Message Boards

Topic : 03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Number of Replies: 437
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 17, 2006, 12:52:01 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/21/06) Contemporary weddings have turned into five-star productions, with couples pulling out all the stops to shine on their special day. But what happens when the bride- or groom-to-be starts making diva-like demands? Mike and Jamie agreed to a small Vegas wedding, but that went out the window when Jamie switched her gown three times, rented a limo to drive her one block and upgraded her engagement ring. Mike says that Jamie also made him un-invite all of his friends and cancel his bachelor party! Are Jamie’s antics a hint of what’s to come in their marriage? Then, Nastassia complains that her husband-to-be, Richard, is cheap. She says he wants her to buy bridal flowers from the grocery store, have her mom sew her gown and even schedule the wedding before year's end so he can get a tax write-off! Will Richard’s tightwad ways force Nastassia to call off the wedding?  Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More March 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
December 2, 2006, 6:15 pm PST

Look again

Quote From: fluffyfat

I'm amazed at the amount of Natassia love going on here.  Does looking a little like Angelina make a girl  perfectly wonderful? 

 

I saw a pouting girl who seemed way into herself.  She didn't crack a smile the whole time she was on air , instead she acted like her little wedding problems were the biggest tragedies in the whole wide world.  At no point did she seem willing to compromise any of her desires for someone else.  It had to be her choice, of music, flowers, dress and honeymoon.  If I had once heard her say that she might be willing to give in on one of those points, if she had smiled or said a single word that sounded like she cared about Richard -- then I might be willing to think she was a sweet caring person.  I think she's passive aggressive and very, very selfish.

 

If he's the one in control and she's so innocent ;ask yourself just who it was that called Dr Phil to help her get her way.

Look again at the show, all I saw from Nastassia was a young woman who was sad, beaten down and loving a man she knew wasn't right for her.  She knew it going in, she knew it during the show, and she knew it at the end of the show.  I tape Dr. Phil so that I can go back and watch facial expressions.  Watch the end when Dr. Phil is standing on stage and his guests are in the audience.  Dr. Phil is offering counselling and advice to Nastassia and Richard.  Watch then, Richards' face when this is offered.  Now, tell me that those of us that have been married to "Richard" don't know what we've talking about.

 

1CareBear

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
December 4, 2006, 8:43 am PST

One more time, Bloss

Quote From: thebloss

Okay, I am so happy as hell somebody out there does give a darn about someone else's welfare.  My world has been so small because I am just too overwhelmed with work, mother and wifely duties, there is no relief from it all to actually go out and do something that I want that makes me happy.  So, I really feel better reading these replies on my behalf. As a matter of fact, I actually did something he has always done to me; I went somewhere, didn't tell him where I was, or when I was coming home and it felt GREAT! I had and felt the power then.

 

You did touch on some very key points that I needed to hear from a different point of view.  I really do appreciate you taking the time to reply to me about all of this.  I didn't take offense because I am so ready to hear everything I need to hear to make better of this situation.  I am taking everything into consideration and thinking long and hard about it.  One thing I read that is the truth, is that he did take away my power and I've got to gain it back but I can't keep fighting with him to get it.  Also, you said "you teach people how to treat you" maybe I should start teaching differently? I think my husband should get professional help, but getting him there wouldn't be easy and possibly would never happen.  He doesn't ever want to admit to having a problem, or being wrong (that IS is problem, he thinks he's always right about everything). 

 

I am seeing things in a different light now and am hopeful for a better future.  You are so right about me being naive too.  I have always been that way.  A pushover.  Someone who lets people just walk all over me.

 

My sister in law who has put up with much of the same abuse from one of my husbands brothers, tells me I should stay with him, that it will get better.  She's been married a lot longer than me. 

 

I appreciate your feedback and please, if you feel you would like to reply, by all means, do so.  I really need to hear it.

 

Thanks so much for your concern

Hey Bloss, you don't have to fight with him to regain YOUR power. You want YOUR  power back? Than, just take it. You don't need permission from your husband. Treat yourself, again. Than, do it again and again and again...Feels great, doesn't it? Doesn't feeling great feel good? You are teaching yourself on how to treat you, now. Keep it up.

