Message Boards

Topic : Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Number of Replies: 2654
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:13:41 am
Author : dataimport
Love them, tolerate them, or despise them? Dealing with the in-laws can be stressful to a marriage. Share your stories and coping strategies.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
upset
April 28, 2006, 10:36 am PDT

favortism among grandchildren?

Hi All,  

This is my first post. I was hoping I could get some opinions and advise.  We have 3 children at home my 15 year old stepson, 7 year old son, and 3 year old son. My MIL has my 7 year old over to her house every saturday night to sleep over as well as takes him many places when she has time off. She has spent time with my stepson and had him sleep over as well when has nothing better to do, but he is not real interested in hanging out with his grandma at his age. Here is what upsets me she does not spend time with our 3 year old. She has had him sleep over twice in his life the last time (about a month ago) at my husbands request so that we could go out for the evening. She will offer to watch the boys every once in awhile so that we can go out (every few months), but has us pick up the 3 year old and keeps the other boys overnight. The only time she see's him is when she comes to pick up our 7 year old and drop him off, maybe a total of an hour each week(I'm being generous here).  We thought maybe she did not want him overnight until he was older, but she does not ask to have him spend time with him for a few hours during the day either. A few times she has brought it up and even picked a day and then blew it off and not said a word about it. Our 3 year old is about the age our 7 year old was when she started having him overnight I can't remember exactly when she started having him. She has always been close with our 7 year old because she watched him for us so that I could work parttime in the evenings and my husband could work on the house when we did some major reconstruction, I feel like she hasn't even give the 3 year old a chance. My question is do you feel this is favortism, I obviously do. Do you think our 3 year old will notice it yet? What should we do about it? My husband won't say much on the subject, I feel because he doesn't want to have to do something about. He hates to confront anyone especially his mom. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs, and as far as I know he has never said  anything to her about any conflicts that have come up over the years. He just can't stand up to her, but he has to be the one to talk to her because it is his mom. I don't think she would take kindly to me saying anything, I'm not even sure she likes me, she is the passive/aggresive type. Never overtly rude but can do some incredibly rude things and look as thought she didn't mean them to be rude. Any suggestions? Sorry so long.                   lovelily 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 28, 2006, 4:35 pm PDT

favortism

Quote From: lovelily

Hi All,  

This is my first post. I was hoping I could get some opinions and advise.  We have 3 children at home my 15 year old stepson, 7 year old son, and 3 year old son. My MIL has my 7 year old over to her house every saturday night to sleep over as well as takes him many places when she has time off. She has spent time with my stepson and had him sleep over as well when has nothing better to do, but he is not real interested in hanging out with his grandma at his age. Here is what upsets me she does not spend time with our 3 year old. She has had him sleep over twice in his life the last time (about a month ago) at my husbands request so that we could go out for the evening. She will offer to watch the boys every once in awhile so that we can go out (every few months), but has us pick up the 3 year old and keeps the other boys overnight. The only time she see's him is when she comes to pick up our 7 year old and drop him off, maybe a total of an hour each week(I'm being generous here).  We thought maybe she did not want him overnight until he was older, but she does not ask to have him spend time with him for a few hours during the day either. A few times she has brought it up and even picked a day and then blew it off and not said a word about it. Our 3 year old is about the age our 7 year old was when she started having him overnight I can't remember exactly when she started having him. She has always been close with our 7 year old because she watched him for us so that I could work parttime in the evenings and my husband could work on the house when we did some major reconstruction, I feel like she hasn't even give the 3 year old a chance. My question is do you feel this is favortism, I obviously do. Do you think our 3 year old will notice it yet? What should we do about it? My husband won't say much on the subject, I feel because he doesn't want to have to do something about. He hates to confront anyone especially his mom. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs, and as far as I know he has never said  anything to her about any conflicts that have come up over the years. He just can't stand up to her, but he has to be the one to talk to her because it is his mom. I don't think she would take kindly to me saying anything, I'm not even sure she likes me, she is the passive/aggresive type. Never overtly rude but can do some incredibly rude things and look as thought she didn't mean them to be rude. Any suggestions? Sorry so long.                   lovelily 

I dont think I would take it too personally. The baby is 3 y/o and chances are your mil may feel like she cant keep up with him. I am soon to be 40 (ancient as my teenager says) and I have a 5 and 6 y/o that I cant keep up with. There is now way I would take on another kid . LOL! Not even for over night. Mine are just too rambunctious!  As far as knowing the difference, my kids were 2 and 3 the last time they had a visit with mil. They havent seen her none for a visit after that, and now they are 5 and 6 and they dont know what her name is or that she is even their grandma. (mil choice).
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 28, 2006, 8:01 pm PDT

