Quote From: chudsonIf you had watched the second half of the show then you would understand that this was simply not a case of a birth mother "changing her mind". She had an absolutely devastating disease that she suffered with for almost 9 months. Imagine how you would feel if you had not digested ANY food or drink for that long. The reason Dr. Phil did this show even when the adoptive "parents" did not want to participate is because he felt that what he learned about Hyperemesis was so horrible that it needed to be discussed on national television.
I understand that adoptive parents go through a lot, but this is not about adoptive parents, this is about women with HYPEREMESIS!!! Dr. Phil is a hero for finally given us a voice.
When you were adopting would you have gone through with it if the birth mother had changed her mind at least twice in three days and even called 911 about it? Although the adoptive parents were desperate for children, they should have seen these red flags and backed out themselves. Desperation is no excuse for being selfish and irresponsible. I would hardly call them gracious for agreeing to an open adoption considering that they had to meet with her for 11 hours to convince her to adoption at all.
The children may be affected by being moved at almost 2 years old, but if the adoptive "parents" had done the right thing, the children would have been back with their MOTHER a long time ago. The children will recover from "reactive attachment disorder" easily since they have infantile amnesia until the age of 4 or 5 (the age when we all develop our long term memory).
I have a lot of sympathy for anyone who can not give birth to children of their own and I think that adoption is a wonderful thing. However, the point of this story is not about the flaws of adoption.It is about the fact that Hyperemesis is so harsh that it can cause a woman to make a decision that she will regret the rest of her life. She is not trying to change the laws in Florida because she is too busy trying to get HER children back. I pray that she does.
I watched the second half of the show. It is about more than HG too. He could have addressed the HG without touching on the adoption issue. I am happy for Dr. Phil for addressing the issue, but at the same time, it royally pisses me off that he refused to even address the adoptive parents as parents. They are and have been for almost two years. Blood does not make a parent, cleaning up puke, changing diapers, holding that child in the middle of the night, now that is a parent.
The family has stated repeatedly that the adoption records are closed and that the kids story is theirs and only theirs.
While I personally would not go through in this case, but I am not the adoptive parents in this case, and let me tell you. If I were, Quets would have never made it to jail. I would defend my daughter with life if it came to that.
Do you know something that the rest of us don't. Do you know that the adoptive parents were in the attorney's office.
I think if anything the adoptive family is following King Solomon's example. They are doing what is best for the kids and keeping them out of the media. The adoption is legal and binding and like I said. She knew going in what the laws were. More than twice she considered adoption. ONly one of the kids, both of the kids. I have NO SYMPATHY for this woman. Infantile Amnesia??? What is your earliest memory, mine is at age 3 at a preschool in Maine. Reactive attachment disorder is not something that is easily overcome. I know a couple who has been through it. It's not so easy. Whatever. Dr. Phil totally disrespected the adoptive parents and that is what ticks me off the most. He didn't call Alison or her attorney on the many holes in her account of what happened. BTW, considering the adoptive parents are the kids legal guardians...how did Alison obtain passports for them. additionally, she stated she hadn't really thought about it before she did it, but the problem is, passports take time. She knew what she was doing and she had no intention of coming back.