Topic : 12/08 Out-of-Control Husbands

Number of Replies: 245
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, December 01, 2006, 03:25:09 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
A marriage vow says, “’Til death do us part.” But what if your husband’s behavior is so outrageous, you fear he’ll end up in an early grave? Dr. Phil’s first guest, Danny Bonaduce, was a child star on the ’70s hit show The Partridge Family, but now he’s infamous for his bad behavior. Danny has been arrested for drug possession, has been in rehab three times and has cheated on his wife, Gretchen. The couple showcases their struggle with his addictions on the VH1 show Breaking Bonaduce. Danny says he’s finally sober, but Gretchen says she can’t stop being suspicious of his every move. Is it too soon for her to trust him? Then, Maggie says she can’t deal with her fiancé, Michael’s, chaotic behavior. Michael admits that he’s verbally abusive to his wife-to-be, even in front of their young daughter, but says he wants to stop. Maggie moved halfway across the country and took their child without telling him. Can Michael get his family back, or has he lashed out one time too many?  Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2006 Show Boards.


User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2006, 4:05 pm PST

Oh please!

Quote From: losinend

Please let me respond one more time. I'm not one to get into any heated debate about issues of domestic violence, abuse and the sort.

 

First of all you can tell me all you want that "it is everybody's business". I can chose to make it my business or I can chose not to make it my business. The only law I have broken is my moral law to not do something about it. I can even turn my back on domestic violence and pretend I did not see anything. What would be the repurcussions? Just my moral conscience would bother me.

 

I think it's a load of crap when someone says, "it takes two to tango." Please, leave that one on the dance floor of the Arthur Murry Academy. Yeah, I believe that the only person responsible for the actual abuse is the abuser and, that a HEAVY consequence needs to be paid for that abuser's action.  

 

I'm not sure what you are referring to in your statement that battered and abused WOMEN do not want to get beat up! It's a very loaded statement. And with that said, are you saying that a person has no other recourse but to stay and continue to get beat up? That they have no other choice? Hey I'm not even coming close to BLAMING the victim. Cannot a person learn to take responsibility to save themselves from this abusive situation? After all, they have the final say so on their demise. They do have alternatives.

 

I'm not really interested in learning about the brainwashing techniques set upon the victims by their abusers or the programming method they use on their families.

 

The only fact I want to know is that abusers (men or women) beat up on their victims and for "love" the victim makes the final choice of taking all of that bull crap.

 

My heart goes out to all of those people who have become victims to abuse. But, you do have choices. Learn them fast before it is too late.  About domestic violence, I make it my business because I chose to make it my business.    When it comes to child abuse I make it my business even when someone says "It's none of your business".   Thank You

You said your not really interested in learning about brain washing techniques set apon the victums by the abusers or the programming method they use on their families. Under these conditions the victums do not make the final choice. They are brain washed and therefore are not in their right minds. Please further educate yourself on the subject.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
sad
December 14, 2006, 6:26 pm PST

12/08 Out-of-Control Husbands

Quote From: mfz705

I can identify totally with Maggie on the show right now....  My ex-boyfriend left me in May - after having an affair with my next door neighbor - he is now my neighbor.  He is a raging alcoholic.  She is as well - together, they are a horrible pair destined to be dead in a year and leave her children w/ no mother.  He is the most wonderful person - sweet, kind, fun person who will do anything for you - when he's sober.  When he drinks - you watch him pound beer after beer after beer - you can literally see him turn into a different person right before your eyes.  When he reaches the threshold of when he should stop but has one more, the person then becomes a raging monster - nasty, horrible, miserable person who vomits and cries and plead forgiveness one minute then rages and calls you the most despicable names the next.

 

I can identify with Maggie because everything Michael said, Charlie said.  I "pushed his buttons as only I can" (a statement he's said to every g/f and his ex wife), he's an admitted alcoholic "and you know that and should understand" (aka, excuse my behavior), within the last several years, he was so verbally and mentally abusive, I didn't recognize it any longer.  Now that he's been gone 7 months, I realize what a horrible existence I allowed to become normal.  It was not normal.  He destroyed his family - he's destroyed every relationship he's ever been in.  In addition to being an alcoholic, he's a deceptive, lying, cheating, thieving, con-artist. 

