Message Boards

Topic : 01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Number of Replies: 1406
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Saturday, September 29, 2007, 09:23:47 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
How well do you think you know your neighbors, your friends and even your child's teacher? It is estimated that four to eight million people in North America are swinging in the suburbs -- mostly middle-class folks from all walks of life. Dr. Phil gives you a closer look at who these couples are who engage in sex with other twosomes. First up, Nita and Walter have been swinging for the last 12 years. They say they are happy in the lifestyle, so why does it cause tension in their relationship? Then, Brent says he has a strong yearning for he and his wife, Renee, to participate in a threesome. Renee says the idea disgusts her, but worries that if she refuses to join in, Brent will leave her. They fight constantly, often dragging their 17-year-old son into the middle of their chaos. Brent says he thinks about having threesomes every other day, but says that his desire is normal. What does Dr. Phil think? And, Dr. Phil viewers weigh in and share their thoughts about the swinging lifestyle. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:06 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

First  of all, I will start out by saying...I do not agree with swinging for my marriage. Not to say that I believe others should follow my opinion and live as I do, but I do not condone it.

The first married couple that appeared on the show who both agreed with swinging, basically contridicted everything they were saying.  The wife claimed that it helped their marriage, but then later stated that she felt inadequate in these situations. I think, no matter how many women and men profess otherwise, feel some sort of insufficiency when allowing other people to enjoy what once took vows to be theirs and only theirs.  I don't understand why couples move to next step of a relationship by getting married when these desires are involved.  Isn't the whole purpose of marriage to be committed to one person for the rest of your life? That's why you can only marry one person at a time.  Yes, maybe having sex doesn't exactly mean your committed to other people, but one of the committments you make in a maritial relationship is to say "I desire you, and only you, and because I do...I want to spend my life and everything I have to offer, with you."  Everything to offer, meaning the gift of sex.  The thing that separates a marriage from a dating relationship is that you have made permanant promise to give yourself to only that person.  If you don't, then what makes a marriage so much more fulfilling then just a dating basis? It doesn't.

We can argue up and down all day, that swinging is right, or swinging is wrong, but the one thing that doesn't lie, and doesn't have a thing to do with religion and moral values, is emotions.
The human emotions are uncontrollable and mold the characters we are.  Just like the wife in the first couple...She was ok with it, but she really wasn't. If swinging was helpful in marriages, and fulfilling to each partner, then why would she have to worry about her husband being overly plearsured by another woman. GUESS WHY? CAUSE IT'S YOUR HUSBAND AND IT'S YOUR DAMN JOB TO DO THAT, NOT SOMEONE ELSES!  I'm sure she doesn't get turned on by watching the man she loves enjoy another womans body.  While some people, like the husband in the second couple, who can watch that and personally enjoy it....The woman in the second couple the entire time, is probably thinking about all the things she feels that woman has to offer her husband, that she doesn't. 

And finally, not to pinpoint the first wife in everything.  The first husband clearly stated that he, after 6 years, did not want to just sit back and watch. That his wife always looked pleasured and fulfilled afterwards, and you know what? He wasn't the one doing it.  So probably do to jealousy. I don't know. Decided if you can't beat em, join em. But obviously it's hurtful to just sit back and see your spouse enjoy other people, and then only get their affection when no one else is giving it. It's sad...it really is.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:18 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: mamanursecd

Just because you don't think it was relevant does not mean no one else did. Dr Phil caters to a very broad audience and I guarantee you plenty of people enjoyed this show.  The wife in the second couple on the show truly needed Dr Phil's help, and I don't think there is anything petty about that.
I did not say that the problem was petty, I said that those kind of situations need to be taken up with a private counselor.  I think that there are many more issues that Dr. Phil could address that don't seem to be of a bizarre nature.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:19 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: rubicon05

Well said!

I second your quote - very very well said!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:22 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

For me if couples want to swing do what you got to do.  None of my business.  Not my choice but not for me to say not to.  I am not putting you all down just don't agree and I do  have a opinion.