To 'Lovelily'

Quote From: lovelily

Hi All,  

This is my first post. I was hoping I could get some opinions and advise.  We have 3 children at home my 15 year old stepson, 7 year old son, and 3 year old son. My MIL has my 7 year old over to her house every saturday night to sleep over as well as takes him many places when she has time off. She has spent time with my stepson and had him sleep over as well when has nothing better to do, but he is not real interested in hanging out with his grandma at his age. Here is what upsets me she does not spend time with our 3 year old. She has had him sleep over twice in his life the last time (about a month ago) at my husbands request so that we could go out for the evening. She will offer to watch the boys every once in awhile so that we can go out (every few months), but has us pick up the 3 year old and keeps the other boys overnight. The only time she see's him is when she comes to pick up our 7 year old and drop him off, maybe a total of an hour each week(I'm being generous here).  We thought maybe she did not want him overnight until he was older, but she does not ask to have him spend time with him for a few hours during the day either. A few times she has brought it up and even picked a day and then blew it off and not said a word about it. Our 3 year old is about the age our 7 year old was when she started having him overnight I can't remember exactly when she started having him. She has always been close with our 7 year old because she watched him for us so that I could work parttime in the evenings and my husband could work on the house when we did some major reconstruction, I feel like she hasn't even give the 3 year old a chance. My question is do you feel this is favortism, I obviously do. Do you think our 3 year old will notice it yet? What should we do about it? My husband won't say much on the subject, I feel because he doesn't want to have to do something about. He hates to confront anyone especially his mom. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs, and as far as I know he has never said  anything to her about any conflicts that have come up over the years. He just can't stand up to her, but he has to be the one to talk to her because it is his mom. I don't think she would take kindly to me saying anything, I'm not even sure she likes me, she is the passive/aggresive type. Never overtly rude but can do some incredibly rude things and look as thought she didn't mean them to be rude. Any suggestions? Sorry so long.                   lovelily 

Well it could be favoritism, but it might not be, too. Like you said, she has an obvious attachement to your 7 year old, which is understandable. Her bond hasn't formed as tight with your 3 year old, but why not start to urge her to take both of the younger boys on Saturday nights from now on? Or, at least every other Saturday? This isn't unreasonable at all. I don't think you could come right out and tell her that you believe she is playing favorites, because she would deny it anyway- but you could tell her in a rational, calm, conversational-type of way that your 3 year old deserves a chance to form that type of bond with her that the 7 year old has. Since its not in a confrontational manner, its okay for you to do this- just to let her know that the kids love her and want to be with her- its flattering.
Just another consideration- have you considered the children's different personalities? Perhaps your 3 year old is more of a handfull at this point? Maybe he wakes in the night, etc., anything like that? Maybe your MIL just needs more time... give her a little slack.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
April 28, 2006, 9:17 pm PDT

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: hollijb5

Hello, I have been with my husband since I was a kid and in that time his parents never thought I was good enough for him! Not only them, but also his 35 year old sister , who has been extremely evil to me. We have three children together, we own a home and there problem is I am a stay at home mother and my husband works! My husband is the one who wants me to stay home.! His sister is 7 years older than me and has never even had her own place. They even told my step son that we don't have enough money, because I do not work. I have begged him to talk to them about putting me down and saying things to my children, but no matter how much it hurts me he will not do or say anything. We fight constantly about it, but that has not gotten me anywhere. How do I really get him to talk to them?

    

     Your husband should really talk to her, you are his wife and the is NO REASON!! for anybody to be talking down about you to your kids, if that is her opion about you then there probally is nothing you can do to change her mind but she really needs to leave the kids out of it...you are there mother and they look up to you..you need to have a serious talk with your husband and tell him you are tired of it and if he dont say anything to her I WOULD!! 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
April 28, 2006, 11:26 pm PDT

I do take it personally though

Quote From: jb7ctx

I dont think I would take it too personally. The baby is 3 y/o and chances are your mil may feel like she cant keep up with him. I am soon to be 40 (ancient as my teenager says) and I have a 5 and 6 y/o that I cant keep up with. There is now way I would take on another kid . LOL! Not even for over night. Mine are just too rambunctious!  As far as knowing the difference, my kids were 2 and 3 the last time they had a visit with mil. They havent seen her none for a visit after that, and now they are 5 and 6 and they dont know what her name is or that she is even their grandma. (mil choice).