I knew him a couple of years before being involved with him - he was sober.  He made that decision after he lost his family.  His eldest daughter was old enough to remember her daddy saying I'm either going to drink myself to death or get my act together (she was 10 at the time) - he chose sobriety and stayed sober for over 10 years.  When we got together, he did not drink which was great - I'm not a big drinker and can find an awful lot of things to do besides going to a bar - and yes, I'm a fun person even though I don't get stupid drunk.  About a year and a half into the relationship, we attended a 40th b/d party for a good friend of his who insisted he have a beer - I saw the change after 1/2 a glass and so did he.  He stopped and he had nothing more to drink until pressures mounted in his world.  A beer here, there, turned into a 6 pack here there turned into a 30 pack in a weekend.    He and the new girlfriend go through a 30 pack just about every night. 

 

I do not have to imagine what Eternal Hell will be like - I lived it the last year of my relationship with him.  The horrid names (those Maggie mentioned were commonplace - the "C" word was his pet name for me), the mental and verbal abuse (I have a college degree, have a great job - he has a high school education, is a laborer and calls me stupid F'g moron), the breaking of precious momentos I held dear, the threats of physical abuse, the witnessing of him beating his dog.   In addition to suffering as I did - I loved him, the more I loved him, the worse things got.  I used to be a strong, no nonsense, no BS taking kind of gal.  Now, I'm a beaten down mentally drained person who allows people to walk all over me.  I realize he did this to me - I allowed it to happen and he ran with it.  I'm a nurturer by nature and my personality enabled him to do the things he did to me and others.  I excused his behavior, I helped him when he got sick from drinking so much, I did everything for him - and worse, I allowed him to manipulate my finances - I am now stuck with over $85,000 of HIS debt and there is not a thing I can do about it because it was on credit cards. 

 

Even worse, I see the same thing happening with the new g/f - he's conned her into buying a new motorcycle (newer than the one I bought and had to have repossessed), conned her into basically supporting him while he goes out with the boys and cheats and lies to her as he's done to me and countless others, she pays for everything, he pays for nothing.  He has a history (which I found out way too late), of using women, getting us to buy the most unbelievable material possessions, and when he realizes the gravy train is over - he destroys the material things, starts his hunt for the new conquest (because he doens't leave the current g/f until he's secured a new one) and then leaves the current g/f with all the bills, the repairs, the destroyed life, the anguish - while he goes onto the new g/f having played up to her how awful the old one was, etc. - garnering even bigger, better, faster, more expensive material things - and the pattern starts all over again.

 

All this from stems from a raging functional alcoholic who sees nothing wrong with his life, lifestyle - that the ex is the one who stifles his independence, freedom, isn't fun anymore, doesn't know how to party, etc. - that's what he tells the potential new g/f's - and the stories are so believable, you feel sorry for how he was "wronged", and you sit with him and have a beer or so, and the stories get taller and taller......  He needs to grow up , take responsibility and be a parent to the 4 children (and 3 granchildren) he's lost.... but that will never happen....  the pattern continues and unfortunately, because of the financial mess he left me with, I cannot move and I need to see this every day as they live next door.  Its a constant scenario of him and her laughing at me, picking on the way I do things and how I do them and how I can't function w/o him, etc.  I hear all the time how I'm such a prude, I'm a jerk, I'm cold, etc. - just because I don't drink a lot.

 

I hate to tell him, but he lost the best thing he ever had - his family knows it, his friends know it, but he just ignores them instead for the 10 year older woman who has a drug addict daughter and a mildly retarded daughter.  They smoke and drink with the drug addict (she's 14), he's been arrested for a DUI (he's a CDL license holder), he's managed to talk his way out of the penalty - how I do not know as his BAC was .16....  His brother afflicted with the same problem should have 7 DUI convictions - but his lawyer got him off of technicalities and he has 2 on record - and they continue to drink.  The holiday season is here and it will be even worse.  I remember last Christmas - he vomited 4 times on a 20 minute drive home because he drank so much....  but I just don't know how to have fun.

