Message Boards

Topic : Toxic Family Relationships

Number of Replies: 2042
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:18:00 am
Author : dataimport
Whether it stems from substance abuse, violence or manipulation, some family relationships are harmful and need to be terminated until the abuse stops. Are you involved in a toxic relationship?

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
blank
October 14, 2008, 9:17 am PDT

Toxic Family Relationships

Quote From: tammyo1973

My homelife was abusive from a young age. Mental and verbal and emotional mostly. I have been punched by my dad. THings ended up being good with us until I married a nice man and my dad lost control of me. My hubby works 80-100 hours aweek, I get to stay home. We have a really nice house. I have 2 children, one from a boyfriend 14 years ago and our toddler who is 3. My 14 yr odl was molested by an ex husband of mine. She has been diagnosed with bipolar, ptsd, and anxiety disorder. My parents wanted me to NOT press charges on ex husband for the molestation. ARE THEY CRAZY i guess so.

Then when my daughter was diagnosed with bipolar, they told me it was my fault and if my husband and myself would spend more time with her she would be ok. We live with her so we spend all our time with her...

I had to have her admitted to a psych hospital (not fun for a mom) and my dad said I should be the one who is locked up.

Anyhow things go tso back we stopped talking for about 1 year. I have begun speaking to them again but cannot get past the last couple years of the stuff with my daughter. Whenever I bring her up in conversation and what is going on with her illness they change the subject or tell me to go to schurch. I do go to church and do not get me wrong I believe and have faith. BUT a mental illness just doesn't go away. Why don't they get it,

I try to not talk about my daughter with them and then they say they feel left out. SO then I end up not talking to them at all.

Am I wrong?

Tammy~ You're 31 years old. You and your family have been abused enough. You are more than capable of making the right choices. What I'm going to say is what I am doing today. Go file a VPO on your parents and ex-husband. Do what needs to be done. Your family is suffering by your indecision and pain. THEY WILL FIGHT YOU OVER THIS!  IF THEY CALL, CALL THE POLICE. IF THEY DRIVE BY, CALL THE POLICE. THEY WILL STALK YOU. THEY WANT CONTROL.  THEY WILL MAIL YOU LETTERS. CALL THE POLICE.

 

I wish I would have done this years ago. If you don't. They will call you crazy. They are the problem. Find peace. Find yourself. You can't do anything about the past but you can change the future. Only YOU can stop the abuse!! 

 

                                                                                                   God Bless                  

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
angry
October 19, 2008, 10:56 am PDT

Toxic Family Relationships

I am almost 45 years old, yet when I speak with my oldest daughter, I can be reduced to the emotional level of a 5 year old.  My daughter is convinced that I abused her as a child ... yet of all three children, she is the only one who feels this way.  I have no idea how to deal with this anymore and today I was so tempted to just remove her from my entire life.  bad side is that I would never get to see my two adorable grandsons anymore then.   I am so upset and confused as to what I can do to fix the issues, yet no matter what I try, it is never good enough, or she feels I always have an ulterior motive.  she believes I am the devil himself and refuses to accept any responsibility in any of this.   

to give you an example of what she was like growing up ......  at the age of 7 - this all occurred durring 1 summer :  she broke into a person's house on the next street, all to get the ice pops in his freezer.  she soaked someone's blow-up plastic pool with lighter fluid and lit it up.  She stole 50.00 out of my purse and spent it at the store where she wasn't suppose to be.  She stole work money from my purse as well.  she regularly stole candy and other items from the nearest convience store.  things only got worse as she got older.   yet she believes I caused all of this to happen because I was so dreadfully abusive to her.   ?!?!?!?!?!!?!??!!??!     

can someone clue me in here on a good way to deal with this now-adult person please.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
October 21, 2008, 10:54 am PDT