 

Keep that "light" in focus, my friend, for it can mean for a better future, not just for you but also for your kids. To be naiive, a pushover and allow people to just walk all over you is a matter of CHOICE! There is power in choices.

 

Your husband DOES need professional help! Is he open to it? You want the truth? Heck, I don't have to answer that for you. You already know. I bet you that once he realizes that you mean business about taking care of yourself, he going to try to reel you back in by making promises, and more promises. Idle promises--done in desparation!!! Or, he just might become very, very angry. So, please be cautious.

 

Oh, hell with it. I'm gonna answer that one question: Your husband definitely needs lots of counseling.  You've allowed him to neglect and abuse you for so long, it is going to take a long time for him to make changes. A LONG TIME, GIRL.

 

By the way, are you gonna take your sister-in-law's advice and stay in the marriage? After all, she sure has lots of experience.

 

Hold on to your power. Only you can give it away.      Peace.

 

 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
hopeful
December 4, 2006, 2:07 pm PST

Bloss, She who has ears (so to speak)

Quote From: losinend

Hey Bloss, you don't have to fight with him to regain YOUR power. You want YOUR  power back? Than, just take it. You don't need permission from your husband. Treat yourself, again. Than, do it again and again and again...Feels great, doesn't it? Doesn't feeling great feel good? You are teaching yourself on how to treat you, now. Keep it up.

 

Keep that "light" in focus, my friend, for it can mean for a better future, not just for you but also for your kids. To be naiive, a pushover and allow people to just walk all over you is a matter of CHOICE! There is power in choices.

 

Your husband DOES need professional help! Is he open to it? You want the truth? Heck, I don't have to answer that for you. You already know. I bet you that once he realizes that you mean business about taking care of yourself, he going to try to reel you back in by making promises, and more promises. Idle promises--done in desparation!!! Or, he just might become very, very angry. So, please be cautious.

 

Oh, hell with it. I'm gonna answer that one question: Your husband definitely needs lots of counseling.  You've allowed him to neglect and abuse you for so long, it is going to take a long time for him to make changes. A LONG TIME, GIRL.

 

By the way, are you gonna take your sister-in-law's advice and stay in the marriage? After all, she sure has lots of experience.

 

Hold on to your power. Only you can give it away.      Peace.

 

 

...let her hear. Every point that losinend makes is a valid one. I will, however, make one caveat to paragraph 3. Even assuming he is open to counseling, beware of him trying to snow over the counselor to make himself look OK, end the counseling, and just go right on as before.

 

There is, truly, power in choices. I made mine over a decade ago and haven't looked back, even though there were declarations of "I still love you..." months after the divorce was final. His daughter (whose pending arrival 11 years ago "ended his life") is starting to wake up to his narcissism. Hopefully, she learns better and before I did!

 

Peace, and good luck.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 15, 2006, 7:47 am PST

11/21 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: heidinindi

Neither of these two is a bad person, nor are they a bad match (based on what came up on this show).  But, at least with regard to their wedding, this couple seems to have a pattern of not being very direct in communicating with each other, and that caused some problems for them.

 

Most women dream of their wedding day from early childhood, so it's normal for them to want the day to be "perfect."  While it sounded like Jamie agreed to small Vegas wedding with few "frills," when it came down to it, she actually wanted something more - and she took their wedding account money got it, much to Mike's dismay.   Mike admitted that selfishness is not characteristic of Jamie, and she insisted that it was "just for the wedding."  So why did that "selfishness" come out then?  Here's my take on the situation: 

 

Jamie failed to communicate or MIke failed to hear (I'm not sure which) what Jamie REALLY wanted for her wedding.  Instead of taking time to communicate more clearly with him about this, Jamie took matters into her own hands and made sure to get the things she wanted (I don't mean she made sure to get her way - just that she went out and got the things she wanted - a chapel, flowers, etc.).  Mike did not.  When Jamie "made him" uninvite all his friends (a poor choice of words unless she physically coerced him into doing this), it would seem that he agreed, willingly or grudgingly, and did this.  He may have resented it, but again, instead of trying harder to communicate what he wanted, he let it go.

