Message Boards

Topic : 07/03 Big Love

Number of Replies: 607
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 26, 2007, 01:55:18 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 1/31/07) The media bombards the public with images of stick-thin bodies, but not all men prefer these types of women. Self-proclaimed "Chubby Chasers" love their women curvy, round and voluptuous. Clayton says he likes the rolls on his wife, Cheryl's, 300-pound body, and he loves to watch her butt jiggle. Cheryl says that she wants to lose weight but fears that if she does, she might also lose her marriage. Does Clayton sabotage Cheryl to keep her overweight? Dr. Phil has a plan to get them both what they want. Then, Phillip says he prefers to date women who are at least 250 pounds. His twin brother, Paul, says he's disgusted by the plus-size women, and his brother is embarrassing the family. He even makes fun of Phillip's dates when he brings one home, calling her fat and stinky. Will these brothers ever be able to find a middle ground? And, go inside a nightclub that caters to big women and men who can't get enough of them! Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 12:56 pm PDT

What did you say?

Quote From: kate2010

"Start looking at the person, not the wrapper"

If people can see past the "wrapper," that's fantastic. But if you tell the person you're with that you love them for their looks, it's not right. You can be holding them back from achieving their goals for themselves and stopping them from living a fulfilling life. They'll be MORE confident if you love them for who they are AND they are happy with themselves.

 I hate to break it to you but the person is a part of the wrapper.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:10 pm PDT

Just Plain Mean

Oh my goodness. You have to be kidding me. The show today made me very furious. I cannot get over the the guy Paul who thought that it was just plain wrong to date obese women. That just is plain mean to judge people by there size. I'm sorry but if your going to do that... I dont think that you should be dating because then your never getting to know a person, your just judging the way they look. And that is the worse thing a person can do. However that night club for the overweight women and guys who like them I think is a great idea because its a place where they can just forget there troubles and let loose. I'm just so furious with that guy. Put yourself in there shoes, how would you like it if people pointed at you and made fun of you because of your weight. And when he said it "should" motivate them to loose weight, hes wrong and sometimes there comfort is food so if anything hes making things wayyyyy worse. I just cant even believe some of the stuff that came out of his mouth. There are just somethings that need to stay inside.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:16 pm PDT

07/03 Big Love

Quote From: meowmeow1

You can't just not look at them when they take up half the sidewalk, walddling side-to-side. Fat people are discusting and should pay more for their clothing!
 As long as you're not rude to us, you can think whatever you want, and the only person you're torturing is yourself. For instance, as an English teacher, I could let myself be bothered by people who can't spell "disgusting"--but I'd only be making message-boards and other online venues unpleasant for myself.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:16 pm PDT

big love

Hello all my name is sharon and  i married a big guy and i only weight 125lbs. soak and wet and the guy that judge fat people have to understand that fat people need love too an he's know beauty queen to be setting up there and judging people. An as for the other twin you go boy because you love who you love and the heart do not lie and have control oover who your heart love.You know that more people are more concern about the person being fat then the person them self so should we love less just because someone is a little  more heavy then you.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:20 pm PDT

07/03 Big Love

Quote From: meowmeow1

 I hate to break it to you but the person is a part of the wrapper.
 "A person is part of the wrapper" doesn't make sense. If you mean "the wrapper is part of the person," then I actually agree. I think Dr. Phil is wrong when he said on the show that being attracted to someone sexually for a physical trait is being shallow. I've learned over the years that no one can argue with physical taste in sexual attraction. If someoen doesn't like fat men, or skinny women, or tall brunettes of either sex, that's kind of like not liking chocolate, vanilla, or pistachio. Fortunately for me, a sassy fat woman, enough men do like fat women for me to be more than happy. However, everyoen derserves respect. That's different from choosing a sex partner. I'm glad Dr. Phil made that point.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:25 pm PDT

07/03 Big Love

Quote From: meowmeow1

I think that guy had a lot of guts to say the truth about nasty fat people. The difference between being  called ugly and  being called fat (when you are  the size of a car) is that one can help it and the other can't. Fat people make me sick and they say they have a disease. They shovel more food in there mouth and get fatter and fatter. It's discusting and it's a big problem in this country By saying it's ok to be this way is just letting them get away with it..

Dr Phil need to know the difference between "Voluptuous", "Big", "Fat", "Overweight" and "Obese". These women were clearly "Obese", not BBW.
 Even if I could be slender and I choose to be fat, why is that an excuse to be rude to me or call me "nasty"?

