Message Boards

Topic : 05/22 The True Life of Marcia Brady

Number of Replies: 260
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, May 18, 2007, 12:42:20 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Every teenage girl wanted to be her and every teenage boy wanted to date her. With her signature perfectly brushed long hair, Marcia Brady, of the hit early 1970s TV show The Brady Bunch, epitomized the wholesome American girl. But the true life of Marcia Brady, whose real name is Maureen McCormick, is far from the world of lighthearted blended-family conflicts that played out on the sitcom in which she starred. Today she is embroiled in a family battle where brother is pitted against brother and father against daughter. Maureen believes her brother, Kevin, has literally brainwashed her father to alienate him from Maureen and the rest of her family, including his grandchildren. She comes to Dr. Phil desperate for help to save her family. First up, Maureen confronts her father and brother for the first time in two years, and even Dr. Phil is shocked by the outcome. Then Dr. Phil sits down with Maureen and her brother, Michael, to try and make sense of the conflict. Plus, Maureen's father and brother, Kevin, make some shocking accusations of their own. If this group must somehow form a family, then why was its most famous member issued a restraining order? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More May 2007 Show Boards

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:08 pm PDT

Ok Let Me Understand Something......

Now that Maureen has made them ALL RICH she is the villain.  Is Kevin that hard up since and envious of his sister's success that he is alienating her and turning their father against her?!?!?!?!

 

I don't understand why Dr. Phil would ask Maureen if she is crazy?  Would someone please explain that question and logic(or lack of) to m?

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:11 pm PDT

Thank you Marcia and Dr Phil

 Thanks so much for doing this show.  Prior to its airing I was unable to articulate how or why my family made me so crazy.  I was always the black sheep, the slut, the drug addict, the alcohol abuser.  In truth I was none of the aforementioned.  Yet, they seem so invested in painting me with a brush of their own device.  After much difficult deliberation I decided it was either my sanity or my family.  I turned my back on them and walked away in my 20's.  It was a hard hard decision.  However, it was punctuated with a peace of mind I had never known before.  I still have my demons...leftover inner dialog they left me with.  In spite of the voracious internal struggle, I have accomplished far more in my life than I dared dream of.  Sometimes....you just have to trust your gut and make the tough choices.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:14 pm PDT

05/22 The True Life of Marcia Brady

Quote From: kaykwilts

I remember watching this series when I was a teen. I never knew that there was turmoil in her life.  Where is her mother in all this?

 

On the show it said that her mother died several years ago.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:22 pm PDT

05/22 The True Life of Marcia Brady

Quote From: kursic

I have no problem with you being Christian or quoting the Bible, as I myself am a Christian too, but think beyond the Bible a bit (that's why God gave you the gift of reason).  Families have always been in turmoil and dysfunction has always existed in families.  In fact, the Bible has plenty of stories about such conflicts.  Families seem like they are horrible now because we as a society are not as afraid to talk about issues of conflict in families, and most people now accept the fact that not every family follows the same structure as other people would like.

 

Getting these issues out is better than simply hiding behind a Bible and in essence blaming God for the course the world has taken.

 

Of course, your original post was mostly incoherent, so don't be surprised if I misinterpreted something.

Just because someone mentions the Bible and prophesy, doesn't mean they are blaming God.  Satan is the father of all lies according to the Bible...not God.  The things that happen can be foretold in the Bible but that doesn't mean God causes it.  Just because you may know something and tell it, doesn't mean you're to blame any more than knowing a neighbor exists and mentioning their name would mean that you created them.  That's ridiculous.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
quiet
May 22, 2007, 2:24 pm PDT

I agree...

Quote From: onecutepeanut

Now that Maureen has made them ALL RICH she is the villain.  Is Kevin that hard up since and envious of his sister's success that he is alienating her and turning their father against her?!?!?!?!

 

I don't understand why Dr. Phil would ask Maureen if she is crazy?  Would someone please explain that question and logic(or lack of) to m?

I don't understand the whole asking her if she's crazy thing, either.  I guess to affirm that to the audience, but then why bother?  Is she supposed to say "yes" to that if she was?  Does a crazy person know if they're crazy?
 

Message Emote
happy
May 22, 2007, 2:29 pm PDT

Sounds like my Sister....

