Message Boards

Topic : 10/11 Munchausen Mom

Number of Replies: 376
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 05, 2007, 11:28:17 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Dr. Phil takes a look at the unthinkable: making your own child sick to fulfill a disturbing need to get medicine, sympathy and attention. The idea might sound unimaginable, but for people with a psychological disorder called Munchausen by Proxy, it’s irresistible. First, see disturbing footage of parents caught on tape actually causing harm to their children. Then, Dr. Phil looks into the mind of one woman, Tracy, convicted of trying to harm her youngest daughter by constantly keeping her sick. Hear from Tracy's oldest daughter, Heather, who survived years of her mother’s abuse. She says her mom forced her into a wheelchair unnecessarily, took her to almost 400 medical visits, and caused her to spend over 100 days of her life in hospital beds -- needlessly. Most disturbing of all is the secret Heather revealed to police about what her mother buried in their back yard. When Dr. Phil makes a phone call to Tracy in prison, will she acknowledge the problem with her parenting? And could she be preparing to have another child? Hear Dr. Phil’s strong words for this Munchausen mom. Plus, how are Tracy’s children doing now that she is out of their lives? Note: Viewer discretion is advised. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 6:59 pm PDT

10/11 Munchausen Mom

 

 

 

  I Agree that this so called mother should be made to have a Hysterectomy. It is amazing that this woman could even get the chance to get pregnant again!
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
sad
October 29, 2007, 7:21 pm PDT

BPD and munchausen

I was just watching this show today here in Tasmania Australia.

I have a granddaughter who was harmed by her mother when she was 3 weeks old and she then came into our care.  My daughter has BPD or Borderline Personality Disorder, which I noticed someone else mentioned in this post.  It is insidious.  Like Munchausen their is very little can be done for BPD sufferers.

And they do suffer, they cannot form 'normal' relationships, it is always all about them.  To the point of neglect of anyone including their children, if their needs are not being met.

When oh when are the powers that be going to recognise Personality Disorders and the destruction they do to families. 

My other issue is this.

I am sure it is the same in USA, as here in Australia, our Welfare system is in crisis overload.

We have 3 categories in which children are placed in when reporting of abuse happens.

Cat 1 -3, with 3 being the least priority.

As the situation stands at present, they are only capable of looking at and dealing with CAT 1 priorities. High 2's a maybe, anything  else falls by the wayside.

So...... in cases like Munchhausens, and BPD or even just PD's where these parents  are extremely good at manipulation and belief of their own stories, what happens to these children.  Because I know in our case, that our daughter was and is extremely good at convincing others nothing is wrong and their is a valid reason for everything.  She too knows all the medical terminology.  She knew what she needed to do to convince the Department that she was capable of having her daughter back.

As in so many cases of BPD and other illnesses, anyone that speaks out or questions them, ends up being the enemy and convinces those who need to be convinced.  If people are not made more aware of these illnesses and the ability to manipulate and what to look out for these little children have little hope.

It has been 17 months since I have seen my granddaughter and I miss her so terribly.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
anxious
October 29, 2007, 8:15 pm PDT

Fear for neice and nephews

Watched this program today in Australia.  I have been praying for Dr Phil to do a story on this as it feels like such an impossible situation.  I have neice and nephews (all under 6) in full time care of their mother who I have suspected for a couple of years of this condition.  Her sister has also quietly raised the concern wtih me and when we attempted to sensitively raise the topic with others in the family there was a very emotional response of my mother in law who has been protecting and covering for her daughter for years. We sought the help of a cousellor and invited mother-in-law, sister and brother to attend.  Unfortunately my mother-in-law railroaded the whole session, sprouting some amazing lies and cover-ups and saying that there really is no concern.  We were very careful not to make any wrong accusations as counsellors are obligated to tell authorities of potential child abuse and we would not want to get this wrong.  We felt that we had brought up the topic within the family to the extent that we could but because we only have suspicions it is hard to get real evidence. 

 

Evidence we know of is: multple hospitalisations for broken bones and cuts requiring stitches, breathing difficulties where ambulance has been called a number of times, infections that required hospitalisation, etc.  She has also had a myriad of illness like diabetes, epilepsy, broken bones, cancer amongst others.  Most recently and most alarming is that one of the children has been diagnosed (according to mother) with scizophrenia, conduct disorder and ODD.  It is at the point now that I do not believe one thing she tells me yet I just nod and show mild concern anyway.

