Message Boards

Topic : Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Number of Replies: 2654
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:13:41 am
Author : dataimport
Love them, tolerate them, or despise them? Dealing with the in-laws can be stressful to a marriage. Share your stories and coping strategies.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
confused
October 29, 2005, 6:13 pm PDT

are all in-laws like this???

 My soon to be in-laws are driving me up a wall,  I am 28 and my fiance is 22.  This doesn't seem to be an issue with me but sometimes I wonder if it's an issue with them....
They have 2 sons and he is the youngest.  The older one is having a baby soon and they are so excited to the point that it seems they are trying to make an issue out of nothing, constantly asking me if this is going to be a compition and I already have 2 kids they consider their grandchildren.......I just reply that if it was then they need to hurry up and ask God for twins since I already have 2.
They will constantly say how proud they are of there oldest son and never compliment my fiance on any good that he does it's always the negative they complain about or bring up issues from when he was a kid.  It's begining to make me resent them and not want to spend any time with them
They are avide Dr. Phil fans and seem to make it a point of telling us well Dr Phil says that you should parent your children this way or this would work sooo much better when there is nothing wrong with the way that we discipline our kids. 
So the question of the day is are all In-laws like this or am I just lucky???????

 
User Mood
Lazy

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2005, 6:28 pm PDT

Mother or friend to babysit

Quote From: rnmom9496

This is my problem I'll try not to be too long. At the end of my hubby's 40th b-day party my bil decided to lite a joint while sitting on my deck with another coulple. I told him (I promise nicely!) 'please don't lite that here' he looked at me filcked his bic and lit up then smoked it at the bottom of the deck stairs. The husband of the other couple made a comment about the joint being so small 'I don't know why your bothering'. I got REALLY REALLY upset. Now my hubby was...well...drunk and wouldn't have noticed a raccoon sitting on his lap, so I know he didn't see. I told him the next day and all I got from him each time I tried to talk about it was 'I didn't see it' and 'what do you want me to do?'. This is what I got for 3 days, so on the nite of the 3rd day I called my mil since my bil lives in her basement. As a courtesy "heads up" kind of thing. (he's 36 BTW) All I did was tell he what happend and that all I was going to say to him was: "If you can't be here for the time your ride is here without doing that crap then either start taking your own car or don't come at all". Which hopefully would 've been the end of it but with this bil NO WAY. All issues with this bil end up in a fight (usually physical) and screaming and yelling (my mil has told my hubby and I to leave before)(yes we've had problems with this bil in the past). A year ago my bil ( actually both my bil's and a friend of 1) lit up a joint in my mil's garage, my hubby wen out and told them to put that stuff away that he (and I) didn't want it around our children. (boys 11 and 9). So he already knew. My mil wouldn't let me interrupt the crown prince's dinner so I said I'd call back. In the meantime she went off on him, he preceeds to call my house swearing at me asking me 'who the f*** I think I am' then hung up on me. My hubby made me call back and this bil told me 'never call here again'. They wouldn't answer the phone until my hubby called from his cell. (guess they thought it was me). My hubby told my mil that we didn't want this bro around our children anymore and that as long a he's living with her the boys will only be over with one or both of us. (no more sleep overs). She hung up on him both times he told her that. Now he's waffling. See we're supposed to go away in Dec for a weekend and she was going to watch the boys but now I'm saying "no way" as long as that bro is in the house. Today I told my hubby that his mom has 2 choices either stay at our house or have his bro stay at a motel for the weekend from when he gets out of work Fri until after we pick them up on Sun. After the 2nd phone call with his mom he got all nervous we wouldn't have anyone to watch the boys so I asked my mother if she would. No my hubby is siding with my mil saying what she's saying that "I'm keeping her from the boys". She can come anytime to the house without calling just come and the sleepovers can resume when my bil moves out.  Did I fail to mention that when I told my mother what happened she said to me that she noticed my bil smoking a 'really small cigarette and didn't blow out the smoke' this was way before he did it in front of me and at that time not only were my kids there my brother's kids and pregnant wife and my friend's kids were there too. OH and my 11 yr old kept asking why we were mad at his uncle and after trying to be evasive he asked if it was because "he smoked in the cellar" he didn't see him smoke but my son said he smelled funny smoke, "like cigarettes but not really" "it was like cigarettes and burning leaves at the same time". That was followed with 2 days of 'where does uncle get this from? Why does he smoke it? What does it look like? How does he make it into a cigarette to smoke? Am I being too harsh by not allowing my boys to sleep over my mil's house until my bil moves out? (it's been 'soon' for a year). I really really feel strongly about this and I'm really really mad and hurt because my hubby isn't backing me up on this. He's threatened to cancel the weekend which I have said fine to. Then he gets mad because we'll loose our $300 deposit. I'm so mad and hurt as far as I'm concerned it's money well spent! My mother and best friend say 'stick to your guns' and I feel it's the right thing to do. Am I wrong? 

