Message Boards

Topic : Arguing Over Money

Number of Replies: 569
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, July 07, 2005, 09:22:45 am
Author : dataimport
Is money the central argument in your home? How do you keep money from becoming a huge problem in your marriage? Tell your story.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 1, 2007, 9:27 am PDT

Arguing Over Money

Quote From: marsplasti

I really dont mind sharing conversation with you. My heart goes out to you and you sound very stressed. First off you need to take care of you first and then the kids and then the hubby.

That being said; I too was married (we are divorced now) to a controlling man who was financially abusive. Yes; that is the term. There were other kinds of abuse but since yours sounds financial we will speak about that for now. Okay; My ex had more children than me and I had one. It was never equal. His kids got more than me and mine. So we too kept everything separate. I never used the joint checking account nor did we ever  have anything jointly. I also felt like a second class citizen. Your husband sounds selfish and only interested in his way or you can take the highway type of personality. Do you think he has some sort of personality disorder?

My ex is narcisstic. That means they only care about themselves and their own families; not their wives nor anyone else for that matter. They come first, then their families. You are on the back burner all of the time and funny you use that expression. Second class citizen because that is what I used to tell my therapist. I always felt like a second class citizen.

Dont feel like a burden. You know marriage is 50/50. Does your husband know that?

Doesnt sound like he wants to change. Leopards dont change their spots; but I digress.

So what if you are a teacher making less money. You know at one point I refused to work because my ex put down my career choices and said because it was seasonal it didnt matter.

Dont listen to your husband. DO WHAT MAKES YOU HAPPY.So if a bill doesnt get paid let hubby pay it. So what is the worst that can happen?

Sounds like you would do so much better without this guy. Trust me I am not in favor of divorce. Actually I am a firm believer in marriage; really; but your guy sounds like he has sooooooo many issues and he isnt working on them.To even go out and buy a motorcycle behind your back was not right (was it behind your back) while you struggle with your children. Oh; By the way didnt he know you had children when you married? He cant say they are a financial burden. You had them when you married right? Your husband sounds immature, selfish, egotistical and controlling. Are you going to ride on this motorcylce? What would happen if you went out and bought a boat? Couples who are married make decisions together but you I am sure know all of that? What broke up your first marriage?

Oh; Why do you have to take a teachers job with less pay next year? Budget cuts?

If I were you and I am not I would quit all jobs and stay home and raise the kids and find something flexible to supplement income and tell hubby to f--- off and let him pay all of the bills. See what happens then? What would he do? Unless you have that in your prenup? Can you explain what is in the prenup. I am not too smart at those documents.

 Actually, he did not buy the motorcycle behind my back.  I was there.  I was supportive. I helped him look for a good deal.  We ride it together.  What bothered me is that he put it in his name and that is understandable but it made all the other financial stuff I'm suppressing bubble to the surface.   I checked the prenup last night and he will probably get the motorcycle if we divorced.....I would not want it anyway.  I guess the whole process of buying it with him and knowing it was only his made me again feel like a second class citizen.  Does that make sense?  Like I'm only a guest on the bike?  But, I feel if he was a fair husband, he would buy me something to make up for his purchase....like a new piano?  Something so I did not feel so second class in the relationship?

The prenup states that everything we owned separately before the marriage remains separate property.  It also states that anything we buy only in our name after the marriage will be separate property (so I was wrong about that one).  I'm sure I could fight this in court, because this is a joint property state but I'm not a fighter.  I could have also told him he cannot buy it without me on the title...but why fight him on it?  I like to ride it?  Anyway, I have no plans of getting a divorce at this point.

Actually, I have the opposite plan than you proposed.  My long term plan is that I'm looking for a better job to shut him up.  Then, when he retires from the military, I will earn more money than he does but I will not share it with him.    ha ha lol   He plans not to work when he retires.  The funny thing is, when my parents pass away, I stand to inherit lotsa money...and I'm not going to share one cent with him if we are still together.  ha ha lol  By the way, I'm not normally like that.  I'm a giver and I take care of people.

My short term plan is to make being a good mother my #1 priority until my kids are gone....one in 2 years and one in 5 years.  If I have to take a part time teaching job (yes, because of the budget cuts) I will.  He can pay the bills or divorce me...whatever.   Yes, I may be better off on my own because I won't have to deal with feeling like a second class citizen.

