Message Boards

Topic : 01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Number of Replies: 1406
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Saturday, September 29, 2007, 09:23:47 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
How well do you think you know your neighbors, your friends and even your child's teacher? It is estimated that four to eight million people in North America are swinging in the suburbs -- mostly middle-class folks from all walks of life. Dr. Phil gives you a closer look at who these couples are who engage in sex with other twosomes. First up, Nita and Walter have been swinging for the last 12 years. They say they are happy in the lifestyle, so why does it cause tension in their relationship? Then, Brent says he has a strong yearning for he and his wife, Renee, to participate in a threesome. Renee says the idea disgusts her, but worries that if she refuses to join in, Brent will leave her. They fight constantly, often dragging their 17-year-old son into the middle of their chaos. Brent says he thinks about having threesomes every other day, but says that his desire is normal. What does Dr. Phil think? And, Dr. Phil viewers weigh in and share their thoughts about the swinging lifestyle. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 8:27 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: easrtern_nurse

First off ... we are very discrete because of people SUCH AS YOU!  What parent in their right mind would tell their middle school children about another adults sexual practices?? My children have met our friends because believe it or not we can act " normal" around other swingers in fact some of our swinger friends are couples with whom we go camping with, their children attend our children's birthday parties and vise versa.. really we can act " normal " from time to time. The same as non swinging families share camping trips, birthday parties etc with other non swingers. Just because we like to do something " different" in our sex lives when we are with other consenting adults doesn't mean we are sex crazed and unable to act in an appropriate fashion when in public. Being discrete also means that the only people who know our activities are other swingers and they are faced with the same discretion issues we are.. Really the only people who attend swingers parties are OTHER SWINGERS!!!!  Because my children are intelligent my husband and I encourage open communication so when questions arise in our home they are answered honestly.. When my child asked about a gay neighbor I simply said " People are free to love whomever they want, it is not for ANYONE to judge another on his or her choices!

Since your children are so intelligent...they must have an opinion of what goes on.....how old are they?  Do they hear things from other kids? 

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 8:31 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: julie1418

You missed the point. Some people would be VERY against sex in a public place. Using one of your own questions.....what if, unbeknown to you, your kids happen to be on the same mountain top and stumbled across you and your husband having sex. How would YOUR public sexcapade affect YOUR children if you were found out? Why is it okay for you to go outside the boundaries of what other people might consider appropriate or moral, and still keep your "perfect" crown perched on top of your head, but NOT for other people??
That's the thing......THE SEX IS WITH MY HUSBAND!!!!!! It isn't with someone who I met at a party....swingers.....IT IS WITH MY HUSBAND!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 8:49 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: profmaryann

So let's get this straight.

 

You "got married for the sex...couldn't think of anything else...", and that was the be-all and end-all?

 

No "This person is someone I LIKE." No "I can see US dealing with the inevitable pitfalls that come with raising children."  No consideration of life outside the budoir.

 

Pretty much, to re-phrase it, "I LUST after this person, so I want to get married."

 

And "everything else just fell into place...perfectly." --?

 

You do realize that your own actions were no more, no less driven by lust than those swingers of whom you are so extremely critical?

 

Prof

You are absolutely right!!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 8:55 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: seniordreamer