  

I agree with you in principle but I think you are getting too bogged down into the detail and the consequences to be effectively making your point.  From what you've written I can't tell whether your husband agrees that your children shouldn't be around drug taking or not.  This is the central point everything you say has to revolve around.  Where BIL lights up, sleepovers and MIL seeing the children are secondary.   

  

Get your mother or your friend to babysit and if they can't cancel the weekend.  Given MIL and BIL I wouldn't be confident to have her babysitting in my house with my children for the weekend.  If BIL showed up and decided to light up she wouldn't attempt to stop him.   

  

The problem here is that MIL and your husband don't like rows and don't want to have one with BIL, which is why you standing your ground is such a problem - it makes it harder for them to fudge around the issue.  Just stick to the line that drug taking around your children is NOT acceptable and you are within your rights to take action to prevent that happening.  MIL is casual about her house being used for drug taking.  Therefore her house is out of bounds to your children unless you or your husband are present to take the children home when necessary.  Given MIL's casual acceptance of drug taking at her house she becomes last resort baby sitter at your house because you are not sure she will adhere to your standards if BIL decides to call.      

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2005, 10:12 pm PDT

Paternity?? To do or not to do...

My husband and I have been married for 8 months and we have a five month old son. I did get pregnant while we were dating and we decided to move in together to see if we could really be in a serious relationship. Everything was going good for us, yes we had our fights, but who doesn't. I never really had a problem with his parents until after we had our son. Now out of the blue, they are asking him to do a paternity test on our son to make sure that he is my husband's child. That of course angered me to pieces and I could not believe that they would say such an absurd thing. I mean they might as well of called me a slut. I know deep down inside my heart that my son is his, but because of their (in-laws) suspicions they wont have anything to do with our son. My parents tell me that I should get a paternity test and prove it to them once and for all and my husband says not to worry about it cause he knows in his heart that our son is his. I know that as long as my husband knows the truth that that should be ok, but I have to live with this uncomfortableness because my in-laws have doubts. My question is... should I just go ahead and get a paternity test or should I listen to my husband and let it go??? Please help!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 9:43 am PST

Its what you 2 think

Quote From: rcmartin

My husband and I have been married for 8 months and we have a five month old son. I did get pregnant while we were dating and we decided to move in together to see if we could really be in a serious relationship. Everything was going good for us, yes we had our fights, but who doesn't. I never really had a problem with his parents until after we had our son. Now out of the blue, they are asking him to do a paternity test on our son to make sure that he is my husband's child. That of course angered me to pieces and I could not believe that they would say such an absurd thing. I mean they might as well of called me a slut. I know deep down inside my heart that my son is his, but because of their (in-laws) suspicions they wont have anything to do with our son. My parents tell me that I should get a paternity test and prove it to them once and for all and my husband says not to worry about it cause he knows in his heart that our son is his. I know that as long as my husband knows the truth that that should be ok, but I have to live with this uncomfortableness because my in-laws have doubts. My question is... should I just go ahead and get a paternity test or should I listen to my husband and let it go??? Please help!
If you and your husband know that this child is his, then the heck with what the inlaws think. If you have only been with your husband during the time you conceived then there is nothing to prove. If they choose to NOT get involved with their grandchild, then dont get involved with them. Even if you did get a test to prove it, you would still be treated and looked at differently by them. It is none of their bussiness how you two decide to live your lives with the beliefs you have. Listen to your husband. Sounds like they are trying to put doubts in your husbands head. YOu have nothing to prove to them, only unless your hubby decides to have it done. But, why put a child through all of that, if you two guys know the truth?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 12:23 pm PST

What about granma in laws??

My husband is an only child and both his parents and grandfather are deceased. His granma is the only one left and lives right next door to us. The problem that I have with her is that she wants to be involved in everything that goes on in my sons life. I feel and maybe I am wrong that he is my son and I will never get these moments back he is only 4.  It's not like I don't want her to see him but not when I am spending time with him. My husband works alot and I am basically a prisoner in my home. I stay indoors all the time because I don't want to see her.If I want to share outside time with my son I take him to my moms house.  

When I see her number on our caller id I get so angry and sometimes if I see her coming up on our porch I don't answer. Part of me feels guilty put part of me feels like she should give me some space. If she does not see my son everyday she acts like it is the end of the world which makes me angry because my parents don't see him everyday and they are cool with that. The other thing is she is his great grandma and most great grandparents are lucky if they  see grandkids once a month.  

She is also very controlling with birthdays and holiday. I hate to feel this way about granma but I just can't help it. She is use to everyone catering to her and what she wants. Talking to other family members everyone has always given in. I don't come from a family like that mine is like we are having dinner at this time if you can make great if not maybe next time. Not her she will hound her until it happens and then you feel like everytime she asks you something you've already made up your mind that no you don't want to. I don't like other people making my decisons.  

