Message Boards

Topic : 04/12 Twin Tug of War

Number of Replies: 849
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 06, 2007, 11:39:40 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Allison Quets made headlines around the world when she allegedly kidnapped her 17-month-old twins across the border into Canada this past Christmas. She had given them up for adoption, but did she do so under duress? She now says she suffered from a pregnancy disease called hyperemesis that left her malnourished and sleep deprived to the point of complete exhaustion. See an exclusive interview with Allison from behind bars where she awaits trial on two counts of international parental kidnapping, with a possible sentence of three years behind bars. Then, look inside the life of a woman who is only three-and-a-half months pregnant and so sick with hyperemesis she spends most of her day on the bathroom floor. Plus, find out what all women need to know about hyperemesis: How you get it, how to know you have it, and whether it could kill you or your unborn child. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More April 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.


Message Emote
blank
April 14, 2007, 10:48 pm PDT

04/12 Twin Tug of War

Quote From: housewife52

I had never heard of Hyperemesis. I looked it up just to see if I could find some information about it. It said that it is rare. More African-Americans have it than Caucasions. Is that pretty much true? There was a lot of information about treatments. I didn't have it with my 2 pregnancies. I'm just interested in knowing about it. It has got to be a devastating illness. I wonder if the mother of the twins was treated unfairly? This illness certainly need to be discussed.
Have you had the opportunity to visit the H.E.R. Foundation website?  www.helpher.org  There is extensive information on Hyperemesis.  There doesn't seem to be any sort of racial distinction in the women, but there does appear to be inherited in some cases. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 14, 2007, 10:50 pm PDT

04/12 Twin Tug of War

Quote From: maesmommy

Since obviously, you didn't grasp the tone and intent of my original message.

 

1.  The laws in Florida may be archaic, but they are the laws.   How many times would you suggest she sign over the children before it's considered a legal and binding adoption? 

 

2.  My husband and I after FOUR failed domestic adoption attempts CHOSE to invest our hearts and souls where we would come home with a China.  God led us to China.  We chose international adoption after the failed domestic adoptions.  We will never have birth mother issues, my daughter was abandoned on the steps of a kindergarten.  Thankfully, her birth family chose 1. not to abort and 2. not to kill her.  Infanticide is still a common practice in rural China. 

 

3. Why should the adoptive parents lose the children they have loved since the day they were placed in their arms.  I don't know about you, but I bonded with my daughter the moment she was placed in my arms that hot afternoon in China.  Actually, I loved her from the first picture, but it took me two months to get her in my arms. 

 

4. The adoptive family, despite having an open adoption, can sever communication at will at any time.  They chose to let Alison remain in contact.  How do you know they didn't look at the best interest of the children.  The woman is still not all there.  Remember, one court already held up the adoption. 

 

5.  Reactive attachment disorder does not have to do with the circumstance that the child came from.  It comes from removing a child from the only environment they have ever known.  The children have bonded with their caregivers in the orphanage regardless of the lack of resources.  They still have a BOND with the caregivers.  Infants and children adopt with those that supply their vital needs, food, safety, warmth and comfort. 

 

I pray that the courts sever any and all parental rights for Alison Quets, I hope she serves consecutive sentences for parental kidnapping.  She obtained passports for those children despite not being their legal guardian.  Considering the time to obtain passports, two to six weeks, there was forethought in what she did.  Additionally, she forged a federal document.  She signed as the children's legal guardian, which by Florida law and decree, she is not.

 

The children were not stolen from the parent, she gave up her rights TWICE.  The first time when she signed the paperwork and then called 911, and then again 3 days later.  I give the adoptive family credit for refusing to try this whole thing in the media and on the Dr. Phil show. 

1. And, how many times would YOU suggest she immediately request the papers back before someone get a clue that she was struggling with this decision.  And, how many hours do you suppose you have to be held in an attorney's office before it's coercion.

