Message Boards

Topic : Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Number of Replies: 2654
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:13:41 am
Author : dataimport
Love them, tolerate them, or despise them? Dealing with the in-laws can be stressful to a marriage. Share your stories and coping strategies.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 2:06 pm PST

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: jenoc99

The only question I have is have you ever complained or talked badly/negatively about your husband to your mother? Or, to your husband to your mother? Because if you have in the past, either of them might be holding onto old resentments over things you've told them in the past.. perhaps a fight that you had, or something hurtful that was said. When a wife complains to her family about things that go on within her marriage, it will definatly cause friction. So, if you have done that, you need to stop ASAP. No more speaking negatively about your husband to your family, or to your family about your husband. (If you ever did in the first place, that is!)  

How long has this been going on? 

This sounds uncomfortable! Since your mom is very sociable, does she try to start conversations with your husband? Have you asked your husband why doesn't he say hi? Thats just rude, to see people and not even say  hello... My advice to you is to have a conversation- not a fight- and ask him why he doesn't speak to your family. Whatever his answer is, consider if it has any truth to it, or if it is just an excuse. SOmetimes when a wife has a good relationship with their family, it can make a husband jelous... he feels 'out of the loop' and he wants to keep you all to himself. I hope that isn't the case with you, though! It is best when there is love to share, and it sounds like there is plenty to go around in your family. 

I wish you the best!! 

no I try to keep that to myself.  My mother wants a relationship with my husband but he shoots down everthing she does.   

I just do not understand it.  so now the come into a room and say nothing to each other. 

  

that is not acceptable with a little one growing up.. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 2:41 pm PST

Same story, different day!

Quote From: mfmauriell

those quotes were great! my MIL should have a copy sent to her! unfortunately she is too busy telling her husband everyday that he is dying and telling her children this as well. even though the Dr. advised her not to but of course she knows better. my father inlaw has prostate cancer and has been going for treatments for a long while, but its starting to get to him, so she reminds him everyday how much he looks tired and that he is dying. her own children dont want to talk to her for long because they know what is next out of her mouth. its a darn shame.  

My MIL is the same, my FIL recently had major surgery and for as well as he was progressing, all she could do was tell him how bad off he was and actually making up new diagnoses for him, like "now you've been through all of this now you've probably got cancer"!  Unbelievable!  Mostly it is just a ploy to have more attention paid to them so she thinks hopefully we will drop what we are doing and come be their hired hands!  NOT! 

  

It is a darn shame!~ 

  

If  my husband had cancer or some other disease I can't even imagine telling him how bad he looks or even that he'sdying, GEEZE!.  Cancer patients and people who deal with chronic disease need all the love and support they can get.   

  

My grandpa always told me to "kill them with kindness" and a "positive attitude goes a long way".  So when my MIL starts her who-is me's, it's all smiles and sunshine from us to her, and she just really can't stand that, go figure! 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 4:48 pm PST

how to get along with my in-laws

Let me by first telling you that I am married and have 2 children.  My husband and I have been married for 7 years.  I have been through a lot in my life being a child of alcoholic parents, My mother also died when my daughter was just 3 months old from being an alcoholic.  I have a mentally challenge sister whom between me and my husband help my father with her.   

My question is how to deal with a mother in law.  I have always tried to get along with her, but sometimes it is very difficult.  She has always been one that would rather buy my children  anything and everything that they want to get them to love her.  I don't always agree with that, but I accept that is how she is.  My problem with her has always been that she will call my son, and tell him she is going to come and get him and they are going to go do something, and then doesn't show up.  And let me add, that she doesn't have alot to do with my daughter.  This is not a one time thing, this has happend since my mother passed away 5 years ago.  I have always expressed to her that just not to call and tell him she is going to get him, just to show up.  Or if she does tell him, to atleast be there as she promised.   

  

Well a couple of months ago, she told my son he could come up and play with her and they would swim, well she was not able to do it again, because she was going out to eat with her step-grandchild.  My son cried forever it seemed like.  So I have been a little upset.  About a week or two later I found out that she told her sister, That I am a pretend mother, I just act like I care about my children.  That I am not a good mother to her grandchildren, or her son.  She told her that she has never liked me or will she ever like me, and that she would like to try and take my children away from me.   

  

I do not have to say that this made me very angry, however I did not say anything to her.  Now a couple of weeks later, it was my husbands sisters wedding shower, and my mother-in-law hit me twice in the face while my children were both holding my hands as we were leaving.   I have not spoken to her since.   