My boyfriend's crazy mother

I'm 19 and my boyfriend is 20. He has told me that ever since he was around 7 his mom has been a bad mother to him. Never paid attention to him and was always yelling at him. His mom has been taking his pay checks and putting them in a dual bank account. His card for it is locked so only she can take out money. He had over $10 000 saved up in it and his mother recently took it all out and paid off her debt with it. He has a truck, sell phone and soon an apartment to pay for and she just took it all. She told him this when he told her that he was going to move out with me. He had two camaros and he told her he was going to sell those to pay for our first and last rent. She handed him a receipt saying that she had sold the two camaros that were under his name. This when he finally cracked. He told me what she did and he actually had a few tears. I have never seen this boy cry and neither has anyone else. He wont take her to court and no one is doing anything about the stuff shes doing. She tells him that she has raised him since he was born there for he owe her. About 2 weeks before thanksgiving his mother told him that she loves the neighbor's boy and she doesn't even love her son. A few mornings ago she woke him up by punching him and then yelling at him because he didn't want to give her his paycheck and she said "if I wouldn't go to jail id kill you right now." Who says that to their son. Who says that to anyone. I come from a very loving family so I'm not use to this. It grosses me out, gives me headaches and I'm about to crack. I don't know what to do. I don't want to talk to her because she wont listen to me and id end up making everything worse. She told him if he moves out the only think he gets is the clothes he wearing. I'm scared shes going to screw him over again and he never gets out of there. We had found the perfect apartment yesterday and now we cant get it and I'm having so much trouble finding another one for December. Please help me. No one else will. His dad just sits and watches and same with his older brother. She doesn't do anything to his brother. He gets whatever he wants. I'm so stuck and its driving me crazy and I'm scared for myself and him.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2008, 5:59 am PDT

Boyfriend's mom

Quote From: sunshine1989

I'm 19 and my boyfriend is 20. He has told me that ever since he was around 7 his mom has been a bad mother to him. Never paid attention to him and was always yelling at him. His mom has been taking his pay checks and putting them in a dual bank account. His card for it is locked so only she can take out money. He had over $10 000 saved up in it and his mother recently took it all out and paid off her debt with it. He has a truck, sell phone and soon an apartment to pay for and she just took it all. She told him this when he told her that he was going to move out with me. He had two camaros and he told her he was going to sell those to pay for our first and last rent. She handed him a receipt saying that she had sold the two camaros that were under his name. This when he finally cracked. He told me what she did and he actually had a few tears. I have never seen this boy cry and neither has anyone else. He wont take her to court and no one is doing anything about the stuff shes doing. She tells him that she has raised him since he was born there for he owe her. About 2 weeks before thanksgiving his mother told him that she loves the neighbor's boy and she doesn't even love her son. A few mornings ago she woke him up by punching him and then yelling at him because he didn't want to give her his paycheck and she said "if I wouldn't go to jail id kill you right now." Who says that to their son. Who says that to anyone. I come from a very loving family so I'm not use to this. It grosses me out, gives me headaches and I'm about to crack. I don't know what to do. I don't want to talk to her because she wont listen to me and id end up making everything worse. She told him if he moves out the only think he gets is the clothes he wearing. I'm scared shes going to screw him over again and he never gets out of there. We had found the perfect apartment yesterday and now we cant get it and I'm having so much trouble finding another one for December. Please help me. No one else will. His dad just sits and watches and same with his older brother. She doesn't do anything to his brother. He gets whatever he wants. I'm so stuck and its driving me crazy and I'm scared for myself and him.
There is nothing that you or your boyfriend can do or say that will ever change his mother; she has to WANT to change- but obviously, she isn’t interested in creating change. She is only interested in keeping complete control over your boyfriend for as long as she can, and at any cost- and I agree with you, it is disgusting.
The best thing your boyfriend can do is make a long-term plan to move out. Because his mother expects his whole check, he might have to ’sneak’ small amounts to save up without her knowing. I know that it is hurtful to think he has to stay living there, but what other choice does he have? Sit down and have a serious discussion with your boyfriend about what his options are. Let him know that you love him, that you are concerned for him, and that you want to help him create positive change in his life so that he has a chance at having a happy future. The longer he stays living at his mother’s home, the more beaten down his self esteem is going to get.
 For his own safety and well-being - physically as well as emotionally - is it possible for him to stay with a friend or relative for a few months while he saves up money?
Another bit of advice- your boyfriend can go to the bank and remove his name off of that bank account with his mother. He is a 20 year old man now, he is able to open his own bank account independent of his mother. He can’t sit around and worry about what mom will do if he does that, he just needs to begin taking action. His mom isn’t expecting that- she is expecting him to remain her puppet. When he begins to stand up for himself and take charge of his own life, he will begin to feel better about himself. No one else is going to do anything to cause this situation to change, so he MUST take matters into his own hands. I wish you the best!
 

