Message Boards

Topic : 01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Number of Replies: 1406
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Saturday, September 29, 2007, 09:23:47 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
How well do you think you know your neighbors, your friends and even your child's teacher? It is estimated that four to eight million people in North America are swinging in the suburbs -- mostly middle-class folks from all walks of life. Dr. Phil gives you a closer look at who these couples are who engage in sex with other twosomes. First up, Nita and Walter have been swinging for the last 12 years. They say they are happy in the lifestyle, so why does it cause tension in their relationship? Then, Brent says he has a strong yearning for he and his wife, Renee, to participate in a threesome. Renee says the idea disgusts her, but worries that if she refuses to join in, Brent will leave her. They fight constantly, often dragging their 17-year-old son into the middle of their chaos. Brent says he thinks about having threesomes every other day, but says that his desire is normal. What does Dr. Phil think? And, Dr. Phil viewers weigh in and share their thoughts about the swinging lifestyle. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 9:16 am PST

Sex is Making Love to the Faithful

Quote From: christab

"Intimate bonding" and all that other stuff you are talking about is called "Making Love" ..... not sex.  Sex is just sex.

 

You know there is a difference, right?

 

In your last line, "We will ultimately pay the price for our actions."  Some people get fabulous mindblowing sex and relationships on levels YOU just can't understand. 

 

Sex is making love to the faithful. We do not want to "understand" the experiences of "the lifestyle" because we know we are not missing out. We don't need opportunities for having “mind blowing sex” and “relationships” aside from our partners, because we are satisfied with the one person we are with and have “mind blowing sex” with them. The only one who is going to have "mind blowing sex" with my husband is me! Our bodies are not used on a whim as a ”sex game toy” with outsiders because we do not want to be sexually close to someone other than our life partner. We have the treasure of an “intimate bonding” of making love on a level that people in "the lifestyle" will never experience. The monogamous who are in a very close long term marriage understand the beauty of being faithful. The faithful are not on the same page as those in the lustful licentious world, and we don't want to be. 

 

 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 10:17 am PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: mimert

AMEN!

I second that AMEN to the following:

 

Quote From: carlyjen7

 

I have been married to the same guy for 36 1/2 years.  Neither one of us has ever had sexual relations with anyone else. He is my best friend and lover.  Marriage is a divinely ordained instution bringing together one man and one women. When I took my wedding vows I pledged myself to him forsaking all others. My spouse is in my soul mate and I can never imagine either one of us wanting to be someone else. Animals will mate with any of the same species. He is not particular.  Has sex been reduced to animalism in our society? If you have to go outside your marriage to find happiness or to "swing" with someone else, you possess a lack of respect for yourself as well as your spouse. You are basically saying that your spouse is not good enough so therefore, you will look for happiness somewhere else. You carry your happiness with you and nothing external is going to sustain that happiness. "Swinging" is another sign of degeneracy in our country and it saddens me greatly to think that people have to resort to this kind of acitivty to find true happiness and love in life.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 10:35 am PST

Very sad for Nita and Walter

I really do feel sorry for both couples. My husband & I have been married for 38 years. The most personal,intimate, loving gift you can give eachother is yourself. Sex without LOVE & INTIMACY would be a very lonely, empty thing. If you both need this playing to be sexually satisfied, how sad. After 38 years we can still rock eachother's world. Yes, the earth does move, we have never needed or wanted anyone else to provide our sexual satisfaction, we very satisfied emotionally and physically.

Brent, I hope you really do understand Renee now. AT the first suggestion (if to me)would have been you heading out the door with a rolling pin aimed at your head. Treat her with respect, she is a loving woman.

Gee, Nita, Walter and Brent, bet you make your parents proud.!!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 12:30 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Our bodies are not used on a whim as a ”sex game toy” with outsiders because we do not want to be sexually close to someone other than our life partner.