 

It feels like the whole family enables this condition no matter how bizarre it gets.

 

I have had a discussion with their father who admits that he is concerned.  I feel it is his responsibility to do something about it but the culture of this large family is one of 'keeping the family secrets at all costs.'  I feel I have done everything I can without reporting to the authorities and I suspect if I did the family would keep quiet for fear of losing the children.  My bringing up the topic has resulted in me and my family being shunned by the rest of the family and has been a great cost already, especially for my children effectively losing their grandmother.

 

It seems impossible!  Would appreciate any advice or encouragement.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 8:21 pm PDT

MSBP VICTIM

 The diagnosis of this is very serious illness [that is also criminal in nature] is sometimes fraudulently used by government paid professionals with malfarious intent. This is what has happened to me; with disasterous results for all. I'm sure there are others. It would be good to hear from you. Anthony
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 8:24 pm PDT

10/11 Munchausen Mom

Although I am not a psychologist, and have only taken a few psychology classes in hig school and in college, I couldn't help but notice that the people described on the show seem very paranoid. This led me to think that perhaps Munchausens by Proxy could possibly be related to paranoid schizophrenia. The sufferers don't believe what they are being showed because they believe that everyone is setting them out or out to get them. The doctors didn't do the proper job or complete the job, therefore they have to "help" their children themselves. All of these thoughts seem to relate to a delusion and paranoia. Just a thought that I had.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 8:34 pm PDT

Survivor!!!

I am an Australian 25 year old mom to one 7 year old and I am a survivor of Munchausens Sydrome but was never called this until much later.

 

My mom was diagnosed Manic Depressive Schitzophrenic and so many other things as her symptoms are incredible severe. I was 'sick' before even being born and was tested constantly for everything, then once born I was medicated constantly with so many medications that I cannot even begin to explain it. Even my formula came on Prescription. I was poked and poked and poked and always diagnosed with this and that and my father was always denied any access to me cos I was 'too sick' I was 5 when I was first started on antidepressants cos I 'slept to much' (prob because he was feeding me antishistimines strong enough to kill a rhino but anyhow) I was always super super skinny cos I am 'allergic' to wheat gluten lactose dust grass cats dogs any animals chlorine and so many more things including asthma preventitives (which convieniently kept me hooked up to oxygen all the time) and then once I was old enough (around 11) I was hospitalised for anorexia (because of my weight and because I didnt have my period yet) after that she started telling people I was mental and I would be admitted to the mental wards where she would do all the 'normal' munchausens crap like make sure I refused to eat drink or take medicine unless she was there. I would scream at the nurses in anger and the doctors because they would never ever listen when I told them I wasnt sick. I was hospitalised again by mom about 2 years ago who put in a 3 day order for me to be admitted to the mental ward again (which coincidentally requires no symptoms) after I had my son. She also told the Dr's that I would harm my son and had me isolated so that I couldnt see anyone but her. I have tried and tried to understand even went along with her lies telling me that I was sick just to try and get her to love me for me but I learned recently that she will never love me she is only ever interested in herself and getting what she needs from me.

 

It hurts every day but I have made the decision 6 months ago that I will no longer have any contact - not for me but for my son - I caught her beginning to do the same with him and it scared the life out of me. I just wish there was a treatment and that it wasnt such an underground diagnosis. I know that she cant help it.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 8:37 pm PDT

I tend to agree

Quote From: grlysogroovy

Although I am not a psychologist, and have only taken a few psychology classes in hig school and in college, I couldn't help but notice that the people described on the show seem very paranoid. This led me to think that perhaps Munchausens by Proxy could possibly be related to paranoid schizophrenia. The sufferers don't believe what they are being showed because they believe that everyone is setting them out or out to get them. The doctors didn't do the proper job or complete the job, therefore they have to "help" their children themselves. All of these thoughts seem to relate to a delusion and paranoia. Just a thought that I had.
I am not a psychologist either but I have wondered whether disassociative disorder is part of the package, where a parent abuses the child and then has no recollection of the event when switching from one altered state to another.
 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
sad
October 29, 2007, 8:52 pm PDT