Message Emote
blank
November 6, 2008, 3:37 pm PST

Toxic Family Relationships

Quote From: equinelvr

After growing up in a household where violence and alcohol was commonplace, I came to the painful conclusion several years back that it was best for me to cut all ties with my parents.  It was not done in anger, nor was it done to spite them.  It was only after much therapy and many attempts to set boundaries with them that I realized it was time to say goodbye and not allow them to continue their now insidious abuse of me as an adult. 

 

While those closest to me understand my decision, there are those who dont understand it and either want to fix it, or try to guilt me into reconciling.  I now feel as if I cant be honest about this decision because of the stigma that comes from not having a relationship with a family. 

 

My childhood was one long nightmare.  My alcoholic dad was a very loud and angry man who would beat me regularly over minor offenses.  He would follow up these sessions with a teary drunken apology.  My mom was uneducated, never worked, and was a very bitter woman overwhelmed with all of her kids.  As the first girl of the bunch, I was singled out for her disdain, disgust, indifference, and yet she wanted full control of me at all times.  Never heard an I love you from her, and barely remember even getting a hug.  Although she didnt go after me physically as often as my dad, she stood by while he beat me and I vividly remember seeing a sick satisfactory smirk on her face whenever she would tell on me, knowing full well what it would lead to.  Because I was treated this way by them, my brothers thought it was ok to treat me just as bad, both physically and sexually.    

 

Fast forward to my late teens/early 20s, I moved out at a very early age and despite a serious lack of social skills and insecurity that just about consumed me, I did well for myself.  I bloomed and became a successful businesswoman who took pride in her accomplishments and for once, her looks.  It was then that for some reason they saw some worth in me.  They wanted me to come to every family gathering and paraded me around like a pony.  The gall still amazes me, but they would actually sit back and enjoy kudos from others for raising such a daughter.  It was at this point where the public I love yous and hugs began 

 

As I got older, I still played the game of were such an awesome family, dutifully attending all family functions, and at the same time, adhered to my moms scripts.  See, whenever an uncomfortable topic would come up, she would immediately chime up with her warped version of events to gloss everything over.  For instance, because she was uncomfortable with my femininity, she would chop my hair off.  Now that I have long hair, I am often asked if it was always like that.  If my mom was around when I would say it was short, she would immediately chime in with it wasnt that short, and that was the style.  No mention of her telling the hair dresser not to listen to me, to just cut it short.  Or, if someone commented regarding how small our house was and how did we all fit, she would immediately gloss this over with well the kids were smaller, there was always plenty of room. 

 

After I got married, and became a parent, I realize that I needed to learn how to parent.  I was heads up enough to realize that I was at risk of either repeating the cycle of abuse, or going full board the opposite way and not instilling structure in my childs life.  This was also the time when I started therapy.  Then, one day when my Daughter was younger, I had what I can only describe as an awakening.  It came in the form of a phone call between my Daughter and my dad.  I saw her face, she looked confused and when I got on the phone, I heard a voice from my past.  It was my dads drunken slurry voice on the other line, and in an instant, I was a powerless child again without any control. 

 

Now its not that I never heard that voice as an adult, I think the catalyst was that my daughter heard it.  After the call, and fortunately out of sight from her, I cried like I have never cried in my entire life.  All the tears that I held in over the years trying to be brave burst forth, and for once, I cried for the lonely girl that I once was, who suffered a long time in silence.  It was then that I saw with clear eyes the full extent of the abuse that I grew up with and just how incredibly toxic my family is. 