Hello everyone, I'm new here; and I haven't read all 1200 replies to this topic because I don't have time, so if I say something someone else said, just consider it my own two cents worth.  The Doctor Phil show from Friday, January 25th just reminded me that there is a great hysteria in this country about sex.  People in Europe go topless at public beaches and no one thinks anything of it.  But here, we have this terrible hysteria about IT; and I don't mean it's funny.  The people who are in the so-called Swinging Lifestyle are just acting out fantasies that everyone else just keeps in their head.  Our society promotes sex as an advertising tool; but also condemns those who try to enjoy it.  How many times have you seen a film about sexually promiscuous people in which they are portrayed as being happy and fulfilled?  Our society frowns on anyone finding sexual gratification in any way outside of the boundaries set by organized religion.  You're supposed to only do it with your husband or wife once a week in the missionary position, roll over and go to sleep.  No wonder there is a 50% failure rate in marriages!  We are smart people with good imaginations; but we are told to keep our ideas to ourself.  Why are we hiding from our sexual feelings?  And why can't we discuss these thoughts freely with the people we choose to share our lives with?  There are millions of married people who are hiding their sexual feelings from their mates.  How does this make marriage fulfilling?  Why get married in the first place if you cannot reveal yourself to your own husband or wife?  We are a frustrated society!  Believe it or not, I once met a man who said he only got married for sex!  He was afraid he would never have any sexual fulfillment without commiting himself to one woman.  But if you are a woman, how would you like to be that man's wife?  The only thing she had for him was her body!  Don't you want more intimacy than that with your mate?  And certainly it is true that Brent, the husband in the second couple on the show, was a very insensitive man.  But everyone who engages in sexual activity outside the normal limits of marriage is not necessarily a cold and nasty person.  And who are we to set limits for other married people anyway?  The first couple on the show did not seem to be so terribly dysfuntional.  Some people are not as insecure as others; and many of them are into the swinging lifestyle.  People who swing have made a clear separation between sex and love.  And why not?  Love IS much more than sex, isn't it?  A psychologist once told me that the number ONE reason for mental illness in this country is the idea that no one has the same thoughts as you do.  Believe me, this is not true!  Whatever you think about when you are sexually aroused has been thought of before by someone else.  You are not strange!  Relax and enjoy your life as much as you can.  Maybe you should get married, and maybe not; but if you DO, then marry someone who understands your deepest desires, and is okay with them!
You are so very insightful and so very right!  It pains me that people are afraid of their own sexuality.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 9:06 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: bam200038

Wow I am going to get blasted by all of you. Lets first off say that I was a JERK for putting Renee through all of that. Without Dr. Phils help and resources I would be still putting Renee through all the cruel and unsensitive bull crap that I put her through. Our relationship is never better now. I would be willing to go back on the show and let everyone know that this kind of thinking is wrong and will hurt a marriage and the one you love. I would like to say thank you to all of you that took my wifes side on the Message board, I know that she was hurting very much and all your thoughts have helped. Once again I was a insensitive, low life bastered for thinking this way. Again I would like to thank Dr. Phil and his cast and resources for helping us get through this.

 

Brent

It is quiet admirable of you to post on here and update everyone.  I am glad to know that things are better and I hope for both your sakes that they continue to improve.  I am curious though, are you still recieving help and how much of the problems you experienced as an individual had to do with swinging or was it other deep seeded problems?  Hope you don't mind me asking.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
flirtatious
January 27, 2008, 9:31 pm PST

Swingers and proud of it

I have only watched one Dr. Phil show, and it was on swinging this past week.  The reputation of Dr. Phil is of the best on entertainment TV and that he always researches his topics.  I was a little disapointed in the swinging episode as I feel that he was unprepared for the show.  The two sets of guests that he had, in my opinion, should not have been on the same show.

My Wife and I have been in the lifestyle for 2 years and have since become part owners of a club for couples in Calgary.  We would open the invitation for Dr. Phil to visit our club and see what really happens.  It is not a sex club, it is not "check your clothes at the door".  It is 100% respect for yourself and others, no exceptions.

From my market research and the habits of people that attend our club, I have determined that around 10% of the population are in need of a differnt way to express themselves, so for the vast majority, it is not for them and they could never understand it.  I also love clasic cars, and people that don't have the same passion can't understand the atraction or why I would spend the money I do...a agree, a far stretch for a metaphore, but still gives the general idea.