 My MIL  has  acted strangely since the 3 year old was born. She was at the hospital when our older son was born, but not when the 3 year old was born, which was unavoidable since I had an emergency c-section. I had been at the hospital for several hours prior to the birth but we did not contact her as we did not have her work number for her new job, besides we had other things to worry about just then. She found out when she got home from work, but she waited 2 days to come to the hospital to come see us and my son was in the NICU and she works very near the hospital. After I got out of the hospital I had to get rides for the first 2 weeks to see my son everyday since I couldn't drive. She wanted to meet my husband at the hospital one evening to see the baby and he asked her to give me a ride since I hadn't been able to get in and see him that day and she would be coming back to town before driving into the city to meet him. She was reluctant to do so, she didn't come right out and say no but you could tell she didn't want to. I told him that the 2 of them could go in and see the baby together I didn't want to ruin her cozy family plan, I just wanted to see my son.  

I was very hurt by her strange behavior at a time when I was going through hell because my son was in the hospital and sick and I just wanted my baby home.  

  

Back to the present,  she doesn't have to keep him overnight if she feels he would be a handful but it would be nice if she would spend some time with him since she spends time with our 7 year old so often.  

 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
worried
April 29, 2006, 12:30 pm PDT

Too far!

Well I think it has gone too far this time! My in laws have decided to have a seperate birthday party for my daughter, so they do not have to see my family! So, basically I will have to endure the wrath of the whole family with no back up. I have begged my husband to speak with them, yet he just wont do it! I feel like no matter how I feel about anything, I just have to put up with it , or lose my husband. I am literally in a constant state of panic , I even had a panick attack last nihght and when I tried to tell my husband he told me to "SHUT UP HE IS SLEEPING!" His sister trys to act like my daughter is hers, this year for family pictures she had her picture thaken with my family minus me! I am at a loss, since I am a stay at home mom I do not have any means of suppourting myself, or my kids. HELP
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2006, 6:15 pm PDT

overbearing in-laws

Quote From: hollijb5

Well I think it has gone too far this time! My in laws have decided to have a seperate birthday party for my daughter, so they do not have to see my family! So, basically I will have to endure the wrath of the whole family with no back up. I have begged my husband to speak with them, yet he just wont do it! I feel like no matter how I feel about anything, I just have to put up with it , or lose my husband. I am literally in a constant state of panic , I even had a panick attack last nihght and when I tried to tell my husband he told me to "SHUT UP HE IS SLEEPING!" His sister trys to act like my daughter is hers, this year for family pictures she had her picture thaken with my family minus me! I am at a loss, since I am a stay at home mom I do not have any means of suppourting myself, or my kids. HELP
Its not fair that you feel victimized by your in-laws! Your husband either knows what his family is doing is wrong and he is too much of a coward to speak up, or, he thinks that their behavior is "normal" because he has been around it for his whole life. Either way, by disregarding your feelings, he is going to degrade your relationship. My advice is to talk about this when your husband is obviously not sleeping, or trying to sleep. He is trying to avoid the inevitable, and he just can't do that. You have to keep pushing!! Don't give up and tolerate this. Your in-laws have a separate birthday party? Why do they get to control your family life-- they don't. You can take back your control, be strong, keep your head up, and start saying "no"
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
frustrated
April 30, 2006, 10:08 pm PDT

guess there's alot of us in this boat

 Hello. I am new to the boards. I couldn't sleep, issues with my MIL going round & round in my head.  

We have been married for 7 yrs, together for 8. I should've know there would be trouble when she came into my house and instead of sitting next her husband she sat next to my boyfriend at the time. I have 3 sons myself(I've been married before) so I know about motherly love and protecting your young. She was a single mom for a while and he is her only son. BUT.............at what point do you let go and let him live his life and not make my life difficult??!!  

I didn't get the wedding I wanted. I am made to feel as if I am not a good mother. It has gotten to the point that I do avoid her. My husband says he understands but will not stand up to her on my behalf. He has said that I am overly sensitive, I read too much into her coments, that's not what she meant..................................................................................................  

In the beginning I told him how I felt. nothing happened. Then we would argue about it. nothing happened. Then I just ignored it and it built up inside until I would explode. nothing happened. WE almost split up last summer. He said I changed and did not appreciate him. Some of that was true, but what I view as the biggest issue in our marriage is still there and always has been. To this day he will not speak up to her. He will to me, but not her. The latest resoning/excuse is that she pays our daughter's pre school tution so I can work(I used to be a stay at home mom until last summer).   