 

I do believe that a lot of people are just justifying their life styling to make it seem it is OK bottom line.  If it is OK there wouldn't be as much effort being put into both agreeing to it, both not getting jealous or in the first couples case, the wife wouldn't be choosing the lesser so to speak of the women for husband to make she sure isn't jealous so that her husband wouldn't end up liking that woman more. 

 

Swinging is what it is.  A whole lot of people couples or groups or clubs or however it is done just having a whole lot of sex.  It is done as the posters have said to have fun, experiment and have sexual fantasies. 

Yes you can go out to dinner and do that stuff but from what the posters say,  it is what it is..... just a reason for a lot of sex.  

 

There seems to be a lot of effort being put into deciding on doing it,  when to,  where to and with whom and then how.  Way too much for me to think about.  I got married to NOT have to put that much effort into all that but to put that much effort into the man I MARRIED.  Key words....  EFFORT TO THE MAN I MARRIED.

 

I agree with one poster on why get married ?  I do believe the posters that say they do it and still love their spouses as I am no one to judge that.  I just believe that some not all, are fooling themselves into why they are in it. 

 

One couple who swung we know is now divorced.  She meet someone else.  The group we saw out at the bar, to be perfectly honest looked and acted like a bunch of immature sex-starved teenagers. 

One gal with one guy this night.  The same guy with another gal the next night.  Some  " playing" with each other out in the open. Wow, I was impressed.....   

 

As far as the first couple and the money they are spending to get membership why then is prostitution illegal ?  A bordello ?  Don't even say it is different.  It is not.  You are paying, OK not for the act itself but for a facility to do it in.  Sounds to me like someone is making a whole lot of money on a lot of sex starved people.  I personally would think that kind of money should go to something more important...  like a child's education.  ( just a side note... )  or maybe the kind of business I should get into...  lots of $$$$( kidding...) 

 

Do what you gotta do swingers just not for me. 

 

As for the couple whose husband wanted her to do a threesome,  the husband is a disgusting *&$#@.......  for making the wife do it, belittleing her, and wh------g her out.  Dump him now.... 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:23 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: tmd5711

 Ok  I get that all humans are not perfect and we are all sinners. But where in the Bible does it say that Adam and Eve went  in their home and spent the evening swinging with a couple named  Joseph and Mary.  I'm just asking?
Ok, well not everyone in America is a Christian, so you can't push christian beliefs on people like that.  When you make reference to that religion like that, your basically assuming that others should think like you. Well fact is, they don't. And they only use these comments to bash who you are and what you believe.  I am not saying that I disagree with you, I very much have a relationship with Christ, but in this debate, bringing up religion in this, is only gonna backfire in your face.  It looks judgemental, even if it's not meant to be.  People will interpret you wrong, and therefore you should just give an opinion without bringing God into, but can still speak from your moral beliefs. Just a thought.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
January 25, 2008, 10:24 pm PST

Really?

Quote From: kjowill

Rarely have I felt so compelled to respond to a talk show.  But today's topic just riled me within.  Come on folks, here we go, turning a blind eye, as if to say, immorality is okay as long as two adults consent. Good gracious and Holy Cannoli! I'm confounded and perplexed.  Ok, here's how I see it, I used to say, hey 'whatever floats your boat, " it's your business, I'm not here to judge. And yet, I ask you, isn't this part of the reason American is in such turmoil today? Our kids have run amuck. They have no fear, no consequence and no respect. Parents are to blame and adults need to take responsibility. I don't buy into it one bit and you won't catch me saying, "it's your business as long as it doesn't infringe on my rights and beliefs. We are copping out  and sending the wrong message.  What ever happened to teaching by example? Are examples of this lifestyle, the message we want to send our kids? 

