Topic : Pornography

Number of Replies: 30846
New Messages This Week: 1
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:18:48 pm
Author : dataimport

Good or bad, does porn play a part in your life? Talk about it here.


For support, please visit the How Porn Has Hurt Our Relationship message board.

 

Please note: While a mature discussion about pornography is the purpose of this board, any posts that are attacking towards another poster, or are too graphic in nature, will be removed at the moderators' discretion.


Join the new Dr. Phil Community! Currently in BETA, the new Dr. Phil Community will allow you to personalize your message board experience. Start by creating your user profile here.

For help and FAQs on the new BETA Community, please click here.




User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 3:26 pm PDT

A Cause

I am appalled by the DCF system in our state and how many child abuse cases are either overlooked or not investigated further enough.  I am sick and tired of turning on the news at night and watching another newscast of a missing/abused/neglected child.  If these people do not want children - then WHY do they have them?!  Why isn't DCF cracking down on all of these social workers who, by not doing their job properly, are letting the abuse and neglect of these children continue?  I'm highly passionate about this issue and know that your question was linked to why you don't engage in an activity (that you have admitted you found arousing) that you think morally and ethically corrupts society as a whole.  Your question is like saying, for example, that even though I know young peoples' and preteens' cigarette smoking is climbing at an alarming rate - that I should put my 'personal enjoyment' of smoking cigarettes aside and NOT smoke; which means that morally I'd be doing the 'right thing' by setting an example to others by not smoking and not contributing my finances to the tobacco companies who advertise to minors.  Sorry to burst your bubble, but my not smoking isn't going to put a dent in the tobacco companies cigarette profits.  Even if five million people quit smoking right NOW, it STILL wouldn't effect them!  What you are speaking of is a global phenomenom which would have to happen in order for people not smoking to make a real, palpable difference in society!  This same metaphor can apply to porn as well.  My not viewing porn isn't going to make it go away or prevent all of the women who choose to do this as their profession or just for fun not engage in it.  Whether you are aware of this or not, some of the products and services you use and rely on everyday in some manner support porn!  Even if you were correct in your assumption that porn itself corrupts society and its youth, it is something that a million housewives/people could never ever eradicate completely.  It is here to stay; and since we do live in this wonderful country we call America, the people who reside within its boundaries will always have the right to choose which private activities they choose to do in the privacy of their own homes and who aren't harming anyone physically or mentally in any way by doing so.  It is regretful that porn has damaged so many womens'/and some mens' self-esteem and has changed some of these peoples' lives forever.  As much as some of those people may not want to hear this, they must know that there ARE people in other walks of life in which porn does NOT pose as a problem or threat in their marriages/relationships.  And since this board does not specifically state that this is an Anti-Porn Board ONLY, then EVERYONE has the right to come here and voice their opinion on HOW porn has affected THEIR relationship(s).
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
hopeful
July 28, 2005, 5:22 pm PDT

In the name of love

There is and has been a lot of talk about if one is doing something that hurts the other it should just be stopped in the name of loving the other. Love being the only reason for eliminating the problem. I’m all for that. The only thing is, does one consider being hurt by the other the same as what the other defines it as?

 

Men and women define some of the important versus the unimportant issues of life differently. To what point do we just acquiesce to become a mirror of the others expectations of us?

 

So changing/stopping/eliminating the actions that causes hurt to another, let’s test out a scenario to see how far we ourselves are willing to go to stop whatever the other sees as hurt to them. All in the name of love of course:

 

Dear, I would like to present a proposal of conduct that is fair to each. If either of us has an issue with the other that causes us hurt, feeling(s) of rejection, desertion, being cheated out of or on, or any feelings of discomfort in any way, the one perceived to be causing the feeling(s) will just stop doing or acting in such a manner. If the one perceived to be causing the hurt feelings believes it is caused by medical reasons they, will get whatever medical exams necessary to discover the cause and follow whatever treatment(s) or therapies required to eliminate the problem. If it is believed to be a natural male or female way of acting they will seek therapy to eliminate that belief structure. The only reason the cause of the perceived issue will be tolerated will be when there is a medical diagnosis that the problem can’t under any circumstance be changed, altered or eliminated. Now, with complete honesty you tell me whatever it is that I do that causes you the slightest discomfort or hurt and I will change it or seek the means necessary to change to the way you want me to be and conduct myself. Then it will be my turn for the same. In this way we can come to complete love and caring for each other.