 

Out of control - yes, he's definitely out of control  And had this been 7 months ago, I would have taken him back in a heart beat because I loved him so much - I still care deeply for him - but the person he was, not who he is now - the person he probably was all along, but masked it for 10 years.   He is on a self destructive path starting with the alcohol and spicing it up with his lies, deceptions, debauchery, con artistry - among many other things.


Anyone who lives with an alcoholic, please encourage them to seek help or get out.  I endured 7 years of hell and I'm just beginning to get back to the person I was and look back and think to myself - what happened to me that I allowed that to happen to me?  He doens't want help - he wants to live the life of an alcoholic - the partier, the fun guy, the man with no responsibility.  I want a life with someone who loves me, cherishes me, wouldn't dare condescend me or call me the most horrid names - unfortunately, he's destroyed just about any trust I have toward men, and pretty much sealed the fate to never let another man get close to me enough that I love and trust them like I did him.  What I see and live with every day is 7 years of my life wasted - wasted because I could have had someone who loved me enough that we would have married and had children.  I'll never have the gift of children because I wasted my love on someone who just wants to be wasted.

 

 

I know how that feels, that you have wasted years of your life.  But you made the first step in leaving.  Now make the most important.  Find out what YOU want in life and follow that.  I don't know how to help you, I wish I did.  It hurts me and makes me sad to see so many women, from all levels of society...those poor to those rich..who have been in the same situation.  We have been controlled because our personality is giving and caring.  Many guys either consciously or maybe subconsciously are drawn to us.  I think my problems came about because of lack of self confidence and low self esteem, plus back in the "old days" women were expected to make it work.  I know I am not stupid but I stayed for 31 years.  By the time I realized that he deep love and concern for me were actually forms of control, I was living a life of hell.  The first time he pitched a fit, it scared me to death.  I started to leave and he a wire from under the hood of my car and it wouldn't start.  I started to walk to my grandparents who lived within a mile.  He told me if I left he would go to the woods and shoot himself.  Right then I should have left.  We had only been married a few weeks.  I should have called his bluff but I didn't.  The horrible thing about it is that every time he pitched his fits and I made up to make life peaceful, I always had to prove that I wasn't mad by allowing him to make love to me.  Many times I cried bitterly because I felt so used.  I truly felt like I was lower than a woman who would sell her body because in a sense that is what I had done.  Allowed myself to be used.  But my price was not money...it was peace.  I was a sunday school teacher and was supposed to teach the children.  He hid my shoes so I couldn't go to church and when I found another pair and tried to sneak out,  he told me if I went to not come back.  By then I was pregnant with our first son.  I couldn't go back home to my parents.  My dad says now that if he had known half of what all was going on that he would have come after me.  But of course in the 70's it would have been a shame for me to have left him.  Down through the years I tried to keep peace.  The kids were always worried and tense when he came home.  They would hear him coming home and it seemed a pall came over our home.  We never knew if he would be in a bad mood and there would be screaming and yelling over any little thing.  Once he smacked our son in the face for yelling over his birthday balloons.  I told him I would call Child Services if he ever hit him in the face again.   He asked me one time if I would allow his parents to adopt our two sons so we could get a "check" for them.  I told him that they were the only things in this life that were mine and he better never ask again.  The FBI came to our home, first because of a stolen vehicle that he and his business partner bought.  He nearly went to the penitentary for that.  Later they came to investigate him because of a bogus coal operation involving lawyers representing their clients in Germany.  I cannot say life was ever boring.  I turned to religion again.  He threatened to come and shoot the windows out of the church if I didn't come home on time.  He accused me of the preacher.  I gave up my religious convictions because I could not handle any more.  Then we had  this new life.  We stayed at the lake on weekends.  I enjoyed some of it but of course that was short lived.  He would drink every weekend and did all sorts of things that totally humiliated me.  Once he was drinking and in front of all our friends he grabbed two of the ladies toes and sucked them.  He once pulled one of our women friends down on his lap and kissed her in front of all our friends...then one night he was drunk and stripped and danced naked with a woman.  That was the end of it all.  I had planned for a long time that I would leave...I had left 3 times before and came back.  This time I planned it ahead and I got me a place to live, had it all ready.....my furniture was two folding chairs, a small wooden kitchen cabinet my father had given me and a wicker rocker.  I took half the dishes and pans and towels.  I left all the other furniture except my computer and stereo.  In other words, I did not rip him off.  The funny part is all the people who saw how he acted and encouraged me to leave...including his sister, they were angry at me....because this man did his usual temper tantrum...but they felt it was his grief...my gosh he should have won an oscar for his performance.  He banged his head on the floor till he bled, laid an empty valium bottle nearby(he did not take them}, broke our picture on the floor near him...called our sons and told them he  couldn't live or some bs. rushed there of course they thought poor Dad had went off the deep end....he had always been off the deep end...and he didn't need liquour to encourage it...he was a selfish individual.  He didn't care that they were worried sick.  He wanted sympathy.  Even my best friend felt sorry for him....I lost her friendship too.  But the boys understood and that is what matters...my sons.  My best friend was not my friend at all.  I hadn't told him where I was, afraid of his wrath.  She felt sorry for him and told him.  It has been a long road, but there is light at the end of the tunnel, for me there was....for you there is.  Hang in there and make yourself happy for awhile...get used to that...it is great.  Find out who you are and revel in it.  The first thing is to forgive yourself for allowing him to take those seven years, then don't waste the rest of them by giving them to him as well.  Sending you hugs...we are need some...Take care and be strong.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2006, 6:35 pm PST