 

Because both of them failed to communicate how much they wanted certain things, they couldn't really negotiate for those things that were truly important to each of them.  The result was that they ended up agreeing, instead, to wedding plans neither was really happy about.  Their response to that was different, though, with Jamie breaking the agreement to get what she truly wanted and what actually made her happy, and Mike sticking with the agreement but silently resenting it.   I'm not sure which was a worse response, but it's obvious why MIke was more unhappy.  He not only resented the things he'd agreed to (no friends, bachelor party, etc) but he also felt betrayed because Jamie didn't keep the agreement and feel equally discontent.  He probably hasn't thought of it quite like that, but it might help Mike to realize that Jamie could have stuck by the plan for a "no frills" wedding, and he would instead have had money left over in their joint account...and a bride who felt disappointed (at best) or resentful (at worst) about her wedding day.  And as Dr. Phil always reminds men, women have a LOOOONG memory.  In the end, I think he probably got the better option - a wife who was content with her wedding day.  I just wish that, if his friends' presence and a bachelor party of some sort was equally important to him, he could have expressed that in such a way that Jamie could have negotiated with him for those things (e.g. perhaps a few friends and a different show for the bachelor party).  Hopefully both Mike & Jamie will learn how to be more forthright with each other as they grow in their marriage.

 

P.S.  While the price of the wedding was not excessive, the price of that purse certainly was!  That merited an apology - especially because of the initial lie.  Hopefully Jamie's learned a lesson from that, too - better to be truthful right away than be truthful after getting caught!  The loss of a honeymoon is a disappointment for both of them, but perhaps Mike could learn from that - if you're planning a surprise, put the money you plan to use for it in a separate account where Jamie can't mistakenly think it's available to buy $600 purses!!

I guess I am atypical in the fact that as a young girl I didnt dream of a perfect wedding and prince charming and all that other fantasy stuff.  I was raised in the real world where I knew I would have to make it on my own and thank god I have.  Even when I was married I was on my own financially to a point - I made my own decisions about what car I wanted - it was MY car and MY money that paid for it.  How women today can still beleive that a man is the be all end all to their lives is beyond me !
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
confused
January 2, 2007, 3:01 pm PST

am trying

Quote From: lucky24

Maybe it's not to late to do the work you need to do to get things back on track?
thanks for replying. i have dedicated my life to fix my stupidity, currently at 8 months. spend sundays together, but she won't go to counseling at this time. says she is enjoying being alone, although she has our 21 year old daughter living with her. doesn't sound like she's alone to me. i still don't get it.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
quiet
March 26, 2007, 1:34 pm PDT

No Matter What The Cost It's The Memories That Count

 

 

My middle school sweetheart and I got married 7-8-06 in a very simple wedding.  And you know what? I wouldn't trade it for the world.  Yes I wanted a huge wedding with the big puffy wedding dress (Well, I DID have that.  Got it off of ebay!) and a gazillion bridesmaids (I had 3) , but we didn't have much money and we had to think of one person first, my Husband's Mother.  She was dying from ALS or more commonly known as Lou Gehrig's disease and it was more important to have her at our wedding than to borrow money for a huge splashy wedding, plan it that way, thus taking a long time and then have her die in the process.  That would have broken our hearts.  As it turned out from the time we got married to the time Mom died was 2 months and sixteen days.  Having her there was worth more than even the most expensive wedding in the world and the memories will be with us for a life time.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
March 26, 2007, 2:21 pm PDT

God Bless you both...your anniversary will be here soon...