 

We need to be careful about what we say is okay in the realm of acceptable behavior.  Attitudes which were showcased by your guests, are no better than the attitudes which perpetuate hatred, or racism, or injustice or oppression. This might be extreme thinking, but it seems your guests are suggesting if two consenting adults agree hatred and racism or oppression is okay then the behavior which arises out of such attitudes is acceptable?  Where, I ask you, do we draw the line?  Our excessiveness, lack of discipline and self-absorbed mentality is why America's families and the institution of marriage is sinking in the waves of a mighty storm. One which we have stirred. When will it end? 

America is in turmail and her children have run amuck because perfectly happily married consenting adults are having sex with other perfectly happily married consenting adults?  You make me laugh ;-)
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
sad
January 25, 2008, 10:30 pm PST

Help for Renee

Sex against your will is called rape.  I just saw this show tonight and while you said that you would get help for her husband, Renee also needs help.  Her face has such sadness and pain.  She was forced into sex with another man while her husband not only watched, but with his blessing.  Such a betrayal.  She should be able to expect him to love and protect her, but he failed.  She also needs counseling.  I am sure her husband does not see himself as an abuser, but that is exactly what he is.  I feel so bad for her. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:33 pm PST

you have a choice...

Quote From: eulas8

This is a first for me, but after seeing the show today I feel as if I needed to write.  My wife and I have been married 18 years. This is the third marriage for each of us.  After being married for about 8 years, the idea of swapping with a couple who were friends of ours came up.  My wife and I were both raised in the South under strict Baptist beliefs, so I guess the thought of us "doing something" was a little on the rebelious side.  I approached the husband of the couple we had thought about and he was interested.  After a few days he told me his wife was too.  Just try it for the fun of it and nothing pushy.  The first time was just filrty, nothing more.  The second time after a few drinks, we went "all the way".  I know this sounds like crap, but seeing my wife with another man, made me feel closer than I have ever been with her.  Most people can't understand or agree with this, but this is how I feel.  Well afterwards, my wife was ok with it, but in her heart didn't feel like it was right.  Maybe it isn't but to me it is like a addiction.  Due to us having sex with the other couple...a couple we had known for many years and were great friends with....the sex ruined our friendship.  Now we have not heard from them or seen them in years.  For that I am truely sorry.  My wife has never been with anyone else, but me, since that time.  The problem is now I can't stop.  I go to swinger web sites and talk to other people in the life style.  Like they said on the show, there are many people into this that you would never expect to be.  So now I meet couples and females who like me are addicted to the sex.  I believe in a big difference in having sex and making love.  So now I sneak around having sex with the ones I can.  Wish I had never started....sort of like a drug addiction.  So be ware of what you start.....

'You choose the behavior' 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
January 25, 2008, 10:34 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: littleskorps

My husband and I have been together for 8 years, married for 5 and in the lifestyle for 2.   We are a professional couple, have childen and live normal lives just like everyone else.

 Although we don't believe that the lifestyle is for everyone, or for every relationship we know that for now, this works great for us.  The key is complete and total honestly and commitment to one another.  Intimacy is what occurs between a husband and wife, the sex or "play" as we call it, that happens in the lifestlye with others is about sex and nothing more...

For us, the lifestyle has done nothing but enhance our sex life, as well as our communication and trust in one another.  I know that my husband is coming home with me at the end of the night, as well as he knows that I will be coming home with him too, then we get to enjoy the sexually charged energy we have created with one another. 

 

 

 

You said precisely how I feel about this topic.

 

While I felt horrible for the second lady of the couples on the show, because her response truly was that of a rape victim, the key is what you say here.  It's about communication and trust.  If one person is not comfortable you *have* to stop or the trust is broken.

 

I'm 42 and I'm a little different from many of the lifestyle posters here in that I'm not in a marriage, long term or otherwise.  I will never be married again.  I've always been a sexually open, and sexually demanding in terms of desire, need, regularity, type person but have never been comfortable enough in a relationship to even breathe my curiosity about the "lifestyle" experience to my partner. 