 

Before I get all the negative responses please take the time to deeply think about how far we ourselves are really willing to go to change in order to meet the expectation(s) of what the other believes we should be. When it comes to true love, isn’t what and whom we are completely dependant upon the other’s view of us?

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
happy
July 28, 2005, 5:24 pm PDT

The cut and paste from another WP works

 Thanks for the tip.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
hopeful
July 28, 2005, 5:41 pm PDT

Thanks for the greetings everyone.

Hi right back at you. Hope you are all doing well. I'm doing okay, thanks for asking. Still up to my caboose in this remodel and the Honey Do list just keeps growing.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 5:41 pm PDT

just thought i would say...

Quote From: sandman4u

Just because you and I watch and enjoy porn, that doesn't mean everyone on this board should (or does).  It is a man's/woman's personal PRIVATE choice whether to indulge in porn or not.  And as long as the person with the opposing viewpoint doesn't shove their beliefs down other peoples' throats, then it is possible that we can all discuss ideas and different points of view on this subject without getting hostile, judgemental or holier-than-thou.  Our opinions are heard and noted, but we have to becareful to not insinuate that others should live as we do just because it works for us.
that was a very well put reply. I do not enjoy porn, and because of experiences i can say that I hate it. It has no place in my life....including my marriage. Now I do feel that it is having a terrible effect on society so i would like to challange the idea that porn is fine overall. However I do not like to judge people and feel that if two people choose to have this in their own relationship privately then that is their business. I do feel that the industry takes advantage of young women and leads them into a dark world that is hard to escape from and though that is not always the case it is the case often enough. I agree that though we are on differant sides of this discussion that if we are able to communicate in a respectful way then we can have intelligent conversations about this and perhaps better understand each others views.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 6:02 pm PDT

How Porn Has Affected Our Relationship

Quote From: sandman4u

I am appalled by the DCF system in our state and how many child abuse cases are either overlooked or not investigated further enough.  I am sick and tired of turning on the news at night and watching another newscast of a missing/abused/neglected child.  If these people do not want children - then WHY do they have them?!  Why isn't DCF cracking down on all of these social workers who, by not doing their job properly, are letting the abuse and neglect of these children continue?  I'm highly passionate about this issue and know that your question was linked to why you don't engage in an activity (that you have admitted you found arousing) that you think morally and ethically corrupts society as a whole.  Your question is like saying, for example, that even though I know young peoples' and preteens' cigarette smoking is climbing at an alarming rate - that I should put my 'personal enjoyment' of smoking cigarettes aside and NOT smoke; which means that morally I'd be doing the 'right thing' by setting an example to others by not smoking and not contributing my finances to the tobacco companies who advertise to minors.  Sorry to burst your bubble, but my not smoking isn't going to put a dent in the tobacco companies cigarette profits.  Even if five million people quit smoking right NOW, it STILL wouldn't effect them!  What you are speaking of is a global phenomenom which would have to happen in order for people not smoking to make a real, palpable difference in society!  This same metaphor can apply to porn as well.  My not viewing porn isn't going to make it go away or prevent all of the women who choose to do this as their profession or just for fun not engage in it.  Whether you are aware of this or not, some of the products and services you use and rely on everyday in some manner support porn!  Even if you were correct in your assumption that porn itself corrupts society and its youth, it is something that a million housewives/people could never ever eradicate completely.  It is here to stay; and since we do live in this wonderful country we call America, the people who reside within its boundaries will always have the right to choose which private activities they choose to do in the privacy of their own homes and who aren't harming anyone physically or mentally in any way by doing so.  It is regretful that porn has damaged so many womens'/and some mens' self-esteem and has changed some of these peoples' lives forever.  As much as some of those people may not want to hear this, they must know that there ARE people in other walks of life in which porn does NOT pose as a problem or threat in their marriages/relationships.  And since this board does not specifically state that this is an Anti-Porn Board ONLY, then EVERYONE has the right to come here and voice their opinion on HOW porn has affected THEIR relationship(s).
Seriously, sandman, I was NOT trying to set you up by getting you to admit to support of some cause that I could then compare to the anti-porn movement. I just wanted to know what you believe. I am a smoker, myself, and can certainly see the dangers that my smoking poses for my children even though I do choose to smoke outside. Certainly, I wish I had never started . . . which, I know, is what everybody who smokes says. There really is no way to live a pure life, is there? No way to live without making some choice somewhere that causes or contributes to a problem for someone else. So we choose our causes and we fight for those and try our best to ignore the corruption in the parts of our lives we're not willing to change. We're all guilty of it.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 6:34 pm PDT