Fortunately no one in my family has been a total victim of my abusive sister like Maureen's father is a victim of her brother.  However, my sister has constantly caused problems in my family, and she has always tried to control us.  I can totally relate to Maureen's comments that being around her brother for a given  period of time makes her feel like she is going crazy.  My sister is one of the cruelest people I have ever met in my life.  However, if YOU were to meet her, you would think she is perfect.  She has the perfect life, a wonderful husband, a large house, and two perfect children.  She knows how to present herself to people.  However, there front doesn't last for long.  They have moved twice in the last 4 years simply because my sister is not happy. 

 

I feel really conflicted because I have removed myself completely from my sister.  She is 14 years older than I am, and I have always looked up to her.  However, when I became a mother I realized she wasn't worth the stress.  Plus, I feel she is too unstable to be around my family.  However, she would never make an effort to see me anyway.  I would have to fly to see her.  I would never want to because I am always on egg shells around her.  She has the same MO as Kevin...acuse and retreat.  Plus, she is very cruel and unapolgetic.  It just breaks my heart that I will never have a relationship with her. 

 

My sister used to have a slight hold on my other sister.  She used to tell her horrible things about my mother and me.  However, luckily my sister saw the light recently after she had a child.  Our older sister was not there for her a bit during her difficult pregnancy, and her new son's medical problems.  In fact she only lived four hours away, but didn't see her new nephew until he was over a year old. 

 

Seeing Maureen's brother makes me very thankful that my sister is no longer controling my family.  It still makes me sad because she does continue to hurt our feelings, but her days as our "puppet master" are over.  It is just heart breaking when this happens in a family.

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:34 pm PDT

05/22 The True Life of Marcia Brady

Quote From: horselightning

This has happened over the last two years. Things arnt that  balck and white in life!

IF you didn't believe her when she said they made her feel crazy then you've never dealt with someone like the members of my family where things are so absurdly ridiculous that it makes your head spin.  I had a situation with my brother before Christmas almost exactly like this and even when you "know" something isn't true, it can make you dizzy and confused when someone accuses you of things that are totally untrue and so bizarre it makes you sick.  My ex-husband was finally diagnosed as bi-polar and once he was on medication, he admitted that he'd told our friends and family in the past a bunch of lies about me, but when he was telling them the things...he truly believed it.  What's so confusing is when they truly believe their own lies and they are so convinced that it makes you feel like you're in the twilght zone or something.

 

Once when I was a teen, my mother told me to clean out all the cabinets and rearrange them before she got home from work, so I did.  When she came home, the very first thing she did was open the cabinets and then she said, "Why did you do this? Why don't you just leave things alone and mind your own business?" And went on ranting for 3 minutes or more.  I had to constantly remember who else in the house heard her tell me to do stuff and have backup to prove she had told me to do it and what time it was and what all she said, verbatim constantly.  I went to counseling for many many years and they would always ask, "What is it you are here for?" and I'd always say, "I have to know if it's my mother that's crazy or if it's me....if it's me, I'll do something about it, but if it's her then I need to know I'm not crazy so I can deal with it."  They always told me it wasn't me after we had talked for just a little while, but I still had to learn how to deal with it.  My mother and brother make me feel crazy many times.  I haven't even spoken to them since right before Christmas 2006 and probably won't.  I'm getting to old to deal with all the craziness and stupidity.  But trust me...people can make you feel that way.  When you hear two totally opposing things where there is no way that they can both be true....it does make you wonder if you've totally lost your mind.  They are so convinced they make you wonder if you've lost it.  I've always said that my childhood was like living in the twilight zone.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:39 pm PDT

"The Maureen McCormick Show"

You heard Ms. McCormick saying to Dr. Phil that she has gone through so much over the years that she would like the chance to share it with everybody.  You heard her say it.  SHE WANTS HER OWN SHOW!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:43 pm PDT

Nice show

It was nice to see Marsha Brady again. (Had a crush on her as a little boy). :P

I really hope Maureen can be reunited with her father, she seems to care for him alot even though he treated her like trash in that one video.

Do a job, Dr. Phil!

Let us know how things go for her too.

 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 22, 2007, 2:44 pm PDT

05/22 The True Life of Marcia Brady

Quote From: jargreen

I'm 48 minutes into the show and I still don't understand what Ms. McCormick is accusing her brother and father of doing.  Has this been unclear to anyone else?  The video footage of her confronting these men show them to be two very reasonable men.  That could have been my pop and me.  Now, I'll get attacked for saying this, I realize.  So, let me have it.

 

But ... isn't this pretty much a case of he said, she said, and the "she" happens to be a celebrity?

Well of course after you watched an hour long show you can judge better than Dr. Phil about who is more competant and truthful.  Get real!!!!  He's trained, what creditials do you have?
 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next | Last