Message Boards

Topic : 05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Number of Replies: 1311
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, May 04, 2007, 12:10:02 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Dr. Phil follows up with the complicated and twisted story of Jennifer and her husband, Jeffrey. He is so obsessed with his wife, he goes to extreme measures to spy on her and keep her under his control. After the last show, Jeffrey chose to seek help at Creative Care in California, while Jennifer headed home. See what private investigators found when they did a sweep of Jennifer's house upon her return. After being in rehab for two weeks and not complying with the rules, Jeffrey receives an ultimatum from the staff at Creative Care. When Jennifer learns the news, she breaks down and shares her thoughts in a video diary. Jeffrey gets re-motivated and stays in treatment, but does his obsessive jealousy end? Afraid for her safety and ready to end the marriage, Jennifer meets with an attorney to find out what rights she has. Then, Dr. Khaleghi, director of Creative Care, has a startling message for Jennifer and reveals why he doesn't believe Jeffrey is ready to see her. And, Jeffrey joins Dr. Phil onstage to share his progress. Is he giving 110 percent like he committed to in the last show or has he been up to his old tricks? Will Jeffrey decide to return to treatment, or give in to his anxieties and return home? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More May 2007 Show Boards

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 10:49 am PDT

05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Quote From: wibblewobbles

Whether his tears are real or fabricated wasn't my issue. She's phony. And after watching the last show (thank gawd it's the last) I'm even more convinced. Yep even she made some tears, for Dr. Phil in his office. Oh and when she was faced with the fact that she had to leave her beautiful house. She was pretty strong worded before that. Victim, I think not. But whatever. Thanks for you harsh judgement by the way. I really needed that. Sheesh.

Don't take it so personal. I wasn't attacking YOU.

 

"And after watching the last show (thank gawd it's the last) I'm even more convinced. "

 

based on what?  Do you know her?  Are you a profiler who's experienced in detecting phonies?  Jeffrey's got you snowed & so why would you think you can see her for a phoney or not? 

 

This person replying to you wasn't taking it "personal" she's frustrated that you're so ignorant & loudly commenting & hurting others with YOUR harsh judgement of an abused person.  You're hurting anyone watching who's being threatened that "no one will believe you".  And sheesh! if you'd educate yourself like this person suggested perhaps you'd be able to see the reality of the situation. 

 

Oh & I'm happy it's the last show too & that Jeffrey's where he can't hurt this poor woman &/or their kids for at least the time being. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 11:14 am PDT

blackvelvetone I didn't misunderstand your post

Quote From: blackvelvetone

I think I am/was being misunderstood here.....I have NO SYMPATHY for Jeffrey what so ever....yes he is totally responsible for his actions, as is my son when he (21 years old) choses to not take medication!!! that's a choice he makes and I as a single parent (always have been) suffer for it and so do the people around him.

I am more than confident that Dr. Phil knows what he's doing and talking about.....I simply see some of the same traits in Jeffrey that I do in my son and my son is NOT LIKE that on medication!!!

I realize that everyone is different....but the similarities are uncanny!!! It just makes one THINK that there MIGHT be some other reason that a person behaves the way they do!!

 

Jeffrey is undoubtedly the most outragous person I have ever seen!!! And I use the term mildly.

My heart goes out to Jennifer.....I just don't understand WHY in her video tape where she is claiming that she might be the "next Nicole Brown Simpson"....she is just sitting there crying about it  and not packing her bags and kids and getting the HELL outta Denver!!!!!!!!!!!!! Doesn't that seem a bit odd to anyone else???

Is a home really more important than a life......JUST GO!!! What is she REALLLLLY waiting for? more drama.??

and I have to tell you I think that what Mike was saying is that if like your son Jeffrey is given a diagnosis of 1 name or the other & they medicate perhaps he would n't be put away and then if & when he choses not to take it he'll slip back into this outragious behavior again.  This is why he said "there are children involved here."  & they've had enough damage done to them.  I realize that you have to deal with your son when he choses not to take his meds. & it must be very dfficult and so we don't want Jennifer having to deal with that as well.  She's had enough dame done to her & so have the kids hearing their mother called all kinds of things & accussed of every horrific thing from being a tart to heaven knows what. 