 

I met my boyfriend early May of 2007.  During the normal course of getting to know each other I asked him if he'd been involved in any threesomes or othersomes.  He told me that he wanted to talk to me about that in person, as he was out of town on business, and not over the phone and I said, "great!"  We did discuss his experience, in detail.  Incidentally, though the sparks were there from the moment our eyes met we waited two months for sex and stuck to getting to know each other as people first.  My choice and he was fine with it and completely respected my decision to wait.  Some might think two months is nothing but, for me, and I'm sure him, it was a long time.

 

I had been in a teenage encounter with another teenage woman and I'd been in a poor excuse for a threesome with two men in my early 20s.  Neither were bad experiences, per se, just inexperience and not knowing what to do or not knowing my body well enough that I didn't think they were a big deal.  Just an experience that I could care less whether or not I experienced them again.

 

Enter the boyfriend.  Communication is great.  Trust is great.  He had tried the lifestyle on a couple of occasions within the last couple of years, swung partners once, but he stressed the communication and trust as well as being with the right, like minded, person, were a must.  We talked, and talked and talked about the possibility, not 24/7 as some would think, but we communicated all of the different possibilities and what we were each curious about; what we were each comfortable trying.  He also said that it's important to have a safe word that tells each other that you don't want to continue and there are no hard feelings if you use it.  No jealousy.  No making the person who uses the word feel bad.  You respect the word.  The situation isn't right so you just stop.

 

We talked about attending a Lifestyle party where two drinks are the limit and there are no drugs allowed, very tight restrictions to be allowed in including a 'first timer' discussion which you had to participate in.  I liked that I had choices, that women held the power in this group, and that my feelings would be respected regardless of what took place.  I was definitely the lead in terms of bringing the subject up.  My big concern, and I did ask him, was, 'is this necessary to your happiness' and he said, flat out, no.  He said, "It's an experience, something to talk about later as a couple, but not necessary to my happiness."  I believed him and I still do.

 

Interestingly enough I bonded immediately with his best friend.  I just adore him, who wouldn't, but I'm not in love with him.  I'm not overly attracted to him physically, although he's a very good looking and well built young man, not my type, but I enjoyed his personality and we just clicked, I trusted him, from the first time I was introduced to him.  So, one night, it just seemed natural to enjoy each other sexually, all three of us.  Both men focusing their attentions on me and I just LOVED it.  His best friend and I also had time afterward to communicate our mutual feeling of "just so you know it was nothing but sex."  Communication is *so* important in this kind of relationship.

 

Also, what may be surprising to other posters, is that I felt nothing for the best friend afterwards, other than genuine friendly affection, but the love I felt for my boyfriend deepened because of the level of trust involved.  It's hard to explain unless you've experienced it.  We've been together several times since that first encounter and it's just friendly, mutually consenting, sex and nothing more.  There is nothing weird between the three of us; none of us are jealous or uncomfortable about this *strange* relationship and there are times when nothing happens at all between us, just laughter and watching sports.  Maybe we are a freak of nature?  I don't know.  What I do know is that I am in love with my boyfriend and he is who I want to take me home each night.

 

Only four months into our relationship we tried a Lifestyle party with lots of communication beforehand.  Overall, it was a great experience and educational.  We haven't been back yet, though we talk about going, but we've had other spontaneous encounters with friends, primarily me with other women (my choice) and him watching or kissing her (my choice) but this is the most free I've felt expressing myself as a sexually vibrant woman in my life.  Only once I felt awkward all of a sudden and used our word and everything stopped right then and there.  He and I talked, when we were alone, about our feelings about the entire situation that night and agreed that it was uncomfortable all of a sudden and it was right to stop.

 

Communication and trust mean everything if you're going to choose to let someone else join your bed.

 

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
January 25, 2008, 10:37 pm PST

Definition

Quote From: raymom5

BECAUSE IT JUST AIN"T RIGHT!!!!

Not for you obviously, but for us it is.  Just wondering why, what we do with others make any difference to you?

 
First | Prev | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | Next | Last