hey allinall

Quote From: allinall

There is and has been a lot of talk about if one is doing something that hurts the other it should just be stopped in the name of loving the other. Love being the only reason for eliminating the problem. I’m all for that. The only thing is, does one consider being hurt by the other the same as what the other defines it as?

 

Men and women define some of the important versus the unimportant issues of life differently. To what point do we just acquiesce to become a mirror of the others expectations of us?

 

So changing/stopping/eliminating the actions that causes hurt to another, let’s test out a scenario to see how far we ourselves are willing to go to stop whatever the other sees as hurt to them. All in the name of love of course:

 

Dear, I would like to present a proposal of conduct that is fair to each. If either of us has an issue with the other that causes us hurt, feeling(s) of rejection, desertion, being cheated out of or on, or any feelings of discomfort in any way, the one perceived to be causing the feeling(s) will just stop doing or acting in such a manner. If the one perceived to be causing the hurt feelings believes it is caused by medical reasons they, will get whatever medical exams necessary to discover the cause and follow whatever treatment(s) or therapies required to eliminate the problem. If it is believed to be a natural male or female way of acting they will seek therapy to eliminate that belief structure. The only reason the cause of the perceived issue will be tolerated will be when there is a medical diagnosis that the problem can’t under any circumstance be changed, altered or eliminated. Now, with complete honesty you tell me whatever it is that I do that causes you the slightest discomfort or hurt and I will change it or seek the means necessary to change to the way you want me to be and conduct myself. Then it will be my turn for the same. In this way we can come to complete love and caring for each other.

 

Before I get all the negative responses please take the time to deeply think about how far we ourselves are really willing to go to change in order to meet the expectation(s) of what the other believes we should be. When it comes to true love, isn’t what and whom we are completely dependant upon the other’s view of us?

So using your script above, I asked my husband, "Is there anything I do that makes you feel hurt, rejected, deserted, and cheated on?" I dropped the discomfort part because I'm certain he could site several things I do that cause him discomfort: I move the seat in his car so he has to squeeze in, I refuse to get a king size bed even though his legs hang off the end of our queen, I sometimes cook with sugar substitutes that cause him GREAT intestinal discomfort. Anyway, his response to the above question was first, "Cheated on? That's pretty specific." I clarified that it needed to be something that causes all of those emotions: hurt, rejection, desertion, the feeling of being cheated on. He then responded, "I don't know. I've never really thought aboutit. If you ever do, I guess I don't dwell on it because what would be the point. It would consume me. I don't have time for that." We continued the conversation and I summarized your post for him. He says that he doesn't see any change that he has made for me as being about me or about not hurting my feelings anymore although he admits that he has certainly made changes that have had that effect. He says that when he's made a change at my request, it has been because I convinced him of the validity of a new way of behaving and he decided on his own that his old reasons for behaving a certain way were illegitimate and the new course of action suggested by me WAS more legitimate. He added that when he changes to please me it's more to please himself, because he likes the response the gets from me.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 6:39 pm PDT

i use to believe

Back in the day when my husband was using porn and i was so young and so desperately trying to figure it all out.....that porn was a way to spice up our relationship in bed. Maybe i did ....maybe i didn't believe this...i am not sure. I was just trying to contol something i couldn't.

 

Now when i look back....I regret ever having brought it into our bedroom. ANd for many reasons. for one.....it didn't change anything. Actually it made things worse because it somehow gave him the notion that I approved of him viewing porn. secondly....he often would watch the porn with me....watch it again on his own and often would beat off to it many times in the days to come. third....it left me wondering if I could do all that I saw in porn....or if I measured up to it all when I couldn't possiby do all that.

