Message Boards

Topic : 12/28 Hobo Daddy

Number of Replies: 649
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, September 21, 2007, 12:20:55 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 09/27/07) Jerry has been out of his daughter, Kayla's, life for 17 years – - by choice.  He went on the run to avoid paying child support, now lives as a hobo floating down the Mississippi River on a raft.  Kayla had no contact with Jerry until a couple of filmmakers decided to make a documentary about his life.  The film is called “Nobody,” and Kayla says it actually glorifies her deadbeat Dad. Learn what Jerry says in the film that is so repugnant to Kayla that she feels compelled to confront her father and set the record straight. Then, Dr. Phil takes you on an unusual search for the man who calls the Mississippi River his home. When the searchers meet Jerry face to face, is he ready for a confrontation with the daughter he hasn’t seen since she was a toddler? Hear why he says he stayed away when tragedy struck their family. Emotions run high when father and daughter face off. But will Jerry have the answers Kayla is looking for? Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 12:32 pm PST

your wrong

Quote From: cohray

jerry is the man and he did the best he could. stop trying to  make jerry suffer, the daughter is very immature and she is over reacting about stupid things like the beer on her head...i mean come on, take a shower, dont cry about it

how insensitive can you be to a younge lady you dont know unless you have lived her life experienced her heartache then you dont know god made each of us unique in how we feel ,experience anything and everthing in our lives, the heartche, thejoy, the good, the bad, the odds the ends the ups the downs of our personal lives

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 12:47 pm PST

12/28 Hobo Daddy

Quote From: fromthesquare

Highlight and show me where I said that Jerry was responsible for Micah's death.  I was referring to a situation in my own life.  I believe you answered the wrong posting.  Unless you think I am a member of Kayla's family- which I am not.  I am confused by your statements and your anger. 

 

PS:  I am really sorry about your son.

I'm sorry I did misquote :O It was late last night

P.S Thank you
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
hopeful
December 29, 2007, 1:00 pm PST

for Kayla

I had a father with the same attitude as Jerry. Though he didn't live in the woods. He did escape his financial responsibilities and his commitments to his children.
I came to realize in my late 20's that I had my own life and had to accept him for what he was. He was a loner, who never should have married my mother and my mother should not have married him. It's not right what he did, but Kayla has to realize that he really doesn't have much of a choice..he is genetically made to be the way he is. And Dr. Phil is right, she needs to let go of the anger, there is nothing you can do to change the past so why let him own all those angry feelings. My father died 2 years ago, he was alone, with a brain tumor and nobody to be his advocate. The last year of his life I was so angry about something he did to my stepfather that I didn't speak or see him until I heard about the brain tumor. I went to see him and for the first time in his life he apologized for everything, and when I left the nursing home that day, I turned around and took one last look at him before I left. He was sitting in a wheel chair looking so sad and so alone. He was waving goodbye, I knew that was the last time I would see him. Kayla, you must move on.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 1:07 pm PST

12/28 Hobo Daddy

Quote From: kaylakristine

It's a long story.. and the show hasn't aired, so I don't want to give it away.  When you watch it, you'll see why I wanted to confront him!!!!!!!!  EXACTLY WHY!!!!!!!

I got ahold of them to help me find him.  I did know he was homeless... a couple film makers made a movie about him, glorifying his life style.  I'm an adult and it was my decision.. not my mothers, not Dr. Phils. 

Think of it this way.. I've been SILENT for 17 yrs..  I think it's my turn to finally speak up, is it not? 

And why the heck do people think I want his money?  WHAT MONEY!???  Do  you think you get paid for being homeless?  What the heck people, get real!!!!!  I HAVE MY OWN MONEY, I'm a nurse, I don't need his beer money for the day, he can keep that.

Just watch the whole story before you guys start sticking up for this pathedic individual... Did you ever wonder why HIS SON wasn't shown in the previews of this show............................................................

 

 

Kayla,
I am much older than you, yet I have lived my life a similar type of father..The best thing you can do is just accept things the way that they are, you cannot change the past. You can only move into the future and set your own examples to your own children.
I long ago had come to terms and understand my fathers mind set, that could never be changed. Your father was just built the way he is, I have a sister just like him and there is nothing we can do to change her either. Please hang in and go get help to sort this out.
Life will be much better for you if you do.
please don't hesitate to as me questions.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
December 29, 2007, 1:10 pm PST

Wow

This whole thing didn't make a whole lot of sense, First off Kayla didn't have any intention of this even being civil.  She was nasty and angry and vengeful.  How can she blame her brother’s death on her father?  I think there needs to be counseling for her.  She says she has kids of her own, well then focus on them and stop hating her father for a lifetime of mistakes.  He can't take, what he did or didn't do back why continue to hate him.  He isn't knocking on her door asking for hand outs, he is off in his own world not bothering his former family.  After 17 years, really what did she want?  Him to pick her up and bounce her on his knee and tell her how wonderful she is.  He checked out along time ago.......move on.  Stop blaming him for things that were out of his control and out of her control as well..

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 1:27 pm PST

KAYLA IS BRAVE AND STRONG.

Quote From: kaylakristine

It's a long story.. and the show hasn't aired, so I don't want to give it away.  When you watch it, you'll see why I wanted to confront him!!!!!!!!  EXACTLY WHY!!!!!!!

I got ahold of them to help me find him.  I did know he was homeless... a couple film makers made a movie about him, glorifying his life style.  I'm an adult and it was my decision.. not my mothers, not Dr. Phils. 

Think of it this way.. I've been SILENT for 17 yrs..  I think it's my turn to finally speak up, is it not? 