Walk a mile

Quote From: aprilcarrieb

You said your not really interested in learning about brain washing techniques set apon the victums by the abusers or the programming method they use on their families. Under these conditions the victums do not make the final choice. They are brain washed and therefore are not in their right minds. Please further educate yourself on the subject.
Look I can understand that you are a strong person and cannot possible understand how anyone can allow themselves to be abused....good for you.  Please don't presume though to act like that we all stay because of love or wanting to be loved.  Not everyone is a strong as you purport to be....some of us have problems believing in ourselves...thank God many women won't put up with it for a second.  Many of us, I believe, have grown up thinking that it is up to us to make our life work.  I remember in my abusive marriage that I kept thinking if I act better it will be better....it was for a bit.  But there was always something else to set things off again.  After awhile you are brain washed into feeling it is your fault and you just aren't doing enough.  By the time you realize that you are not doing a thing wrong, usually you are in a tight web of control...I am glad you are a strong person and have not dealt with this.  Right now I would never allow this to happen to me again...not abusive...not control....but in this not so perfect world...all of us are not perfect...some of us need help...
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2006, 6:47 pm PST

AMEN

Quote From: Pleasance

Domestic Abuse, or Domestic Violence is NOT about a couple having problems, or a fight.

 

Domestic Abuse is a systematic group of tactics that ONE PERSON CHOOSES TO RAIN OVER AND DO TO ANOTHER INDIVIDUAL....their partner, spouse, girlfriend..........child......IN ORDER TO HAVE POWER, CONTROL, ABUSE AND OR VIOLENCE OVER ANOTHER.

 

 

 

It only TAKES ONE PERSON TO RUIN, DESTROY, OR CAUSE LIVING HELL IN A RELATIONSHIP.

 

 

IT DOES NOT TAKE  2.....................even if you just stand there........and don't open your mouth......the abuser will abuse.......and abuse........and abuse !

 

 

It only takes one person to destroy a relationship, a child's life.......an entire family.

 

DOMESTIC ABUSE IS NOT ABOUT MARITAL PROBLEMS......

 

DOMESTIC ABUSE IS NOT A COUPLE'S PROBLEM......

 

DOMESTIC ABUSE LIES SQUARELY AT THE FEET AND ON THE SHOULDERS OF THE ABUSER........AND IN MORE THAN 95% of the time the abuser is a MALE.