 

That is your choice. My sister-in-laws church plays a game at every picnic where they pass an orange from person to person tucked under their chins, sure looks sexy from the sidelines

 

 

We have the treasure of an “intimate bonding” of making love on a level that people in "the lifestyle" will never experience.

 

We were monogamous for the first 13 years of our marriage so I guess we know all about "intimate bonding" and then tried and enjoyed swinging for the next 20 years. Swinging is better for us, but then you will never experience that. You live your life, I will live mine.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
February 9, 2008, 1:36 pm PST

pop religion and such...

Quote From: sara2007

I disagree with you. You need to read and think about this commandment THOU SHALT NOT COMMIT ADULTRY. Explain to me how swingers are not committing adultry.

Thanks, I read all of them! Are you positive that you follow all ten commandments? Or do you pick and choose which ones are most important based on a priority level that you or society have set ...not God?

 

This book of the law shall not depart out of thy mouth; but thou shalt meditate therein day and night, that thou mayest observe to do according to all that is written therein: for then thou shalt make thy way prosperous, and then thou shalt have good success.    Joshua 1:8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
sad
February 9, 2008, 1:54 pm PST

abused and confused

Quote From: sublimebabi22

I'm 23 years old. I've always had a weight problem. My parents have always been verbally abusive and my father is physically abusive. I started having sex and smoking pot when I was 15. I was raped at that age too. This started a long line of having sex with guys just because they wanted to have sex with me despite the fact that I didn't want to have sex with them. I've been told this is because I feel other people's feelings are more important than mine. I also figured that if I did what they wanted maybe they'd want to actually date me. My first relationship was my high school sweetheart and it was decent. I cheated on him with an ex of mine because the guy wanted to not because I really wanted to. That relationship ended shortly thereafter when he broke up with me. When I was 19 I met a 29 year old who already had a girlfriend. I ended up going out with him officially after they broke up. He beat me almost everyday and was verbally and sometimes sexually abusive to me. He eventually cheated on me and left me. My next relationship was when I was 21 with a 26 year old. He was verbally, sexually, and (a few times) physically abusive. In the beginning of our relationship I cheated on him much in the same fashion as the first boyfriend. He was enraged about it. I didn't know what it would lead to. He eventually started harassing me to have sex with other men. He'd harass me about it constantly and make me tell him stories of having relations with other men. If I didn't want to he'd threaten to leave me. He didn't want to be involved he just wanted to listen from the other room. His other main stipulation was that is be unprotected sex. So, I went along with it. I believe it was five different men throughout the course of our 11 month relationship. The worst time was when he brought me to see his friend and his girlfriend for the friend's birthday. He asked me to have sex with his friend before we even went down there and I told him no. Much like the woman I saw on the show today it made me feel degraded, dirty, unloved, sick to my stomach, etc. So, when we went to see his friends I wanted to go to bed early. My boyfriend then proceeded to scream at me for about two hours straight to "play cards with them." So, I finally gave in because I knew he wouldn't stop screaming at me and I knew he would break up with me if he didn't get his way. He broke up with me at least twice a week a few months into our relationship. That's one of the main ways he got me to do the things he wanted me to do. So, by playing cards he meant having sex with his friend whilst he had sex with the friend's girlfriend. It was the worst experience of my life. It went on for hours and was very physically painful. My boyfriend also performed oral sex on her and had unprotected sex with her. He kept saying he wanted to have sex with the friend's girlfriend but she didn't want to anymore. So, he got mad and decided he'd have sex with me since he couldn't have sex with her anymore. He then forced me to kiss him and perform oral sex on him after he had done those things with her. This went on for a few more hours. When he was finally done he went to bed. The next day I was bleeding and mentally tormented. We had an hour ride home and I cried the whole way home. He screamed at me that if I didn't want to do it I shouldn't have done it. Throughout our relationship I had sex with other men at his demand quite a few times but this incident was by far the worst. He didn't care what it did to me and figured I'd "get used to it" like the husband on the show. And, like the woman on the show I went along with it because I was terrified of losing him. Watching the show today made me cry and brought up a lot of terrible feelings. I just thought I'd post this to let people know what it can really do to someone.