It started for us with my wife and I having serious issues sexually.  Meaning sex was not happening for close to 6 years.  We would be close maybe 1 or 2 times a month, and for me, that was not enough.  I love my wife deeply and worked for 6 years to try and fix things for us.  I thought I was seriously sick and read books and talked to people to find out if I was abnormal.  I have since found out I am not, but do have a sex drive that is greater then average.

My Wife and I have 3 parts to our relationship.  One is friends, and she is the best friend I have ever had or ever can imagine having.  Second is marriage and huband and wife.  We were both single parents, both had spouses cheat on us and leave us with the kids.  We now have another child together.  It was after the birth of our son that her sex drive went away.  The third part is lovers.  We have always said that as long as one of those is strong, we can work on the others when needed.  ANd for 10 years now it has worked famously.  Marriage is not easy, and anyone that says you are ment to be together has never had a stable long term amrraige.  it just isn't so.  it is the hardest thing I do and requires more time then anything else I do.  She is that important to meto give my entire life to my family and my best friend.  One day the kids will be gone, and we will only have each other....

Ok, back to swinging.  When we first met, our sex drive for 2 years was unreal.  Couldn't get enouugh.  And my wife alwaysliked to talked about or watch videos of other girls.  At the time, I just thought it was cool. 

After 6 years of our relationship as lovers being dead, she told me to go find what I needed and to be safe becasue she "was never going to have sex again."  The very next day on a business trip, I was aproached by a very sexy female to have a fun night with no strings.  I turned it down.  If I could not have sex with my wife, I did not want to have sex either.  So we talked and talked and talked, for months on how to fix this and be happy together.

I read, and can't rememebr where now, about homosexuality and bi-sexuality and how many people can and will supress these feelings because of society.  There was more to it, but I took that information to her and asked her about her fantasy's.  She admited to me that since she was a teenager, she has had sexual fantasies about girls.  She had surpressed them her entire life.  Once we started to talk about them, her sex drive came back.  Although, still only 1-2 times a month, but it was a willing 1-2 times a month which was 1000% better then doing for me.

We then explored the swinging lifestyle.  We met some couples but never did anything other then talk for 6 months until we knew what we wanted.  What we wanted, was what she wanted and she lead the way 100% with my encouragment and support.  We wanted Tracey to explore her bi- or homo sexuality.  I think there are many different opinons still on if they are both the same or choices, and I will touch back on that later.

We found a girl that we both found atractive, inteligent and desireable.  My wife then was able to explore her bi-sexuality.  I can tell you, that since that expereince 18 months ago, we are still at 1-2 times a month, rather now the oposite...only 1-2 days a month we are not intimate.  As soon as she was able to learn that what she was feeling was aceptable and not a freak of nature, she opened up and became more comfortable with who she is.  Once she acepted who she was, she was able to act on her desires.  She found out it is ok to like sex and to want it.  She was told her whole life that being gay is wrong and that girls should keep there sexuality to the themsleves.  Females can have the same desires as men, and htey do, just they are not allowed to talk about it in society.  Tracey does not consider herself Bi-sexual, but I disagree and that is a fun subject for us.  She agrees 100% that she needed to explore and still does need that female female interaction more then just as friends.

We have progeresss and moved to differnt fantasys and have since become active i t he lifestyle with couples with "full" swap.  This again was her move to meet with couples, and I support her 100%.  for about a year now, the exploreing for her has moved into what do WE want.  It is 100% for us and we never do anything we don't want to do and know the otehr will not as well.  We would never eventhink of asking the other to "take one for the team".

Now, some facts to know.  About 1 in 20 meetings result in play, and about one in 3 of those results in sex.  60% of the memebers of our club never swap, but like the enviroment becasue of the RESPECT that is shown and the saftey for the ladies.  We have not told anyone, because our children are 12, 11 & 7 and too young to understand if they were to hear something.

Now to touch back on someting from earlier.  In today's world, it is ok to be gay or lesbian, but being bi-sexual is still looked at as a sickness.  And I can tell you this from personal expereince.  Although I am not bi-sexual in the least, I do have many friends that are, as is my wife.  I can assure you that the descrimination that is out towards these people is as bad as it was to the homosexuals in the 70's and 80's.

