Message Boards

Topic : 05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Number of Replies: 2447
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, May 04, 2007, 12:13:43 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
The incredible drama continues involving Jeffrey, an obsessive husband who won’t let go of his wife, Jennifer. After the last show, Jeffrey is on his way back to the treatment facility, when his anger gets the best of him, and he jumps out of the car and goes on the run. He finally calls his therapist from a taxi cab, but soon after is on the loose again. After four hours and a frenzy of phone calls with Dr. Phil show producers, see what Jeffrey demands. With the stress and pressure getting the best of her, Jennifer sits down with Dr. Phil to discuss their next step. In a hurried panic, Jennifer heads home and is shocked by what she finds when she walks in the front door. She takes her kids and flees to her mother’s house. Even though she’s in a safe place, why does she say she still lives in fear? Then, Jennifer’s attorney files papers and meets Jeffrey in front of a judge. Will Jeffrey be able to comply with the judge's orders? And, Jeffrey resumes talk with the Dr. Phil staff. What is he asking for? Jeffrey’s behavior continues to shock and mystify Jennifer and leaves her with only one choice. Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More May 2007 Show Boards

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:18 am PDT

His object

Quote From: oldbeachhippie

I do NOT condone Jeffery's unskilfull behavior.  Jennifer, on the other hand was portrayed through all of this as "Saint Jennifer" the innocent victim.  I ain't buying it.  Dr. Phil should have spent more time exposing her actions...that may have significantly contributed to this situation.

 

Jeffery is way over the edge. 

 

Some spouses enjoy keeping their partners "off balance".  In a loving, trusting, respectful relationship you do not taunt your partner.  I would not care if my wife had a MY SPACE site as long as she did not "make herself available" to others.  I would be upset if she (my wife) locked me out of her site...and would not divulge the contents.  This would keep my "un-centered" and off balance.  I would not do that to her.

 

The photo of her snuggled in a new strangers shoulder, is a symptom of what "abuse" Jeffery himself was subject to.  That photo did not look innocent.  If my wife was taking photos like this with guys she knew only 5 minutes, I would question ALL of her actions.

 

I have enough self esteem that I would not stand in front of the *** kicking machine, but would leave.  Jeffery wanted a relationship with a woman,the mother of his kids, who probably could (or would) not emotionally reciprocate with him.  His methodology for dealing with her was and is very skewwed and unskilfull.

 

Dr. Phil, I wish you had taken her to task.  Yes, Jeffery is a basket case.......the story has two sides and you portrayed only one side.....is it for ratings.....sensationalism......making Jeffery look like a nut case.......would that have been diminished if it had been shown there were valid reasons that helped push him over the edge?

 When the object of an abuser tries to escape the abuser,   and when it dawms on the abuser tht he is about to lose power over his object, that frequently pushes the abuser "over the edge." 

However,  no one is obligated to put up with abuse, and the sense of inadequacy and panic is an internal problem,  not one imposed on him by the person who leaves.  She is allowed to want to leave that!

Jeffrey was jealous and controlling of Jennifer prior to any rational impression he may have had that she was stepping out on him.   She was young and pretty, but in love with him when they married.    Do you understand, he  was "that way" before they married.  He was that way before they MET! 

His bizarre accusations and monitoring began without any  "valid" reasons or provocation.

His reaction to the photo was irrational, but you know that.  Lets say the outlandish claims of Jeffrey were true,  and that this man is now Jennifer's boyfriend.   Even if it were his business anymore who she appeared in photos with, she has no obligation to please him with her choice of activities or friends.  He's been served with divorce papers, and his say in her romantic life is at an end.  He's upset because she is beyond his control, and clearly not going to reconcile. 


 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:22 am PDT

As far as the sugar daddy thing

Quote From: doncarl

 

Jenifer got pregnant and married after 2 months of dating ?

 

Could it be that at 19 years old she found a 30 year old SUGAR DADDY?

 

Jenifer...a mother of 3,  leaves her husband home babysitting while she goes out clubbing  

 

I would love to hook Jenifer up to a lie detector and ask about her affairs, that would be a great Dr Phil 1 hour show !

 

I read alot of post that say her affairs have nothing to do with it, but I think her affairs drove her husband into his bizarre controlling behavior.

 

I am shocked at dr. phil.... he usually see's both sides of the story, but for some reason he has blinders on and only see's her side.

DR: PHIL: JENIFER'S ACTIONS CAUSED THIS PROBLEM !!!

 

 

 

 

 

 Jennifer worked, or tried to, anyway.