You have been abused and you are confused about  relationships between men and women. You have had some very bad luck and made very bad decisions because you didn't get the help that you needed. Your experiences have nothing to do with swinging.

Ask Dr. Phil for help. Right now!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 3:15 pm PST

Where is that 'happy marriage meter' everyone's using?

Quote From: faithful4ever

I second that AMEN to the following:

 

Quote From: carlyjen7

 

I have been married to the same guy for 36 1/2 years.  Neither one of us has ever had sexual relations with anyone else. He is my best friend and lover.  Marriage is a divinely ordained instution bringing together one man and one women. When I took my wedding vows I pledged myself to him forsaking all others. My spouse is in my soul mate and I can never imagine either one of us wanting to be someone else. Animals will mate with any of the same species. He is not particular.  Has sex been reduced to animalism in our society? If you have to go outside your marriage to find happiness or to "swing" with someone else, you possess a lack of respect for yourself as well as your spouse. You are basically saying that your spouse is not good enough so therefore, you will look for happiness somewhere else. You carry your happiness with you and nothing external is going to sustain that happiness. "Swinging" is another sign of degeneracy in our country and it saddens me greatly to think that people have to resort to this kind of acitivty to find true happiness and love in life.

 

I have been married for 27 years and he is my best-friend and lover. He is my soul-mate and I can't imagine either of us wanting to be with someone else. Our marriage brought together one man and one woman.When I took my wedding vows I pledged myself to him forsaking all others. We have not ever gone 'outside' our marriage for happiness and never will. Neither of us is under the impression  that anything external is going sustain our happiness, nor are we under the impression that anything external can ever come between us.

We did not resort to this kind of activity to find true happiness and love in life. What ever gave you that idea? That is just as ridiculous as trying  to find true happiness and love in life by having sex as a single person. Sex is not love and love is not sex. They are not interchangeable! One thing I have is  insight that you cannot possibly have....I have been in a monogamous marriage for decades and I have spent a few years swinging.You are only in a position to comment on monogamous marriages. Your personal experiences do not include swinging so any comments made about the subject by you are hearsay and not facts.

I am not saying that you are not happy  in your  marriage or that you have not found true love because you choose to have sexual relations with one man. That would be just as offensive as you have been towards me. A strong, long term marriage really only requires that the couple agree on the terms. People divorce  over disagreements about money, raising the kids, sex, careers, chores,etc... Isn't it terrific when you can find someone who shares the same beliefs as you. I think so.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 4:49 pm PST

Faithfulness within “The Lifestyle”

Quote From: faithful4ever

Faithfulness vs. The Lifestyle

 

It is obvious people in the lifestyle of swinging think they are having it all. They believe they are open minded and sexually positive because they have fun sex with people other than their spouse or partner. Sex is the intimate bonding between two people, and those in the lifestyle see it as recreation to participate in with others.

 

Some years back, a middle aged woman Realtor who recently married a popular Realtor in my area was canvassing my neighborhood. I had heard about their marriage through one of their advertisements and I told her how happy I was for them. As we talked, she stated that she and her husband had an awesome lifestyle, and I innocently said that my husband and I did also. She said, You do? When I did not respond with whatever she was looking for, she informed me that we were not on the same page. I realized that she was fishing for sex partners when I remembered the term lifestyle was used for swinging. Her name and picture is no longer part of his business so it looks like they divorced after a few short years.