So the swinging lifestyle gives people a place to be themselves with no one judgeing them....ever!  You can be safe and explore, and you can try new things.  Where would peopel go if it was not for swinging clubs.  In the 80's when Gay bars were becoming known, this same talk about imorality and desease of society was prevelent.  But today, it is main stream and accepted.  Today, if you say negitive words about homosexuals, you can and often are charged with hate crimes.  Yet, anyone can make a comment about degenerate swingers and "get away with it" for lack of a better term.  I appoligize, my PHd came from the bottem of a Froot Loops box.  :-)

We have talked many couples out of the lifestyle, becasue it simply is not for them.  Their marriage is not secure enough and they are truely not the 10% that it benifits.  When we see those people and meet them, we tell them.  We have had marriages fall apart before our eyes, and our inexpereince thought it was swinging, but the reality was shown to us later.  People who cheat will cheat whether they swing or not.  Marriages will fall apart if they are "normal" or swingers.  Swinging does not keep a marriage together.  I will say that again.  SWINGING WILL NOT KEEP A MARRIAGE TOGETHER.  it also will not break it up.  It will however, show the symptoms of a good or bad marriage and give both the oprotunity to show themselves.

Everyone has a differnt sexual fantasy.  everyone has a sexual fantasy.  Even Dr. Phil get's sexualy turned on by something.  Some peoples' are more tame, others more wild.  Dr. Phils fantasy, to some, will be sick and degenerate.  Our fatasy's to some, are very tame..or "vannilla".  A term used for non-swingers. 

So I would invite Dr. Phil to judge me.  Maybe not on TV where we can be seen because of our children as they are more important to us then life itself, but to still judge us on what we do.  I would love the oprotunity to have a conversation with an educated man on the subject and be challenged and be held to acount for our actions.  Please come and see what the club is and who we are.  Do some research and talk to peopel that are real swingers, not peopel that force their spouse into something they do not want to do.  respect of yourself and others is our only rule, and we have no doubts that Dr. Phil could follow those rules.

I look forward to the future of the lifestyle, and to watching it become more mainstream in society.  It already is sneaking into our TV shows, movies and pop culture.  It does remind me of homosexuality in the 80's.  In 20 years, the talks will be very diffent then today.

thank yo for your time,

Playfullcouple

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 9:51 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: momisme2

I would think that 99% of swingers would agree that it IS possible for a non-swinger to have a deep and committed relationship within the boundaries of marriage. But at the same time, the swinger community would also argue that these deep committed monogamous marriages are in the vast minority.

And on the opposite side, as you can read,  there are many monogomous couples who would argue that these deep commited swinging realtionships are in the minority. 

You dont seem to be saying anything different than your opposition.  Youre just saying it nicer.  LOL

AS swingers, we also see so many unhappy couples that are not swingers.

The absolute WORSE marriage of all our friends was a couple involved in this lifestyle.   "Unhappy couple" doesent do their relationship justice.  They ended in a nasty divorce.

When we go out partying with several swinger couples doing "vanilla" activities like dancing or bowling or dinner, we have a blast like we are in College again. We laugh, flirt, smile interact more intently with others and generally have a great time.

If youre implying that monogmous couples dont know how to have fun bowling, having a nice dinner, flirting with each other etc.,  I would say your view is skewed by a need to feel superior to what you call "vanilla" couples.

Obviously, the judgements and wrong assumptions run rampant on BOTH sides of this debate. 