 

Which brings me to my next part & the part of this your recent post that did frost me. 

1st.   you say don't understand in her video tape where she is "claiming" this implies you think she may not be telling the truth.  Women are *threatened* by their abusers all the time that "No one will believe you & then I'm going to................."  You don't really want to empower abusers right?

 

2nd I don't believe she was "claiming that she might be the 'next Nicole Brown Simpson" she was crying because OTHER people were telling her to " get out, RUN you're going to be the next Nicole Brown Simpson"  & no it didn't seem odd to me that this woman would be frozen with fear at that moment because Jeffrey was still in the center & she's sitting there surrounded by PI's & taking in info & getting instruction on the course of actions from her lawyer.  Just because she wasn't packing a bag & running didn't mean she wasn't prepairing to leave.  She was being SMART & listening to her lawyer & the other professionals around her.  The home is important because she had her career derailed by this thing called her husband going squirrely on her co-workers & getting her fired.  To help her restart her life & for her children to have a proper place to live she *needs that house* & her having that home helps to minimize the risk of her going back to an abuser because she can't take care of her children.  That was before he was in jail & the likely of a woman returning to an abuser is high.  "Is the home more important than a life" this statement trivelizes or critizies her once again & makes it sound as though her priorities are off or that she's being frivolous.  Don't you think she's had enough of that?    When you ask what she is waiting for really "more drama"?  you make it sound as though she's having fun here.  She is SCARED STIFF & she has reason to be! 

 

becareful how you judge someone because it could easily be you being judged & the things you do turned around to make you sound like you're unfit, silly, fivolous, making it up, irresponsible, the source of the problems etc. 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 11:23 am PDT

05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Quote From: alishia

Well I will not say all that because I never heard how he was with her before she cheated on him. Was he nice? from what I seen on the 1st show he became this way due to her cheating. Now that's no excuse for his behavior.  I would leave him, but she is the reason he is like he is. She not only cheated but she kept trying to have affairs. The marriage is over. I do not believe it can be saved.

 "I never heard how he was with her before she cheated on him."

 

You weren't paying attention & if you go back & read "what happened on the show" you seel he "started questioning her just after they married"  which was when she was pregnant with their child.  At the time she was practically a child herself.  after a year & a half in their 2nd year of marriage she cheated on him.  & I can certainly see a young woman of her age thinking "Ok if he's going to accuse me..........."  Abusers don't become abusive they abuse form the beginning & manipulate the situation the way they want it to go & picking a 19 yr. old to marry is the start because it's easy to con someone who's young & inexperienced.  once pregnant & then married just 2 months after starting to date he had her "hooked"  This is *very common* & among the list of things to look out for when dating as a sign of an abuser "If he wants the relationship to progress real fast & marry right away".  They're "hooking you".  classic.

 

"She not only cheated but she kept trying to have affairs. "

 

This is taken from the obcessive dillusional thoughts of this man that has been twisting things so long even HE believes the lies.  Remeber just a joke of "You're a sexy bitch" to a girlfriend in an email had him accussing her of being a lesbian.  He's a liar & her continuing to try to have affairs is HIS dillusion. 

 

"but she is the reason he is like he is. "  People aren't made into abusers they come that way & the victim just doesn't see it. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 11:25 am PDT

05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Quote From: missnatalie

what is with you and "getting it" and "not getting it" and some of us "do get it"  everyone knows just as much as you do and everyone "gets it" in their own way. 

"everyone knows just as much as you do and everyone "gets it" in their own way. "

 

no you don't & there is no "your own way here"

 

abuse is abuse is abuse.  & it's abuse you "don't get."  & that's why the person wants you to "educate yourself" because you clearly don't know *anything* about it. 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 11:35 am PDT

Enjoying the drama a bit too much?

It seems to me that she's enjoying the drama a bit too much.  If she wasn't...if she was sincerely tired of his actions, she would have taken advantage of the time away from him and turned her home phones off.  But she answered all his calls. I don't think she could handle a simple life without him.  She's just as addicted to his actions as he's addicted to her.