 

For the first time in my life, I spilled the beans.  I told the family secrets to a therapist.  It was chaotic and intense being completely 100% honest about everything since it went against the family creed of keeping secrets and lying by omission.  I realized then that in a sick way, I was still very much tied to my family.  And with my open eyes, I realized that they were still very much abusing me. 

 

It was during this time that I learned a little more about alcoholism, and learned what a narcissist is. It was also when I realized that some serious boundaries needed to be set up between me and them including making sure that my Daughters time with them was monitored for her protection.  Had my first honest conversation with my mom, asking her some hard questions about my upbringing, all the while explaining that I want to have an honest relationship with her.  She either denied or claimed to not remember.  I was in tears during this call but the only time she cried was when she turned the conversation around to her, and talked about what she endured growing upAlthough I wasnt expecting someone who seemingly has no feelings to suddenly feel something, I was hoping that she would at a minimum, acknowledge my feelings.

 

I began setting boundaries such as if they are in my house, I do not want to hear gossip about others. (She is a major gossip who likes to play her kids against each other)  In addition, I asked that they keep their drinking to a minimum around my Daughter.  Most important of all, I told them if she is over their house, they are not allowed to drive her anywhere. (Although my mom drinks less, way too much alcohol is being consumed for either of them to be driving)  Needless to say all of my attempts were a bust.  They not only drove my daughter (asking her not to tell), they took her to catechism (knowing full well I do not share their beliefs nor am I raising my Daughter with them) classes behind my back, they even tried negatively talking to my Husband about me to deflect anything that I might be saying about them, and all the while boo hooing to everyone who will listen about what a horrible and mean daughter I am

 

After one last booze infused Christmas gathering, I decided enough was enough.  With the support of my loving husband I decided that the only way I could ensure that my focus remains on MY family (i.e., him and my Daughter) is to say goodbye.  I was not about to waste anymore energy trying to fix or even maintain a relationship with them.  Since they couldnt accept boundaries, I knew they wouldnt accept a goodbye from me.  So without any fanfare, I/We simply faded away from them and for the first time in my life, I was genuinely happy. 

 

As is the case with every toxic family, if they see you moving away from them, they try to pull you back in.  I cannot begin to tell you the lengths they have gone to try and lure me back into the fold.  Ive even moved out of state and when they realized this, they cried to my in-laws asking for my new contact info, all the while bemoaning that they have no idea why I am doing this to them.  They now once again have my contact information so a clean break was not to be. 

 

So here I am today, in a position where Im genuinely happy, and yet I get a bit down when Im faced with judgment for my decision.  In my heart of hearts, I know the important people in my life understand, and that I shouldnt allow others to make me feel bad.  I guess the issue is that while I dont shout it from the roof top, I do want to continue to be honest when I'm asked about my parents and siblings.  And my wish for a subject as controversial as this one is that others can agree to disagree with me and move on.

 

Has anyone made the decision to cut ties with their toxic family?  And if so, are you feeling the same way?  Id really like to hear from you. 

 

In the meantime, many blessings to each and everyone on this board for being brave enough to  tell their stories.  

 

I too have to deal with a toxic familys but it is my husbands mom and step dad and his evil drama drivin sister.  We cut ties from his alcoholic mom and step dad in 2003 when our son was just 2.  We also cut ties with his evil Sister because she enjoys hurting others and creating toxic hurtful drama and turning my husbands mom against us.  Now we are dealing with his step mother that has major anger issues and control issues. She is slowly turning my husbands father against him and I. When we have talked to her in the past she has taken things we have said out of context and used it against us. We think she is suffering from insecurity, feeling Jelouse of us and not feeling loved by her husband. She has driven my husbands sister and brother away from the family. She has been charged with abusing the sister and had to go for anger managemnet. We dont feel comfortable letting our son go out to see gramma and grandpa if grandpa isnt home in fear she will possibly physicaly or emotionaly hurt our son.  I'm hoping we can some how work out our differences and stay a family so my husband doesnt have to live a life without any parents. But time will only tell.  Some times I regret us breaking away from his mom and step dad. I feel like im to blame for our leaving them, even if it is for the best!   Best wish's to you and I pray you will have piece in your life!!

