Topic : 06/06 Suing for Love

Number of Replies: 692
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 12, 2007, 02:56:16 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 10/19/07) Have you ever been so devastated after a breakup that you wanted someone to literally pay for your broken heart? When Bonnie and her ex, Charles, broke up, she says he went to an unexpected low. He wrote and distributed The Bonnie Chronicles -- a diary that she says is all vicious lies. He claims she has AIDS, seasonal bipolar disorder and is promiscuous. She took him to court and won a monetary settlement, but he maintains that the book is truthful and says he's not paying her a dime! Bonnie says she's ready to move on, but is she really done with Charles? Then, Dawn unknowingly had an affair with a married man and was sued for her crime of passion. You won't believe who sued her, and what she has to pay. And, DrPhil.com viewers weigh in with their thoughts about suing over a lost love. Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.


User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:24 pm PDT

The Bonnie Chronicles

Quote From: confuzzledwife

This Bonnie is a nut- I don't believe her.. surprised Dr. Phil said "you don't seem the type to whore around".. Can Dr. Phil be that blind?  I could see right through her- it's always the ones that don't look the type ... you can see it in her eyes, she's nuts.. why did she quit her job as a teacher if she had nothing to hide?  So what if she had to be investigated- if she had nothing to hide, she should have just done what the school wanted, instead- she quit.. that shows me guilt.

Another thing, I think she's jealous over him getting back with his ex. I believe she swung that baseball bat around- I know people like this...  they look so innocent.. but they are master manipulators.. am I going to be sued now? heh

Yeah the guy's quirky.. but I believe him- he had every right to tape record her phone conversations.. if she had nothing to hide this wouldn't be a problem- she's a psycho.

Are you Charles wife?  This man is every woman's nightmare.  Relationships should alwys remain private, even when they end.  What good does it do to assassinate someone's character?  Makes Charles seem like a little kid on a play ground.  I was totally disgusted with him and what he did.  He had no right to do what he did.  Whatever happened in they're relationship had nothing to do with her family, friends or her work.  And he must have been nuts for saying she had Aids, he had to have known it was something that could be proven with simple blood tests, what a fool he has made himself look like.  This is the kind of guy that every woman should be wary of, remember his face ladies, if he comes on to you, run, run as fast as you can.  Jealousy can be a very sick and demented disease.  Wow can't believe what he did.
 

Message Emote
quiet
October 19, 2007, 2:35 pm PDT

Charly is TROUBLE

Ladies, If you see Charly coming, run as fast as you can!! He is incredibly immature, vengeful, sneaky, malicious,and downright Trouble. Who knows exactly what happened between him and his former girlfriend, but for him to "chronicle" it and add some very, very ugly, destructive lies, and then distribute it to family and co-workers, is beyond the pale. He deserved to lose the lawsuit and should be made to pay the $52,000. Can't the court order the $$ withheld from his pay and/or social security check?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:39 pm PDT

10/19 Suing for Love

Quote From: guisabien

I am very tired of women that sleep with married men and claim to have no responsibility in any aspect of their indiscretion.  Face it they are getting something out of it otherwise they would not do it.  They want what the wife has, they are jealous, they want no strings, they like having men that know how to treat a woman well, they are looking for financial security, or whatever.  They are not innocent, whether they know it in the beginning or not.  At some point they do know...how many of them stop?   They say they don't have anything to do with the relationship of the marriage, but they would be wrong.  A marriage provides a soft place to fall and when trouble strikes, that discomfort motivates many to solve their issues.  When someone else interferes with that process and provides a "soft place to fall" and some unrealistic fantasy, how can you reconcile?  Go for it, sue 'em.  I have heard so many women say that they prefer married men because it is so easy and no strings and the men are so doting....well, maybe this would make them think twice before they go for a married man.  The wives have really had no identity in this triangle until divorce...they become the hated "other woman" that doesn't deserve their husband.  Maybe laws like this will help the wives become a real entity and discourage mistresses from doing this.  Please remember that marriage is a legal contract and those that interfere with the intention of breaking that contract have culpability....  Anyone who is sued for this gets what they deserve, no exceptions. 
I posted earlier, and couldn't get what i wanted out the way i would have liked cause I was upset about the whole thing. I think you hit the mark. I agree totally!!!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:42 pm PDT

suing for love

Quote From: cathym1

Sue his first wife?  What the hell is wrong with you, Lady?  Since when isn't your husband responsible for his OWN actions?  He left you and I'm sorry but thats not HER fault.  She doesn't owe you anything, she has no loyalty to you...why should she be responsible?  Shes not the one who is committed to someone else!  Sure, she might have emailed your husband behind your back..but guess what...HE EMAILED HER BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Sueing the lover is crap.  I've been cheated on before.  Not once did I blame her!  She knew about me..she believed his lies that our relationship was banging on the rocks.  It doesnt' matter what she told him.  He was the one in the relationship, not her!!! 