 

2.  My husband and I considered a China adoption for the same reason as you.  Too bad this couple did not do the same.  But then again, what's cheaper and faster than a private, pre-arranged adoption with a mother in distress?

 

3.  Possibly, Allison bonded with her children as she was struggled for months to sustain her pregnancy with them.  And then perhaps, more so after they were placed in her arms.  Or perhaps, while she cared for them for the time that she had them.

 

4. "The woman is still not all there."   Your genuine knowledge of this?  Or, are you basing it on the science of shifty eyes like a few others?

 

5. "Reactive attachment disorder does not have to do with the circumstance that the child came from.  It comes from removing a child from the only environment they have ever known.  The children have bonded with their caregivers in the orphanage regardless of the lack of resources."  Based on this statement, you have opened your own child up to reactive attachment disorder.  And, the custodial parents, in this case, are not the only parent these babies have known. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 14, 2007, 10:56 pm PDT

04/12 Twin Tug of War

Quote From: dink1958

I think everyone on the message boards misses the point..This woman broke the law....and as far as I am concerned she is uing this illness for an excuse for her behavior..I sympathize with anyone who has had this disease, but it is no excuse for breaking the law..She took those children out of the US illegally and no matter what disease she had , she should suffer the consequenses of breaking the law like anyone else..And aren't u people tired of people using every excuse imaginable for breaking the law..and that is what people hire smart lawyer for, to find them an excuse to get around the law....Wake up.This woman gave those children awway and then because she couldn't get them back using the legal system, she stole them...

Dink,

 

Maybe we are just missing your point. 

 

"And aren't u people tired of people using every excuse imaginable for breaking the law.."

 

And, maybe "us people" recognize she only used one excuse, and it's medically documented by her hospital records.  Hmmm......that was a toughy.

 

Message Emote
blank
April 14, 2007, 11:17 pm PDT

04/12 Twin Tug of War

Quote From: cashee

"Do you want me to say that Allison should have her cake and eat it, too? "

 

LOL ... OK, maybe this is tasteless... but is there anyone else out there who finds this quote ironic?

 

 

 

Two points of clarification: she used the babies' own passports, and Tyler is a little boy.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
April 14, 2007, 11:24 pm PDT

Thank You for making this known

I had hyperemesis with my last pregnancy.  With my first pregnancy I had morning sickness that was bad but tolerable.  With my second one it wasn't that bad and passed within a couple of months.  With my third it was awful.  I have never felt so miserable and awful ever before in my life.  I had months of just staying in bed and doing everything I could to take care of my girls between when they got home from school till my husband got home from work.  For months I couldn't cook or clean.  With the help of zofran I got through my pregnancy.  Even though I was sure three children was plenty that was the final deciding factor that I never wanted to be pregnant again.  This is definitely a condition that if you haven't had to deal with it or had a family member that has had it you wouldn't understand it.  It is something I wouldn't wish on anyone.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
upset
April 14, 2007, 11:29 pm PDT

Free Alison . . .

First, please let us know when they do "the right thing" and free this woman and drop all charges. I do pray and hope she gets her children back.

As a single woman in her 40s, also; this show helped me be more sure of my decision [a couple of years ago] to not even attempt to get pregnant. I have decided that adoption is the way I will become a mother.

I believe there are so many children, already born, that really want and need a mother and if those children come to me via adoption; they were and are "my children".

In vitro/artificial insemination did cross my mind. But, to carry a child for nine months did not seem a good option for me. I am overweight. My health is generally good, but not perfect, and it wouldn't be fair for the child or for me to take any chances. Then hearing about this terrible disease confirmed my decision.

My heart goes out to all of you who have suffered from this awful disease. I will seek to help, in any way I can, to find a cure for it, too.

Love and Light,
Angela Theresa
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
April 14, 2007, 11:37 pm PDT

Bears Repeating:

 This comparison on the effects of HG bears repeating and is taken directly from the HER website.  The link to the HER website is as follows:

http://www.helpher.org/index.php

*Take special note of the post-partum recovery time.

