Message Boards

Topic : 01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Number of Replies: 1406
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Saturday, September 29, 2007, 09:23:47 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
How well do you think you know your neighbors, your friends and even your child's teacher? It is estimated that four to eight million people in North America are swinging in the suburbs -- mostly middle-class folks from all walks of life. Dr. Phil gives you a closer look at who these couples are who engage in sex with other twosomes. First up, Nita and Walter have been swinging for the last 12 years. They say they are happy in the lifestyle, so why does it cause tension in their relationship? Then, Brent says he has a strong yearning for he and his wife, Renee, to participate in a threesome. Renee says the idea disgusts her, but worries that if she refuses to join in, Brent will leave her. They fight constantly, often dragging their 17-year-old son into the middle of their chaos. Brent says he thinks about having threesomes every other day, but says that his desire is normal. What does Dr. Phil think? And, Dr. Phil viewers weigh in and share their thoughts about the swinging lifestyle. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
naughty
January 24, 2008, 1:18 pm PST

Married and on the down low...

I am a single, bisexual man that has had sex with married men most of my life. There seems to be a new wave of men wanting to explore this type of secret fantasy life. We don't love or care about each other. We simply enjoy each others bodies and then we go home to our families and resume our lives. I know I have personally had the discussion about this being wrong with most of them, but they don't look at it as cheating because there are no emotions involved. We just meet up, have our little fun and go our separate ways until the next meeting. Woman certainly will never understand it, but believe me, there are a large number of married men that do this at parks, theaters, in cars and at their own homes. In prison or jail it's called, "gay for the stay". Then when they go home it's back to heterosexual relations. Just look around, keep your eyes open and you might just see someone you know having a little fun.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 1:40 pm PST

Why would people do it?

The number one rule of swinging is:   No one has to do anything they don't want to do.  

 

That said, I would like to share a couple of observations:

 

It takes a lot of trust in your partner to indulge in such pastimes.  I lived this lifestyle for many years.  These were not all total strangers.  They were my best friends.  The relationships also lasted years.  We just happened to get together for dinner, dessert and dessert instead of dinner, dessert and Trivial Pursuit.  You would never know by looking at us that we were "those" kind of people.

 

In my experience, the couples who got involved in the swinging lifestyle to "save a marriage" were the most likely to get divorced.  Why?  In my opinion it is because for some people, they have to put some "space" between themselves and their partner in order participate in a sexual way with another individual.   It is trading intimacy with your partner for passion with someone else.

 

Monogamy or an open marriage of any degree - marriage is a partnership deal.  Both partners have to be on the same page and in agreement with the rules on the playing field for the relationship to work.

 

Today I'm involved in a  second, long term relationship.  This one is monogamous and always has been. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 2:12 pm PST

Human Conditioning?

Quote From: vabtrfly

Without picking apart your post piece by piece.... (I just don't have that kind of time, sorry.)

 

In short... for people to engage in the swinging lifestyle, it is necessary to stretch boundaries beyond the norm of human conditioning. That's not a guess, it is fact. Often times, serious personality disorders and/or sexual addictions are at the forefront of such sexual behaviors. Once these addictions/disorders are fed, they become habit. Just like any other "junkie" people will do whatever is necessary to get their "fix." In the case I stated, it most definitely was the swinging that ended the marriage. Why? Because the mere act of swinging blurred the lines between acceptable vs. unacceptable behavior. It stretched an already overly thin boundary to it's breaking point to satisfy an addiction.

 

As far as the masturbation statement...

 

When one engages in sexual gratification with another person whom they do not have an emotional and/or strong physical connection, it quite simply is.... nothing more than the act of using someone elses body for the purposes of maturbation. There is no true intimacy with a stranger, therefore it becomes nothing short of a sexual release. Much like a teenage boy thumbing through a Playboy magazine and masturbating at the images he sees. It is a purely mechanical behavior with the end result being sexual gratification. The same may be said of people who prefer to watch their spouses engaging in sexual activities with someone else.

If you believe that you and your husband are using each other's bodies to maturbate with, then maybe you don't share as strong a bond with each other as you claim. If there is no difference in the type of sexual satisfaction/intimacy that you share with your spouse than with the strangers that you meet online or at some swingers club.... you have just proved my point.

 

Addressing the issue of children again... is your need for sexual pleasure so much more important than your children? Scenario: A friend of your child's stumbles upon information that you thought you covered up and hid behind locked doors. This friend decides to share said information say, at school for instance. Before you know it, your child is being ridiculed by schoolmates because of your choices. Is that fair??? I know,  right now you're thinking,"that would never happen!" Yes, it most certainly can. It most certainly has. This is probably the least of bad things that could happen.