  

my husband has still talked with her, and my daugter.  However my son will not have anything to do with her.  Even though I have tried to explain that its ok, and sometimes grownups do childish things, that she is still his grandmother. 

  

My mother-in-law, will not let this rest, she is still telling people that I'm not a good wife, and that my husband is unhappy in our marrige.  I have asked my husband this and he says this is untrue.  That he is very happy to be with me.     

  

  

It is very hard to have this going on in my family, is there any advise on how to deal with my mother-in-law.  I feel I can't trust her, or that I should ever go around her again.  However, I love my husband and I do not want him to feel that he is in the middle between us.  Because after losing my mother, I would never want to be in the way of my husband and his mother.  Because to me that is a bond that should not be broken.   

  

Thanks for any advise you can give. thanks 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 5:54 pm PST

Your MIL

Quote From: apayne

Let me by first telling you that I am married and have 2 children.  My husband and I have been married for 7 years.  I have been through a lot in my life being a child of alcoholic parents, My mother also died when my daughter was just 3 months old from being an alcoholic.  I have a mentally challenge sister whom between me and my husband help my father with her.   

My question is how to deal with a mother in law.  I have always tried to get along with her, but sometimes it is very difficult.  She has always been one that would rather buy my children  anything and everything that they want to get them to love her.  I don't always agree with that, but I accept that is how she is.  My problem with her has always been that she will call my son, and tell him she is going to come and get him and they are going to go do something, and then doesn't show up.  And let me add, that she doesn't have alot to do with my daughter.  This is not a one time thing, this has happend since my mother passed away 5 years ago.  I have always expressed to her that just not to call and tell him she is going to get him, just to show up.  Or if she does tell him, to atleast be there as she promised.   

  

Well a couple of months ago, she told my son he could come up and play with her and they would swim, well she was not able to do it again, because she was going out to eat with her step-grandchild.  My son cried forever it seemed like.  So I have been a little upset.  About a week or two later I found out that she told her sister, That I am a pretend mother, I just act like I care about my children.  That I am not a good mother to her grandchildren, or her son.  She told her that she has never liked me or will she ever like me, and that she would like to try and take my children away from me.   

  

I do not have to say that this made me very angry, however I did not say anything to her.  Now a couple of weeks later, it was my husbands sisters wedding shower, and my mother-in-law hit me twice in the face while my children were both holding my hands as we were leaving.   I have not spoken to her since.   

  

my husband has still talked with her, and my daugter.  However my son will not have anything to do with her.  Even though I have tried to explain that its ok, and sometimes grownups do childish things, that she is still his grandmother. 

  

My mother-in-law, will not let this rest, she is still telling people that I'm not a good wife, and that my husband is unhappy in our marrige.  I have asked my husband this and he says this is untrue.  That he is very happy to be with me.     

  

  

It is very hard to have this going on in my family, is there any advise on how to deal with my mother-in-law.  I feel I can't trust her, or that I should ever go around her again.  However, I love my husband and I do not want him to feel that he is in the middle between us.  Because after losing my mother, I would never want to be in the way of my husband and his mother.  Because to me that is a bond that should not be broken.   

  

Thanks for any advise you can give. thanks 

You can't trust your MIL because she is an untrustworthy person! 

Your MIl would love it so much if she did cause problems between you and your husband, because then, the things she is gossiping about would be true AND she could have her little boy (your husband) back all to herself. That is probably what most of this is about- her being jelous of the relationship that you have with your husband. She wants to be you. 

She says terrible things about you, why do you permit your children to be with her? How can you trust her to be kind to them and not say terrible things to them? I'm just curious to know how you rationalize her behavior. I understand how you feel because you have lost your own mom, however, that doesn't mean that you can compare your mother to your MIL... people are not all the same, your MIL is not pure, innocent, and all-good. She is manipultive, controling, and likes to start chaos. You would be better off by taking these privledges away from her- don't allow her to bring her chaos into your life any longer. She is poisoning your happiness, and she will continue to do it for as long as you allow her to. My advice for you is to take back your personal power!! You deserve to have peace and happiness in your life starting today. I wish you the best!! 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
quiet
November 3, 2005, 5:42 am PST

Look at it this way...

Quote From: apayne

Let me by first telling you that I am married and have 2 children.  My husband and I have been married for 7 years.  I have been through a lot in my life being a child of alcoholic parents, My mother also died when my daughter was just 3 months old from being an alcoholic.  I have a mentally challenge sister whom between me and my husband help my father with her.   

