Message Boards

Topic : 08/13 The Dr. Phil House: Saving Grace

Number of Replies: 1627
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 06, 2007, 11:30:39 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/09/07) Two-and-a-half years ago, Cat and Todd left their 6-year-old daughter, Grace, with Todd’s parents for the night. Little did they know, it would be the night that changed their family forever. Grace’s grandfather, Steve, molested her, and after Grace told her grandmother, Ann, about it, Ann failed to report it. After confronting Todd’s parents, Cat and Todd pressed charges. Steve served eight months in jail and is now a registered sex offender. Neither he nor Ann has seen Cat, Todd or their grandchildren in over two years, but they desperately want to put their family back together. Steve says he’s ready to do what he can to heal his family, but Todd and Cat are not convinced. What does Steve say is his reason for stealing Grace's innocence? Dr. Phil meets with the grandparents and gets to the truth of what really happened, while Todd and Cat watch from behind a two-way mirror. Will the unvarnished truth be too much for them to handle? Can this fractured family ever heal and move on? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More August 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
April 9, 2007, 11:59 pm PDT

More to the story?

First off I like to say that the grandfather should never see or talk to that child or any other child!! The grandmother should not be able to see her either till she finally gets a grip on the situation. I can not believe that in over two years she still doesn't get!!! I find her more guilty than her sick husband. One for the obvious, not telling the parents and getting her out of the home immediately, but for getting upset at her own son for calling the police! I couldn't believe my ears when she said,"... we could of handled this with in the family"!!!!!!!

 

In addition, I think there is more to the grandfathers story that maybe no one yet knows or will ever know. I can not believe that in his 62 years he has not done something like this before. Either to another family member or to a stranger. His statement about how "she liked", or " I never thought she would tell", makes me think he has gotten away with this behavior before and I urge that person(s) to come forward. That 8 month jail time is a joke!! This girl and her family are going to suffer in some way for the rest of their lives. Obviously from watching the show he doesn't get it, he didn't even seem sorry for what he did!!!! Another reason why I think he has done this before.

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 12:14 am PDT

Saving Grace "Forever"

I am not even done watching the entire show and I had to comment on what I know is true from experience. My own mother disregarded my cry for help at the age of 4 when my uncle was abusing me. I was in turmoil for years and after years of therapy, too many unresolved issues as an indirect response from the trauma, and so much more that I do not want to mention, I recently found the power to let go and forgive my mom for her choices. I am still very angry about it, and watching this show with the Grandmother to Grace who is in fact enabling her husband and who is not now or has ever done the right thing by protecting her poor grandchild, just infuriates me. She is just as sick as the grandfather is. Had my mother just validated my cries for help, instead of ignoring me, not only would I have felt like someone cared about me, but perhaps my uncle could of been stopped. I should mention that my uncle did get his own daughter pregnant, while his  own wife stood by him. He never went to jail.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 12:40 am PDT

Saving Grace

Dear Dr Phil,

I work part time and when I have to work, I tape your shows. I find you to be so intelligent and on the money with issues. I started watching your show after work tonight ( at 12:45 AM ) on Saving Grace. ALOT of what you said hit home for me personally since I was molested at an early age by my Grandfather ( I wont call him Grandpa because he dont deserve that title ). He not only molested ME but other family  members! ( LONG STORY ). HE NEVER SPENT ONE DAY IN JAIL or was told to the authorities!! You stated that Graces Grandmother should have protected her because after all Grace told her it happened and yet she covered it up. My family never sent my Grandfather to jail because they thought if my uncle knew he would literally KILL him! He was finally told after my Grandfather passed away. Naturally he was mad  to say the least  which is one of the feelings he felt I am sure.

 

I am glad that you had Grace's parents in another room actually listening to what REALLY happened to poor Grace, the TRUTH. I found it amazing how he could claim that the DEVIL made him do it, and that NOW he is a born again Christian. Well let me say this, a BORN again CHRISTIAN would ADMIT his fault, REPENT and ask for FORGIVENESS to all that he has hurt include Christ himself and not put on this poor me, I didnt do it the devil did!!! What CRAP! YOU Dr. Phil really SEE through people and that is why I love your show, not to mention that I learn from you, Thank you!

 

Dr Phil I also noticed that his wife was holding his hand through the entire show, how disguesting is that, what denial she is in herself. I would NEVER let Grace see her Grandparents, either one of them since they cannot own up to what they each did to her!