 

I understand.  You don't really want to blame the responsible party...so you blame the other woman...who is most often referred to as a "Wh*re"  Shes not!  Your husband/boyfriend/S.O is!  Even if she repeatedly calls after he broke it off with her....guess what again, open your eyes!!! She wouldn't be calling him if he wasn't encouraging it in some way! 

It takes 2 and yes she should sue them both.  Maybe people will stop cheating and getting involved with married men.  Tell him after he gets a divorce you be with him, instead making it easier for him to leave by giving him a roof over his head for poor behavior.   Every married person I ever talk to especially men, say they are unhappy...Boo Who.. too bad open your walet and tell her to bring her purse.  Get some morals people ! 
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:44 pm PDT

10/19 Suing for Love

Quote From: debbgirl

Are you Charles wife?  This man is every woman's nightmare.  Relationships should alwys remain private, even when they end.  What good does it do to assassinate someone's character?  Makes Charles seem like a little kid on a play ground.  I was totally disgusted with him and what he did.  He had no right to do what he did.  Whatever happened in they're relationship had nothing to do with her family, friends or her work.  And he must have been nuts for saying she had Aids, he had to have known it was something that could be proven with simple blood tests, what a fool he has made himself look like.  This is the kind of guy that every woman should be wary of, remember his face ladies, if he comes on to you, run, run as fast as you can.  Jealousy can be a very sick and demented disease.  Wow can't believe what he did.

I wouldn't be suprised if charlies diary was completely correct about her. I know a few ladies who don't look manipulative and who look like proper ladies but during certain times in their life had plenty of "cheating" affairs. My own mother used to leave me at the house while she went out drinking with her boy friends and she seems a great deal like bonnie.  I would describe my mother is seasonal bipolar too (where she used to get depressed and get stir crazy over the winter and be almost un-bearable to live with).

 

I can imagine there is lots of bias in a personal diary in the document he wrote, but i do not doubt it was truthful.  I am NOT suprised a court judged against him for writing it too, if she is a great liar and the jury didn't even bother reading the document.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:45 pm PDT

she doesn't seem the type........

I was surprized that Dr. Phil said that................. she doesn't look like the type.........guess what?she looks just like the woman my husband had an affair with. This woman was co-worker of my husband's- not very attractive, glasses, mid-50's....... Turns out she is the office tramp. She has been having affairs while married and the mother of 3 children for over 25 years!!!! all of the men she had affairs with were married and she knew it. in fact, that was what made them attractive to her- in her sick mind she felt like she won them away from their wives!  This woman was an accountant type by day- yet she also was an alcoholic, would go out drinking with the guys only, would pursue her latest guy relentlessly, she would not give up until they gave in to her....she promised them everything.... in fact this nerdy looking older woman thought of herself as a femme fatale-would expose her breasts to men at work etc. And............. the sex she was into was the kinkiest kind- sado-masochism, bondage, exhibitionism.......she pursued these  nerdy middle aged men ,flattered them etc.

her husband is finally divorcing her.........she has been responsible for a number of marriages falling apart over the years....and guess what ?sh'e been seen out drinking with (you guessed it-another married co-worker).

So, Dr. Phil- you absolutely cannot judge a book by it's cover......

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:48 pm PDT

10/19 Suing for Love

Quote From: debbgirl

Are you Charles wife?  This man is every woman's nightmare.  Relationships should alwys remain private, even when they end.  What good does it do to assassinate someone's character?  Makes Charles seem like a little kid on a play ground.  I was totally disgusted with him and what he did.  He had no right to do what he did.  Whatever happened in they're relationship had nothing to do with her family, friends or her work.  And he must have been nuts for saying she had Aids, he had to have known it was something that could be proven with simple blood tests, what a fool he has made himself look like.  This is the kind of guy that every woman should be wary of, remember his face ladies, if he comes on to you, run, run as fast as you can.  Jealousy can be a very sick and demented disease.  Wow can't believe what he did.

It was not clear that he mass produced the document and sent it to everyone.  He may have sent it to her and the school when asked. I wish they had of went into a bit more detail about that on the show.  How many copies did he send it to. Who did he send it to.