My question is how to deal with a mother in law.  I have always tried to get along with her, but sometimes it is very difficult.  She has always been one that would rather buy my children  anything and everything that they want to get them to love her.  I don't always agree with that, but I accept that is how she is.  My problem with her has always been that she will call my son, and tell him she is going to come and get him and they are going to go do something, and then doesn't show up.  And let me add, that she doesn't have alot to do with my daughter.  This is not a one time thing, this has happend since my mother passed away 5 years ago.  I have always expressed to her that just not to call and tell him she is going to get him, just to show up.  Or if she does tell him, to atleast be there as she promised.   

  

Well a couple of months ago, she told my son he could come up and play with her and they would swim, well she was not able to do it again, because she was going out to eat with her step-grandchild.  My son cried forever it seemed like.  So I have been a little upset.  About a week or two later I found out that she told her sister, That I am a pretend mother, I just act like I care about my children.  That I am not a good mother to her grandchildren, or her son.  She told her that she has never liked me or will she ever like me, and that she would like to try and take my children away from me.   

  

I do not have to say that this made me very angry, however I did not say anything to her.  Now a couple of weeks later, it was my husbands sisters wedding shower, and my mother-in-law hit me twice in the face while my children were both holding my hands as we were leaving.   I have not spoken to her since.   

  

my husband has still talked with her, and my daugter.  However my son will not have anything to do with her.  Even though I have tried to explain that its ok, and sometimes grownups do childish things, that she is still his grandmother. 

  

My mother-in-law, will not let this rest, she is still telling people that I'm not a good wife, and that my husband is unhappy in our marrige.  I have asked my husband this and he says this is untrue.  That he is very happy to be with me.     

  

  

It is very hard to have this going on in my family, is there any advise on how to deal with my mother-in-law.  I feel I can't trust her, or that I should ever go around her again.  However, I love my husband and I do not want him to feel that he is in the middle between us.  Because after losing my mother, I would never want to be in the way of my husband and his mother.  Because to me that is a bond that should not be broken.   

  

Thanks for any advise you can give. thanks 

 If she had hit your son, twice, in the face, would you allow her near him again? That was not OK, and to make it worse, she hit you in front of her grandchildren. She has already ruined her image as a loving grandmother in your children's eyes. They are justified in not wanting to see her, or be near her. Your telling them it was OK is not OK. You are sending your son the message that adults do this to each other. What a horrible thought! Violence is a dealbreaker,and she brought it on herself. You do not let your children in the presense of anyone who can't control themselves, related to you or not. This woman is unstable, unpredictable, and unreliable. It's understandable that your husband would want to interact with her from time to time, but I would never again allow her to be alone with my children.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 7:59 am PST

HELP

I have never done this before so here it goes... My husband and I have been married for 10 years and in whose years I have let my mother in-law pretty much do or say what ever she wanted to. Even though we are in our thirty's she will not let the idea of my husband being a child go. My husband is a very strong willed person but is very respectful and doesn't want to hurt anyone but lately we have had to let those ideas go (I will get to that later) All of our problems started one week before our wedding. She had bought her dress and we were on our way to pick it up now I had not seen the dress (I had alot of other things on my mind) at the store she said I will show you the dress when we get back to the house.I thought that was strange but didn't think much about . At there house she showed it to me and it was WHITE. Now this lady is not someone without class she knew what she was doing. I really was so surprised I didn't say anything and now I know I should have. At the wedding she saw my mother crying as I was walking down the ile and later that day in front of very one made a rude comment about it. Well years have went on and thing have went from bad to HORRIABLE.My children have been born and she has always had pride that she is the MEAN GRANDMA.  Telling everyone that is a joy to her. She has always made it clear that they are her children. When letting them see her for a day or two and they would get a runny nose or something the first thing she would do is give them medicine even though she knows I don't believe in doing that. She is very controlling and Yells alot. It doesn't matter if you have just meant her or if you are her husband. My husbands Father just lets her run his life and everyone elses. He has given up and if anything is starting to turn into her.  