 

Where my opinions are based from??? Well documented studies of sexual addiction, as well as the DSM (Diagnostics and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.) The terms: sexual promiscuity/deviancy (including by not limited to multiple partners, orgies, etc.) impulsivity, obsessed with fantasies of unlimited sexual performance, etc. start to jump right off the page at you. It's all there in black and white.

 

 

 

 

....for people to engage in the swinging lifestyle, it is necessary to stretch boundaries beyond the norm of human conditioning.' I am sorry but, human conditioning sounds like a form of mass brainwashing to me. I would like to think that I stretch those boundries everyday in numerous ways!

In the case I stated, it most definitely was the swinging that ended the marriage. Why? Because the mere act of swinging blurred the lines between acceptable vs. unacceptable behavior. Again, you miss the point....whether you are in a monogamous lifestyle or not , the married couple decides together what is acceptable or unacceptable. This marriage had problems going into swinging!

You are very insistent that this wife had/has a mental health disorder...why would the husband abandon his wife when she needed his support the most? I sincerely hope that your friend, his fiancee, realizes that this guy hits the road when the going gets tough!

It is ridiculous to suggest that those of us who choose to 'swing'  have mental or personality disorders! Don't forget...We are your banker, doctor, next door neighbor, friend, teacher, fireman, etc... Surely you are a better judge of character than to let yourself be taken in by a Swinger! 

Are you saying that masturbation is wrong also? What exactly is your definition of normal sex, married or otherwise? I would think that each couple has boundaries and limits. I have heard of those who do not consider oral sex as normal,I know many others who think that is a big part of sex. Doesn't each couple define their boundaries? And if a couple reach a mutual decision to swing isn't that their business?Btw...girls masturbate too! 

You are correct that the intimacy between the 2 couples is not the same as experienced by each individual couple .The intimacy exists in a swinging situation for the exact reason it exists for that couple when they are alone....they truly love,trust and accept each other. Again...we both want this and we only do this together. I believe that there is a very clear distinction between love and sex and I never confuse the two! I never said there was no difference in the type of sexual satisfaction/intimacy that you share with your spouse than with the strangers that you meet on line or at some swingers club....

Again...my children are adults and no longer live at home.Your scenario is not plausible. And...yes my sex life is very important. You're not suggesting that I refrain from sex by anyones definition because there are children who may snoop? Many responsible parents have photos, home videos and toys.If a child's' friend found those items that child could also be ridiculed..... I repeat, a child needs to be taught respect for his parents privacy.

My question stands about your opinions.... I am not a sex addict and I don't know anyone who is. I am not promiscuous ( I have had 5 sex partners in my 40 + years) or deviant . I am not sexually impulsive, I have never engaged in an orgy,and I am not obsessed with fantasies of unlimited sexual performance,etc...  Most of all, there is a whole lot of erroneous information in black and white! Yeah...even in medical books!

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 2:37 pm PST

Re. to Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: zimexlady

People who swing have ultra low self esteem and turn to activities that lower that esteem even more.

AMEN!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
January 24, 2008, 2:49 pm PST

good greif

Quote From: dreamspeaker

 

To MrTruelove

However people validate their sexual lusting its nothing more than creative self delusion at best. Most people were brought up to believe that sex is a gift to be shared between a husband and his wife. To share it with others devalues the act into something that has lost its beauty. It's no longer special.

"...keep thee only unto him/her"? There's a reason that line is in there.

I'm curious. Without being crude, can you tell me, do you, as the man, share yourself with other men? Or is it only other women? Does it bother you that he may please her more than you can? Do you ever fear that she may find herself yearning for him and not you? Is it possible that she may have these same fears about you? Are you sure?

I know of a couple who tried a threesome with a female friend. Later, because of the implied freedom , the husband enjoyed an oral sex act with another female in the kiddy's wading pool, unknown to his wife, while she entertained friends in the living room. When he was caught in the act her anger genuinely surprised him. Their marriage went downhill after that. Hearts were broken, trust was lost, the kids lost their father, the family unit disintegrated.

I can't say that this will happen to everyone who plays this game, (and it is a game) but the chance of keeping the trust alive in the marriage is not good. Once that line is crossed and either one has sex with someone else without the other partner's permission or knowledge, the marriage is over. And, that WILL happen sooner or later. The 'implied' sexual freedom is too hard to resist.