 

as far as aids, I believe he said her boyfriend had aids and she has been "exposed" to HIV.  I don't agree with sending the note everywhere but if she was that disgusting of a person she deserves to be exposed. She also sent out those flyers too (which they even showed in the show). I doubt all those people are lieing although one never knows. I caught my X cheating and she lied right up unto the point I played the tapes of her lieing to all her friends and talking to her boyfriend on the phone about their afair. Some people lie lie and lie, and then lie some more. 

 

It would have been great had they have played the security camera feed of her threatening that lady with a bat. She probably still would have denied it.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:50 pm PDT

10/19 Suing For Love

Quote From: juliebgg

I read your story, and I am happy that you saved your marriage. There is something I was concerned about in your post.  Why did your husband believe the lies your "friend" told about you instead of believing you?? He should have come to you and told you what this "friend" told him, rather than just believe her lies. It sounds like both you and your husband now realize that, instead of confiding in the "friend" when things were troubled in your marriage, you should have gone to each other. The friend who was the outsider in all of this clearly took advantage of both of you for her own personal gain.  I wouldn't evn bother with someone like her.  She is manipulative, and not good friend material. 

 

Thank you for your response ... My husband did not speak with me or question me because he didnt want to know the truth. All of that was just an excuse for him to do whatever he wanted and think that he could get away with it. She did put us against each other and did use me to get to him and she used him to get to me. I was having feelings of suspicion with how they would talk on the phone when I was not there. I had phone records and asked him not to call her anymore, that we needed to work on our marriage and felt that she was just causing problems. He promised, but hid his calls. It all came to a head and it was a very hard time for me. They were caught sending messages, phone calls, etc even after he promised that.  When I caught him, he cried and truly expected me to kick his ass to the curb. Thankfully we had already started counseling for my children and family long before this, so we started dealing with it. I was afraid that if I contacted her fiance that she would re-direct her anger towards me and my husband. I did not say anything until my husband finally broke down and told me every single detail -- they had started the affair almost a year before I had any questions and that he felt trapped when I would go see her, eat lunch with her, etc. because she would hold that over his head. She could have told me at any time, but did not. She lied to him about being engaged, so I called and compared notes with her fiance who was an old friend of mine. He had wondered what  was going on and together we confronted her. My husband got a reality check about what she would say to her fiance about him and would go off. There were so many lies entangled around all three of us that it was hard to start all over again.

It has been since June of 2005 and every day we get stronger. I finally have a husband that I can talk to and knows who loves me with his every breath. He knows that he has had his one chance and that is it. We both are committed to our relationship and now that we talk and are truly each other's best friends, our marriage just works. We learn more about each other everyday. I have built up a lot of trust in him from him being accountable for where he is and what he is doing. I also supply that information whenever he questions because we do not have anything to hide. I did not have an affair, but the only thing that we have a a priority now is our relationship with each other and our kids.

I do not have much to do with the other woman. I had to forgive her because I try to be a religious person. I cannot be forgiven for anything that I have done if I am not able to forgive people for what they have done to me.

IT is truly not something that I would want to go through again, but it taught me so much about myself, my husband and my life. It's crazy, but we were headed on such a downward spiral that the only way we got out of it was this reality check. My husband has owned up to everything that he has done and knows that no amount of talking or apologizing would work. He has proven to me that he is sorry for what he put me and himself through. He has said that he would not disrespect me or himself ever again. 

 

Cassie

 

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:52 pm PDT

10/19 Suing for Love

Quote From: freelancemom72

If my husband had an affair I'd be too busy making HIS life miserable to worry about the other woman!!! 

 

Just my two cents.  : )

 

 

haha.. why is this ok to say yet when a man does it, it's horrid?

 

THis is like on Ophra today when the wife said she tried to knock out her husbands teeth after she caught him and the audience all cheered and clap for her. Are you KIDDING ME! Nothing gives a woman or man the right to strike you. Do you think if a man said he slapped his wife when she caught her the audience would cheer? No? Don't tell me it's because a man is bigger. THat is a cop out. Striking someone has little to do with size.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2007, 2:54 pm PDT

the bonnie chronicles

 Bonnie's x is arrogant beyond belief!  The sad point is that he believes his own "truths"!!  However he projected the emotional level of tantrum throwing 2 year old.  (harsh toilet training perhaps!) Bonnie should move on and realize that this could go on for years as he loves to play the victim/martyr game and she feeds him!  Bonnie move on and don't look back, and take this as a cheap lesson on how perhaps you escaped death!.
observer in Rockwood
 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next | Last