  

Well alot of bad things have happened lately and that is why I am writing. Over the course of one year we have pretty much stopped talking. Something happened to me I woke up. I have for some reason not wanted someone else to have that control over me. But I feel bad for my kids. I was in the hospital for a day and needed someone to watch them during that one day she took them and had they're pictures taken and then didn't even bother to tell me about it. And wasn't going to offer any to me. When we told her that she had no right to do that She said that she had every right to do what ever she wanted with the kids. Even though she has asked to see the kids once over the last year. I  asked my oldest who is eight if he had fun with her on that day and he said that all she did was yelled. There is so much more that I could say but don't have room for like that we all did go to counseling and he said that it wasn't going to work it's self out and that we needed to keep going but they (inlaws) said that they didn't want to do it any more (I guess they didn't like what the counsler had to say) I have made a big change in my life and I have to be honest my husband loves that I am finally standing up for me and our marriage. But I don't want to be the bad one with Christmas coming. Should I bite the bullet and have dinner with them on the holidays or should I think of it like this "they don't want to be with us for the rest of the year so why should we see them on a special day" I should mention that my husband is AWESOME and is behind me 100% and hates how his parents treat people. Honestly he is the one that doesn't want to spend any more time with them I really think that they have hurt him for the last time.  

  

What should I do and am I handling this all the right way? 

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 8:23 am PST

your toxic in-laws..............

Quote From: ldr12976

I have never done this before so here it goes... My husband and I have been married for 10 years and in whose years I have let my mother in-law pretty much do or say what ever she wanted to. Even though we are in our thirty's she will not let the idea of my husband being a child go. My husband is a very strong willed person but is very respectful and doesn't want to hurt anyone but lately we have had to let those ideas go (I will get to that later) All of our problems started one week before our wedding. She had bought her dress and we were on our way to pick it up now I had not seen the dress (I had alot of other things on my mind) at the store she said I will show you the dress when we get back to the house.I thought that was strange but didn't think much about . At there house she showed it to me and it was WHITE. Now this lady is not someone without class she knew what she was doing. I really was so surprised I didn't say anything and now I know I should have. At the wedding she saw my mother crying as I was walking down the ile and later that day in front of very one made a rude comment about it. Well years have went on and thing have went from bad to HORRIABLE.My children have been born and she has always had pride that she is the MEAN GRANDMA.  Telling everyone that is a joy to her. She has always made it clear that they are her children. When letting them see her for a day or two and they would get a runny nose or something the first thing she would do is give them medicine even though she knows I don't believe in doing that. She is very controlling and Yells alot. It doesn't matter if you have just meant her or if you are her husband. My husbands Father just lets her run his life and everyone elses. He has given up and if anything is starting to turn into her.  

  

Well alot of bad things have happened lately and that is why I am writing. Over the course of one year we have pretty much stopped talking. Something happened to me I woke up. I have for some reason not wanted someone else to have that control over me. But I feel bad for my kids. I was in the hospital for a day and needed someone to watch them during that one day she took them and had they're pictures taken and then didn't even bother to tell me about it. And wasn't going to offer any to me. When we told her that she had no right to do that She said that she had every right to do what ever she wanted with the kids. Even though she has asked to see the kids once over the last year. I  asked my oldest who is eight if he had fun with her on that day and he said that all she did was yelled. There is so much more that I could say but don't have room for like that we all did go to counseling and he said that it wasn't going to work it's self out and that we needed to keep going but they (inlaws) said that they didn't want to do it any more (I guess they didn't like what the counsler had to say) I have made a big change in my life and I have to be honest my husband loves that I am finally standing up for me and our marriage. But I don't want to be the bad one with Christmas coming. Should I bite the bullet and have dinner with them on the holidays or should I think of it like this "they don't want to be with us for the rest of the year so why should we see them on a special day" I should mention that my husband is AWESOME and is behind me 100% and hates how his parents treat people. Honestly he is the one that doesn't want to spend any more time with them I really think that they have hurt him for the last time.  

  

What should I do and am I handling this all the right way? 

  

How sad that your MIL hadn't spent time with the kids for awhile, and all she could do when she did see them was yell. She has serious issues that won't be solved by  having a holiday dinner with her. My honest advice to you, is to have a great, stress free holiday without the inlaws! Your MIL just wants to drag you down, she gets enjoyment out of controlling other people's lives... don't give her one more day of power in your life. Its a good thing that you are gaining strength and taking a stand for yourself, and for your kids. You are a strong role model in their lives, it is important that they see mom and dad stick together and stand up for what they believe in. You are also protecting your children from being mistreated... I know that it would be wonderful if suddenly, she was a nice grandma... but obviously that isn't going to happen. There isn't anything that you can do to make it happen, either. You deserve to have peace and happiness, so go for it. I wish you the best!! By the way, YOU are not the "bad guy"..... she is the bad guy. You know that in your heart. 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 10:54 am PST