 

Most women I have met on here in the last couple years....that have tried using porn in their bedroom....came to regret it later in life. Most women who thought it was okay for their men to use it....came to regret it later in life. WHy.....because what they once believed would just be a small factor in their husbands lives....became a controlling factor. These women all speak from experiences and have come a long way in growing.

 

So when I see some young married couple spicing things up with porn....I laugh and say...."they too will come to think differently."  When I see someone who has been married for a whole 3 minutes ....talking about how great their sex lives have become because of porn.....I again laugh and know that this too will come crashing down. It seems it always does. Now I know some of you will say ..."not me."  you just wait....You just wait.  The day will come....

 

 

SO if you really want to spice things up....why don't you try to fantasize together. DO things together! Are your imaginations and brains that turned off?  Do you not know each other?  Do you not care enough about each other to figure it all out? Since when is sex....between two people and everyone who wants to watch? Is nothing sacred? Do we really believe that this is what God had intended for sex to be? I don't think so....but then maybe some don't believe in God? Or maybe some just choose to ignore him when it comes to sex.

 

Just my two cents!

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
chillin'
July 28, 2005, 7:29 pm PDT

Lilacmess

You're correct when you say that there is no way to live a pure life.  You're also correct when you say that no matter what decision you make to do a particular activity, your decisions will always inadverdently effect someone else.  Not to trivialize the code of monogamy which men should honor with their wives (and visa versa); but it's my belief that with the way the media is in our society presently and the way porn, promiscuity and adultery have permeated our homes, jobs and lives - there are alot WORSE things husbands could be doing instead of looking at pictures of naked women or video clips of them in his own home!  Women simply do NOT understand the temptations men face EVERY SINGLE DAY.  Even when a marriage is at it's optimum level of happiness and sexual satisfaction - there STILL are times when a husband can be tempted to touch or kiss upon another... believe me, it's happened to me many times during the course of my marriage.  And many times I've had to gather up all the strength and resolve that I had within me to NOT go through with it.  Not only because I love her, but because I feel she deserves the same faithfullness from me that I want and expect from her. So, when a man chooses to be faithful to his wife, he knows that he can never ever touch or do anything else physical or emotional with another woman.  Men marry and honor their marriage vows because they feel that this one woman is WORTH it for them to forever relinquish all other chances of being sexual with beautiful and compatible females.  But in husbands doing this, it is then the wife's responsibility to honor her marriage vows and realize that since her husband will ONLY have THEM as a sexual partner for the life of the marriage - she should be prepared to avail herself physically and emotionally for sex with him throughout the life of the marriage.  Also knowing since her husband's first attraction to her was for her physicality, that she should strive to maintain her figure and her sexual attractiveness for him as men are highly (almost chronically) visual.  She should also be prepared to be willing to experiment with him sexually as there are probably many things he would like to try to do with her and to her during lovemaking.  The problem with this is, ALOT of women either lack one or two of these three things...and sometimes lack all of them!  Women expect men to give up ALOT when they request of him to NOT look at other women and to NOT to look at porn or go to strip clubs, etc.  Just because we are in LOVE with the woman of our dreams, doesn't mean we lose ALL desire to look at other beautiful women!  My point being this:  (not to make it sound like she should be 'grateful' because he doesn't commit adultery or engage in immoral internet activity with other women) IF the WORST a husband EVER does in his marriage is look at porn (AND as long as he DOES satisfy her sexually and loves her dearly), then...the wife should consider herself very fortunate!  It may not seem this way to women and they may get defensive, but it's the God's honest truth.  But when these same wives then restrict (& oftentimes remove) the ONLY means of his looking at other women that he has, then one of only two things will happen.  He will either HONOR her wishes and will wish he could do it....OR....he'll just DO it.  And if his resentment for her grows - then he may commit actual adultery.  Not saying women should just acquiesce their husband's porn usage...just saying there ARE WORSE things he COULD be doing.  My opinion only.               