I constantly feel that he chooses her over me. He says that is crazy. Call ME crazy, but I feel that your husband/wife should be #1 on your list of priorities and you should do whatever you can to make them feel safe, secure, and loved. That's what I thought I was doing all these years by "living" with the situation.   

NOW, she is moving back up north and that has brought a whole new set of issues, mainly the kids visits. She is expecting to have them come up for a month at a time during the summer. I didn't know we got divorced and she got visitation rights! The worst part of that is she asked the kids if they wanted to come up for a month infront of my husband & I without asking or talking to us first!!!!!!!! Yet I make too much out of things???  

I could go on 4ever on this topic. I feels sooooooo good to "tell" someone other than hubby though. Still, nothing will change, but at least it's out there and not pent up inside.  

Thanks for listening.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 30, 2006, 10:30 pm PDT

A month without the kids!!

Quote From: daytodayx4

 Hello. I am new to the boards. I couldn't sleep, issues with my MIL going round & round in my head.  

We have been married for 7 yrs, together for 8. I should've know there would be trouble when she came into my house and instead of sitting next her husband she sat next to my boyfriend at the time. I have 3 sons myself(I've been married before) so I know about motherly love and protecting your young. She was a single mom for a while and he is her only son. BUT.............at what point do you let go and let him live his life and not make my life difficult??!!  

I didn't get the wedding I wanted. I am made to feel as if I am not a good mother. It has gotten to the point that I do avoid her. My husband says he understands but will not stand up to her on my behalf. He has said that I am overly sensitive, I read too much into her coments, that's not what she meant..................................................................................................  

In the beginning I told him how I felt. nothing happened. Then we would argue about it. nothing happened. Then I just ignored it and it built up inside until I would explode. nothing happened. WE almost split up last summer. He said I changed and did not appreciate him. Some of that was true, but what I view as the biggest issue in our marriage is still there and always has been. To this day he will not speak up to her. He will to me, but not her. The latest resoning/excuse is that she pays our daughter's pre school tution so I can work(I used to be a stay at home mom until last summer).   

I constantly feel that he chooses her over me. He says that is crazy. Call ME crazy, but I feel that your husband/wife should be #1 on your list of priorities and you should do whatever you can to make them feel safe, secure, and loved. That's what I thought I was doing all these years by "living" with the situation.   

NOW, she is moving back up north and that has brought a whole new set of issues, mainly the kids visits. She is expecting to have them come up for a month at a time during the summer. I didn't know we got divorced and she got visitation rights! The worst part of that is she asked the kids if they wanted to come up for a month infront of my husband & I without asking or talking to us first!!!!!!!! Yet I make too much out of things???  

I could go on 4ever on this topic. I feels sooooooo good to "tell" someone other than hubby though. Still, nothing will change, but at least it's out there and not pent up inside.  

Thanks for listening.  

 When my children were young my Mother-in-law who lived 300 miles away used to take them for weeks at a time in the Summer. It was wonderful and all my work colleagues who had to juggle child care around their time at work, were very jealous. It gave my husband and I time on our own and the girls loved their time at Grannies. She also would take them on holiday to the beach. They have lots of lovely memories and we enjoyed the respite.
If you and hubby are having a difficult time I would suggest you grab this opportunity with both hands, I maybe wrong but if she wants to look after the kids let her, she could be doing it to give you a break and even if that isn't the reason just think how nice it would be to re-build your relationship with hubby.
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
April 30, 2006, 10:42 pm PDT

Getting Along With Your In-Laws

Quote From: mmcturk

 When my children were young my Mother-in-law who lived 300 miles away used to take them for weeks at a time in the Summer. It was wonderful and all my work colleagues who had to juggle child care around their time at work, were very jealous. It gave my husband and I time on our own and the girls loved their time at Grannies. She also would take them on holiday to the beach. They have lots of lovely memories and we enjoyed the respite.
If you and hubby are having a difficult time I would suggest you grab this opportunity with both hands, I maybe wrong but if she wants to look after the kids let her, she could be doing it to give you a break and even if that isn't the reason just think how nice it would be to re-build your relationship with hubby.
my kids have summer programs to attend and she only wants the grandkids that are hers, so we would still have teenagers here.
 
First | Prev | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94 | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | 99 | Next | Last