What I'm focusing on in counseling is to stay positive and focus on what makes me feel happy. I focus on my children and doing things with them.  I make friends that support me and don't bring me down.  Husband was single and on his own for 17 years...that will make any man self absorbed.  He has changed some...but not enough.  These things take time and I'm willing to give him some time to change.  He has trust issues but I have done nothing but been honest and trustworthy in terms of money I make and my job and child situation.

If you think what I'm dealing with now is bad, he was worse when we first got married.  Now, at least whenever there is a big purchase he buys it without complaining.  Can you believe that when we went on our honeymoon he expected me to pay 1/2 and when I did not he was angry and held it against me.?  He knows better than to do that now.  I have told him off quite a few times and I call him on his BS.  I tell him he should go find a sugar mama to support him because I can't support him on a teacher's salary.  Just so you know, I am strong and have not fear of being along if this does not work.  I speak the truth...say how I feel....and smile! 

Thanks so much for talking to me..the motorcycle made me feel down....I needed to talk and I needed to vent.  I'll write again soon.  Thanks again!





 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
July 1, 2007, 9:47 am PDT

Ah Ha!!! Hard Work For Sure!!!

Quote From: lauteaeng

 Actually, he did not buy the motorcycle behind my back.  I was there.  I was supportive. I helped him look for a good deal.  We ride it together.  What bothered me is that he put it in his name and that is understandable but it made all the other financial stuff I'm suppressing bubble to the surface.   I checked the prenup last night and he will probably get the motorcycle if we divorced.....I would not want it anyway.  I guess the whole process of buying it with him and knowing it was only his made me again feel like a second class citizen.  Does that make sense?  Like I'm only a guest on the bike?  But, I feel if he was a fair husband, he would buy me something to make up for his purchase....like a new piano?  Something so I did not feel so second class in the relationship?

The prenup states that everything we owned separately before the marriage remains separate property.  It also states that anything we buy only in our name after the marriage will be separate property (so I was wrong about that one).  I'm sure I could fight this in court, because this is a joint property state but I'm not a fighter.  I could have also told him he cannot buy it without me on the title...but why fight him on it?  I like to ride it?  Anyway, I have no plans of getting a divorce at this point.

Actually, I have the opposite plan than you proposed.  My long term plan is that I'm looking for a better job to shut him up.  Then, when he retires from the military, I will earn more money than he does but I will not share it with him.    ha ha lol   He plans not to work when he retires.  The funny thing is, when my parents pass away, I stand to inherit lotsa money...and I'm not going to share one cent with him if we are still together.  ha ha lol  By the way, I'm not normally like that.  I'm a giver and I take care of people.

My short term plan is to make being a good mother my #1 priority until my kids are gone....one in 2 years and one in 5 years.  If I have to take a part time teaching job (yes, because of the budget cuts) I will.  He can pay the bills or divorce me...whatever.   Yes, I may be better off on my own because I won't have to deal with feeling like a second class citizen.

What I'm focusing on in counseling is to stay positive and focus on what makes me feel happy. I focus on my children and doing things with them.  I make friends that support me and don't bring me down.  Husband was single and on his own for 17 years...that will make any man self absorbed.  He has changed some...but not enough.  These things take time and I'm willing to give him some time to change.  He has trust issues but I have done nothing but been honest and trustworthy in terms of money I make and my job and child situation.

If you think what I'm dealing with now is bad, he was worse when we first got married.  Now, at least whenever there is a big purchase he buys it without complaining.  Can you believe that when we went on our honeymoon he expected me to pay 1/2 and when I did not he was angry and held it against me.?  He knows better than to do that now.  I have told him off quite a few times and I call him on his BS.  I tell him he should go find a sugar mama to support him because I can't support him on a teacher's salary.  Just so you know, I am strong and have not fear of being along if this does not work.  I speak the truth...say how I feel....and smile! 

Thanks so much for talking to me..the motorcycle made me feel down....I needed to talk and I needed to vent.  I'll write again soon.  Thanks again!





Okay; You sound good and confident and strong so you will be okay. You just needed to vent.

So forget the motorcycle for now. Who cares? Let him have his name on it. You need to pick your battles in an extended family with money and all. Why cant you buy your own piano?

I wouldnt fall into the trap though of making more money for hubby. I would fall into the trap of making more money for me. How do you know when your parents will die? Are they old?

Cant rely on the future. We only have the present and the past is gone.

Here is what I think? If you do everything your husband says like if you get another job with more money because he wants you too then this will just go on and on and on. You also talk alot about divorce even though you dont want one. I would talk that out with the therapist.