 

Another thing I want to point out Dr Phil is that this is a LIFE changing thing for the victim!! I have forgiven my Grandfather after years of therapy, however it at times still affects my realtionships today and it certainly affected my realtionships in the past.

 

I am looking forward to watching part 2 and having Grace tell her story, we all have one. Unfortunately there is so many people out in the world that have been molested in one way or another ( and YES it IS sex even without penetration!!) and are either afraid or STUFF the feelings inside and TRY to go on with life.

I also feel that he SHOULD indeed register as a sex offender and that he really had no right to hide his apearance, we NEED to know what these people look like.

 

Keep up the great job Dr Phil.

SweetSherrie

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
angry
April 10, 2007, 12:41 am PDT

I really can't take it...

...when goons like this try to excuse their behavior with religious jargon like possessed, devil made them.

 

And then they have the utter gall to decide that their supreme being (like they had a direct email from him/her) forgives them or even that they just "accept" their supreme being (like they were atheists when they raped the child) wipes it all away,

 

Look, I believe in God, but they should stop using their relationship or lack of as an excuse. Even assuming that they know, "God forgives them," according to my relgion (I'm Jewish) they can only be forgiven  by God for sins against God, and not for sins against another person. For that kind of forgiveness they gotta fess up that what they did was wrong and ask forgiveness from the victim.

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
sad
April 10, 2007, 1:18 am PDT

Thanks to Mom for SAVING GRACE!!

Thank you to the MOM for taking such quick action and not ignoring or blowing off Grace's revealing of her abuse. I kept wanting to jump thru the TV and hug Cat for her courage and for doing the right thing without hesitation and for crying for her daughter. I wanted to scream at both GP's (and did at the TV more than once) for trying to defend their actions and saying they should have talked about it between them before the police were called. There is NO excuse for what either of them did. The grandfather has NO remorse and the grandmother was supposed to be the adult and protect that child with everything she had...both said thay would do the same thing again!!!!!!!!! We'll see how next weeks show goes as far as the Dad. He seemed sincere but I was worried that he had so little compassion for his daughter and so much for his father...I caught a hint at the end that he might be understanding that maybe his father didn't deserve his compassion and concern. Like I said, we'll see.

I have personal experience from Grace's point of view...except that it was my brother and not my GF. I was molested by my older brother from the age of 6 until he left home when I was 13...he was 4 years older. I am now 45, have never told my family what happened, and it still effects my life a great deal. My parents were there in body but not in spirit...I was always well fed, clothed, etc. and I'm sure we looked like the typical "happy family" from the outside but my concerns and mental health were almost always blown off and ignored...and sometimes my physical health. I lost trust in my parents (and people in general) early on because some of the smaller issues were ignored...I still have trust issues with every person in my life! I have spent almost every special occasion, holiday and birthday around my brother and I can't say it has made the days more festive. I cringe whenever he gets close to me or hugs me, I do my best to sit as far away from him as possible at the table or when the family is sitting around visiting and I still worry that my family will find out and blame me...he told me he would tell my family it was my fault if I ever told after he forced me to perform oral sex on him at age 11 (that still makes me want to vomit). Some of the touching and "milder" (if you can call it that) abuse felt good to me because at least I was getting some attention...even if it wasn't the kind I needed...and that has caused a great deal of confusion for me. Basically, because of the abuse and my inability to reveal it and get help until about the time I turned 30 (when I was considering suicide, was deep in a major depression, and simply didn't want to hurt any more), I have very little self esteem (even after years of counseling), constantly question my worth and my own instincts, and feel permanantly damaged. I have occassional moments when things are going well when I actually feel reasonably human and can feel what I imagine "normal" people feel like but it never lasts more that a few days. I have to say that I have had quite a few major events in my life (house fire at 16, parents very ugly divorce at 18, loss of several family members, etc, etc.) but I can honestly say that none of them has made as big an impact on my entire being or effected my life as entirely as the sexual abuse or the fact that my parents weren't present enough to notice or make me feel loved and safe enough to reveal the truth. At this point I will give myself a pat on the back and say, in spite of it all, something inside me has gotten me into my 46th year, gotten me to go back to college in my 30's and graduate (something I never thought I was smart enough to do) with a 3.775 GPA, gotten me interested in art, and kept me from ending my life many times. Don't know what it is but it has been there so far and hope it continues to be.