If anyone out there needs support and information on HG, this is the place.

Area Impacted: Morning Sickness: Hyperemesis Gravidarum: Employment May lose an average of 0-3 weeks of employment and/or use sick time. Job performance is reduced. Often are unable to work for weeks or months and may lose their job or be forced to resign.  Daily Activities Can perform most household responsibilities at some point during the day or week when symptoms are less intense. May be unable to perform even simple household chores or care for themselves (shower, drive, etc.) when symptoms are severe. Energy Level Fatigue is mild to moderate and decreases workload. Recumbent rest is needed to alleviate symptoms. Fatigue may be severe for weeks or months. Bed rest is often a necessity. Prolonged fatigue is very common. Relationships & Socialization Relationships may be stressed but social functioning is only temporarily curtailed. Relationships are often greatly strained and may dissolve. Isolation is common and may lead to depression. Abuse and neglect of the mother may occur. Finances Financial loss due to medical care, loss of work, and use of sick time is significant but usually within a few thousand dollars. Financial loss due to medical care, loss of income, and additional paid services (child care, house cleaning, errands, etc.) can be devastating. Stress Level Psychological stress is mild to moderate and may result in manageable depression during pregnancy. Psychological stress is typically moderate to severe and often results in anxiety and depression. Increased risk of postpartum depression (PPD). Recovery Postpartum recovery is typical and usually takes a few months. Postpartum recovery is prolonged, averaging 6 months – 2 years.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
April 14, 2007, 11:43 pm PDT

Thank you Denielle and Bronco!

Quote From: deniele

UNTIL YOU HAVE GONE THROUGH HYPEREMESIS YOU HAVE NO IDEA JUST HOW SERIOUS IT IT. To say feel free to keep belly aching about how terrible it is has infuriated so many of us. Have you ever vomited 30 times a day for months? Have you ever thrown up blood and bile ??  Did you ever feel so week you could not function for 4-7 months?? So many of us were so excited for Dr. Phil to discuss this disease and all it took was an ignorant comment like yours to take way from the this big step forward.. 

 

I have only been through this once and it is a horrible thing . I had 2 surgeries from the damage to my esophagus and my body is still not right after what I went through. My doctor told me I would have hyperemesis just as bad if not worse next time so I am not going to try again. But, many women were misinformed believing it might not come back. And other women are so strong to put their bodies through this to have another child. And then there is you who questioned the severity!!! when you have NO idea what we all went through. I used to say I would not not wish this on my worst enemy . Well, after reading what you wrote I must say for a moment  I wished you could experience Hyperemesis if only for 1 day so you would not be so ignorant about our suffering and know just what strong women we truly are!!!

Hello all of you . . . ! Wow, that person who attacked all of you and Allison. Sometimes this world is scary.

I have never suffered hyperemesis and never well. Because I choose not to become pregnant in this lifetime. I have female issues [one ovary and cysts on the remaining one] and decided, as a single woman in her 40s and overweight; my children will come to me via adoption.

Nevertheless, I have had stomach flu [recently] and spent three days feeling like you dear, strong individuals feel for months! I prayed, begged and thought about death or a coma for all three days, as I rolled around the floor and didn't think I'd survive! For nine months or one more day would've had me out of my mind even more! Thus, no, I could never agree that's it's easy to get through hyperemesis; or even morning sickness for three months! [my best friend had three months of morning sickness and I thought she was going to vomit the child up!]

As the woman on Dr. Phil said -- After what I just went through for only three days; I would think I'd consider and pray for the ending of the pregnancy. I have no threshold for that kind of pain. I've also had food poisoning about three times!!! To the person who put you all down with her post "oh please" . . . I don't wish ill on anyone, but yeah, she should try food poisoning or stomach flu for even a day or two . . . and then tell us how she feels?!

May peace be there for all of you . . . and Allison and her twins. And the custodial parents.

Love and Light,
Angela Theresa

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
April 14, 2007, 11:52 pm PDT

Wow, Dena!

