Message Boards

Topic : Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Number of Replies: 2654
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:13:41 am
Author : dataimport
Love them, tolerate them, or despise them? Dealing with the in-laws can be stressful to a marriage. Share your stories and coping strategies.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 7:49 am PDT

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: twins2006

I was just recently married on September 1st but have been with her 7 years . My wife just found out she is pregnant for twins and my mom is really excited maybe too excited. My wife is getting really overwhelmed by all the phone calls and advice . My wife feels my mom is treating her like an idiot and I think my mom just wants to help I am in the middle and have talked to both sides. I want my wife to comfortable and yes i want one big happy family what can i do to help? 

  

  

Joe 

I know you want to honnor your mother. However your future children are at stake. Your wife could get so stressed out that something could happen to them. My husband had to take his mother aside when she started the same stuff. It used to drive me insane, she'd call 20 times a day and would leave the longest messages. It would stress me out to the point of tears. Just think about your wife and children. Your wife doesn't need the additional stress or to hear she's not right. Stand up for her she may not be in the mood to. 

Stephanie  

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
October 21, 2005, 11:12 am PDT

What do I do?

I have a sister-in-law that I cannot stomach!  My husband and I have been married for almost 11 years and we have 2 children.  His family lives 4 hours from us and his mother just recently passed away.  Now he wants to spend Thanksgiving with his sister and I do not want to-at all.  My choice is, either spend it with a woman I despise or spend it without my husband.  I would like some feedback, but before anyone jumps on this-here is the history:  It all started when our daughter was born 6 years ago.  His sister had a fit because she was not named the Godmother.  We had never given her any reason to think she would be-she smoked and drinks heavily and not to mention, she has no control over her own kids and she is just a spaz!  Then one year, we were visiting for the 4th of July-and had brought our chocolate lab puppy along.  She proceeded to get drunk and started making a scene-calling her own mother a bitch and carrying on about how our "viscious attack dog" had "gouged" her daughter.  (They were playing and our puppy jumped up and scratched her arm.)  We exchanged words that night  and didn't speak to each other for 1 1/2 years--fine by me!  I finally agreed to bury the hatchet - no apoogies were ever offered.  Everyone else had excused her behavior as "that's just the way she is."  My mother-in-law became very ill, so we spent last Christmas with his family, anticipating that this would be her last .  My SIL starts in-by making a spectacle out of me, in front of a room full of people-most of whom I had never met before (friends of hers).  As if it wasn't bad enough that I had to spend the holidays with strangers, now she has to make snide comments about how I am the "queen"-everyone waits on me and I hadn't helped her do anything all day.  This woman is a control freak-to the extreme.  I had offered to help, but she didn't need it.  My husband is always good about helping out and letting me relax.  Plus, my daughter was the youngest child there and nobody was playing with her-so I was keeping her entertained.  By the end of the night, my husband and her are shouting at the top of their lungs-she is calling me names and complaining about me to him, as if I am not in the room.  Every time I try to defend myself, she reads something else into what I am saying.  Eventually, I give up and become concerned about my MIL-as we think she had had a minor heart attack earlier in the day.  She is becoming increasingly stressed-she fell in the bathroom.  I decided to not feed into my SIL-I just take care of my MIL.  I am talking to her, calming her down...when my SIL sits down, points her finger in my face-right in front of this frail woman who looks like she is knocking on death's door!  I finally put my hand in her face and told her to shut up-I was not going to do this anymore because of her mother.  (oh, I forgot to mention that her own mother had called her a bitch earlier and she actually threw a glass at her!)  PSYCHO!  We had plans to see a movie in the IMAX theater the next day, but instead, we packed up our stuff and left early the next morning.  Our children were upstairs listening to the arguing the whole time.  What a way for a 9 and 5 year old to spend Christmas!  I am sure her kids are used to her ranting and raving, but my kids are not.  So, now he wants to spend Thanksgiving with her!  This has always been our one holiday that we spend together.  We never go anywhere, or do anything with anyone else.  We have never spent Thanksgiving with his family, ever.  But now, "it's the first one since mom died" so he feels guilted into going .  I am torn because I have told my husband how I feel.  I don't care if I ever see her again-I cringe at the sound of her voice or the mention of her name.  She stresses me out, as do her kids.  I want to spend my traditional Thanksgiving in a nice quiet, peaceful environment, with my family, as I always do.  Am I a bad wife for not compromising so my husband can be with his family?  The thing that makes me the most angry is that this woman never apologizes.  Everyone excuses her behavior because she is nuts.  She has untreated adult ADHD and is the biggest drama queen you'd ever meet.  I want to be with my husband for Thanksgiving and more importantly, for my children to be with their dad.  But, in my heart, it just makes me sick to think of spending another holiday with that woman.  Peoplel say they understand why I am angry, but is it wrong of me to STAY so angry?  I just don't think I have the energy for her, but I don't want to upset my husband.  What do I do?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 23, 2005, 9:00 am PDT

Anger, frustration, resentment...........