 

 

 

 

 

AMEN and AMEN....you are so right

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2006, 6:55 pm PST

12/08 Out-of-Control Husbands

Quote From: flrat69

When he kills her will she have done enough?  I do not me to demean you experience in any way, but please keep in mind that each situation is different.  Is a person compelled to let verbal and emotional abuse become physical before acting?  I agree with the concept of counseling, but not to the extent that she endangers herself or her children in the process.  The children don't need a martyr; they need a mother.
Thanks for you comment...children don't need a martyr...they need a mother....a woman doesn't need to be beaten senseless...or even "smacked around"...mental, verbal and emotional abuse can leave scars that are deep and take a lot of work to heal....
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
December 15, 2006, 8:26 am PST

Enlighten Me, please

Quote From: aprilcarrieb

You said your not really interested in learning about brain washing techniques set apon the victums by the abusers or the programming method they use on their families. Under these conditions the victums do not make the final choice. They are brain washed and therefore are not in their right minds. Please further educate yourself on the subject.

Okay, with that provocative thought and the information about  the "brainwashing" theory that you speak of, the victim is not in their "right" mind. Is that "legal" right mind? Does that defend the victim in court, lets say for example, when the victim reaches the point when she ends up killing the abuser because the victim was not in their "right mind".  Will the victim get off? Is that a legal defense? In that example, the victim did indeed make a final choice and that was to kill the abuser. But than again, the victim could have chosen to stay and take the beating or take the kids and run. Either way, a choice was made.

 

I'm not the one who needs an education. I'm not totally hip on your "brainwashing" theory.

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
December 15, 2006, 9:47 am PST

Danny the Bad BOY, I do mean BOY

I'm saddened every time I see Bonaduce as it's just 'anything for attention or money', one way or the other.

 

One thing I had to comment on, that Dr. Phil didn't 'mention'. (Dr Phil is SO right on about so much, especially the 'boy' he was dealing with).

 

Danny looks like death warmed over. A year of 'sobriety' and/or clean and sober should have him looking and sounding better than he does. I notice no difference at all from seeing him on past shows, here and there.

 

I'm recovering and in one year, I didn't look red, swollen, shaky and behave like I had a bad hangover.  He sounds 'raspy' although that's a voice of booze and cigs and drugs, no doubt.

 

When will Young Dan start looking and sounding like the 'sobriety/clean year' he claims? If AA was his choice, (I'm certain it's not, or if so, it's quite 'sporadic if at all'..then he'd sound better and somewhat more 'contrite' vs 'justifying all he's done' without an ounce of gratitude.

 

Dan needs a shrink that will 'get to his insatiable need for attention' and resolve issues no 'wife' can. That's another 'life devoted to Danny's life', which must be getting pretty old over there. 

Far as the 'kids' being just fine..wait, just wait til they're 'adults' and have to start living as though they're trying to balance marbles on a ship being tossed around on an angry sea.

 

Poor Dan. Honesty was the first step for most I know, including myself to get and stay clean and sober, plus gratitude for those willing to help us. I get the feeling he 'expects it' and so far, he's right. Gretchen isn't helping him by being a new MOM vs being a partner, wife and supportive friend. He sounds like he always does, which is sad and distressing for anyone to see.

Dr. Phil was right to mention how anyone living and putting up with an alcoholic is constantly being used but this fella is in need of serious help and when he learns how to listen, he'd get a lot further ahead.

He needs a 'medical doctor' as well. Perhaps it's high blood pressure keeping him look so bad?

ML

 

Message Emote
blank
December 15, 2006, 10:27 am PST

Educate yourself on the dynamics and yes the "brainwashing techniques" of the ABUSER

Quote From: losinend

Okay, with that provocative thought and the information about  the "brainwashing" theory that you speak of, the victim is not in their "right" mind. Is that "legal" right mind? Does that defend the victim in court, lets say for example, when the victim reaches the point when she ends up killing the abuser because the victim was not in their "right mind".  Will the victim get off? Is that a legal defense? In that example, the victim did indeed make a final choice and that was to kill the abuser. But than again, the victim could have chosen to stay and take the beating or take the kids and run. Either way, a choice was made.

 

I'm not the one who needs an education. I'm not totally hip on your "brainwashing" theory.

 

 

Yes, then if you don't know of the brainwashing techniques and the Batterers and Abuser's mind games, "crazy-making" "gas lighting"  ......yes you would do yourself and everyone around you the service of educating yourself on the true dynamics of Domestic Abuse and Domestic Violence.

