User Mood Touched
Message Emote
|
July 7, 2008, 3:08 am PDT
I agree. Humans are violent naturally.
Quote From: j_quantzWe as a species are prone to violence. We have it in us, and it is presented in many ways. To deny that is to deny part of our humanity. That being said, we are not 'supposed' to display it. It is socially unacceptable. Yep, people still act out violently, but there are government sanctioned punishments for it. The specter of punishment doesn't seem to curtail acts of violence. Currently 10% of the population is incarcerated, most for violent crimes. Jails and prisons are overcrowded and the building of more and more facilities to house inmates is underway. It's one of the few "growth" industries in our currently depressed economy. There are forms of violence that are legislated to be acceptable in some form. Like war. Or capital punishment. The taboo against acting out violently is also circumvented and presented to us in a socailly acceptable 'fake form', such as in works of fiction, films, art, etc. Some are based on real-life incidents, some are fantasy driven scenarios. Our primitive brains are still with us, and we have this need to discharge our violent impulses in 'safe ways.' And can cite free speech to defend it. People do not necessarily act out in violence after viewing violent images. We don't need to see violent images to act out violently. Our primitive brain does it for us. But I wonder if those who relieve their primitive, violent impulses by watching and enjoying 'fake violence' would have been those who would have been a part of 'real violence' in ages past, such as the Romans who watched people being attacked and eaten by lions or slaughtered by gladiators in the Coliseum? That was certainly an accepted, government sponsored and sanctioned form of entertainment for the masses and punishment for those who violated laws or edicts. "Everybody' was doing it. The emperor approved and made it available. So it was okay, right? Or have we become more 'civilized' in this modern age? Just askin'. Then there is the question: does 'fake' violence beget 'real' violence? Or is it the other way around? Again, just askin'. I have found that most people put very little critical thought into why they do what they do. As long as it's there, available and socially 'acceptable', and fills some need, they buy into it, and defend their choices and actions as acceptable because it's not 'real'. It's just entertainment, what's the problem? IMO, the problem is that it DOES affect us in negative ways, be it desensitization to violent images, or an increase in tolerance to violence in society. We as a society are becoming MORE violent, not less. The defense has been that as long as it doesn't affect them personally, in "real' ways, it is okay. I have a hard time believing anyone who says that they enjoy seeing 'fake', socially acceptable violence but are horrified by the real kind. Or that they are two completely separate entities that do not belong together in any way, shape or form. IMO, they are two sides of the same coin. It's just that one is acceptable in this society, and one isn't. So far. One is affecting someone in negative ways and one isn't. As long as it isn't them, no harm done. Feeding our primitive, violent impulses by looking at and enjoying 'fake' violence, forms of violence that are becoming more and more disgusting, is not totally benign and harmless, IMO. Frankly, it horrifies and scares me. To me, THAT is really scary. But, I also understand that some people do view "fake" violence as entertainment only, and would never act it out or defend real violence. I just don't happen to be one of those people. And as hard as I try, I can't truly understand someone's need for that type of entertainment. Even though I possess the same primitive brain that they do. But then again, my perception of it has been 'tainted' by real life events and real-life violence that has affected me and mine. So my view of it has been colored by that reality. I do not get any pleasure out of seeing entertainment presented as violent images, murders, decapitations, killings, tortures, of any kind. Human or animal. There is enough of that really happening, really occuring. I just don't get why someone would enjoy seeing it, 'fake' as it is presented to be. Yuck. I have killed a bee because they can sting a fly, because its annoying ; a snake, because I am afraid of it; an unborn human (abortion) without too much guilt.....I am just as capable of violence as anyone else. As I get older and wiser I look at these choices and look around and see many other people doing exactly the same thing - it is in our nature to kill. We are all sentinent beings and we all suffer with this affliction. Each person has their own reason and purpose for doing what they do, or don't do, we are all on a mission a journey of self discovery, I believe we are destined from the moment in time that time itself has evolved.
I don't like to judge, even though that is what I do. My judgement is based on how I want things to turn out and anything in the way should be looked at with a close point lens making sure it doesn't get in the way of the big plan. This is where we lose consciousness and live in fear. When we live in a fear, we become frozen. Anytime we are afraid, hurt, sad, mad, happy, its because we have chosen to be this......we can blame someone that crashes into our car while at a red light, but if one thinks about it, do you really think that person actually wanted to ram you???? It becomes a personal attack when we are scared vs. life and what it throws at us and not being shaken so much.
When given a choice to see a murder movie or one about our world, philosophy, psychology, health, I would rather see the latter. Some would prefer the murder movie in a heartbeat. Does that make that person suddenly one that should be judged and ridiculed? What about the guy that wants to watch porn over having sex with his wife? In all honesty, I would rather see people evolve more spiritually and use the intuition that we all have but shove aside because doing the right thing seems so much more unobtainable when so many are doing the wrong. Its all in our evolution and I believe some of us are more evolved spiritually and some are way advanced. I believe our youth, despite all the gore and narcissistic tendancies, are right on the mark. They are not listening to adults, politicians, government and you know what??? That is a good thing.
What other people do to harm themselves and others, and take it as a personal attack , is taking that persons suffering and carrying it around with us all day. Even if someone was to put my house on fire, and he proclaims hatred towards me, I am still not offended or at least my goal is not to be offended so that it takes away my ability to be compassionate towards others. If I am not compassionate towards my enemy, then how I can I claim to be a compassionate person ? (even if only to those that I find worthy?). I had to do a lot of forgiving when I saw the medical world destroy my mother. There was neglect, incompetencies beyond my imagination, my mother died because I was afraid of her health, so I took her to the hospital. She would have lived longer had I chosen to stay out of.
I contributed to the death of my mother because I thought I knew what was right for her.....I intervened where I shouldn't have. I had to give her one last chance because I felt guilty because I felt I never did enough for her. Now she is gone, like we will all be one day. So whether we die by the hand of someone else, or by our own, or by natural causes, death is as much a part of life as life. So it is natural to think about it and even have a inquisitiveness about it. I believe, wholeheartedly, that if we stop focusing on death, we can truly live.........since we know we will all be there one day.
Violence is innate in us. I agree. I still do not like to be startled or scared by monsters or human and it just seems so inhumane to watch someone else suffering, bleeding to death. My rational mind says it is not good, my innate humaness says "well, maybe its ok". I even have difficulty watching wild animals in the jungles tearing eachothers flesh apart for food...but something about that seems acceptable. Why? Could it be we are truly a species like in the wild? We are not too far removed from the flight or fight response are we?
|