Quote From: marasmom

I have a sister-in-law that I cannot stomach!  My husband and I have been married for almost 11 years and we have 2 children.  His family lives 4 hours from us and his mother just recently passed away.  Now he wants to spend Thanksgiving with his sister and I do not want to-at all.  My choice is, either spend it with a woman I despise or spend it without my husband.  I would like some feedback, but before anyone jumps on this-here is the history:  It all started when our daughter was born 6 years ago.  His sister had a fit because she was not named the Godmother.  We had never given her any reason to think she would be-she smoked and drinks heavily and not to mention, she has no control over her own kids and she is just a spaz!  Then one year, we were visiting for the 4th of July-and had brought our chocolate lab puppy along.  She proceeded to get drunk and started making a scene-calling her own mother a bitch and carrying on about how our "viscious attack dog" had "gouged" her daughter.  (They were playing and our puppy jumped up and scratched her arm.)  We exchanged words that night  and didn't speak to each other for 1 1/2 years--fine by me!  I finally agreed to bury the hatchet - no apoogies were ever offered.  Everyone else had excused her behavior as "that's just the way she is."  My mother-in-law became very ill, so we spent last Christmas with his family, anticipating that this would be her last .  My SIL starts in-by making a spectacle out of me, in front of a room full of people-most of whom I had never met before (friends of hers).  As if it wasn't bad enough that I had to spend the holidays with strangers, now she has to make snide comments about how I am the "queen"-everyone waits on me and I hadn't helped her do anything all day.  This woman is a control freak-to the extreme.  I had offered to help, but she didn't need it.  My husband is always good about helping out and letting me relax.  Plus, my daughter was the youngest child there and nobody was playing with her-so I was keeping her entertained.  By the end of the night, my husband and her are shouting at the top of their lungs-she is calling me names and complaining about me to him, as if I am not in the room.  Every time I try to defend myself, she reads something else into what I am saying.  Eventually, I give up and become concerned about my MIL-as we think she had had a minor heart attack earlier in the day.  She is becoming increasingly stressed-she fell in the bathroom.  I decided to not feed into my SIL-I just take care of my MIL.  I am talking to her, calming her down...when my SIL sits down, points her finger in my face-right in front of this frail woman who looks like she is knocking on death's door!  I finally put my hand in her face and told her to shut up-I was not going to do this anymore because of her mother.  (oh, I forgot to mention that her own mother had called her a bitch earlier and she actually threw a glass at her!)  PSYCHO!  We had plans to see a movie in the IMAX theater the next day, but instead, we packed up our stuff and left early the next morning.  Our children were upstairs listening to the arguing the whole time.  What a way for a 9 and 5 year old to spend Christmas!  I am sure her kids are used to her ranting and raving, but my kids are not.  So, now he wants to spend Thanksgiving with her!  This has always been our one holiday that we spend together.  We never go anywhere, or do anything with anyone else.  We have never spent Thanksgiving with his family, ever.  But now, "it's the first one since mom died" so he feels guilted into going .  I am torn because I have told my husband how I feel.  I don't care if I ever see her again-I cringe at the sound of her voice or the mention of her name.  She stresses me out, as do her kids.  I want to spend my traditional Thanksgiving in a nice quiet, peaceful environment, with my family, as I always do.  Am I a bad wife for not compromising so my husband can be with his family?  The thing that makes me the most angry is that this woman never apologizes.  Everyone excuses her behavior because she is nuts.  She has untreated adult ADHD and is the biggest drama queen you'd ever meet.  I want to be with my husband for Thanksgiving and more importantly, for my children to be with their dad.  But, in my heart, it just makes me sick to think of spending another holiday with that woman.  Peoplel say they understand why I am angry, but is it wrong of me to STAY so angry?  I just don't think I have the energy for her, but I don't want to upset my husband.  What do I do?

No, you are not a bad wife for not compromising over Thanksgiving! 