Munchhausen Syndrom by Proxy

A few years ago I wrote to the Dr. Phil. show asking about Munchhausen syndrom. Since then I have watched the TV guide in hope that one day something would be on the show and today it was. Seeing what happened to those children makes my situation seem really unimportant but these things do have an ongoing if not everlasting effect. Some years ago I realised that my mother had possibly - to a small degree - suffered from Munchhausen and Munchhausen by proxy. How do I deal with this at age 61? Do I still try and put it in the background of life? Has anyone out there faced the same problem and successfully dealt with it? If so I would like to hear from you as here in Australia there seems to be very little known about Munchhausen.
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2007, 2:02 am PDT

be strong

Quote From: melyssa_sea

I am an Australian 25 year old mom to one 7 year old and I am a survivor of Munchausens Sydrome but was never called this until much later.

 

My mom was diagnosed Manic Depressive Schitzophrenic and so many other things as her symptoms are incredible severe. I was 'sick' before even being born and was tested constantly for everything, then once born I was medicated constantly with so many medications that I cannot even begin to explain it. Even my formula came on Prescription. I was poked and poked and poked and always diagnosed with this and that and my father was always denied any access to me cos I was 'too sick' I was 5 when I was first started on antidepressants cos I 'slept to much' (prob because he was feeding me antishistimines strong enough to kill a rhino but anyhow) I was always super super skinny cos I am 'allergic' to wheat gluten lactose dust grass cats dogs any animals chlorine and so many more things including asthma preventitives (which convieniently kept me hooked up to oxygen all the time) and then once I was old enough (around 11) I was hospitalised for anorexia (because of my weight and because I didnt have my period yet) after that she started telling people I was mental and I would be admitted to the mental wards where she would do all the 'normal' munchausens crap like make sure I refused to eat drink or take medicine unless she was there. I would scream at the nurses in anger and the doctors because they would never ever listen when I told them I wasnt sick. I was hospitalised again by mom about 2 years ago who put in a 3 day order for me to be admitted to the mental ward again (which coincidentally requires no symptoms) after I had my son. She also told the Dr's that I would harm my son and had me isolated so that I couldnt see anyone but her. I have tried and tried to understand even went along with her lies telling me that I was sick just to try and get her to love me for me but I learned recently that she will never love me she is only ever interested in herself and getting what she needs from me.

 

It hurts every day but I have made the decision 6 months ago that I will no longer have any contact - not for me but for my son - I caught her beginning to do the same with him and it scared the life out of me. I just wish there was a treatment and that it wasnt such an underground diagnosis. I know that she cant help it.

you really need to get as far away as possible from your mother as you can.  Here in Australia you have lots of support as a sole parent, go straight to your local court house tomorrow morning and file for sole custody of your son, even if no one is contesting this they will put this in place so that when the day comes when she tries to have him legally taken from you she will not be supported by legal aid and will have to pay through the nose to do so.  Also a legal will kit worth about $25 dollars from your local post office or good newsagent will make you a legal binding document that lets you state who your son will go to if you are ever "unable" to care for him, which she has shown she is willing to prove you unable at the drop of a hat to get to him.  I know what it is like to be struggling for money and being a single parent but it is not a lot if your child's life is at stake.  Good Luck and stay strong, my thoughts are with you, all the best, raven xx
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 30, 2007, 2:13 am PDT

blessed

Quote From: helpthekids

go to my diaries an read up alittle more on thi , we have the 2 little babies  and are adopting them and maybe the ew baby as well.

 

we are all deeply shocked, saddened and confused by this story.  I would just like to tell you that you have so many people wishing you well in caring for these children and that our thoughts and hearts go out to you.  It was horrible what these children have had to endure but they are blessed that you just happened to be married to the brother of these children, and that you and your husband are doing what you are.  I sincerely hope that you get custody of the child Tracy is now carrying.  My only worry now is not for the future of your children, but for what will happen when she gets deported, I shudder to think she will meet someone, get pregnant and start this nightmare all over again.  Wishing you and your family all the strength and best wishes, my heart goes out to you, including dear Heather. xxx raven

 
First | Prev | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | Next | Last