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
November 9, 2008, 8:13 pm PST

toxic family relationships

hi my name is kelli i was watching one of your programs on toxic familys. How parents can munipulate there childrens minds. that show was very touching it reminded me of the book "THE CHILD CALLED IT" author is Dave Pelzer. How his mother munipulated her family including the father. she abused the children. she was an alcoholic. i think  when the topic of munipulation was on,  Dave Pelzer should of been a guest on the show.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
November 13, 2008, 8:19 pm PST

kick him to the curb?

My sister is about to marry a this man!    he keeps quitting jobs becuase he doesnt want to pay child support... he is $73,000.00 behind on child support...   He has not filed taxes for 6 years  /  he has bills that are in collections   Our cousin did an internet seach and find out stuff, like the fact that he never as lived by himself, she found some other info but my sister refuses to accept it.   last year she was supposed to marry him but she called if off because his ex-girlfiend he lived with's   14 year old daughter.... .   she called it off because .. the ex-Girlfriend had a fourteen your old daughter , he felt like she was his daughter so he was sneaking around an lying about the 14 year old girl....gong to see her...people who sneak around and lie are doing something bad...Period......if he was really wanting to mentor  to her about Christianity, he would have never lied.....he would have been more convincing and going to church to prove his heart is right....God would not want us lying about something so pure and good.....  If a preacher came to me and talked about church I wouldnt believe him if he didnt go to a church! Period!!!!   When she first started talking with Mike he told her he was a Christian... what church was he attending NADA  if Mike were really a Christian he would be willing and begging heru to attend every Sunday and Wednesday with him....nothing would keep him away from his church....   when she first got with him he was living with his ex.?  (what was his reasoning behind this?) why would this be okay?  I would be constantly worrying he is moving to the next girl...     there are men out there that are not marriage material......   he constantly is lying, and a master manipulator (he has books on How to read a person like a book) and he has been a very good car sales man... he can persuade and talk you into stuff..... (forces her to give in or wears you down trying to convince you),  sneaking around, stumbling to answer you when he has been on the phone with someone....      he told her he quit his car sales job.... but the truth was he told his boss he was taking a few days off to work out problems with her......and never got that trucking job   she kicked him out when she called it off last year and moved him out but he insisted and manipulated her into holding his stuff......I told her to get all this stuff out and he left some stuff and I kept telling her that is his foot in the door!    She cannot trust him to be alone with her girls... so he is back now......and they are to be married after Christmas..     
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 14, 2008, 7:13 am PST

Sister's decision

Quote From: shanasfashions

My sister is about to marry a this man!    he keeps quitting jobs becuase he doesnt want to pay child support... he is $73,000.00 behind on child support...   He has not filed taxes for 6 years  /  he has bills that are in collections   Our cousin did an internet seach and find out stuff, like the fact that he never as lived by himself, she found some other info but my sister refuses to accept it.   last year she was supposed to marry him but she called if off because his ex-girlfiend he lived with's   14 year old daughter.... .   she called it off because .. the ex-Girlfriend had a fourteen your old daughter , he felt like she was his daughter so he was sneaking around an lying about the 14 year old girl....gong to see her...people who sneak around and lie are doing something bad...Period......if he was really wanting to mentor  to her about Christianity, he would have never lied.....he would have been more convincing and going to church to prove his heart is right....God would not want us lying about something so pure and good.....  If a preacher came to me and talked about church I wouldnt believe him if he didnt go to a church! Period!!!!   When she first started talking with Mike he told her he was a Christian... what church was he attending NADA  if Mike were really a Christian he would be willing and begging heru to attend every Sunday and Wednesday with him....nothing would keep him away from his church....   when she first got with him he was living with his ex.?  (what was his reasoning behind this?) why would this be okay?  I would be constantly worrying he is moving to the next girl...     there are men out there that are not marriage material......   he constantly is lying, and a master manipulator (he has books on How to read a person like a book) and he has been a very good car sales man... he can persuade and talk you into stuff..... (forces her to give in or wears you down trying to convince you),  sneaking around, stumbling to answer you when he has been on the phone with someone....      he told her he quit his car sales job.... but the truth was he told his boss he was taking a few days off to work out problems with her......and never got that trucking job   she kicked him out when she called it off last year and moved him out but he insisted and manipulated her into holding his stuff......I told her to get all this stuff out and he left some stuff and I kept telling her that is his foot in the door!    She cannot trust him to be alone with her girls... so he is back now......and they are to be married after Christmas..     
Is your sister open to your advice? My advice to you is this: don’t push her too hard because then, she might alienate you, and that would give this guy exactly what he wants. Don’t allow him to do that. Although it is so annoying and hurtful to see your sister be taken advantage of, try to help her by giving her kind encouragement. Get her involved in some activity with you, just to get her & the kids out of the home & away from him, so she can realize that she really can feel happiness when not around him, and that she has her own mind. This guy might be a great manipulator, but on some level, your sister is allowing it. She is going to end up alienating her own children if she doesn’t smarten up soon. Do you think she would read a self help book or consider therapy for herself? Ask her if she would. If she says, ‘what do I need therapy for?!’ Let her know it is because she allows this guy to walk all over her. Ask her to give it a try, at least before going through with the wedding; that is all you can do. I wish you the best!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 14, 2008, 8:45 am PST