Thanksgiving should be a pleasant time for you and your family. If your husband chooses to feed into his sister's controling nature, so be it... You need to make peace with his choice if he does decide to go there for the holiday. I know that this makes you feel so many different emotions, mostly angry and sad, however, if he does go there for the holiday, you need to have a smile on your face and say to him, "i really wish that you'd stay here and have a peaceful, calm holiday, but I understand your feeling guilty and you are torn, so we will see you when you get back...." You probably can't imagine saying those words and truly meaning it, but when you let him go and allow him to see for himself that YOU ARE RIGHT. The only way he will find out is if he goes, otherwise, he will always think to himself that he is a crappy brother for abandoning his poor sister after their mother died.. even though you and I know thats not the case, thats how she is presenting it to him and trying to gain his sympathy. You know how she is, but because your husband grew up with this drama queen, he is "used" to this behavior as being "normal" and he feels it is neccessary to give her chance after chance. It is reasonable for you to ask that he defend you if she says anything bad about you, and you should request that he bring you up if she doesn't ask about you and the kids, too. He is a grown man, he shouldn't feel torn between his families, you need to be the bigger person and let this woman show your husband what a big b*tch she truly is, I don't think she will dissapoint you!! He will come home and say, "honey, you were right!!"  

I wish you the best! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 23, 2005, 4:54 pm PDT

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Iv been with my partner for 7 years,just resently we have been having problems. His mother doesnt have anything to do with our three year old daughter she say is because our relationship is so rocky and she is worryed i will leave and take our daughter and she wont be able to see her ive told her its not the case and i would never stop her from seeing her granddaughter but she keeps pushing her away and has more to fo with my partners sisters child than she does her first grandchild and this is really upseting me and i dont know what to do. Ive asked my partner to talk to his mother about it but he just doesnt seem to care. Has anyone got any suggestions on how i can get  my mother inlaw to have more to with my daughter?
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 6:01 am PDT

it's her loss

Quote From: joaniebabe

Iv been with my partner for 7 years,just resently we have been having problems. His mother doesnt have anything to do with our three year old daughter she say is because our relationship is so rocky and she is worryed i will leave and take our daughter and she wont be able to see her ive told her its not the case and i would never stop her from seeing her granddaughter but she keeps pushing her away and has more to fo with my partners sisters child than she does her first grandchild and this is really upseting me and i dont know what to do. Ive asked my partner to talk to his mother about it but he just doesnt seem to care. Has anyone got any suggestions on how i can get  my mother inlaw to have more to with my daughter?
Your mil is just making excuses for her "own" behavior by not having anything to do with her grandchild. You cant force her to see her but I would leave the door open for when she gets ready. I know exactly how you feel. My mil has had nothing to do with her grandchildren that we have and it has been nearly 2 years since she even had a visit with them and we live walking distance away. No b-days, no phone calls no nothing. She has everything to do with my husbands first child by a ex girlfriend and her excuse to us is "well, your kids have their parents together and he dont". "I feel sorry for him" AND " we go directly by a schedule and we dont have time to come see them". BUT they see the other child every other weekend and he is in another county. Dont allow any excuses from her, she is being selfish in her own way and it is her loss not yours or your childs. With the way my mil acts towards our kids, we prefer her to stay out of the picture mainly because she cant treat them fair and she shows no feelings towards our kids. It is a shame they have to act like that and be that way towards a child.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 6:01 am PDT

it's her loss

Quote From: joaniebabe

Iv been with my partner for 7 years,just resently we have been having problems. His mother doesnt have anything to do with our three year old daughter she say is because our relationship is so rocky and she is worryed i will leave and take our daughter and she wont be able to see her ive told her its not the case and i would never stop her from seeing her granddaughter but she keeps pushing her away and has more to fo with my partners sisters child than she does her first grandchild and this is really upseting me and i dont know what to do. Ive asked my partner to talk to his mother about it but he just doesnt seem to care. Has anyone got any suggestions on how i can get  my mother inlaw to have more to with my daughter?
Your mil is just making excuses for her "own" behavior by not having anything to do with her grandchild. You cant force her to see her but I would leave the door open for when she gets ready. I know exactly how you feel. My mil has had nothing to do with her grandchildren that we have and it has been nearly 2 years since she even had a visit with them and we live walking distance away. No b-days, no phone calls no nothing. She has everything to do with my husbands first child by a ex girlfriend and her excuse to us is "well, your kids have their parents together and he dont". "I feel sorry for him" AND " we go directly by a schedule and we dont have time to come see them". BUT they see the other child every other weekend and he is in another county. Dont allow any excuses from her, she is being selfish in her own way and it is her loss not yours or your childs. With the way my mil acts towards our kids, we prefer her to stay out of the picture mainly because she cant treat them fair and she shows no feelings towards our kids. It is a shame they have to act like that and be that way towards a child.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 12:17 pm PDT