 

Please reach out and do so.

 

This word CHOICE gets thrown around too lightly when it comes to the women and children in domestic Violence and abuse situations.

 

Ever hear of the Stockholm Syndrome?

 

Battered Woman's Syndrome?

 

 

Its real.........its fact............its true ................   and it happens in far too many cases than you realize.

 

Domestic abuse and Domestic violence ..... is not about couples having problems......its far too complex........... its not normal at all.

 

 

 

Message Emote
blank
December 15, 2006, 10:35 am PST

Its "losinend" that you intended this post for, I believe

Quote From: stormydaughter

Look I can understand that you are a strong person and cannot possible understand how anyone can allow themselves to be abused....good for you.  Please don't presume though to act like that we all stay because of love or wanting to be loved.  Not everyone is a strong as you purport to be....some of us have problems believing in ourselves...thank God many women won't put up with it for a second.  Many of us, I believe, have grown up thinking that it is up to us to make our life work.  I remember in my abusive marriage that I kept thinking if I act better it will be better....it was for a bit.  But there was always something else to set things off again.  After awhile you are brain washed into feeling it is your fault and you just aren't doing enough.  By the time you realize that you are not doing a thing wrong, usually you are in a tight web of control...I am glad you are a strong person and have not dealt with this.  Right now I would never allow this to happen to me again...not abusive...not control....but in this not so perfect world...all of us are not perfect...some of us need help...

It was" losinend  " that you intended your post for I believe.

 

As April........was in agreement and understood.

 

Take care.

 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
December 15, 2006, 12:17 pm PST

12/08 Out-of-Control Husbands

Quote From: melanielu

I'm saddened every time I see Bonaduce as it's just 'anything for attention or money', one way or the other.

 

One thing I had to comment on, that Dr. Phil didn't 'mention'. (Dr Phil is SO right on about so much, especially the 'boy' he was dealing with).

 

Danny looks like death warmed over. A year of 'sobriety' and/or clean and sober should have him looking and sounding better than he does. I notice no difference at all from seeing him on past shows, here and there.

 

I'm recovering and in one year, I didn't look red, swollen, shaky and behave like I had a bad hangover.  He sounds 'raspy' although that's a voice of booze and cigs and drugs, no doubt.

 

When will Young Dan start looking and sounding like the 'sobriety/clean year' he claims? If AA was his choice, (I'm certain it's not, or if so, it's quite 'sporadic if at all'..then he'd sound better and somewhat more 'contrite' vs 'justifying all he's done' without an ounce of gratitude.

 

Dan needs a shrink that will 'get to his insatiable need for attention' and resolve issues no 'wife' can. That's another 'life devoted to Danny's life', which must be getting pretty old over there. 

Far as the 'kids' being just fine..wait, just wait til they're 'adults' and have to start living as though they're trying to balance marbles on a ship being tossed around on an angry sea.

 

Poor Dan. Honesty was the first step for most I know, including myself to get and stay clean and sober, plus gratitude for those willing to help us. I get the feeling he 'expects it' and so far, he's right. Gretchen isn't helping him by being a new MOM vs being a partner, wife and supportive friend. He sounds like he always does, which is sad and distressing for anyone to see.

Dr. Phil was right to mention how anyone living and putting up with an alcoholic is constantly being used but this fella is in need of serious help and when he learns how to listen, he'd get a lot further ahead.

He needs a 'medical doctor' as well. Perhaps it's high blood pressure keeping him look so bad?

ML

he is bipolar... thats alot more than just needing attention...

 

I have never used drugs to the point he has or drank, but I am on medication for bipolar and I can tell you those meds make you shake very bad, I do not look like 100% everyday. In fact after a manic phase I slept for one whole day... and looked like crap for a while after.

 

Bipolar, is very tiring and you need the right doctors BUT you also have to be very diligent with therapy and meds. Obviously he needs help in some of these areas.

 

Its never going to go away but it can be managed if he woudl just get the help he needs

 

 

 

 

First | Prev | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | Next | Last