Quote From: deeblonde61

DR PHIL,

 

IN 1998 I WAS  INVOLVED IN  A CASE THAT  INVOLVED A ADOPTION OF MY SON,  IT WAS DURNING A TIME  WHEN I WAS  UNDER A GREAT DEAL OF STRESS, HAVING MAJOR DEPRESSION ISSUES, & I WAS ABOUT TO HAVE SEVERAL BACK & KNEE SURGERIES, SO I WAS NOT ABLE TO FUCTION REAL WELL ,

MY SON & I WERE  LIVING WITH  FAMILY FRIENDS  AT THE TIME, & THEY WERE A RETIRED COUPLE  THAT LIVED IN A VERY SMALL TOWN & HAD AFEW ACRES FOR  ANIMALS SO WHAT I THOUGHT WAS A PERFECT PLACE TO RASIE MY SON HAD TURNED INTO A NIGHTMARE ! 

DURING  THE TIME WHEN I HAD TO HAVE BEEN OF MY KNNEE'S  RE DONE ,  THEY BROUGHTUP THE FACT THAT THEY REALLY WERE AFRAID THAT MY SONS FATHER WAS GOING TO COME AFTER HIM & TAKE HIM AWAY FROM ME !  WELL YOU CAN  GUESS  THE  THOUGHT  OF TERROR  THAT  I HAD  TO FACE WITH THAT ! 

SO THEY CAME UP WITH THE IDEA OF  A  ADOPTION  ""ON PAPER "" ONLY  TO GET  THE  FATHER OUT OF  THE PICTURE ! ( WHAT I DID NOT KNOW AT THE TIME IS THAT  THE 3 OF THEM WERE  IN THIS WHOLE THING TOGETHER  TO GET  THE FATHER  OUT OF PAYING SUPPORT  FOR MY SON .

WELL THEY  FOUND AN ATTY  THAT WOULD HANDLE EVERYTHING FOR  THEM , & THEY STARTED THE  PROCESS ! 

THEY MADE ALOT OF PROMISES TO ME LIKE  " WE  ARE TO OLD TO RAISE  A CHILD  SO IF YOU EVER WANT TOTAKE THE  BOY & LEAVE IT WILL BE FINE !

OK  I KNOW A REALLY STUPID MOVE ON MY PART TO  TRUST IN THAT !

 

WELL THEY SET THE ATTY APPOINTMENTS  DID ALL THE PAPER WORK , PAID ALL  THE FEE'S  DID IT ALL  EVEN MADE SURE I NEVER WENT  ANY WHERE  ALONE !

WHEN  THE STATE  DID  THIER  INVESTIGATION  THERE WERE THERE, IN FACT  WHEN THE  SOCIAL WORKER QUESTIONED WHY I WAS STAYING  ON IN THE HOME  THEY TOLD HER THAT I WAS  STILL GOING TO RAISE  MY SON  JUST  I HAD BEEN DOING  &  THAT  IT WAS IMPORTANT TO THEM THAT I REMIAN AS  HIS " MOMMY"

 

WELL THAT  WENT FINE TIL  I FOUND PAPERS THAT  THEY HAD FILED FOR  SOCIAL SECURITY PAYMENT FOR HIM !  ( THEY WERE ON SOCIAL  SECURITY DISABILTY )

SO IF THEY WERE TO HAVEA CHILD ADDED TO THE FAMILY THE WERE  GOING TO GET A INCREASE  FUNDS EACH MONTH  ( ABOUT  $ 800.00 )  & WHEN THE ADOPTION WAS  FINAL  THEY GOT ABOUT  45k  SO  MADE  THIS WHOLE PLAN  VERY PROFITABLE FOR THEM ,

ABOUT 2 MOS BEFORE THE FINAL DATE  I CALLED THE ATTY & THE STATE  TO  STOP  THE ADOPTION  , WELL WHEN THEY  FOUND OUT I HAD CALLED ALL THE PHONE'S WERE TAKEN OUT OF THE HOUSE , & MY  CAR KEYS WENT  MISSING , I WAS NOT  ALLOWED OUT OF  THIER SITE !