mother in law or nightmare

I have been with my husband three years we both have been married before and I have a 8 year old son and he has an 8 year old daughter and we now have a 7 month old son together. Our relationship has been far from easy between the ex's. But his mother feels that she is his daughters mother due to her helping him over three years ago. I have tried to allow her time to adjust to the fact that i take care of her now ( she lives with us). However she treats both thegrandsons different then the grandaughter. I have ask and told her that they need to all be treated equal. So I'm at a loss and not sure what else to do as to sometimes I feel I will always have this problem. My husband just says I tell her and she doesn't listen shoudn't this be his battle not mine????  Help :(
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 6:06 pm PDT

divorced inlaws

Quote From: belle_x

My husband and I have been married for about a year now and we also have an 8 month old son. His parents recently divorced right before the birth of our son. His brother and two younger sisters all are in college but his little sister who is only 14 lives with my father-in-law. My husband was going to college but dropped out because he had to pay the bills for my father-in-law since my father-in-law does not work. With all the pressure from relatives, my father-in-law has decided to remarry by the end of this year. If this marriage does occur, he informed my husband and I and we will have to take care of his 14 year old daughter because his new wife won't want her. My mother-in-law refuses to pay child support for the 14 year old either. I feel so angry that my in-laws are not taking responsibility for their children. My husband and I are newly weds and are first time parents of an 8 month old and feel so stressed at the thought of taking responsibilty of a 14 year old. To make matters worse, I don't even get along with the 14 year old. She criticizes everything I do and tells my son that I am a bad mother. I want to get along with my in-laws but I am at my wits end. Please help! 

  

belle 

There is no getting along here without both of you putting your feet down. 

  

This is something your husband should be nipping in the bud. But apparently not if he would quit school to support his father who does not work? 

  

Your husband needs to put his wife and child first and be responsible for you and your baby, that is where his loyalty should be not his dead beat father. Have him tell your FIL & MIL that if they don't look after their daughter he will report them to child welfare! And then follow through. That will get their attention. You guys need to put up a united front here. 

  

If your FIL punishes you by not speaking ever again to you, not much of a loss. But my guess is that he will be coming around when he needs help so you won't be loosing him for long. But if you say no and be consistant, he will get the message and quit using you both. 

  

BTW when the 14 year old comes to visit and I am talking about visits that last hours not days. You remind her whose house she is in and that her comments about your mothering skills are not welcome and if she keeps it up tell her she is not welcome in your home. 

  

I don't believe you guys should have to do any compromising here. These people are dumping their responsibilities on people who have allowed it to happen in the past. Ask yourselves why are they imposing themselves on you? My guess it has more to do with knowing you will let them and wearing out their welcome elsewhere than anything else. 

  

Sounds harsh, but unless someone else has some logical suggestions....... 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 10:21 pm PDT

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: jb7ctx

Your mil is just making excuses for her "own" behavior by not having anything to do with her grandchild. You cant force her to see her but I would leave the door open for when she gets ready. I know exactly how you feel. My mil has had nothing to do with her grandchildren that we have and it has been nearly 2 years since she even had a visit with them and we live walking distance away. No b-days, no phone calls no nothing. She has everything to do with my husbands first child by a ex girlfriend and her excuse to us is "well, your kids have their parents together and he dont". "I feel sorry for him" AND " we go directly by a schedule and we dont have time to come see them". BUT they see the other child every other weekend and he is in another county. Dont allow any excuses from her, she is being selfish in her own way and it is her loss not yours or your childs. With the way my mil acts towards our kids, we prefer her to stay out of the picture mainly because she cant treat them fair and she shows no feelings towards our kids. It is a shame they have to act like that and be that way towards a child.
  i understand what your saying and the door will always be open for her but it really hurts that she spends everyday with my partners sisters child but not mine which is her first grandchild she is always making excuses of why she cant pick my daughter up and why she cant play with her but yet she always picks her grandson up and plays with him this really hurts me exspcially when i see the expression on my three year old daughters face as if to say why cant nanny play with me. When she does decide to interact with my daughter she gets really huffy when my daughter pulls away and it makes me feel like saying well its your own fault because she doesnt really know you as you dont spend time with her but i just bite my tounge and say nothing. I surpose one good thing is,is that my daughter has a really good relationship with my mum and loves going there to her nan's.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
October 25, 2005, 8:15 am PDT

You are good!

