Topic : 03/06 Etiquette Dilemmas

Number of Replies: 1000
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, September 14, 2007, 03:44:36 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 09/18/07) Does it annoy you to no end when someone uses a cell phone at the dinner table or chews with his or her mouth open? Along with author Peggy Post, Dr. Phil tackles the dos and don’ts of etiquette. One issue making recent headlines is appropriate in-flight attire. Kyla was flying to Phoenix on Southwest Airlines when an employee informed her that her outfit was too skimpy. Kyla saw nothing wrong with the way she was dressed and was appalled when she was asked to cover up. Did the airline go overboard, or was Kyla too tantalizing for take-off? Then, Kate took her 19-month-old son on his first flight, but she was removed from the plane when he became too talkative. Was the airline out of line for telling Kate to shut her baby up? Peggy Post weighs in on this polarizing problem. And, Joan says she doesn’t have any peace at home because of all the noise her family makes – from loud chewing to clinking dinnerware. Her husband, Bob, says he and their three children have to walk on eggshells around Joan just to eat dinner. Is Joan overly sensitive, or does her family need to be reined in? Plus, meet a woman who says her husband’s bad manners didn’t disturb her until she had a baby, and a guest who nominated herself as having the worst etiquette in the country! Share your own etiquette peeves and join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More September 2007 Show Boards.


User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 6:55 am PDT

09/18 Etiquette

Quote From: lamc74

Child behaviour is one of my soap boxes. My oldest daughter was two years old the first time I had her on an airplane. She alternated sitting  in her seat and sitting in my lap. Otherwise she behaved like an adult. We talked but she was not loud or disruptive to others on the plane. When she had to go the the bathroom she quietly told me and held my hand as we quitely  walked to the bathroom and back.  No child can be expected to be an adult but at that age children have the capacity to be able to learn right from wrong to a greater extent than most parents realize. Maybe they don't want to realize this because it puts the responsibility on them for their childs' behaviour. Both of my children were taught to have manners in public at a very young age. At one time my two daughters, who were teenagers at the time, and I were in public having our senses assaulted by a screaming, crying, kicking brat. The mother was doing nothing with this kid to let him know that you shouldn't  behave that way in public or anywhere else. I looked at my daughters in astonishment and said "You two never acted that way." My oldest daughter said they knew they wouldn't like what  happened if they did act that way. You don't have to beat or abuse a child in any way to teach them. But it does take work and thought and I feel most parents don't want to be bothered. They would rather cruise and let the kid do whatever he or she wants and somehow that parent has the abiblity to ignore the brat. I can't ignore it. I doubt I would have been able to ignore the brat on the airplane. I did not force my bratty kids on others and I do not appreciate it when someone forces his or her bratty kid on me. That mother and child should have been removed from the airplane. I remember hearing about that incident on the news. My daughter that has a little boy heard about that, too. We three flew from Dallas to St. Louis. My daughter was scared to death fearing she and her baby would get thrown off of that airplane. The baby was 22 months old at the time and he can be a handful. But I wasn't worried. I knew she disciplined her child. He was a little testy and fidgity but he was not noisy and unruly and disruptive. He did fiine. That is my proof that very young children can behave on airplanes without disturbing others. I recall a trip I took on an airplane sitting across from two little girls. One was under a year old and I think the other was three. Ay first I thought "Oh, no." But those children behaved. They weren't perfect little adults but they did not create a problem. I commended the parents for obviously disciplining and training their kids. More proof that children can behave on airplanes. Again, don't force your bratty kids off on me.

 

Did you actually listen when you heard the story about the mother and child. Because the child was not being disruptive or as you say BRATTY. He was only saying Bye-Bye plane. And not only was the mother upset, quite a few of the other passengers were too. One even went so far as to refuse to fly because the mother nor her child did anything to deserve being thrown off the plane. What would you have done if you hand been told to sedate one of your precious little angels? According to the other passengers the mother remained calm and DID NOT create a scene and the child was NOT being disruptive at all.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 7:07 am PDT

09/18 Etiquette

Quote From: shelly_80

I agree with you on your first point about etiquitte, however, your second is a little frustrating to me.  What about the saying "there is a time and a place for everything"?  You're probably asking, "well, what about it?"  She was flying to Arizona, she wasn't going to a bar to pick up guys. Get my drift?

 

I don't consider being told to put clothes on grounds for a law suit based on discrimination.  I have CP so, when I think of discrimination I think race, ethnic background, religious conviction, physical abilities , etc.  Things we can't help, not things we can like the way we dress.  Once it was brought to SWA's attention, she was asked to change so apperently she was the one breaking the rules, otherwise the person who made the initial complaint would have been informed the she was within dress code. 