Quote From: pennynewman71

 

 

My middle school sweetheart and I got married 7-8-06 in a very simple wedding.  And you know what? I wouldn't trade it for the world.  Yes I wanted a huge wedding with the big puffy wedding dress (Well, I DID have that.  Got it off of ebay!) and a gazillion bridesmaids (I had 3) , but we didn't have much money and we had to think of one person first, my Husband's Mother.  She was dying from ALS or more commonly known as Lou Gehrig's disease and it was more important to have her at our wedding than to borrow money for a huge splashy wedding, plan it that way, thus taking a long time and then have her die in the process.  That would have broken our hearts.  As it turned out from the time we got married to the time Mom died was 2 months and sixteen days.  Having her there was worth more than even the most expensive wedding in the world and the memories will be with us for a life time.

May you have many more together...weddings are way out of hand here in this country...I had three wedding 2 daughter and one son...who I took loans out for weddings that were median priced...5,000. each...still a lot of money.  It was very difficult for us to not do so...our in-laws own a resturant and we were forced to have big wedding for my in-laws...we had kept it down to 100 plus wedding party (ies) it was difficult...I did not invite my friends... nor some of my relatives...to make my husbands family happy.  One marriaged died fairly quickly...the girl my son married...

married his best friend after they were divorced 2 mon.  Her mom wanted a pot luck wedding...

when they married...she said they would not last...I didn't listen to her...we had that big wedding for them...33 people showed up at wedding without letting us know they were coming...what a mess that day was...

Oh well...I am just blabing here...God  Bless all the Grooms and Brides who marry for love...God...and family....not in that order God comes first...I pray for all who marry today that they will think before they decide whom to marry.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 26, 2007, 3:31 pm PDT

Inverse Relationship

I have been married three times and I have a theory...

 

The amount of happiness and longevity you have in your marriage is inversely proportional to the amount of money you spend on the wedding.

 

If a person is so wrapped up in possessions and things, there is nothing left to give to your spouse - or your future.  I am amazed at how some people spend 10s and 100s of thousands of dollars on weddings for marriages that are then plagued by debt and unhappiness.

 

Find a JP and get married.  Then you will have more money to build longer lasting memories on, and perhaps even have a down payment on a house.

 

Likewise, I am alarmed by the size of some engagement rings I see.  There is another materialistic item that just sets ordinary people up for failure.  How can a normal person with a normal income keep up with that kind of standard?

 

Be yourselves and be happy... that is what really matters.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 26, 2007, 8:11 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

Quote From: djmixon

I have been married three times and I have a theory...

 

The amount of happiness and longevity you have in your marriage is inversely proportional to the amount of money you spend on the wedding.

 

If a person is so wrapped up in possessions and things, there is nothing left to give to your spouse - or your future.  I am amazed at how some people spend 10s and 100s of thousands of dollars on weddings for marriages that are then plagued by debt and unhappiness.

 

Find a JP and get married.  Then you will have more money to build longer lasting memories on, and perhaps even have a down payment on a house.

 

Likewise, I am alarmed by the size of some engagement rings I see.  There is another materialistic item that just sets ordinary people up for failure.  How can a normal person with a normal income keep up with that kind of standard?

 

Be yourselves and be happy... that is what really matters.

   

    It really  bothers me when i hear  of all the money people are spending on weddings,; for most its a downpayment on a house, have they thought abaut that?

My husbond and I was 21 when we got married; my dress cost $20, my husbond had a new suit on, no tuxedo, my flowers paid for by my husbond, thats the tradition, where I come from, and the florist delivered them 1 hr. before i left for church, they vere buitifull.  The reception was held at my mothers apartment, ,,,, Bedroom empty,,, set up for sit down dinner for 26 guests, food came from a hotel in town; cost: less than $100:00, my mothers 2 girlfreinds did the serving, and after we all dansed the night away, this is 43 years ago, and  we atill talk abaut the fun we had.

  I have 2 daughters, married, the  weddings cost us, $ 4000.00 for 56 people, the other $ 7000.00 for 134 people, and yes that incl. hall, food, free bar and vine with dinner, and all had a great time, and our daughters/soninlaws both moved in to houses at the same time. All I am saying is that it is possible to have a nice wedding without spending a small fortune.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
March 27, 2007, 2:33 pm PDT

03/30 Nightmare Brides and Grooms

People should think before they get married. Make sure its the right one and that it is love!
 
First | Prev | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | Next | Last