And why the heck do people think I want his money?  WHAT MONEY!???  Do  you think you get paid for being homeless?  What the heck people, get real!!!!!  I HAVE MY OWN MONEY, I'm a nurse, I don't need his beer money for the day, he can keep that.

Just watch the whole story before you guys start sticking up for this pathedic individual... Did you ever wonder why HIS SON wasn't shown in the previews of this show............................................................

 

 

   Kayla, I wish more people would confront  their reality like you did on the show! If people were as BRAVE AS YOU  then the world would be a Healthier place.Kayla years ago I researched people that live the [HOBO] lifetyle and I found that MOST of these folks are in this lifestyle because they are emotionally damaged and resist REALITY.They are _not_brave like you KAYLA :0) These Hobos tend to fear reality and they run away physically from responibility.WORST of all they run away from the [TRUTH and GOOD MENTAL HEALTH].Kayla,I must tell you that I am a man that knows it is NOT OK to physically _or_emotionally abandon children.I APPOLIGIZE for your dad.I'm sorry that you and your brother did not get what KIDS need and you suffered as a result.I know you will strive to be a Healthy parent, I can SEE THAT IN YOU Kayla./
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 1:54 pm PST

To Kayla and Family

If you're reading these posts, I hope you can see that most people here are sincere and want you to find healing and happiness. I agree, you need to find a way to stop the cycle of hatred, anger, and bitterness. It's not too late...and you certainly don't want to pass it on to your children...not if you love them and care about them. Show them that their mom can forgive and love...children learn what they live.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 2:14 pm PST

Very powerfull!!!!!

Quote From: hankscmkjv

 

STOP criticizing men who are often denigrated, psychologically batterd and marginalized by a selfish and ignorant populace.

To begin with, men who live in glasses may wish to stop throwing stones.

A large percentage of men are just one "false allegation , ie 911 call away from becoming "Hobby Daddys"

yet they fail to see it.

 

Those who are quick to stone "dis-enfranchised" dads, may do better by deeply reflecting on their own lives, and ask WHY this one time boy,  with hopes and dreams,.......... has turned out this way.

 

Christians know that Christ chose to fraternize with the marginalized, recognized the holiness of the beggar "at the back of the synagogue" over the alleged holy man at the fron,....

and even promised heaven to a sinner who recognized Him as Lord as he faded from this life after being battered, spit on , degraded and so forth.....

 

So,  judge not these modern day possible "Jesus of Suburbia's" , but fulfill your Christian obligation ,as the Samaritan did many years ago, and show some compassion, rather than blindly criticize another helpless soul.

 

best regards,

Hank

Montreal Canada 

 

 

I totally agree Hank!!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 2:20 pm PST

Miserable

I was so upset when I saw Kayla on the show yesterday but still sympathetic.  She and her mother were so angry and bitter that it showed all through the show.  She just needs to cry.  It was so obvious that Jerry loved his son and she was so upset that she couldn't take that from him.  Kayla's mother need to stop feeding into that madness and they need to start healing.  Her anger still doesn't change the fact that he is her biological father. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2007, 2:21 pm PST

12/28 Hobo Daddy

This is a very sad situation.  My heart goes out to Jerry, and this is why.  From what I gathered from the show, Jerry's x-wife stopped letting Jerry see the children due to his partying, and lack of parental skills, when the children were young.  Jerry still paid child support due to his wages being garnished.  When the x-wife went after the back child support, then he decided to go on the run.  By this time she had another husband who was playing the roll of father for the children.  She wanted the money, but didn't want Jerry to be a part of the children's lives.  After years of telling the children how terrible their father was, she successfully was able to turn the daughter against him, but not the son.  When the son got older he found his father, and rekindled the relationship.  They partied together, which is irresponsible on Jerry's part, but just might be the reason why the son wanted the relationship with his Dad in the first place, thinking that his Dad was cool...that is the way that children think.  I don't feel it is right that Jerry is being blamed for the son taking his own life, but I have a feeling he would have been blamed regardless.  When people loose the ones they love under these kind of circumstances they are looking for someone or something to blame.  The mother, and daughter saying he took his life because he didn't want to end up like his father, is a pretty shallow excuse of escaping any blame that they maybe responsible for, or have partaken in.  Maybe the reason he took his life is quite the opposite reason, then they think, maybe he was tired of the hatred, and resent showed towards his father, plus his own family problems, and it was just more then he could bare, who's really to say. As far as the daughter saying that the documentary was glorifying a dead-beat father...what part of homeless, and being a hobo is glorifying?  Unless one has been homeless, one has no idea the hell, and hard times one goes through, it is not an easy life by any means.  I can say this sincerely because I have been homeless before, and not by choice.  As far as I understand the daughter has never watched the documentary, and more or less this was a way for her to discredit her father.  The hate, and disrespect she showed for her father to me was repulsive.  Jerry showed more respect by showing up on the show in the first place, and being as humble as he was, then either of them.  I think this was a cruel way of both the mother, and the daughter to publicly humiliate the man.  Dr. Phil was so right by telling the daughter that she must get past this in order to live a healthy life, and in order to have healthy relationships with others, including her own children...I praise you Dr. Phil for saying this.  I know this all to be a fact because I have lived it, and I am past it.  The only difference between me, and Jerry's daughter is...my father refused to have anything to do with me period, and I have gotten past it a longtime ago!  Jerry could have fled to Mexico, and been a beach bum if he was really the monster that they both tried to make him out to be.  I say forgive the man and get on with the rest of your life, to both the daughter, and mother!

 
First | Prev | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | Next | Last