 

Furthermore, it is up SWA and every other airline what their customers wear.  To fly on buddy passes you HAVE TO wear the appropriate attire, no if , and's or but's.  I am aware that she was not flying on a buddy pass.  I just think it needs to be accross the board.  I've been reading other posts that feel the same way I do and I'm wondering where are our rights to not  be exposed to people who think they have a right to dress how they choose, in public no less?  You can dress however you so choose in the privacy of your own home but the minute you step out into public you make it the publics business. Not to mention,  what about the kids on that flight who probably unintentionally saw her underwear as well?  Shouldn't parents have a right to voice their opinions if they feel someone is not dressed appropriately with their chioldren present?  I think so!  I would be shocked if this particular situation doesn't majorly change things in the way of dress code.  It very well should.

SWA DOES NOT have a dress code, so she wasn't violating anything.  In fact when she flew back on the same airline, the female attendant on that flight COMPLIMENTED her on her attire. So she flashed her panties when she sat down, get a grip  it's not going to damage little Johnny for the rest  of his life or make little Mary want to be a hooker. You people make it sound like she was just wearing a G-String and Pasties.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 8:36 am PDT

Every Young Man's Battle

Quote From: cissie88

SWA DOES NOT have a dress code, so she wasn't violating anything.  In fact when she flew back on the same airline, the female attendant on that flight COMPLIMENTED her on her attire. So she flashed her panties when she sat down, get a grip  it's not going to damage little Johnny for the rest  of his life or make little Mary want to be a hooker. You people make it sound like she was just wearing a G-String and Pasties.
"Every Young Man's Battle" is a book I recommend to every young child and their parents.  Things people see do stick in their heads, and it is hard to erase.  That is why porn is not sold to young children, and ID's are checked at the movie theatre for "R" rated movies.  So when these girls walk around in public like they just jumped off the front page of Playboy the public needs to be concerned.  A male would be arrested for for exposing himself in that way.  Why aren't these women/girls getting arrested.  I fully support SWA.
 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
upset
September 17, 2007, 8:48 am PDT

dress code on southwest

the girl who was kicked off the airline was not even wearing the outfit that she shows in the media. Her clothe were more reveling. Southwest employees were approached by other passengers who were offended by her outfit. she had on a see through top showing her bra and yes the skirt with no panties! I work for the airline and I know that we pull them off and put them in the jet way to talk not in front of the other passengers. She is lying! Also, we are told in training that if there are numerous passenger complains we have to talk to the person before we can leave it is how we work. she has lied about this from the beginning and I am proud to work for an airline who feels that the matter was handed the right way.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 8:53 am PDT

09/18 Etiquette

Quote From: pierson4

"Every Young Man's Battle" is a book I recommend to every young child and their parents.  Things people see do stick in their heads, and it is hard to erase.  That is why porn is not sold to young children, and ID's are checked at the movie theatre for "R" rated movies.  So when these girls walk around in public like they just jumped off the front page of Playboy the public needs to be concerned.  A male would be arrested for for exposing himself in that way.  Why aren't these women/girls getting arrested.  I fully support SWA.
The woman was fully dressed, so tell me WHY she should have been arrested?  Last time I checked a Playboy out, most of the women were nude. A flash of panties is NOT going to afffect a rational young person.  But  one who is raised by people who overreact to this type of situation could be I suppose.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
ecstatic
September 17, 2007, 10:29 am PDT

Thanks for covering for me

Quote From: cissie88

Did you actually listen when you heard the story about the mother and child. Because the child was not being disruptive or as you say BRATTY. He was only saying Bye-Bye plane. And not only was the mother upset, quite a few of the other passengers were too. One even went so far as to refuse to fly because the mother nor her child did anything to deserve being thrown off the plane. What would you have done if you hand been told to sedate one of your precious little angels? According to the other passengers the mother remained calm and DID NOT create a scene and the child was NOT being disruptive at all.

Bravo to your message, I totally agree with you.  To lamc, when you said that the mother and her child should've been thrown off that airplane, did you mean Kate and her son, or the mother and that bratty child that you encountered on your flight?  I'm sorry that you had to go through dealing with a psychotic toddler on your air flight, but Kate's child was only saying "Bye-bye, plane" with an indoor tone of voice (at least, I believe he used an indoor tone of voice.)  You must not have very much tolerance in you, or else you would've thought that was sweet, too.  Admit it.  Even when I read the story on Yahoo!, I never saw anything about the kid crying, kicking and screaming.  (Unless I had a screaming baby next to me, or some kid kicking my seat, I'd just try to ignore it; after all, what business would it be of mine?)

 

My point is that didn't sound like a brat to me.  Don't speak unless you know all the facts. 

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 3:26 pm PDT

slutty dressing and cell phones...

Why do women today dress so slutty? Why do  you have to reveal everything? What happened to modesty? come on--people wear mini skirts and show cleavage at church...why must you do that at church?