No matter how good you think your marriage bond is now, under the surface lies a subconscious fear that 'she' or 'he' will never be able to satisfy the other's sexual needs. This opens up another can of worms that you will never again be able to put the lid on . As they say, "curiosity killed the cat". And, anyone curious enough to want to play this game should first consider if its worth losing the ones you love.

There's also the dangers involved. What dangers you ask? It is well known that multiple partners increase a women's chances of getting cervical cancer. Also, there's the increased chances of STD's, not to mention the danger of 'romantic attachments' being formed which can lead to stalking or worse.

You may think your relationship is on solid ground, (and, it may be) but what about the possibility of emotional illnesses in the people you engage in this game with? Can you guarantee their mental stability? A lack of emotional/mental well-being can and will endanger you or/and your wife? (Heaven forbid anything should happen to the children!!!)

It has been estimated that 1 in 25 people is a sociopath/psychopath. These individuals have no conscience. They can blend into society and go unnoticed like a camelian. They will go to extreme lengths to get what they want, not caring who they hurt. That attractive blond, that muscular beefcake, both can make anyone lust after them. But, add mental illness and a fixation for the husband (or the wife) and you may wake one night to find muscle man looming over you as you sleep with malicious intent. Check out the info on this link to see if you may know a sociopathic person: http://www.takebackyourheart.com/

I believe poor Renee (THE FOCUS OF THIS SUBJECT) might be married to a sociopath/psychopath. Brent does not appear to feel the compassion necessary to insure a happy marriage and is only concerned for his own desires. Renee should seek self awareness to understand why she feels it necessary to forgo her own happiness for that of her selfish, self serving husband. Only then will she find the strength to stand up for herself.

This long palaver was not meant to change your behavior. I doubt anything anyone says can do that. Not until you find out for yourself the hard way will the 'game' lose it's appeal.

However, hopefully, there are others out there that may be thinking of playing this game without completely knowing the rules or considering the consequences. Perhaps now they will think twice before starting something that may ruin their lives. Be careful. Momentary pleasures may produce never ending nightmares.

God Bless you and Enlighten you to a better way of loving.

At first I thought this was funny.  I was going to ask if you hide under your bed when you hear the door bell . As I read I realized that you are serious. You posting is like one big collection of all the misinformation available about swinging! Thanks for the laugh!

 
User Mood
Embarrassed

Message Emote
embarrassed
January 24, 2008, 3:20 pm PST

confused

My husband talked me into swinging, it took him a year to make me agree.  I thought it was fun the first year but trying to have him stop now and he won't.  I have felt used and pimped out for the past two years now.  Our marriage was strong before swinging now we fight all the time about it.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
January 24, 2008, 3:33 pm PST

Not playing nice!

Quote From: vabtrfly

I disagree with human conditioning, it may stretch boundaries beyond the norm of your social or religious conditioning

 

Exactly where did I say social or religious conditioning? I said human.

 

As a sexual being and I thank God for that, he could have made us like animals , only sexual at certain times or seasons. That is part of being human.

 

Having an isatiable appetite for sexual gratification is an animalistic behavior. It brings one down to an animal like state. When I say insatiable, I mean quite frankly, that your sexual appetitte can not be satisfied by your spouse which is WHY you choose the lifestyle. And for the record, there are many species of animal that mate for life, so your comparison is rudimentary at best. There are however, species of monkey that engage in sexual behaviors for anything but, procreation. Hmm....

 

We do not swing with anyone who is stressed to be there, why would we? We are there to have fun and sex.

 

Of course not. You find like minded people who are also sexually insatiable and you feed off of each other's wants.

 

Most of our close friends, the kind of friends that would help you bury the body type, have started within the context of swinging. We can be more open and honest with them about all that happens in our lives than we can be with "vanilla" friends, they are a lot less judgmental.

 

So what you're saying is that swingers basically have no boundaries??? Isn't that what I said???

"Help you hide the body types" as opposed to doing the right thing? How could other swingers be judgmental? They are afterall, engaged in the same behaviors as you, correct???

 

 

Go to any "vanilla" social event and watch the reaction to a sexy lady entering the room, some folks will almost shun her, others will almost drool, neither would happen at a swingers event. She would be allowed to be sexy and who she is.

 

This is a highly unlikely scenario for many reasons. Swingers are not lacking in jealousy, envy, or haughtiness. "Vanilla" folks don't have a market on those emotions. I have interviewed hundreds of people in the lifestyle (for a college thesis on human sexuality) and from what I've been told there is an enormous amount of jealousy, pettiness, envy, and separatism based on outward appearances. I mean think about it... would anyones real sexual fantasy involve a rotund, unattractive woman? Or a short, balding, unattractive man? I doubt it based on my research. As a matter of fact, I found that most swingers are either.... middle aged and less than average in appearance or young and totally lacking in maturity and experience. They often times engage in sex with people who they see as below themselves (whether that be physically, intellectually, or fianancially.) This from the horses mouth.