Happy married couples rarely talk about divorce or do they?

Can you focus on being married and forget about the money part and just be happy the way he is? I dont know for I am just grasping at straws now. Can you tell me what you love about your husband? Something positive?

I understand if you just need to vent.

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 1, 2007, 10:16 am PDT

Arguing Over Money

Quote From: marsplasti

Okay; You sound good and confident and strong so you will be okay. You just needed to vent.

So forget the motorcycle for now. Who cares? Let him have his name on it. You need to pick your battles in an extended family with money and all. Why cant you buy your own piano?

I wouldnt fall into the trap though of making more money for hubby. I would fall into the trap of making more money for me. How do you know when your parents will die? Are they old?

Cant rely on the future. We only have the present and the past is gone.

Here is what I think? If you do everything your husband says like if you get another job with more money because he wants you too then this will just go on and on and on. You also talk alot about divorce even though you dont want one. I would talk that out with the therapist.

Happy married couples rarely talk about divorce or do they?

Can you focus on being married and forget about the money part and just be happy the way he is? I dont know for I am just grasping at straws now. Can you tell me what you love about your husband? Something positive?

I understand if you just need to vent.

 

 

I know....we tend to focus on the negatives when complaining and forget the positives.  It's the positives about him that help me not give up.  And, the reality is, the fact that he is financially secure it a positive because I'm a teacher and I want to be with a man who is stable and has made good investments and can take care of me if I ever got sick or something bad happened.  But, would he is the big question?  Would he take care of me or would he leave me if I was no longer able to work? The reason I wonder this is because I have had some health problems lately and you think about those things.

Another big positive is that he is kind to me and my children for the most part.  He loves our puppies and is kind to them.  He wants to have more puppies.  He speaks of our future together and wanted my parents to come visit when his parents were here so they could meet. He is good to my parents and even bought my father a father's day present.  He is considerate and tends to my emotional and physical needs.  He has adjusted to thinking as a "we" instead of an "I" in most matters except money, of course.   We have the common interests of music, exercise, travel, and reading.

We were brought up in similar bacrounds so we have that in common.  You are probably going to fall over when I tell you this but my husband is a chaplain (yes, a minister) in the military.  So, my friends expect more of him when it comes to fairness about money.  My hope is that when my children are gone he will stop being so controlling about money.   I told him I expect him to support me if we move for his career and if I can't get a job right away he will have to deal with it.

So, we have lotsa positives.  Sometimes, in moments of crisis, the negatives are all you can think about.  Anyway, thanks again for listening.  It's hard to give a balanced prespective online.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 3, 2007, 2:27 pm PDT

Prevention of an Argument

I want to post to get some opinions on what I should do to prevent arguments in our future relationship.  We have been dating for over a year now, and we are not quite paying bills together yet. We don't live together, and if I were to say something about how he spends his money he gets upset because its "his money." I would agree that if he were telling me how to spend my  money I would be upset also. I have although offered him ideas on how I save ( I feel I am pretty good when I need to be).

We do talk alot about our dreams, ambitions, goals, such as buying a house next year.  He seems to have potential to be someone who can do the right thing with his money, but for now he struggles with spending on un-necessary items (im guilty sometimes too). He does admit he knows he has this problem and says he wants to fix it, but he never seems to do anything about it. 

After being with him I see where he gets his "problem" from.  His mom seems to get him out of money ruts all the time. So I don't think he understands that in real life, no one can help him like that.

For now I say who cares, there are other things to worry about, enjoy what you got now.

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
July 5, 2007, 2:53 am PDT

please dont laugh

hi im kim

my husband and i have been married for 2 yrs now and i have to say that money aint really that big a issue in owe house, we make sure that the bils are payed and what ever is left over is what we live on for the rest of the fortnight....

 

we have 2 children 2 and 3mouths, i must addmit thou that since having the children money is a bit harder to come by as i cant work and living of 1 wage is hard but i think that money is there to be spent and thats what i do wit it....

 

my huband and i always talk about everything and rarely fight... our fights are pathetic actually.

 

i spose that compared to some of the posts i have read up in here i am lucky????

 

i dont understand why some ppl fight over money?

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
July 5, 2007, 8:02 am PDT

Dont Know what to do...