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 3:07 pm PST

How In Tarnation Do You Deal With Inlaws That Are Compulsive Liars?

How does one deal with in laws, in my case a sister-in-law, that lie constantly about you to other family members.  These family members are all the way on the west coast and we're here in the midwest so my sister in law BANKED on the fact that we'd NEVER talk - well guess what?  She "banked" wrong.  My husband and I will be married for 15 years next May and my sister in law has tried darn near everything to "smear" my name.  My husband and I even supported her when she went to college because her parents were divorced and at one point in time she wasn't speaking to her father and in another point in time she wasn't speaking to her Mother(her mother allegedly emptied out her bank account) - but now she has turned the tables on me.  My husband knows exactly what his sister is all about but will not "ruffle anyone's feathers" (meaning he'd rather not deal with it).  In talking to family on the west coast - I NOW KNOW about ALL the lies she told them and when I CONFRONTED her on them this past week (mind you to have me confront someone takes all the gumption I can gather) - she either changed the subject or just chose to hear what she wanted to hear and "took it out of context" - I mean this girl has said some awful things about me over a 5 year period - heck, no wonder the family out there disliked me - heck, I'd dislike me if I did the things she SAYS I did.  I can't win and want to know how to handle this?  Has ANYONE OUT THERE EVER experienced this???   Do I have to become a liar to CATCH A LIAR?  KILL HER WITH KINDNESS, WHAT?  She's ruined my name and I never did ANY of the things she said I did? How can I compete with a liar?!?  UGH!!!   *SIGH* *Sigh*
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 3:45 pm PST

Mother-in-laq

I have found that the only way to deal with my mothe-in-law of thirty years is to never step foot in her house and forbid her to step foot in mine. 

  

She is a very controlling woman to the point that her sons, aged 71 and 75, become 10 and 14 year-olds in her presence.  My husband (aged 71) has very severe health problems which she refuses to acknowledge and will go out of her way to make worse.  Unfortunately, as the saying goes "only the good die young," this woman will live to 500! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 3:49 pm PST

Granma in laws

Quote From: etcjeanie

I have found that the only way to deal with my mothe-in-law of thirty years is to never step foot in her house and forbid her to step foot in mine. 

  

She is a very controlling woman to the point that her sons, aged 71 and 75, become 10 and 14 year-olds in her presence.  My husband (aged 71) has very severe health problems which she refuses to acknowledge and will go out of her way to make worse.  Unfortunately, as the saying goes "only the good die young," this woman will live to 500! 

I have said that before she will live to be 150 just to torment me!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2005, 5:20 pm PST

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: zulutango

That's another thing I forgot to mention, she said where ever we move she is also moving with us.
Maybe it's time to put a lock on your bedroom door.  At least she won't be going through your personal stuff.  You could always put very kinky underwear in the laundry basket, and if you don't put a lock on your bedroom door, try leaving a few "toys" around.  If your in-laws are invading every other space in your lives, at least try to get your bedroom back. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
frustrated
October 30, 2005, 5:23 pm PST

Mother in law takes no responsibility

The main problem with MIL is that she always has to have someone to blame for her problems. No matter what she does, she can always justify it in a way that lets her off the hook. Example: she asked to have our older two kids (aged 6 and 4 at the time) overnight. We agreed and arranged to pick them up at 10.30 the next morning. When we arrived, our son told us that MIL had taken him with her to walk the dog, leaving our 4 yr old daughter at home alone. We hit the roof, and said that the children would not be allowed to sleepover again. MIL explained her actions, first by saying that she didn't think about it. I said that I need someone who thinks before they act to look after my kids. She then tried, "I did think about it; you have no idea. I agonised over the decision for half an hour, with the dog whining the whole time. I was torn between the dog and the kids, because I love them both." That's even worse, in my book. Why did she not take the 4 yr old? Because she wouldn't walk fast enough for the dog. What is worse, she told our son not to tell us, which proves that she knew it was wrong. The whole thing blew into a big drama, and MIL has hardly spoken to us since (our daughter is nearly 6). She refuses to see the children under our supervision, as she thinks that says we don't trust her. We told her we don't trust her, and she needs to prove that we can by seeing the children when we are there. I am not cutting her off over one incident. She will always be my husband's mother. There have been lots of times when she has acted irresponsibly, and she always talks her way out of it, instead of saying that she's sorry and actually changing her behaviour! All I can say is that we are a united front, I have a wonderful supportive husband. I wish she could see what a great family we have, and be a part of it instead of undermining and sabotaging it. As it stands, we have had to say that our marriage and our kids come first. If she endangers that unit, she is not welcome.
 
First | Prev | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | Next | Last