"And on the opposite side, as you can read, there are many monogomous couples who would argue that these deep commited swinging realtionships are in the minority." momisme2

 

 

momisme2,

If you are saying that deep committed swinging relationships are in the minority of ALL married couples then yes, I would agree based on the fact that swingers themselves are in the minority. If you were saying that out of ALL true "swinger" relationships that those that are deep and committed relationships are in the minority I would STRONGLY disagree. I'd gladly hold 100 average true swinger couples up against 100 monogamous (and truthful) couples in a "happiness" contest any day of the week. I think the results would shock the average vanilla couple how high the "happiness" percentages would be among swingers and how deeply committed they are to each other as a couple. The only difference between a deeply in love and committed vanilla couple and a deeply committed swinger couple is that they don't limit their spouse’s sexual expression to the benefit and enjoyment of both of them.

 

I would also like to point out that many non-swingers tend to mischaracterize a desire of one spouse or another to "step out" of the relationship without the consent of the other and have sex with others as a "swinger" couple. This is just not the case. With TRUE swingers, it is 100% consensual and there is no one party being forced by another. BOTH are wanting, seeking, desiring the exploration together. To think otherwise would be similar to classifying all women that may have experimented a little with other women in college as lesbians. Classifying these types of relationships where one party seeks sexual gratification without the true consent of the other and the ensuing disaster that occurs as a "failed swinger marriage" is not even close to being accurate.

 

Swingers don't feel a need to feel superior to anyone. Honestly, we don't. That's why you don't see them lashing out with the same venom you see so quickly flowing from the religious right or from more conservative couples and laughably, even some singles on this forum. Many of us simply feel that we have found the secret to true trust and happiness with our spouses. If others don't want to know about that happiness or explore it, that's 1,000% fine with the swinging community. But don't expect the mass condemnation to cause swingers to live what some would call a more conventional lifestyle. We've been there and we like it much better where we are. If we ever tire of it, we'll give it up. But even if we do, we've already learned the secrets of a truly happy relationship are 1,000% trust and the ability to open our minds to the possibility of exploring anything that makes us happy as a couple.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 10:54 pm PST

I agree with you

Quote From: dreamspeaker

 

To MrTruelove

However people validate their sexual lusting its nothing more than creative self delusion at best. Most people were brought up to believe that sex is a gift to be shared between a husband and his wife. To share it with others devalues the act into something that has lost its beauty. It's no longer special.

"...keep thee only unto him/her"? There's a reason that line is in there.

I'm curious. Without being crude, can you tell me, do you, as the man, share yourself with other men? Or is it only other women? Does it bother you that he may please her more than you can? Do you ever fear that she may find herself yearning for him and not you? Is it possible that she may have these same fears about you? Are you sure?

I know of a couple who tried a threesome with a female friend. Later, because of the implied freedom , the husband enjoyed an oral sex act with another female in the kiddy's wading pool, unknown to his wife, while she entertained friends in the living room. When he was caught in the act her anger genuinely surprised him. Their marriage went downhill after that. Hearts were broken, trust was lost, the kids lost their father, the family unit disintegrated.

I can't say that this will happen to everyone who plays this game, (and it is a game) but the chance of keeping the trust alive in the marriage is not good. Once that line is crossed and either one has sex with someone else without the other partner's permission or knowledge, the marriage is over. And, that WILL happen sooner or later. The 'implied' sexual freedom is too hard to resist.

No matter how good you think your marriage bond is now, under the surface lies a subconscious fear that 'she' or 'he' will never be able to satisfy the other's sexual needs. This opens up another can of worms that you will never again be able to put the lid on . As they say, "curiosity killed the cat". And, anyone curious enough to want to play this game should first consider if its worth losing the ones you love.

There's also the dangers involved. What dangers you ask? It is well known that multiple partners increase a women's chances of getting cervical cancer. Also, there's the increased chances of STD's, not to mention the danger of 'romantic attachments' being formed which can lead to stalking or worse.

You may think your relationship is on solid ground, (and, it may be) but what about the possibility of emotional illnesses in the people you engage in this game with? Can you guarantee their mental stability? A lack of emotional/mental well-being can and will endanger you or/and your wife? (Heaven forbid anything should happen to the children!!!)