Sister in law from hell

My husband and i have been married almost 3 years now. My in-laws (husband's parents) live with us upstairs as we have a 2 family house. We live very well together and have no problems expect one...my horrible sister in law. She has tried to break my husband and i up severl times by telling lies to each of us and that has been going on since we were dating. Now she has a child and every time my in laws don't do exactly what she wants she throws a huge fit and tells them they will never see their grandchild again. I have basicly had it with her and if i never see her again that would be too soon. However it hurts my in laws to no end that their daughter causes so many problems and that we bascily want nothing to do with her. Now the holidays are coming up and they want her here for the holiday dinner and i'm saying no way as is my husband because of all the problems. I need help...suggestions....something on how not to hate her and maybe how to deal with her so my in laws can stop hurting over this.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 11:42 am PST

same old song please help me

 I've posted a message about this before but I need some more help! 

  

My MIL wants my daughter to call her MOM. I am so sick of it and I honestly can't handle this anymore. I've talked to her about it, and I assumed after our convo. it had been taken care of but I am very wrong. She's doing it 10 times worse and louder than before. I'm at the point where I just to not be around her at all. I know she thinks my daughter is her child but she's not.  

 I don't know if this all got worse because I don't want her in the delivery room this time when I have our second child ( she drove me nuts the first time) or what. 

 Please I'm close to tears please help me. 

Stephanie  

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
chillin'
November 3, 2005, 12:17 pm PST

Why are you in doubt?

Quote From: ldr12976

I have never done this before so here it goes... My husband and I have been married for 10 years and in whose years I have let my mother in-law pretty much do or say what ever she wanted to. Even though we are in our thirty's she will not let the idea of my husband being a child go. My husband is a very strong willed person but is very respectful and doesn't want to hurt anyone but lately we have had to let those ideas go (I will get to that later) All of our problems started one week before our wedding. She had bought her dress and we were on our way to pick it up now I had not seen the dress (I had alot of other things on my mind) at the store she said I will show you the dress when we get back to the house.I thought that was strange but didn't think much about . At there house she showed it to me and it was WHITE. Now this lady is not someone without class she knew what she was doing. I really was so surprised I didn't say anything and now I know I should have. At the wedding she saw my mother crying as I was walking down the ile and later that day in front of very one made a rude comment about it. Well years have went on and thing have went from bad to HORRIABLE.My children have been born and she has always had pride that she is the MEAN GRANDMA.  Telling everyone that is a joy to her. She has always made it clear that they are her children. When letting them see her for a day or two and they would get a runny nose or something the first thing she would do is give them medicine even though she knows I don't believe in doing that. She is very controlling and Yells alot. It doesn't matter if you have just meant her or if you are her husband. My husbands Father just lets her run his life and everyone elses. He has given up and if anything is starting to turn into her.  

  

Well alot of bad things have happened lately and that is why I am writing. Over the course of one year we have pretty much stopped talking. Something happened to me I woke up. I have for some reason not wanted someone else to have that control over me. But I feel bad for my kids. I was in the hospital for a day and needed someone to watch them during that one day she took them and had they're pictures taken and then didn't even bother to tell me about it. And wasn't going to offer any to me. When we told her that she had no right to do that She said that she had every right to do what ever she wanted with the kids. Even though she has asked to see the kids once over the last year. I  asked my oldest who is eight if he had fun with her on that day and he said that all she did was yelled. There is so much more that I could say but don't have room for like that we all did go to counseling and he said that it wasn't going to work it's self out and that we needed to keep going but they (inlaws) said that they didn't want to do it any more (I guess they didn't like what the counsler had to say) I have made a big change in my life and I have to be honest my husband loves that I am finally standing up for me and our marriage. But I don't want to be the bad one with Christmas coming. Should I bite the bullet and have dinner with them on the holidays or should I think of it like this "they don't want to be with us for the rest of the year so why should we see them on a special day" I should mention that my husband is AWESOME and is behind me 100% and hates how his parents treat people. Honestly he is the one that doesn't want to spend any more time with them I really think that they have hurt him for the last time.  

  

What should I do and am I handling this all the right way? 

  

 Your kids don't like to visit them, your husband (who is their son is) done with them, I don't see why you are agonizing about this. Somewhere in our 30's most people do "wake up" and become completely separated from their parents, from a dependency viewpoint. This is what has happened with you. Your MIL has gone out of her way to get you to run from her, so don't feel bad about it. She has taught you all how to treat her, go ahead and treat her that way.

And about your wedding, everybody there saw what she was up to, and probably talked about her later with shaking heads. I know I would have.
 
First | Prev | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | Next | Last