Jeffrey sabotaged that to the best of his ability.  He would reset her alarm to make her late to work.
He would call people out of the company directory, male or female,  and directly accuse them of sleeping with his wife...at 3 AM!   His monitoring and accusations would escalate until she would leave the job or get fired.  
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:24 am PDT

05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Quote From: oldbeachhippie

I do NOT condone Jeffery's unskilfull behavior.  Jennifer, on the other hand was portrayed through all of this as "Saint Jennifer" the innocent victim.  I ain't buying it.  Dr. Phil should have spent more time exposing her actions...that may have significantly contributed to this situation.

 

Jeffery is way over the edge. 

 

Some spouses enjoy keeping their partners "off balance".  In a loving, trusting, respectful relationship you do not taunt your partner.  I would not care if my wife had a MY SPACE site as long as she did not "make herself available" to others.  I would be upset if she (my wife) locked me out of her site...and would not divulge the contents.  This would keep my "un-centered" and off balance.  I would not do that to her.

 

The photo of her snuggled in a new strangers shoulder, is a symptom of what "abuse" Jeffery himself was subject to.  That photo did not look innocent.  If my wife was taking photos like this with guys she knew only 5 minutes, I would question ALL of her actions.

 

I have enough self esteem that I would not stand in front of the *** kicking machine, but would leave.  Jeffery wanted a relationship with a woman,the mother of his kids, who probably could (or would) not emotionally reciprocate with him.  His methodology for dealing with her was and is very skewwed and unskilfull.

 

Dr. Phil, I wish you had taken her to task.  Yes, Jeffery is a basket case.......the story has two sides and you portrayed only one side.....is it for ratings.....sensationalism......making Jeffery look like a nut case.......would that have been diminished if it had been shown there were valid reasons that helped push him over the edge?

A person with a problem like Jeffrey's doesn't get that way from "being pushed over the edge."  You can't MAKE someone that way after they're an adult.  Jeffrey got that way from his childhood, and now it is hard-wired into him and probably impossible to change.  Undoubtedly Jennifer has some issues herself to have hooked up with him, but please if you don't believe me that she did not make him that way, you need to read a book called Stopping a Stalker by Robert Snow, which will make you understand that what makes a stalker is usually one of two major things and both originate in childhood.  He is either sociopathic, has no empathy or conscience, which would normally be due ot extreme neglect or abuse and no one good to model after, or he has very low self-esteem, something that made him feel worthless when he was a child -- or both, which is what I think in Jeffrey's case. 

 

As a caution, if you are a person who believes a love interest pushes you to violence or stalking, I am going to tell you straight up, YOU need psychotherapy before you go off on someone, because no one can make you do something like that.  It has to come from within.

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:25 am PDT

Can It be Fixed

Quote From: gotjohn

Jeffery's behavior is not his identity but a symptom that can be fixed. It's just too bad it had to go this far without doing something about it. It's apparent that he has control issues, insecurities, and is a pathological liar. Just because he was honest about telling those horrific events did not free him from the consequences of them. The divorce was over years ago and he needs to let it go. He needs to focus on acknowledging his problem, to recognize there is a future and a hope, and that this is not some 6 week program but quite possibly be for the rest of his life.

Logically, It can be fixed. But in his mind set he may never let anyone help him fix this.  Even if he admits he has a problem, the issue is will he let someone get close enough to help him. Then will he actually retain what they are trying to help him with.   When do we know when a person is too far gone?
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:28 am PDT

05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Quote From: oldbeachhippie

I do NOT condone Jeffery's unskilfull behavior.  Jennifer, on the other hand was portrayed through all of this as "Saint Jennifer" the innocent victim.  I ain't buying it.  Dr. Phil should have spent more time exposing her actions...that may have significantly contributed to this situation.

 

Jeffery is way over the edge. 

 

Some spouses enjoy keeping their partners "off balance".  In a loving, trusting, respectful relationship you do not taunt your partner.  I would not care if my wife had a MY SPACE site as long as she did not "make herself available" to others.  I would be upset if she (my wife) locked me out of her site...and would not divulge the contents.  This would keep my "un-centered" and off balance.  I would not do that to her.

 

The photo of her snuggled in a new strangers shoulder, is a symptom of what "abuse" Jeffery himself was subject to.  That photo did not look innocent.  If my wife was taking photos like this with guys she knew only 5 minutes, I would question ALL of her actions.

 

I have enough self esteem that I would not stand in front of the *** kicking machine, but would leave.  Jeffery wanted a relationship with a woman,the mother of his kids, who probably could (or would) not emotionally reciprocate with him.  His methodology for dealing with her was and is very skewwed and unskilfull.