THE ADOPTION WENT THROUGH  EVEN WITH MY OBJECTIONS  , I WAS  KEPT OUT OF THE COURT ROOM & THE  ATTY WAS TOLD THAT I WAS  HIGHLY MEDICATED  SO  ANYTHING I WOULD SAY  WAS  NOT WHAT I  REALLY MENT !

 

ABOUT 6 MOS AFTER  THE FINAL , I FOUND MORE  LEGAL PAPERS  & STARTED ASKING QUESTION , I TOLD THEM THAT I THOUGHT  IT WAS GOING TO BE BEST  IF  WE  LEFT ,  I WAS TOLD FINE THAT I COULD LEAVE BUT I WAS NOT  TAKING  MY SON ,

THE  GENTLEMAN IN  THIS  THING HAD BEGUN  TO BE VERY PHYSCIAL WITH ME HE WAS  DRINKING MORE , THAN BEFORE  & GOT VERY ABUSIVE  AT TIMES , 

ON AUG 1999 I TOLD THEM THAT  WE WERE GOING  FOR A ICE CREAM & WE  WENT  TO BE WITH MY FAMILY --  THE HAD  THE SOCIAL SERVICE DEPT  MEET WITH  MY FATHER , MYSELF & MY SON -  THE RIPPED MY SON OUT OF MY ARMS  (  HE WAS  KICKING & SCREAMING  FOR ME TO HELP HIM  THEY TOLD ME THAT IF I MOVED I COULD BE SHOT  FOR INTERFERRING  WITH THEM -   THEY  FILED CHILD STEALING CHARGES AGAINST ME  & I SPENT 22 DAYS IN JAIL  THEN  I WENT  BEFORE A JUDGE  IN CALIF  & HE  TOLD ME  THAT  SINCE I HAD  A CASE TO HAVE THE ADOPTION OVER TURNED  !  THAT  IF A WAS SUCCESFUL IN THAT  , THEN HE WOULD DISMISS MY CHILD STEALING CASE !

 

IN 2000  I  WAS  IN COURT  FOR  4 HRS & THE JUDGE TOOK A BREAK & CAME BACK EVEN WITH OUT HEARING THE OTHER SIDE  HE  OVERTURNED  THE ADPOTION  & RESTORED ALL MY  PARENTAL RIGHTS , BUT HE DID NOT  SEND MY SON HOME WITH ME

HE WANTED TO GIVE ME TIME  TO GET A PLACE TO LIVE  & TO GIVE  MY SON A CHANCE TO GET USED TO THE CHANGE -  BUT  THEY WERE  STILL GETTING $800.00 @ MONTH  SO THEY DID NOT WANT TO LET THAT  GO ,  IT TOOK ANOTHER  13 MONTHS FOR ME TO GET  MY SON HOME WITH ME ,

DURNING WHAT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE A TRANSITION TIME I WAS NEVER ALLOWED TO TALK TO MY SON ALONE 1 OF THEN WAS ALWAYS WITH IN EAR SHOT  I HAD TO HAVE THE SHERIFF INFORCE  MY TIME VISITS  4  TIMES , IT WAS  REALLY CRAZY WHAT THEY PUT US THROUGH ,

BUT IN  2002 MY SON WAS  ABLE TO SPEND A FEW OVERNITE VISITS  DURNING ONE OF THOSE  VISITS HE TOLD ME THAT  HE WANTED  TO COME & LIVE WITH ME  FOREVER!

I TOOK HIM BACK & THE NEXT MORNING AT 7:30AM  MY PHONE RANG  IT WAS  THE WOMAN IN TEARS !  SHE TOLD ME THAT  I NEEDED TO MEET HER  & THAT MY SON WAS  COMING TO LIVE WITH ME BUT THAT I NEED TO CALL THE ATTY & TELL THEM THAT  THEY WOULD HAVE TO DRAW UP THE PAPERS TO RELEASE THEM OF GURADIANSHIP  !

