Message Boards

Topic : 07/16 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Number of Replies: 422
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 02, 2007, 02:58:57 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 02/05/07) Meet three women ready to divorce their controlling and chauvinistic husbands. In a last-ditch effort to save their marriages – and their sanity – Tara, Amanda and Cherie turn their husbands in to Dr. Phil’s Man Camp, an intensive week-long stay in The Dr. Phil House designed to give them an attitude adjustment and a new appreciation for their wives. Scott has anger issues, Nic had an emotional affair and John thinks he’s superior to all women. Because the wives are also guilty of everything from name-calling to cheating, Dr. Phil brings them in too, unbeknownst to their husbands. All the women say they are tired of being treated like maids, so while the husbands are away, the wives mess up The Dr. Phil House -- in spectacular fashion! Years of pent-up frustration leave the house in a colossal disarray. When the men see the destruction and learn it is their time to clean, tempers flare. One husband refuses to participate and demands an explanation. After a heated discussion, he hangs up on Dr. Phil and storms out, leaving his heart-broken wife behind. Can she convince her husband to return with a participative spirit, or is this the end of their stay … and their relationship? Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 9:45 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: gwarrior6

You have to give her credit for getting the help.  If she was yelling at her husband in front of her daughter and NOT getting help, that would be one thing.  But she's trying to improve the situation-at least that's progress.  No parent is perfect, but she's going on national tv and saying "I'm a bad parent".  That's got to be hard-and hard for her husband to be the bad guy to get help.

 

I do agree that if you do choose to go on national tv, you are putting yourself out there for criticism.  You have to know that some people aren't going to like you or agree with everything you say- big deal.  Who cares?  None of us are in her life, so i don't see how it matters.

Sometimes I really doubt the people on these shows really want help. Really. I think they are all getting their "pay off" from each other for behaving like this and being in front of an audience just makes it all that much more juicy for them.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 9:48 am PST

Hey

Quote From: ricschic

I just want to let you know that there is a message board on this site dedicated to abused women. Whether it be the survivors, or those living with it still every day of their lives. There is helpful information, and resources as well. It's there if you just need to vent as well. There is a common denominator there, the fact that all the women have been or are being abused. Please check it out....
Hey, thank you very much. I will go check it out.  THANK YOU!
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 9:53 am PST

Growing up

     For Tara and Scott, I think there's just a whole lot of growing up that needs doing. I used to run after my highschool boyfriend like that when I was 19. I loved and hated the drama at the same time. At 20, we broke up. We were too immature to have a relationship that serious. Luckily, we always used protection, so there were no children. We both knew that would have been a disaster. I shudder to imagine what might have happened to a child in a house with the two of us.
On the subject of growing up, it comes with time, or radical change. Remember when you were a kid and  your Mom said, clean your room! And you argued and argued and argued. By the time you were done complaining about it, you could have had it finished and been gone, but when you're a kid, you don't see that. Scott is still a kid and so is Tara. They're kids with a kid. I hope they get things worked out by the end of the show. Sometimes you just have to knuckle down and do something you'd rather not do. Sometimes you don't get to freak out on the world around you, it's not appropriate. Sometimes you have to be nice and calm, even when you're angry. The day you can start to do this, when you can control your emotions and not let them control you, then you're growing up. I wish everyone on the show the best of luck!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 10:06 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: gwarrior6

You have to give her credit for getting the help.  If she was yelling at her husband in front of her daughter and NOT getting help, that would be one thing.  But she's trying to improve the situation-at least that's progress.  No parent is perfect, but she's going on national tv and saying "I'm a bad parent".  That's got to be hard-and hard for her husband to be the bad guy to get help.

 

I do agree that if you do choose to go on national tv, you are putting yourself out there for criticism.  You have to know that some people aren't going to like you or agree with everything you say- big deal.  Who cares?  None of us are in her life, so i don't see how it matters.

hey thanks for your consideration. i really appreciate it. I guess you are one of the more mature ones. Look i am not sticking up for scott behavior... You know no one has even thought about this...if he is so bad then why is he there...he did not have to go i am the one that signed up for this. He thought he would give it a try. they did not tell us before we went that we were going to have to do the exercises or maybe scott would not have gone. all i am saying is that apparently he knew he had a problem or he would not have been there to begin with. I think the world would be much better if everyone would notice a few positives to go with the negatives, maybe the world would not be so hateful...anyway thank you very much..and about the national tv thing well i dont think you can just call up the best realationship counselor in the world and set up and appointment...you have to go on tv to air this business and besides that is negagive thinking again becuase scott and i putting that out there is helpin others with the same problems. so say what you want but truth be known their life must be pretty bad if all they have to do is be negative toward people they dont even know.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 10:28 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: taramichelle

hey thanks for your consideration. i really appreciate it. I guess you are one of the more mature ones. Look i am not sticking up for scott behavior... You know no one has even thought about this...if he is so bad then why is he there...he did not have to go i am the one that signed up for this. He thought he would give it a try. they did not tell us before we went that we were going to have to do the exercises or maybe scott would not have gone. all i am saying is that apparently he knew he had a problem or he would not have been there to begin with. I think the world would be much better if everyone would notice a few positives to go with the negatives, maybe the world would not be so hateful...anyway thank you very much..and about the national tv thing well i dont think you can just call up the best realationship counselor in the world and set up and appointment...you have to go on tv to air this business and besides that is negagive thinking again becuase scott and i putting that out there is helpin others with the same problems. so say what you want but truth be known their life must be pretty bad if all they have to do is be negative toward people they dont even know.
Three things.