 

Dr. Phil, I wish you had taken her to task.  Yes, Jeffery is a basket case.......the story has two sides and you portrayed only one side.....is it for ratings.....sensationalism......making Jeffery look like a nut case.......would that have been diminished if it had been shown there were valid reasons that helped push him over the edge?

i agree...
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:29 am PDT

Could have been handled better

Quote From: lori528

 Okay, I'm  not a therapist, but this situation seemed to be handled very badly. First of all, what is up with "Creative Care" letting Jeffrey have access to a computer and phone while he's in treatment??? When it was determined that Jeffrey was dangerous, why was he not locked up in a psych ward? He just gets to go voluntarily to "Creative Care"? And although I do like Dr. Phil, I don't think he was protecting Jennifer enough in this situation. Jeffrey beat her home and when she found him there, he could have hurt her, hurt the kids, etc. She was alone!! She should have been traveling with a body guard or something. Anything could have happened here! This was a total mess in my opinion. Luckily for everyone, Jeffrey is in jail and Jennifer and the kids are not hurt, but it was LUCK, not skill, in my opinion.

I have had some family situations that have involved trying to get someone into treatment or to stay in treatment, so I may be able to explain part of it.  In this situation, Jeffrey admitted himself to treatment voluntarily.  Creative Care could not keep him there involuntarily.  Even if he was determined to be dangerous, there has to be a hearing and a court order to keep him institutionalized against his will.  Also, his therapist said that it was possible for Jeffrey to be a threat, he had not stated at the show that he was definitely or highly likely to be a threat.  Dr. Phil told Jennifer he felt that Jeffrey was definitely capable of harming her.  So at the show, no absolute determination had been made by his therapist that he was dangerous, therefore, there had been no action taken legally.  Normally, something like that can take a lot of time.

 

As far as her going home by herself.  I did not get to see the end of the show, due to it being interrupted by a live news cast, but I personally believe that with Dr. Phil's resources he could have sent someone home with her for protection. 

 

We were not there and did not see everything that transpired.  She may have refused to have someone come with her. Or maybe the therapists may have thought that having someone show up with her if he was there, may have made the situation more volatile.  If she showed up with a man, Jeffrey would have probably thought it was a boyfriend and went absolutely nuts.  Although, if someone was sent home with her and waited outside the house in case there was trouble, maybe that would have worked.  But, I really could see the situation getting further out of hand if a plain clothes security person showed up.  I can't even imagine what would go through Jeffrey's delusional mind at that moment.

 

Jennifer handled the situation the best that she could.  She asked him to leave, when he refused, then she could involve the police.  Unfortunately, as you saw in the show, the police can't get involved just because someone says that there is an issue, no court orders had been drawn up at the time she returned home.  YES, she and her children were VERY LUCKY that he did not harm them.  I applaud her for handling the situation the best that she could. 

 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:31 am PDT

05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Quote From: shoyt_2001

 Hey there.  I am right there with you.  No one can really know what it is like until they have lived it.  These people who come out and say she shouldn't do this or that on the internet or myspace have no clue that it might be the one place that someone can contact you and you can "talk" and say what you want if even for a few minutes. 

For every "case" we see on Dr. Phil there are thousands, if not millions of people who are in the same situation. 


I understand the numbness.  You never know what is next and you can't make plans because every plan you try to make is thwarted.  Just like we saw on Dr. Phil today.  Jeffrey changes plans as often as he changed taxi's.  He changed demands, he change plans, he changed his story, he changed his location.  Everyone was trying to figure out how to respond to each one as if it really meant something but in the end they were just jerked around by Jeff AGAIN.


He continued jerking everyone around for the next two weeks.  Why is anyone on this message board giving him a pass?  He needs psychological help and nothing else.  No wife.  No kids.  If he won't stay in therapy he needs to be in jail or prison. 

No one wants to watch the lead up to a murder and that is exactly what we have been watching.   I have been following court cases on domestic murders for years.  It is not only men murdering their wives.  There are wives murdering gtheir husbands also.  So for the people who are acting like it is a free pass for the women, sorry, that arguement won't work.  I'll be happy to state cases of women who are in prison for murdering their husbands if it will make your vision a bit clearer. 

Jennifer and Jeffrey probably see each other as multiple different people. 

She sees him as the man she thought he was when they first met and she has added to that image any positives things he has done over these 11 years.  She also sees him as the person he really is and that is too scary to deal with so she sees him in a third way, as a man who will rationally let her go if he realizes that he can't have her. 

Jennifer, he is the scary person with you and he always will be.  Keep working on getting away.  His own image is tied up in yours and you have to break every connection to him since he will not do the work that would have given him his own identity if he had stayed in the program at Creative Care.  Three times he has broken his promise in the program.  That's it.  Don't believe any commitments he says he will make. 