 

 

Vanilla is a term in the swing world to describe non-swingers and I won't go into what "pistachio" means LOL

 

Don't you mean un-evolved? It seems to me that there is a fair amount of judgment from your side as well.

Now I understand...you have contributed to the erroneous information printed in black and white. I believe that your personal beliefs colored your perceptions during your 'interviews'. This is obvious by the way you argue with the positive personal experiences of swingers posted here.I could tell you how I feel about an event in my life only to have you tell me I am wrong!

This is where you screwed up big time....I mean think about it... would anyones real sexual fantasy involve a rotund, unattractive woman? Or a short, balding, unattractive man? I doubt it based on my research.

 You are 100% wrong!  There are many men who desire larger women. I think I have seen this on a Dr.Phil episode. I have seen many men on-line looking for Big Beautiful Women...so, yeah I believe there are real sexual fantasies involving them.

This whole post is offensive, idiotic and just plain mean spirited!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
January 24, 2008, 3:49 pm PST

On the down low= cheating

Quote From: elflauta

I am a single, bisexual man that has had sex with married men most of my life. There seems to be a new wave of men wanting to explore this type of secret fantasy life. We don't love or care about each other. We simply enjoy each others bodies and then we go home to our families and resume our lives. I know I have personally had the discussion about this being wrong with most of them, but they don't look at it as cheating because there are no emotions involved. We just meet up, have our little fun and go our separate ways until the next meeting. Woman certainly will never understand it, but believe me, there are a large number of married men that do this at parks, theaters, in cars and at their own homes. In prison or jail it's called, "gay for the stay". Then when they go home it's back to heterosexual relations. Just look around, keep your eyes open and you might just see someone you know having a little fun.

Your not helping.... 

 If your wife does not know, it is cheating. Your spouse is the person that you should share your life with, good and bad, honestly and truthfully. I am all for 'to each his own'  but I think when your married it should be 'to each couple their own'.You left her out of this decision that affects her too. re-think it, Buddy.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 3:58 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: trueroot

My husband talked me into swinging, it took him a year to make me agree.  I thought it was fun the first year but trying to have him stop now and he won't.  I have felt used and pimped out for the past two years now.  Our marriage was strong before swinging now we fight all the time about it.
I am sincerely sorry for you. He should never have 'talked you into anything' that you didn't really want to do.I am curios though, is he a very controlling person in other ways? If swinging were not a factor would the relationship be all that you want it to be? I do think that you should stop this right now. I wouldn't do it even one more time! You cannot control what he does...you don't have to do this just because he wants you to. It is your life and you have to be true to you.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
ecstatic
January 24, 2008, 4:18 pm PST

Yeah!

Quote From: cfnamier

You said human conditioning and I still disagree with that. Humans are not by nature monogamous that is why we make up social and/or religious contracts. If we were monogamous by nature those would not be needed.

 

As far as being insatiable, I do like to have at least one orgasm per day and sometimes two or three. I think that puts me in the highly sexed but not insatiable range.

 

As far as friends who would help me bury the body, some of them would even let me plant it on their property LOL

 

As far as what you learned about swinging through interviews for a paper, I have been in the swinging lifestyle with my wife for 20 years, and for 2 of those years owned a bar that was known as a "swingers bar"(couples only on Saturday night), so I think I will take my "hands on" knowledge over your interviews.

 

As far as we swing with people we see as below ourselves that is just wrong. We have partied with a wide variety of folks, up and down the scale. that is rarely even thought about. I am only interested in swinging with folks that desire to swing with us.

 

I am sure when the show airs (here it is at 3 pm Friday) Dr. Phil will bring out folks who have no business in the lifestyle we enjoy and I will watch it a say to myself  "he is an ass and wants to, she doesn't, so they should not do it" just like the rest of the viewers. Dr Phil is not going to show anything positive about swinging, but I still agree with about 75% of what he puts on.

 

Most people should not try swinging, it is dangerous. Most people should live their lives straight and clean and reverent, I do not mind being in the minority.

 

Well I am going to leave this board for a while, we have a date this Saturday night with another couple and I will assure you all we will have fun and sex.

 

Peace

 

 

You said it!

 
First | Prev | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | Next | Last