1-Yes I did think of  "if he is so bad then why is he there"...and I think that one some level you guys get off on screaming at each other this way and I think an audience makes it even better for you.

2-If doing a few exercises would have stopped him from going then he's an even bigger jerk.

3-How are your Scott apologetics helping other women?
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 10:33 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: taramichelle

hey thanks for your consideration. i really appreciate it. I guess you are one of the more mature ones. Look i am not sticking up for scott behavior... You know no one has even thought about this...if he is so bad then why is he there...he did not have to go i am the one that signed up for this. He thought he would give it a try. they did not tell us before we went that we were going to have to do the exercises or maybe scott would not have gone. all i am saying is that apparently he knew he had a problem or he would not have been there to begin with. I think the world would be much better if everyone would notice a few positives to go with the negatives, maybe the world would not be so hateful...anyway thank you very much..and about the national tv thing well i dont think you can just call up the best realationship counselor in the world and set up and appointment...you have to go on tv to air this business and besides that is negagive thinking again becuase scott and i putting that out there is helpin others with the same problems. so say what you want but truth be known their life must be pretty bad if all they have to do is be negative toward people they dont even know.
BTW, just because someone disagrees with you doesn't make them immature. That accusation is so ironically immature.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 11:09 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: penny_lady

BTW, just because someone disagrees with you doesn't make them immature. That accusation is so ironically immature.
hey you are alot like me you always have to have the last word!! Dr.phil will talk about that in a later episode. you should tune in
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 11:14 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

I could not believe what I was hearing and seeing when I was watching this show. It was amazing that these woman would let this go on for so long. I mean I completely understand that when you love someone so much and have a child with them it may be very hard to just walk away but come on already! This is affecting their children most importantly, themselves and everyone else around them. How could you put up with that cruel treatment day after day. You loose your self esteem and most importantly your sanity. I wish all these woman the best of luck in getting the help their relationship needs to be healthy again and or the strength to move on and live their lives to the fullest with complete happiness.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 11:18 am PST

02/05 The Dr. Phil House: Man Camp

Quote From: taramichelle

hey you are alot like me you always have to have the last word!! Dr.phil will talk about that in a later episode. you should tune in
I actually don't have a "last word issue" I was simply making another post because I had more to say.

Instead of attacking people on a message board why don't you take your anger out on those who deserve it.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
February 6, 2007, 11:43 am PST

You Said "It In A NutShell'

Quote From: fluffyfat

I feel like I'm betraying my gender a little but really, just because we can have babies and men can't is no reason to act like women suffer all day every day while men enjoy a bed of roses. I've worked full-time and I've been a SAHM and I always managed to keep the house clean and the laundry caught up with no help from my husband. I'm not saying it isn't nice if they do help and everyone should pick up after themselves, but if I'm home all day, with time to watch Dr. Phil, while my husband is out working non-stop for 8-10 hours then why on earth should he have to come home and help me do dishes? I've seen the men have to do the woman's work on several of these shows but I've never seen the woman go off and do the man's job. I consider myself a feminist. I believe in equal pay for equal work and equal opportunities in education and employment. What I don't get is why men should have to treat their wives like helpless infants who aren't capable of keeping up their half of the deal. These men today were obnoxious. They should never, ever talk to their wives with disrespect or treat their wives like sex workers. On the other hand the women hold responsibility, too. They themselves were all seen usuing vulgar language and one woman has chosen to actually be a sex worker. Maybe if they behaved a little better they would be treated a little better.

I have to respond to your quote. I am glad to hear you response, because I was starting to believe that a good mother and wife like yourself doesn't exist anymore. I am glad a SAHM believe that both parties are responsible to keep the marriage going and correct their own faults insteadof blaming each other. I am not bragging on you, but I could just kiss and huggyou because that's what I would like my wife to say. I try hard to provide and please my wife but society is putting pressure on the SAHM to go to work. Now my wife is  thinking that homelife is boring and ancient. My wife is out searching for a job after 9 years of being a domestic engineer and homeschool teacher. No one needs abuse - husband or wife but negioation where both become winners or as I would say "everyone gets a piece of the pie."

 

Women stand up for your husbands!

 
First | Prev | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | Next | Last