I am by no means an expert but I can understand how hard it must have been for that dear innocent child to not only reveal her abuse to her grandmother and have it brushed off like a daydream but then to have to reveal it again to her mother. She is one brave little girl...I wish I had half her courage. At this point, my guess is she may not totally understand the gravity of what has happened to her but, considering the response of her grandparents on today's show, I wouldn't let either one of them near her. When Grace is an adult, and understands, then it would be up to her if she wanted contact with either of them. In any case, the child's best interests should be first and foremost until she is grown and can make her own decisions. As someone said in another post...DNA should mean nothing in what happens from now on. Just because they are her grandparents doesn't necessarily mean they should be a part of her life. I'll be interested to see Grace's side of things (again, a very brave and strong little girl) next week and see what else happens. Thsi was a very difficult show for me to watch and brought up a huge amount of pain and frustration but it has also helped me look at things from an another perspective I haven't had much chance to see before...

Thank you to Dr. Phil, Grace, and Grace's family for being willing to open themselves up on the show... it has effected me very deeply as I'm sure it has so many others. Anything that brings these kinds of situations into the light helps those children who CAN'T speak up.

Aimee



 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 1:27 am PDT

too many sick people in this world

I had a hard time watching the show but made myself watch it cause I was an abused child and then in my marriage. I guess I am still trying to figure out what makes people think they have such a right to someone's body like that. Why they need that control over another human being. I was so controlled and believed for years it was all my fault. My father touched me and then my step-father. I was in and out of foster homes til I went and got emancipated at 18. I will have scars for the rest of my life from what the abuse caused. The one thing this little girl has going for her is two good parents who are they for her. I understand the parents wanting to get their family back together but I don't see that happening or in the best interest of the child. The grandfather will do it again. My step-father had six months of therapy while I was sent to foster home, came back and he tried to do it again. I was 15 then and old enough to run away. I was charged with being an unruly child, spent a night in jail, and never looked back again. I lost my mother over it, she sided with him, and then she died in my senior year, after finding out that I told her the truth about him.  My step-father done all this and I blame him for my mother's death in a round about way. When she found out that I told her the truth, 3 yrs prior, she died of a massive heart attack that night. My step-father blamed it on his alcoholism. My mother was a very naiive person and not a strong woman to take care of herself, I can't blame her. The one thing I do blame her for is the fact that I long for a mother now. I raised 3 kids and there were lots of times I wished to have had a mother to call or calling someone mom. I feel I got the short end of the stick and I am a very private person because of it I think. I don't feel whole or normal for the most part. I find myself very sad at times when I long for that kind of a relationship that I was cheated out of. I was raped of my innocence and then he took my family away from me. No one said that life was fair and it isn't. I feel very sorry for what this pervert done to this family. If the grandmother loves her son and granddaughter then she better wake up and see how things really are in her household before it is too late and she finds herself all alone some day, yearning to have some kind of family helping her in her golden years.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 1:57 am PDT

04/09 The Dr. Phil House: Saving Grace

Quote From: sun_shinemary

You really need to talk to a professional about what happened to you.  My heart breaks for you with what you have been living with all these years. I am a survivor and have been in and out of therapy for about 17 years.  If your health insurance does not cover therapy, check with your local health department.  I know it seems like it wont do any good to dig all that stuff up after all these years, but take it from one who has lived it, you can take your life back.  I will be praying for you.  Please get the help you so desprately need.

I am sorry to read that your brother done this to you. I am a mom and my daughter and son both were sexually abused by their older brother while growing up. My oldest son went to prison and is out now. It isn't easy on the family but I as their mother have to protect them so we don't have their older brother around them at all. It is hard on me not having all my children present at family gatherings but that is what my two youngest prefer even after having therapy. It is their right and they need to feel safe, even as adults. I often wonder if my son would molest someone else's child since he abused his siblings. He is a registered sex offender and is in therapy but is quite mad at the fact his siblings want nothing to do with him now. He says he is sorry and he done the time but he just doesn't get it. He has no empathy in him. How can one move on in life if they have not bothered to deal with past issues? You owe it to yourself to learn all you can about your past and allow yourself to grieve and get past the shame it has caused. Then you will know if you can still attend these family gatherings knowing your brother will be there. Please get the help you need to take care of yourself and feel free again. If and when you decide to tell your parents, I hope they are the understanding, caring kind and will know in their hearts you are not making this up and be there for you. Your therapist , whom should be trained in childhood sexual abuse, can help you with all this. My heart and prayers goes out to you as you go through your recovery.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 2:39 am PDT

04/09 The Dr. Phil House: Saving Grace

I actually wanted to vomit watching this episode. But thank God for it. I have never had this much  insight into a molester ways. The more we know about how these people operate, the more we can protect our children.