Jeffrey sees Jennifer as someone who can make him big and important.  But he sees that only because he knows that he is not big and important.  So he has to do two things.  Bring her down to a level below himself, and elevate her above himself.  Obviously there is a problem.  You cannot knock someone down and build them up at the same time in your own mind.  Unless you have a divided mind.  Opposite urges are driving him but the end is control over every situation he encounters but it has to be through Jennifer.  He is trying to make her responsible for everything in his life.  He has to build her up for his image to the outside world and knock her down for his image in the world that they live in where he wants to control her every move, and his kids view of her, and her family's view of her, and her co-workers view of her, and he neighbors view of her.   He is in a fight against himself with Jennifer in his scope. 

If Jennifer is looking for approval it is mostly that she hopes to live another day and find someone who can help get her out of this insanitiy.  This is not a third world country and it is insane that the police couldn't help her because Jeffrey hadn't physically hurt her, even though a psychiatrist said he was a danger to his wife.

But they could go after him for not paying a cab?  Something is not right about that. 




When you are in that situation, you do see that person as different people. Occasionally you see glimpses of the man you fell in love with, and these are the glimmers of hope that you cling to when things get bad. Most often, you see the ups and down, the peaks and valleys of their strange behavior and you try to cope with it the best you can. The reason that Jennifer didn't change her phone number is probably because everything is in his name. That is common in situations like this. They control everything. I don't really expect the modern, striding woman who can, is allowed to take care of herself to understand this. This is almost a medievil living arrangement that one must live in. He controls the money, keeps the finances from you, gets angry at you when you ask, misleads you about them, etc. The house, the bills, etc, are usually in his name and the companies won't talk to you about them just because you are his wife. They must have his permission, written or verbal. Fat chance there. AS for his changing, that much is true. I have thought often about perhaps I should be taping conversations because he changes what he says so much. They do this to make you think you are nuts. You aren't of course, but you don't know that until he is gone for a period of time. It is effective at keeping you off your balance though, very effective. Until my husband was gone for almost 9 months, I really thought I was stupid, forgetful, and almost retarded.  I asked him about every decision and informed him about everything I was doing, as if I was double checking, right down to going to the bathroom, because I was so uncertain of my own decision making. It was weird to not have him around at first, hard, but then just as I was getting used to it, he came home. He comes and goes as he chooses and doesn't hold a job. It is, of course, my fault-sometimes. It changes with his whims. One in situations like this often think of leaving, but when you are in, you are just trying to get from day to day, not thinking steps ahead. Perhaps the women who are forming judgements about Jennifer out there (or women in her situation) should go down to the local women's shelter and volunteer for a while. Get a taste of our reality.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
May 12, 2007, 8:37 am PDT

05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Quote From: ivorydog

her myspace page was set to private, but he is a hacker, remember?

Oh .... I see.   Yes, I guess you are right.    My other question is How did he get the babysitter out of the house, after Jennifer called her to update her on what is going on???

This was a powerful show and I do hope they all get help before it's too late.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:42 am PDT

05/11 Obsessive Love: On the Run

Quote From: seymour2

 
I don't mean to be insensitive and I understand that she married at 19 (although I don't get why one would do that in our generation and only after two months of dating). But if you are so sure he walked into this marriage sick, then why did she get married with a sick man? That's water under the bridge now, but she'll move on with her life at one point... These are things she needs to get a good, deep answer to before she gets involved with anyone again.
People can have a  host of serious issues that don't generally show up until after the marriage.  As manipulative as Jeffery is,  I'm sure he had her controlled and brain washed when they married and convinced that he was a Prince.  She, being 19, and not having been around the block a few times would be especially vunerable to someone as cunning as that.  Don't get me wrong, I think Jen has some things to work through, but she truly is the victim here.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
May 12, 2007, 8:48 am PDT

causes

Quote From: doncarl

 

Jenifer got pregnant and married after 2 months of dating ?

 

Could it be that at 19 years old she found a 30 year old SUGAR DADDY?

 

Jenifer...a mother of 3,  leaves her husband home babysitting while she goes out clubbing  

 

I would love to hook Jenifer up to a lie detector and ask about her affairs, that would be a great Dr Phil 1 hour show !

 

I read alot of post that say her affairs have nothing to do with it, but I think her affairs drove her husband into his bizarre controlling behavior.

 

I am shocked at dr. phil.... he usually see's both sides of the story, but for some reason he has blinders on and only see's her side.

DR: PHIL: JENIFER'S ACTIONS CAUSED THIS PROBLEM !!!

 

 

 

 

 

Who is to blame for causing all of the other mentally ill people ??? Is it different in each case ?

 

 
First | Prev | 104 | 105 | 106 | 107 | 108 | 109 | 110 | 111 | 112 | 113 | Next | Last