Food For Thought

"Enmeshment refers to an extreme form of proximity and intensity in family interactions...In a highly enmeshed, over involved family, changes within one family member or in the relationship between two family members reverberate throughout the system... On an individual level, interpersonal differentiation in an enmeshed system is poor...in enmeshed families the individual gets lost in the system. The boundaries that define individual autonomy are so weak that functioning in individually differentiated ways is radically handicapped."

 

"We're enmeshed when we use an individual for our identity, sense of value, worth, well-being, safety, purpose, and security. Instead of two people present, we become one identity. More simply, enmeshment is present when our sense of wholeness comes from another person."

 

"Enmeshment doesn't allow for individuality, wholeness, personal empowerment, healthy relationships with ourselves or others, and, most importantly, a relationship with our Higher Power."

 

“If a parent loves a child as a substitute for a friend or partner, emotional chaos will follow, often across generations.

 

Instead of adding meaning to life, toxic entanglements support manipulation, emotional blackmail and codependence.”

 

The shared experiences and love that bond family members are the basis for some of the strongest relationship bonds that humans can experience. While we need strong nurturing family bonds to function in a society of families, many people are bonded by unpleasant or toxic beliefs.

 

If you experienced trauma or abuse, you may suffer relationship bonds as limiting beliefs and dysfunctional habits that impact your family, work and social life. You may suffer from identity loss that bind you to certain people or groups.  The strongest bonded relationships seem to be based on a shared sense of identity. Relationship bonds can be substitutes for identity - and hence a form of identity loss. Often, dysfunctional behavior appears to be based on toxic beliefs that support pleasant feelings of connection and identity.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 18, 2008, 9:11 am PST

Subtle Type of Abuse??


A good friend of mine is in a bad situation. Her husband has been out of work for years but refuses to look for a job. He's healthy and very mechanically inclined, can fix just about anything and worked as a mechanic for a long time. They have two young children at home. She works from home doing small typing/computer tasks and watches the kids when they're not in school. He sits around and bitches at her about how she can't take care of kids right, her friends, her church, her cooking....just about everything.
There's very little money coming in. They have no health insurance. His unemployment ran out long ago. He has a large 401k plan, bank accounts, other investments all in his name only and he hasn't spent any of it. Their house and car are paid for. They have always lived a very simple life with no extravagances. There's no drugs, booze, cheating involved. She's looking for work outside the home with hours that will allow her to be home when the kids are there. So far no luck although she keeps applying and interviewing. She wants to sign up for low cost health care for her and the kids but is afraid she'll have to report all of his resources and the fact that he refuses to work. He is no longer providing any kind of financial support for his family. Outside of divorcing him is there any help she can get? Can anyone else relate to this situation?
 
First | Prev | 194 | 195 | 196 | 197 | 198 | 199 | 200 | 201 | 202 | 203 | Next | Last