 

And ONLY 8 months in county lock up!?!  I am geting so sick of these pedophiles geting such lax sentences. I don't want to hear about another Polly Klaas or Jessica Lunsford. It's got to end. How many more children have to pay with their lives before people wake up and do something about this?

 

And as a devout Christian I have to add this since it was brought up on the show. Yes, in the Christian faith we believe in the existence of satan and demons. The devil is the master at luring and deceiving. But at the end of the day, we recongnize that we have free will, the choice to say no to the devil. I am tired of people professing their faith in God and using backsliding as a reasonable excuse for their sin. Also in the Christian faith, we are taught to know that although we sin and may ask for forgiveness, that we may not be freed of all repercussions of what that sin caused. Like in this pedophile's case, loosing his family. A person who recognizes what he has done would realize it would be unacceptable to have a future relationship with this child. God says to forgive, but He also says to not be a fool. And it would be foolish to trust a pedophile.

 

I feel awful for that pedophile's wife. She definitely was wrong for her part in it and probably should have gone to jail for it too. I just don't think she can even face what's right in front of her. Her facade is falling apart. She wants to believe so bad that this is just a small avoidable problem. She's holding on tight to a fantasy. I will be praying for her because what's happened is going to hit and hard. I will also be praying for this child and her parents. I know how bad just watching this episode made me want to vomit, but to have to actually live it. I can't even imagine. God bless 'em.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 3:23 am PDT

IN Grace's Father's shoe's

My father is a convicted child molester.He molested his granddaughter when she was 6 years old.It is ok to not have a relationship with your father actually it would be in your daughter's best interest for you to never speak to either of them.I haven't spoken to my father since this tragedy was brought out in the open.I think my father is a very disgusting and nasty man.MY children are not aloud to see him or to speak to him.I hate him for what he has done.He only spent a year and in my opinion he should be spending a life sentence for what he did to that innocent little girl.If u let Gracie have a relationship with her grandparent's you will only be opening up a door for him to violate her once again please think about what you would be doing to your daughter.
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
sad
April 10, 2007, 3:31 am PDT

My heart is broken for Saving Grace.

 At the age of eleven, a trusted friend of my family, started molesting me. The molestation continued two or three times weekly until I turned fifteen. As a child of eleven, I was terrified to tell, terrified that no one would believe me, terrified that my father would've choked the SOB until he was dead, there would've been no pulling him off of the man. How horrible that this six year old child that actually had the courage to tell, told and was completely betrayed by a grandmother. How strong Saving Grace was to be able to tell her mother after her grandmother betrayed her. Only three years ago, eleven years after it stopped happening to me, did I actually trust anyone enough or feel safe enough to tell. It is a very slow process for me, my parents still do not know and I don't know if I'll ever be able to tell them. Only the man I am married to now, did I feel I could trust. Only now, at the age of 28, have I got the courage to talk about what happened, because the man that molested me, was a man that I loved and a man that my family trusted. The only good thing that has come from my situation, is that as a mother of four children, two of which are 7 & 5 yr old girls, I can communicate with them in their language, and I have explained good and bad touching, and also have left a open line of discussion, so that they  feel they can come to me and ask anything or tell anything. I feel that Graces grandfather and her grandmother have no right in her life, and I'm enraged also at her father for the lack of emotion for his daughters ordeal. Graces mother, I feel, has been the only one to do right by her daughter. This child, as with so many others will be in my prayers, for what can only be called an epidemic. So little of the cases go untold and unpunished. This "epidemic", we must remember not only runs rampant in little  girls but also in little boys . So leave the communication lines open for your children. It is better to believe your child and it not be true, than to not believe and for it to be true. May God protect our children.
 
First | Prev | 62 | 63 | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | Next | Last