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2005, 8:18 pm PDT

sandman

Quote From: sandman4u

You're correct when you say that there is no way to live a pure life.  You're also correct when you say that no matter what decision you make to do a particular activity, your decisions will always inadverdently effect someone else.  Not to trivialize the code of monogamy which men should honor with their wives (and visa versa); but it's my belief that with the way the media is in our society presently and the way porn, promiscuity and adultery have permeated our homes, jobs and lives - there are alot WORSE things husbands could be doing instead of looking at pictures of naked women or video clips of them in his own home!  Women simply do NOT understand the temptations men face EVERY SINGLE DAY.  Even when a marriage is at it's optimum level of happiness and sexual satisfaction - there STILL are times when a husband can be tempted to touch or kiss upon another... believe me, it's happened to me many times during the course of my marriage.  And many times I've had to gather up all the strength and resolve that I had within me to NOT go through with it.  Not only because I love her, but because I feel she deserves the same faithfullness from me that I want and expect from her. So, when a man chooses to be faithful to his wife, he knows that he can never ever touch or do anything else physical or emotional with another woman.  Men marry and honor their marriage vows because they feel that this one woman is WORTH it for them to forever relinquish all other chances of being sexual with beautiful and compatible females.  But in husbands doing this, it is then the wife's responsibility to honor her marriage vows and realize that since her husband will ONLY have THEM as a sexual partner for the life of the marriage - she should be prepared to avail herself physically and emotionally for sex with him throughout the life of the marriage.  Also knowing since her husband's first attraction to her was for her physicality, that she should strive to maintain her figure and her sexual attractiveness for him as men are highly (almost chronically) visual.  She should also be prepared to be willing to experiment with him sexually as there are probably many things he would like to try to do with her and to her during lovemaking.  The problem with this is, ALOT of women either lack one or two of these three things...and sometimes lack all of them!  Women expect men to give up ALOT when they request of him to NOT look at other women and to NOT to look at porn or go to strip clubs, etc.  Just because we are in LOVE with the woman of our dreams, doesn't mean we lose ALL desire to look at other beautiful women!  My point being this:  (not to make it sound like she should be 'grateful' because he doesn't commit adultery or engage in immoral internet activity with other women) IF the WORST a husband EVER does in his marriage is look at porn (AND as long as he DOES satisfy her sexually and loves her dearly), then...the wife should consider herself very fortunate!  It may not seem this way to women and they may get defensive, but it's the God's honest truth.  But when these same wives then restrict (& oftentimes remove) the ONLY means of his looking at other women that he has, then one of only two things will happen.  He will either HONOR her wishes and will wish he could do it....OR....he'll just DO it.  And if his resentment for her grows - then he may commit actual adultery.  Not saying women should just acquiesce their husband's porn usage...just saying there ARE WORSE things he COULD be doing.  My opinion only.               

I've got to tell you, sandman, you're the only man I've ever encountered who professes to feel so strongly about his right or need to look at other women. And I've been around the block a few times. I've had two husbands and several boyfriends and numerous male friends who have treated me like one of the guys. I've been totally upfront with every man I've given my heart to about my feelings about pornography . . . and not a single one of them ever objected to giving up porn for me. Actually, my current husband is the only one who would probably say that he's never had any moral qualms over pornography and has just given it up because this pleases me and he likes the way pleasing me makes him feel. The others all practically thanked me for suggesting to them that they make me they're only sexual outlet, as if they had just been waiting for some woman to come along and say, "Hey, I'm here and I'm all for you, but I'm all you can have!" In fact, my first husband said that looking at pornography had always made him feel guilty and the guy I dated for three years after him said that he had gone to a strip club once but that the whole experience embarrassed him. So I think you need to keep your opinion about the necessity of being able to look at other women sexually in perspective. Perhaps it's a huge sacrifice for you not to go to strip clubs or to not act on sexual impulses with other women, but the sacrifice isn't quite that great for a lot of guys. And honestly, if I thought that not looking at porn or going to strip clubs came as a huge sacrifice for my husband, I wouldn't have married him because I wouldn't have had any faith in his ability to continue to refrain from doing those things. And as for temptation, women get tempted, too, you know. Men hit on me, I'm sure, as often as women hit on you. I just don't respond to it. I don't allow it to even reach that point where I might have to use some will power to turn down a kiss. Hell, I don't even allow men to buy drinks for me because there's no point in leading them on. I'm a married woman and I can pay for my own drinks. My husband has gained forty pounds since we got married and, as we've discussed, I'm the one with the higher sex drive. Still, I have no desire to look outside our marriage for sexual titillation or fulfillment. Hmmm.....

 

First | Prev | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | Next | Last