 

Some people are so focused on sex it is like an addiction. Sex is important to a marriage, but a successful happy marriage is more than having sex. My husband and I are attractive 50 year olds and have been faithful to each other throughout our 28 year marriage and nearly 30 year relationship. Our marriage has been filled with great joy, but also the sadness and challenges that come with life. We took care of my mother for six months after she had a stroke while our children were still young. For the past year we have been weathering the storm of losing my husbands dear mother and are watching his father go deeper into the world of Alzheimers. A big part of our lives is making sure Dad is well taken care of and we have found the perfect place for him. He does not recognize us when we visit him but the visits are pleasant, and after driving 50 miles to his care facility a few times a month it becomes our time together. We are looking forward to a retirement filled with travel around the United States as my husbands parents did before Alzheimers ravaged Dads brain. What holds us together through the difficult times? It is our love and commitment to each other. Our faithfulness to each other comforts us through the difficult times and strengthens the passion in our marriage. There is no one on earth I would rather be with than my husband and we know that we are sexy- especially together. Our commitment, love and attraction for each other is very deep and we definitely have fun together. I think the sexiest thing about my husband is his sense of humor. My husband makes me feel complete and we are happy we belong only to each other. I thank God that all the romantic feelings I felt when I first met my husband still come rushing back after nearly 30 years. We have found that our place of refuge and comfort is with each other and we do not need or want anyone else in our relationship to keep us satisfied. I know I have the golden ticket and have tapped into the Mother Lode- my husband feels the same about me.

 

The swingers say their groups are safe, but there is still a risk of unwanted pregnancy since birth control does not always work. Also, what if the health certificate a new member presents is a fake?  We all have heard that condoms do not always work. STDs like Herpess, and AIDs can bring permanent physical consequences if just one person comes into the group and is not clean, even if they say they are. The Human Papaloma Virus is linked to numerous sex partners and can cause cervical cancer and oral cancer so there is a cancer risk linked with promiscuity.

 

If children are in the home, they will feel there is something that is just not right in the family since children have a tendency to compare their family to others, especially teenagers. My husband and I have two adult children that admire the dynamic of our relationship. My 21 year old son has watched how friends parents treat each other and even ignore each other. He told me that he hopes to have a marriage as good and close as his dad and I have and I pray that my children have at least what we have when they marry, if not better. My 26 year old daughter recently thanked me for how I answered her question about what "sexy" meant when she was child. I told her that a sexy woman was strong and had a great sense of humor. Unfortunately, her friends asked their mothers the same question and were told that being sexy was all about having a sexy attitude and dressing provocatively to entice men.

 

To those who believe in God and are considering the lifestyle, ask yourself what God would think before you go down that road. Christians believe that God is the designer of marriage and marriage is representative of our relationship to God. I personally think God is examining how we treat our marriage partners to see how close we try to live by His example of Love, faithfulness, unity and intimacy. Sex was created by God to be more than just sex and can be a spiritual experience. Married couples take vows to be faithful to each other, forsaking all others. Sexually bonding to someone other than the spouse breaks the marriage vow. A link that I will not name here was sited in a previous post. It is filled with scriptures being pulled out of context and has misinterpreted Gods own words. If you are a Christian and read it dont think God is agreeing with what the web sites spin about Christian sexuality is. They take scriptures that actually mean obvious condemnation and destruction of the people, then distort them to be something positive about certain sexual acts they themselves describe. Do your own prayerful research for the truth in the scriptures because spiritual things are spiritually discerned.

 

Sexual freedom with emotional monogamy in the lifestyle does not make sense to those of us in a monogamous relationship. The thought of our life partner telling us they are sexually excited by someone else is disgusting to us. We do not desire or even have time for social events to meet sexual partners and would not find it exciting to have our partner see us having sex with someone else. We who are faithful to our partners are not missing out on anything because we have everything we need. Sexually exclusive couples believe that the intimate sexual connection between two people committed only to each other is beautiful and romantic. Sex is a special and precious gift. I bet the people in "the lifestyle" would never leave the pink slip to their car lying around at one of their "parties" for just anyone to pick up, so it looks like their pink slips are treated with more value than their spouses and marriage licenses. The lifestyle sounds emotionally lonely. Those in the lifestyle of lustful licentiousness will never understand or experience being fulfilled with the sweetness and strength of sexual exclusiveness in a life long marriage. We are all born with free choice of how to live our lives, but we will ultimately pay the price for our actions.