She puts herself out there--head on a strange guy's shoulder---uploads it on the internet for him to see, and then feels sorry for herself when he accuses her of having an affair.  I'm sorry, but in my book, that IS an affair.  And her defense is "I' only met him two hours ago"  Who DOES that? I wouldn't trust her around my husband.  This is all too obviously waving a steak in front of a lion's cage. 

I feel sorry for the kids...and the people who'll have to put up with them when they grow up in this twisted family.  They all need help.

Jeff, your best bet is to let her go,  get the treatment you need for your affect disorder, and find a woman who will love you for who you are.  I don't believe you're going to harm Jen.  But I do believe there are women who would love you and respect the marriage vows.  But get help first.




 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 12:42 pm PDT

05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Quote From: vicky63

It seems to me that she's enjoying the drama a bit too much.  If she wasn't...if she was sincerely tired of his actions, she would have taken advantage of the time away from him and turned her home phones off.  But she answered all his calls. I don't think she could handle a simple life without him.  She's just as addicted to his actions as he's addicted to her.

She puts herself out there--head on a strange guy's shoulder---uploads it on the internet for him to see, and then feels sorry for herself when he accuses her of having an affair.  I'm sorry, but in my book, that IS an affair.  And her defense is "I' only met him two hours ago"  Who DOES that? I wouldn't trust her around my husband.  This is all too obviously waving a steak in front of a lion's cage. 

I feel sorry for the kids...and the people who'll have to put up with them when they grow up in this twisted family.  They all need help.

Jeff, your best bet is to let her go,  get the treatment you need for your affect disorder, and find a woman who will love you for who you are.  I don't believe you're going to harm Jen.  But I do believe there are women who would love you and respect the marriage vows.  But get help first.




What a wonderfull message with logic and not all emotional.

Thank you.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 1:09 pm PDT

ok... We know he lost it but...

Quote From: c1d1v3a4

Poor little guy is traumatized.....so that explains the taking nude pictures of her, trying to get her to have sex with his friends, locking her in the basement, GPS'ing her car, hiding cameras everywhere to watch her, hiring people to follow her and watch her every move?    Nope not traumatized.....just a FREAK!
 If she was a Good wife to begin with , she wouldnt have cheated ...
 ...he lost all trust of her , but he still gave her a chance because of the kids
... She messed up as a wife.. thats it ... if he was really that bad before the marriage how come didnt she call dr phil then? ...

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 1:11 pm PDT

Get a grip

Quote From: sassie1

Quote from sassie:   I wholeheartedly agree with you on this one!  I watched the show yesterday and couldn't believe what I was seeing, Jenn out with other men that she just met and having pictures taken with them and if that wasn't enough, having them posted on the internet where she knew Jeffrey would go and that he would see them..How ridiculous!  I am not excusing Jeffrey's behaviour however but I did see some lttle things that made me wonder if Jenn was agging Jeffrey on instead of helping and some of those tears didn't seem sincere for I also saw some laughing mixed in with them. I think the most important thing on my mind in such a situation if I was as terrified of someone as she made herself out to be , would have been my children, they come first but I didn't see that as the case in yesterday's show...Drama,Drama!!

Yeah Jennifer was laughing...what a crime....to think that she actually had a moment of laughter out of years of hell, God forbid.

 

Again I am amazed at some of you people. A friend of hers from Iowa thought she might enjoy going out to a community event and her friends took pics of her with other people. She did not post these; someone else did and who cares??????

 

Have you never been to a party or wedding where people ask to take pics ? Or a church picnic? Many times I have met people at socials and someone will come up and take a pic of a group or with those I have met at a conference. Does that mean I am "out" with those men?

Hey...the phone is ringing....it's the 1800s on Line One for you.

 

And uh, how could she possibly know that freako Jeffrey--who is supposed to be in rehab focusing on his illness--would instead be spending his time searching all the internet pages in Iowa to find pics of his wife with people she's just met?

 

Here's the REAL question---if this guy is really committed to getting better then why isn't he spending his time doing that? Hmmm...