It has been estimated that 1 in 25 people is a sociopath/psychopath. These individuals have no conscience. They can blend into society and go unnoticed like a camelian. They will go to extreme lengths to get what they want, not caring who they hurt. That attractive blond, that muscular beefcake, both can make anyone lust after them. But, add mental illness and a fixation for the husband (or the wife) and you may wake one night to find muscle man looming over you as you sleep with malicious intent. Check out the info on this link to see if you may know a sociopathic person: http://www.takebackyourheart.com/

I believe poor Renee (THE FOCUS OF THIS SUBJECT) might be married to a sociopath/psychopath. Brent does not appear to feel the compassion necessary to insure a happy marriage and is only concerned for his own desires. Renee should seek self awareness to understand why she feels it necessary to forgo her own happiness for that of her selfish, self serving husband. Only then will she find the strength to stand up for herself.

This long palaver was not meant to change your behavior. I doubt anything anyone says can do that. Not until you find out for yourself the hard way will the 'game' lose it's appeal.

However, hopefully, there are others out there that may be thinking of playing this game without completely knowing the rules or considering the consequences. Perhaps now they will think twice before starting something that may ruin their lives. Be careful. Momentary pleasures may produce never ending nightmares.

God Bless you and Enlighten you to a better way of loving.

 You have made more sense than many I have read.  I made the mistake of writing a post calling the whole thing evil and they wouldnt  print mine.  A little to harsh i guess.  Yours was better.


 

Message Emote
blank
January 27, 2008, 11:12 pm PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: bearcourage

So, according to you, it is your business that I liked to be tied up, blind folded, and have anal intercourse with my husband while we watch a good porn?  Hmmmm....why is that?  Now as far as wearing a "Scarlet Letter" so to speak, maybe that isn't a bad idea....follow me on this one....atleast we would know the rapist, child molesters and murders of the world.  I will tell you straight out, I'm not ashamed of anything that I do.  And as for doing it and other people seeing it.....HELLO!....we are swingers!!!!  I, myself, am an exhibitionist so being watched it right up my alley!!!!

 

As for the bad things happening for a reason subject, you contridicted yourself on that one left and right.  I hate to hear people see that because I can't help but think of people who have lost children.  Can you honestly tell me that you believe that those people are being punished by your God or their God for something they have done?  I just cannot agree.  I do believe that all things happen for a reason, often times those reasons are very hard to see but that their is an entity higher than myself that knows farther ahead in the future than I so I must trust that that entity knows best.     I truly and honestly hope nothing horrible ever happens to you because you will tear yourself up trying to figure out what you did wrong to deserve it. 

yes, I was kidding you, I don't care what you do in your bedroom as long as it don't involve me in any way.  I do think it would be a good motto though, to live life as though everyone is watchin, but the bedroom  I would definitely want to be off limits.  I guess we differ in that area, I don't think I could feel comfortable with other people watchin. 

 

You know nothing about my god, that kinda thinking is not applicable to my beliefs.  Things happen because thats just how the cards fell.  All you can do, is try your best to play your cards wisely, and hope thats enough to carry ya through.  Sure, there will be bad beats, but as long as there's a chip and a chair, there's a chance.  ;)

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 28, 2008, 1:48 am PST

01/25 Secrets in the Suburbs

Quote From: raymom5

Since your children are so intelligent...they must have an opinion of what goes on.....how old are they?  Do they hear things from other kids? 

You ask everyone how old their children you'll notice pedophiles do the same thing.. That I refuse to answer as god only knows who watches the boards .. you can tell everyone and their dog about your kids and how they are etc etc.. I have no desire to. You are only looking to attack ...thump your bible and your morals someplace else. My children are intelligent but so are their parents and again I will say that because I am DISCRETE my kids don't know about MY SEX LIFE!
 
First | Prev | 101 | 102 | 103 | 104 | 105 | 106 | 107 | 108 | 109 | 110 | Next | Last