infection which caused her to cry uncontrollably because she was in pain.  I did my best to comfort her, even took her to the downstairs rec room, but HE came bellowing to shut the kid up because he was important and needed to get sleep so that he could perform his duties.  Didn't  learn, though, still too proud.  My second daughter was born in 1991 and things spiralled out of control at that point.  He was the man, he was the breadwinner, he was the most intelligent.  I can still see after being divorced for 2 1/2 years, him pointed to his beloved Professional Engineer license saying "who's the smartest one here, obviously, the one with his name on the wall. "  He used to tell me all the time, I needed him because he was the smart one, he would make sure we had all we needed.  I wasn't allowed to go to the grocery store, Wal-Mart, shopping malls, because I wouldn't be able to make smart decisions about what his family needed. 

 

Nastassia, I've met that man who says he wants to do anything to make you happy before, I met him when I was 18 in 1978 and I can tell you without fear of being wrong, it will be the same story for you.  I just pray to God that if you go through with it, the first time he raises his hand to you and hurts you, you will (a) get out of the house right then; (b) call the police and have him hauled away.  I sure wish that was what I had done 25 years ago. 

 

You're a grown woman, you will do what you want, but please just read what I wrote and think about it first.  I do want you to know you are worth more than what you're settling for.  He ain't that cute!

 

God Bless You, 

 

1CareBear

See THIS is the kinds of posts that probably go ALL the way through that Nastassia really needs to read & listen too.  This is all sooooo classic & it has nothing to do with planning the wedding.  Nastassia's family probably already didn't like him and the planning of the wedding was probably the first thing that was going to drive a or *the* wedge between her & her family.   They wouldn't give their blessing for this marriage & it's because of this behavior that they're seeing.  They're begging her not to make this huge mistake they see & she doesn't.  Love is blind when you're in it.   Listen to your family  
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 9:00 pm PDT

So...what happened

So....did they get married????
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 9:15 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: chainfree

Natassia:  You have more going for you than Richard does.  More marriges are made out of need than want... PLEASE, Sweetie - listen to your heart.  Your "sole mate" is out there, just not today or him.  Richard will try to manipulate ANY help Dr Phil provides.  He TRIED to manipulate Dr Phil and like Dr Phil said - there was more he wanted to say but didn't.  YOU KNOW WHAT DR PHIL WANTED TO SAY!  Richard actually went on the show thinking you were the problem.  The man is a CON!  Let go, Let GOD!  This will only get worse and all Richard can think of is keeping you from "growing"!  Richard actually feels that as long as you both are "getting help", it keeps you from "moving on".  Move on, Sweetie.  PLEASE!

These are the posts that Natassia needs to read & really listen too.  Are these the things your family & friends are saying to you?  Please just listen & get out of there........  Many many people are seeing this because it's very reall & you need to head this warning.   I notice it's always Richard that writes here & so I can only hope you're permitted to read the message boards.
 
First | Prev | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | Next | Last