 

I think given the fact she flew from California to Virginia and then upon arrival with no sleep drove immediately to Iowa does show that she cares about her children.

 

Get a grip people-going out to a community event IS normal, so is laughter.

 

I maintain that because Jennifer is beautiful, some of the women here (probably jealous) are not cutting her any slack. If she was overweight and ugly would you still be accusing her of this? I doubt it.

 

I guarantee you though regardless of how she looked, Jeffrey would. Once a control freak, always a control freak.

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 1:18 pm PDT

05/10 Obsessive Love: Secrets Revealed

Quote From: momakababe

I hope this is your last posts here to.  I nor anyone else here professed to be "professional" except for the person claiming to have a degree in psychology who blames victims for their abuse. 

 

2nd you asked

"What married woman with 3 kids will have a man in her home for at lest 16 hours while her husband is out of state.."

 

well they (Jeffrey) did NOT say that this man was at her house for 16 hours.  Jeffrey said he'd gotten a "weird vibe" & DROVE 16 hrs. back straight.  He didn't say he thought the man was there he just got a weird vibe & for all anyone knows perhaps she was on the phone or computer making plans or was expecting this OM & that's the "weir vibe" Jeffrey picked up.  This affairs was (listen carefully now) * years ago!  so there would be how many children in the house 1?  At the age of what 21 yrs. old after 2 years of being emotionally battered & ACCUSSED of an affair is it that difficult for you to think (you do think right?)  that this YOUNG woman reacted in a defiant manner thinking "If I'm gonna be accused of it I might as well be unfaithful".  It's an immature thought & action but then she was a 21 yr. old emotionally BATTERED woman.  Now of course this is just 1 of many things that could have been part of the reasoning for this young woman & I don't know but neither do YOU. 

 

You want to hear what's best for the kids to have that manic as far from them as possible.  And my question to you is what kind of woman hears of the abuse a woman like this has suffered & then questions the womans behavior?  I can't imagine how any of these women hang onto their sanity under the conditions they live & you're spinning an affair that happened 8 yrs. ago in an abusive marriage into something more than it is.  3 kids?  she already had 3 kids?  Perhaps you're just looking for what she'd done wrong.  Maybe you're trying to reason with your own mind why you tolerate the abuse you're dealing with? 

 

Either way I hope you stope re-inforcing the myths of abuse because it's damaging.   

Well I will respond.  I don't know if you are a professional or not.  I don't believe you are.  First of all if you are a professional you would not degrade a person for expressing their opion.  Degrading a person is not showing  much for your profession.  You are an angery person and may have your  reasons for that.

 

What evidence do you have he was treating her this way after the wedding.  She is the one that told him she had an affair.You also are making assumesons when you don't know all the facts

either. Your answer regarding the kids is insuffience  As a professional don't you realize what effect her activities will or has on the kids.  Every one agrees he needs help and should be removed from them till he has help.  That only helps one half of the problem. She also, along with the kids, needs help.  Which the doctor has never address or offered.

 

Sorry this is so long. It's disturbing to think this is supose to be a civil talk with all people with difference opions.

 

Also I am not a women but a 69 year grandfather with 2 daughters and five granddaughter and not some nut.

 

My grandkids are great. I go to all their activities.When they want to talk, which is often, I listen with all my attention. I don't have all their answers. But the important thing is I listen no matter what the subject.

 

We must relize their are two sides to all problems.  Women can also be abusers.  Check out some of the studies on the internet about this subject.

 

 

 

 

 

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 2:15 pm PDT

Why did Maria the babysitter allow Jeffrey to

Questions?

 

Why did Maria the babysitter allow Jeffrey to take the kids from her home back to Jennifer's house?

 

I thought she told Jennifer in the phone call that she would keep the children safe, while waiting for Jennifer's mother to come for them, if she did ... cause Maria was not leaving her own children to take Jennifer's kids to the grandmother.

 

Why weren't the police called by Maria when Jeff showed up?

 

 

Why wasn't a call  put in to the police when Jeffrey took Maria's phone and got some information from Maria's phone regarding the situation?

 

 

 
First | Prev | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | Next | Last