Quote From: jenoc99

No, you are not a bad wife for not compromising over Thanksgiving! 

Thanksgiving should be a pleasant time for you and your family. If your husband chooses to feed into his sister's controling nature, so be it... You need to make peace with his choice if he does decide to go there for the holiday. I know that this makes you feel so many different emotions, mostly angry and sad, however, if he does go there for the holiday, you need to have a smile on your face and say to him, "i really wish that you'd stay here and have a peaceful, calm holiday, but I understand your feeling guilty and you are torn, so we will see you when you get back...." You probably can't imagine saying those words and truly meaning it, but when you let him go and allow him to see for himself that YOU ARE RIGHT. The only way he will find out is if he goes, otherwise, he will always think to himself that he is a crappy brother for abandoning his poor sister after their mother died.. even though you and I know thats not the case, thats how she is presenting it to him and trying to gain his sympathy. You know how she is, but because your husband grew up with this drama queen, he is "used" to this behavior as being "normal" and he feels it is neccessary to give her chance after chance. It is reasonable for you to ask that he defend you if she says anything bad about you, and you should request that he bring you up if she doesn't ask about you and the kids, too. He is a grown man, he shouldn't feel torn between his families, you need to be the bigger person and let this woman show your husband what a big b*tch she truly is, I don't think she will dissapoint you!! He will come home and say, "honey, you were right!!"  

I wish you the best! 

Thank you so much for responding!  I talked to my husband last Friday night and told him my decision was to stay home.  He was really disappointed of course, but says he understands my feelings, to a point.  He is a people pleaser-so he wants me to do what I need to do to make everyone happy and keep peace in the family.  He said eventually I have to lay my cards on the table for her!  This upset me because being a people pleaser all during my childhood and adolescent years, only got me hurt and helped me learn that I have to make my own decisions and stand up for what I believe in-regardless of how it makes anyone else feel.  I am not a cold hearted bitch, I understand the pain he is going through with the loss of his mom, but who wants to spend Thanksgiving crying and mourning?  I am human, I do feel bad for not being with him-but I avoid my own father and my own brother because of how they make me feel-so why should I allow his sister to walk all over me?  She never asks where I am when he goes to see her without me-so it's obvious that she doesn't like me either.  But, he sugar coats everything and makes excuses-I told him no more.  The thing is, after how she treated me at Christmas time, I honestly doubt that she even thinks she did anything wrong.  I will be made out to be the bad person-no matter what I do and I am afraid that eventually, it's going to drive a wedge between my husband and me.  She is all he has left other than an aunt and a cousin who lives in DC.  I hope you are right-I hope that she gets upset when he tells her why I am not there.  I hope she goes into one of her fits and starts calling me names-anything just to piss him off and make him realize what her true colors really are.  I told him, I could write her out of my life completely and it really would not bother me.  Yesterday, I asked him if he would stay home with me and the kids for Thankgiving and then he could drive down over the weekend to see his family.  He said no, the whole point was to see his family and cousin on Thanksgiving.  I offered to hold off on our dinner until Saturday after he gets home and he didn't even sound like that was really all that important to him.  Then he said I only made the offer to make him feel guilty-which is so not true.  I didn't think about it that way at all--I was just trying to talk him into a compromise.  Since he has NEVER spent Thanksgiving with his family, I guess I don't understand the importance of it now.  I know his mom is gone, but if he insists on mourning her, why can't he do it with us?  As awful as this sounds, I feel like he is choosing HER over me.  I should not be competing for him with her-but I know that is how she will see it-like she won.  She told me a few years ago during one of our arguments that "blood is thicker than water baby."  That alone tells me that she is going to do her best to take him away from me.  I came from a broken home and I do not want to raise our kids that way.   This whole situation just pisses me off and like you said, makes me feel so many different emotions.  I will try to put the smile on my face as he walks out the door on Thanksgiving day, but I will be crying inside.  So-piss on him-I will make our turkey and we will do what I normally do on Thanksgiving-have a nice peaceful meal and talk about what we are thankful for.  I have to admit though, the evil part of me wants to go with my husband and ruin her holiday the way that she ruined mine.  I could- not eat my food, complain about dessert and heaven forbid-break a piece of her Waterford!  Hey-she throws it at her own mother, so why can't I wing one at her right??  Unfortunately, I have morals and values and as fun as that would be, my kids are more important than sinking to her level.  What a bitch!  Anyway-thanks again for your advice and making me feel better about my decisions.  All the best!! 

 
First | Prev | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | Next | Last