 

WELL I PICKED HIM UP & WE WENT RIGHT TO THE COURTS & I SPOKE TO THE JUDGES SEC & TOLD HER WHAT HAD HAPPEND HE TOLD ME WHAT TO DO & 30 DAYS LATER IT WAS ALL OVER !

 

I DONT KNOW  IF MY CASE CAN HELP ALLISON  AT ALL BUT MAYBE IT MIGHT GIVE HER  SOME  HOPE !!!

 

MY SON IS 15 YRS OLD NOW  & HE STILL CARRIES SOME SCARS FROM WHAT I ALLOWED TO HAPPEN BUT HE KNOWS THAT  MOM MAKES MISTAKES  & IF WE LEARN FROM THEM  THEN WE GROW & ARE BETTER  PEOPLE  FOR  LIFE !

 

I HAVE NEVER SHARED MY STORY WITH ANYONE OUTSIDE MY  IMED FAMILY BUT IF WHAT I WENT THROUGH CAN HELP 1 PERSON  ALL OF THIS HAS BEEN WORTH IT !!

 

THANKS YOU FOR LETTING ME WRITE THIS  GOD BLESS YOU

 

DENA

 

 

I'm not involved with this case, besides this board. But, I'm very upset for Allison and was feeling very sad and upset at the injustice of the whole case.

You're story gave me some hope for humanity and the rights of parents. Thank you, from me, for sharing. I do hope Dr. Phil shares this with Allison. And do know, Dena, your story is very encouraging and hopeful for others.

I, too, have not shared this. But I went through a custody situation with my boyfriend's biological child. We lost the case and his child was adopted by her foster parents.

It was very painful for both of us; and, in fact, was the main reason he and I broke up soon after. Still, we remain friends.

Your story helped me feel better that sometimes the laws do the right thing. I hope they do that for Allison.

Love and Light,
Angela Theresa
 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
blank
April 15, 2007, 1:43 am PDT

Get the story straight!

Quote From: justnancy

You're right I paid absolutely no attention to this story I didn't note her twitchy, disturbed affect or the mental instability that oozed from her every pore.  I paid no attention to the complete lack of responsibility she expressed for her actions or the psychological disturbance that clearly transcended the HG.  Count me corrected.

 

Do you want me to say that Allison should have her cake and eat it, too? She's obviously not responsible enough to put her pen to a legal document, but she's more than responsible enough to raise two girls.  She's calculated enough to forge documents and get her children out of the country, but she's too weak and frail mentally to make any decisions that count legally just listening to her talk she didn't do anything wrong.

 

But I wasn't paying any attention to that.

 If you are going to make a statement about this situation - make sure you are accurate in your facts!!!!!!!!!! ALLISON DID NOT FORGE DOCUMENTS. SHE HAD THE BABIES' BIRTH CERTIFICATE AND PROBABLY THEIR SOCIAL SECURITY CARDS IF THEY WERE APPLIED FOR AT BIRTH. She obtained the passports legally - you can read this in the reports about her situation. You will see she did not lie to the border agents and traveled under her own name. That is not dishonest behavior. You sound like you have decided she is guilty and you don't even know the details. Read the stories and info out there and make informed statements, please! I'm assuming you must be friends with the Needhsams to say such unfounded remarks.

You make these comments about her instability or disturbed affect but you give no reason for it. She was calm and composed but anxious. Good grief - do you see that this woman has been thru hell for the last few years! Give her a break here. She was not of the right mind at the time of the signing to make such a decision. That was over a year ago. Should she have been caring for the babies at that time - maybe not - but that doesn't give ANYONE the right to take them forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Did you read that she said no immediately? Why would anyone keep her kids - that is cruel and causes irreparable harm to the kids. Where is your heart? Have one?
 
First | Prev | 59 | 60 | 61 | 62 | 63 | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | Next | Last