My husband and I have been married since April... we never talked about money or anything like that before we got married... when we got married he didnt have a job and since then he has gotten a job but I still pay all the bills.... I am in the Army and I get paid extra for being marriend and he says that the extra pay is to pay for bills and after that my money is my money his is his but the bills are more than the extra pay so I dont have any money to spend on myself after I pay all the bills and buy groceries. But when he gets paid he doesnt pay a cent to the bills he just blows it on things he doesnt need when he has stuff he needs to spend it on like his horrible credit or his vehicle fines or his lack of vehicle insurance or even vehicle registration it drives me nuts and everytime I bring it up all he has to say is that his money is his mine is mine and that I shouldnt worry about what he does with his money... ugh!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 6, 2007, 8:12 am PDT

What is small and irritating before marriage becomes huge and

Quote From: jltaft

I want to post to get some opinions on what I should do to prevent arguments in our future relationship.  We have been dating for over a year now, and we are not quite paying bills together yet. We don't live together, and if I were to say something about how he spends his money he gets upset because its "his money." I would agree that if he were telling me how to spend my  money I would be upset also. I have although offered him ideas on how I save ( I feel I am pretty good when I need to be).

We do talk alot about our dreams, ambitions, goals, such as buying a house next year.  He seems to have potential to be someone who can do the right thing with his money, but for now he struggles with spending on un-necessary items (im guilty sometimes too). He does admit he knows he has this problem and says he wants to fix it, but he never seems to do anything about it. 

After being with him I see where he gets his "problem" from.  His mom seems to get him out of money ruts all the time. So I don't think he understands that in real life, no one can help him like that.

For now I say who cares, there are other things to worry about, enjoy what you got now.

intense after marriage.  Please, please, get all the money issues cleared up and come to an agreement (maybe even in writing) before you get married.  I can tell you from experience that things will change after you get married.  What if one of you , god forbid, loses their job or gets sick and can't work....will the other partner pick up the slack?   You never know what the other person is thinking.  My fiance said, let's have a joint account.  When we got married, he changed his mind because he realized how much more money he has than I do.   Selfish, I know.  Now, I have lost my job and my child support is cut in half.....and I have to depend on him to pick up the slack.  Will he?  I don't know yet.  So, take my advice and talk out every scenario now before you get married.  Things change after you get married.  Most people really let their hair down afterward and before everyone wants it to be so romantic and laa laa in love land...but that is not reality.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
hopeful
July 6, 2007, 11:33 am PDT

dont fight becasue we agree

my wife a I dont fight over money or should I say lack of money we agree that it is a problem but dont know how it fix it. we bouth work full time and have a 14 month old. how is in daycare 20 hrs  wks with is good, but it that i what is cousing our short fall in cash every month. My wife are talking about her quiting job and being home with the kid I know that would make her so very happing becasue my son was born she has not wanted to work, and I tryed to go back in the service but I was disquailfed from service. she is going to work tell we both have our cars payed off and then she wanted to medical bill from home. what this means for me it I need to get a job with good health benifets and about $20 hr I dont know were that may be. I have limited skills in an office but I do have a degree it is a Ast. I need some addvice so my wife dont have to work and we can still meet our bill if anyone has any ides let me know and I will greatful.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 6, 2007, 5:31 pm PDT

money

So here is my problem.  My boyfriend and I argue over whether we should have a financial plan.  I want one, and he doesn't.  He does not want a plan, and feels that it is too "restrictive."  I worry because he buys things, and then worries about paying for it after, whereas I save and then buy.  He owes some money, and doesn't seem too worried about when it will get paid.  We have separate accounts, but live together and have discussed marriage but I feel that this is something that should be talked about.  He refuses, and it always ends up in an argument. Advice?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 10, 2007, 8:22 am PDT

HELP

I am in a relationship now. We have been dating for over 2 years. I have two kids from a previous marriage. Me and my boyfriend live together. W ehave for over a year. We fight about money all the time. He says that since he makes a lot more money than I do, I should RESPECT him and tell him when I spend money. Now it is ok if I spend money here and there but if it is over $50 I should talk to him first. Now keep in mind that I make over 50,000 and he makes around 100,000. The only reason I am telling you this is because I work my butt off and make my own money, Why should I have to tell him when I spend money on me and the kids. I should not have to make a phone call to him everytime I spend money on my kids, or should I? We do have join accounts but he spends money like we have a endless pit of it but he says that is ok because he makes more and he can buy what he wants. Am I wrong for feeling this way? HELP!!!!!
 
First | Prev | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | Next | Last