 

Women/girls wear these mini-skirts and show tons of cleavage and then they get mad when men treat them like objects and whistle and say obscene things. DUH. If you show everything men are going to look. and a lot of the girls like the attention.

 

what happened to being noticed for your other qualities like being smart...no they think the way to be noticed is to show their body and leave nothing to the imagination.

 

and on the subject of cell phones---I think they are so annoying. Im sitting somewhere with limited parking and I'm waiting forever because this woman is talking on the cell phone while attempting to back out of a space in a big suv--cant you tell the person on the phone to hold on for a second. My mom works as a cashier andshe said she gets people who come in to check out and they don't even pay attention to the cashier because they just talk on the phone the whole time. how rude.


And you won't believe how many times a cell phone rings in church....gracious...Can you turn it off for an hour?

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 5:52 pm PDT

09/18 Etiquette

It amazes me how many people actually pay attention to what others are wearing, I mean really aircraft seats are not set up like say train seats, so unless someone's child was hanging over the seat, how would they see anything ?  Okay, maybe she flashed when putting bags in the overhead, but how many passengers (unless you have a thing about watching others) were really paying that much attention.  Look at it this way, at least you KNEW for sure she wasn't hiding ANYTHING in that outfit ( tongue in cheek ) to be honest I wouldn't wear it (don't have the legs for it ), but what an airline charges for its tickets, no I wouldn't want them dictating what I can or cannot wear anyway.

As for the baby, OMG, if he was just babbling happily (beats the screaming child in row six , right ?) then whoever complained its their problem, and yes they should get over themselves, even a crying baby, his/her ears might be REALLY aching (I know when I fly my ears are in agony for the better part of the flight and NOTHING helps), if it bothers a person that badly, bring earplugs or charter a private flight, its PUBLIC transportation, that means you have to deal with every type of person imaginable.

Not only do I consider peeing on the seat, and using a cellphone while a clerk is waiting on you rude, or making sure EVERYONE in the restaurant hears your phone conversation, how about people using terms of endearment to you "sweetheart " , "dear" and my personal favorite "honey " to total strangers ? I can tolerate it from older people, but NOT people my age or younger, that drives me nuts.

As for noise sensitivity, migraines , adult ADHD and other illnesses can be culprits, but we do not live in a silent world (no kidding, there have been times I wished I would lose the hearing in my other ear as well, yes babies crying, screaming kids, they can send me up the wall, why ? It's the pitch of the wailing, however I do realize that there is probably a reason for it and have learned to remove myself.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
September 17, 2007, 5:55 pm PDT

Cover-up

I am a girl and I go to an all girl's college and I hate it when I see other girls breasts or underwear. It is sick and whether anyone likes it or not little kids look at things so the airline had every right to tell her to cover-up. She also went on the plane of her own accord therefore she gave her consent to abide by their rules (spoken or unspoken). People in this country need to learn morals.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 7:13 pm PDT

09/18 Etiquette

Quote From: ceildh1

It amazes me how many people actually pay attention to what others are wearing, I mean really aircraft seats are not set up like say train seats, so unless someone's child was hanging over the seat, how would they see anything ?  Okay, maybe she flashed when putting bags in the overhead, but how many passengers (unless you have a thing about watching others) were really paying that much attention.  Look at it this way, at least you KNEW for sure she wasn't hiding ANYTHING in that outfit ( tongue in cheek ) to be honest I wouldn't wear it (don't have the legs for it ), but what an airline charges for its tickets, no I wouldn't want them dictating what I can or cannot wear anyway.

As for the baby, OMG, if he was just babbling happily (beats the screaming child in row six , right ?) then whoever complained its their problem, and yes they should get over themselves, even a crying baby, his/her ears might be REALLY aching (I know when I fly my ears are in agony for the better part of the flight and NOTHING helps), if it bothers a person that badly, bring earplugs or charter a private flight, its PUBLIC transportation, that means you have to deal with every type of person imaginable.

Not only do I consider peeing on the seat, and using a cellphone while a clerk is waiting on you rude, or making sure EVERYONE in the restaurant hears your phone conversation, how about people using terms of endearment to you "sweetheart " , "dear" and my personal favorite "honey " to total strangers ? I can tolerate it from older people, but NOT people my age or younger, that drives me nuts.

As for noise sensitivity, migraines , adult ADHD and other illnesses can be culprits, but we do not live in a silent world (no kidding, there have been times I wished I would lose the hearing in my other ear as well, yes babies crying, screaming kids, they can send me up the wall, why ? It's the pitch of the wailing, however I do realize that there is probably a reason for it and have learned to remove myself.

You're brilliant as always my dear...(purplepenny here)...I too don't get how people care or even really NOTICE what other people are wearing. Even if I notice what someone may be wearing I kinda goes in and out of my mind in a matter of seconds.
 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Next | Last