In fact, it's not that easy. Look at how many people really try hard, lose weight, but regain it. The only kind of person I will even listen to about weight-loss is someone who has lost over 60 lbs. and kept it off for over five years. Such people do exist, and I admire them. But you know what? They're generally not the people saying that fat people are lazy and sloppy.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:27 pm PDT

I think your wrong.

Quote From: meowmeow1

I think that guy had a lot of guts to say the truth about nasty fat people. The difference between being  called ugly and  being called fat (when you are  the size of a car) is that one can help it and the other can't. Fat people make me sick and they say they have a disease. They shovel more food in there mouth and get fatter and fatter. It's discusting and it's a big problem in this country By saying it's ok to be this way is just letting them get away with it..

Dr Phil need to know the difference between "Voluptuous", "Big", "Fat", "Overweight" and "Obese". These women were clearly "Obese", not BBW.

In my opinon, your wrong. You said that they make you sick by saying that they have a disease, if you think about it they are sick. Not the type of sick you would go to the doctors for, but they are at high risk for a lot of things just like anyone who was sick with the flu or virus would be. They eat a lot because thats what there bodies need to keep going. Its just like you stoping for a snack, you may not eat a lot but its a way for your body to fuel up, and thats the same for them. And were not letting them get away with anything because there is nothing to get away with. It not like its a crime or something to be obese or overweight, its not against the law and you act like they are breaking the law... and they are not!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:28 pm PDT

Ignorance is Bliss

This show does prove that not all men desire skinny women.  People in general have this idea that because your thin that you are healthy.  Look at the problem we have with anorexia and other eating disorders.  THEY AREN'T HEALTHY!  Society has pushed everyone to think that if your not thin, your not attractive or liked.  Over weight people are people, they have feelings and just because they look different why does anyone have the right to judge?  I personally don't like a lot of thin people because they have no personality or brains.  I think there are a lot of skinny attractive people who think that they can get by in this world solely on their looks. They look down on other people and they think they have been given the right to judge because they are thin.  I think that if someone is happy with themselves and content to be over weight, they have chosen that life for themselves.  Unless your completely sheltered, we all know the health risks to being over weight and having someone badger you because of your looks is not going to motivate you to lose weight.  Dr. Phil recognizes the health risks involved with these individuals but also realizes that they are people.  I have more respect for a person who is heavy and confident with themselves.   We also have to remember that back in the 1800's women who were bigger were considered beautiful.  It just goes to prove that society has changed and the media/advertising medium have dictated to us as whole what is beautiful.   I have a brother who is excessively over weight.  I love him for who he is but wish he would lose some weight so that he would be healthier.  I want him to be around for a long time.  I have no right to judge him because I'm anything but skinny.  But I am concerned about his health and I really do want him to be around for a while!   I see both sides of the equation but I do not desire to be thin or skinny.  I strive to be healthy and happy no matter what my size! 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:33 pm PDT

07/03 Big Love

Quote From: bzfran

 I too am a happily married BBW.  I agree 100%.  If you love someone you want them to be healthy so that you can live longer happier lives together.
I'm married and I'm a BBW.  I believe that you can be big, beautiful and healthy.  I have no desire to be thin or look like everyone else.  I just want to be healthy and be around for a long time so I can share my dreams and goals with my wonderful husband.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 1:36 pm PDT

07/03 Big Love

Quote From: cwarford

I really believe that the reason any man would want his female partner to stay overweight would be the fact that he has some insecurities.  I agree that some men do not object to having a woman that is a little heafty or thick but to be extremely overweight or unhealthy just shows he is not secure in himself.  If a woman wants to lose weight she needs to do so.  She would be better off healthy and without him than overweight, unhealthy and with him!
No, really, there are many other reasons to enjoy a fat partner:  softness, warmth,  a lot to grope--and this is totally apart from being attracted to  a pleasant, intelligent, friendly, funny, and otherwise nice person who just happens to be fat. Actually, in today's society, a person needs *more* self-confidence to date a fat person, as the show demonstrated.  You have to be strong enough to know what you like and not go with what others say you should like.

Also, I think there's less conflict between living a healthy life and having a fat-loving spouse than people seem to be assuming.  Many fat people can live very healthy lives, exercise and eat wonderfully, and lose weight--but still be fat, just less fat. It's very rare for someone who's clinically obese to reach insurance-chart weights and stay there; but losing only 10% of your weight can improve health. I'm fat, and that's certainly been the case with me. 

Also, do you feel that all people whose spouses are unhealthy are insecure? What about someone who marries someone in a wheelchair or blind due to a disease? Or someone with cancer? I'd say, again, that they may well be stronger than most people, not weaker.
 
 
First | Prev | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | Next | Last