Put your hands over your ears and close your eyes....I am in a marriage every bit as happy as yours and we occasionally swing!

I believe you are happy, I believe it just 'cause you said so and I don't have facts to the contrary. Notice that I did not say that you think you are happy just because I have a different approach to life than you. I am not threatened by your monogamous marriage, I wish that you were not threatened by my non-monogamous one.

Why do so many posters mention that the thought of their spouse being attracted or turned on by another as 'disgusting'. Of course they are turned on by another! Hopefully they do not act on it without the consent of their spouse.:)

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 9, 2008, 7:26 pm PST

message for christab

Quote From: christab

"Intimate bonding" and all that other stuff you are talking about is called "Making Love" ..... not sex.  Sex is just sex.

 

You know there is a difference, right?

 

In your last line, "We will ultimately pay the price for our actions."  Some people get fabulous mindblowing sex and relationships on levels YOU just can't understand. 

 

Its funny you say the same thing that the man who keeps wanting me to "participate" in the swinging world because "its just sex"! He has told me how many women he has had "sex" with over the years - almost boasting about it. And several even were "falling in love with him" even though he was married at the time. Such shallow thinking! It was like he was keeping "score"!!!! I actually have a very bad impression of the swinging world because of how he went about it with me....it was all about him and what he wanted...not what I wanted! Christab...when you are old and gray, will you still be swinging? Does not seem like a pretty picture to me...Cant imagine someone using me for "just sex". I have a lot more self esteem and confidence in myself to not have to satisfy someone elses "mindblowing" sex drive for their pleasure!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 10, 2008, 3:07 am PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: workingal

Its funny you say the same thing that the man who keeps wanting me to "participate" in the swinging world because "its just sex"! He has told me how many women he has had "sex" with over the years - almost boasting about it. And several even were "falling in love with him" even though he was married at the time. Such shallow thinking! It was like he was keeping "score"!!!! I actually have a very bad impression of the swinging world because of how he went about it with me....it was all about him and what he wanted...not what I wanted! Christab...when you are old and gray, will you still be swinging? Does not seem like a pretty picture to me...Cant imagine someone using me for "just sex". I have a lot more self esteem and confidence in myself to not have to satisfy someone elses "mindblowing" sex drive for their pleasure!

Workingal ...

 

You keep posting about a married man you were allowing to cheat on his wife ... He is not a swinger ... He is a controlling...(.it was all about him and what he wanted...not what I wanted! ) cheating ass.

 

Swingers are couples who are committed to each other, not cheating on their wives, they participate with their wives with another couple, not some part time girlfriend who cheats with a married man. We don't play with1/2 of a couple YOU do, we in the swing world just call both of you cheaters not swingers.

 

Group sex with a bunch of single people is NOT swinging it is group sex, it is different. If my wife and I play with a single, male or female, they are not a cheating spouse they are single.

 

As far as swinging when old and gray WE DO and have a lot of fun doing it. I am 56 my wife is 54 the couple we played with last weekend he is 58 and she is 51. My wife and I have been together since 1968, 40 years, we as a couple have been swinging with other couples for 20 years. My wife was not used by the other husband they enjoyed sex together, I did not use the other wife we enjoyed sex together. I love my wife and nobody uses her, swingers live by NO MEANS NO. If my wife did not want to have sex with someone all she has to say to me is NO and the whole evening stops, we pack up and split. Plain and simple, we leave or ask them to leave. I have never cheated on my wife, she has never cheated on me, WE swing we don't cheat. I know most of you on this board do not see the difference, we do and that is all that matters.

 

 

 
First | Prev | 127 | 128 | 129 | 130 | 131 | 132 | 133 | 134 | 135 | 136 | Next | Last