Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 Suing for Love

Number of Replies: 693
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 12, 2007, 02:56:16 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 10/19/07) Have you ever been so devastated after a breakup that you wanted someone to literally pay for your broken heart? When Bonnie and her ex, Charles, broke up, she says he went to an unexpected low. He wrote and distributed The Bonnie Chronicles -- a diary that she says is all vicious lies. He claims she has AIDS, seasonal bipolar disorder and is promiscuous. She took him to court and won a monetary settlement, but he maintains that the book is truthful and says he's not paying her a dime! Bonnie says she's ready to move on, but is she really done with Charles? Then, Dawn unknowingly had an affair with a married man and was sued for her crime of passion. You won't believe who sued her, and what she has to pay. And, DrPhil.com viewers weigh in with their thoughts about suing over a lost love. Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
June 6, 2008, 10:22 am PDT

06/06 Suing for Love

Quote From: cynfool

 I'm sorry, but it is ridiculous that there is no accountability or responsiblity for your actions anymore. Our "sue happy" society holds everybody accountable for bad decisions, but the one that made the bad decision. I only caught the last part of the show today, but I agree with the lady that was sued for loss of affection. She was not to blame. The husband was to blame for breaking his commitment in the relationship. He lied. He cheated. Good lord, if the wife wanted to sue someone she should have sued her gutless husband for divorce. These laws allow for someone else to be held responsible to the commitment of the relationship rather than the two people that entered into the commitment of the relationship. What is to keep this from becoming some new type of scam?
This "lady" broke a commitment, too. To her spouse. Seperated? That means still married, folks. They were  both seperated during their affair. And, both to blame. As far "alienation of affection" laws, I'm undecided.
 

Message Emote
blank
June 6, 2008, 11:02 am PDT

Take responsibility

Has this country just totally lost its mind?  Does anyone have to take responsibility for their own actions anymore?  Funny how the woman has to pay money but what about the husband cheating?  How can anyone justify blaming someone for "stealing" their husband?  If your husband is going to cheat he's going to find someone to cheat with.  Blame that idiot!  Sure your mad if the other person new he was married but if it isn't them then it's going to be someone else.  Wake up people, take a good hard look at yourself before you start pointing fingers at other people.  We've all done things in our lives that are small and big mistakes but you take the responsibility for it, not blame the rest of the world. 

What's to stop people from pulling scams using this law?  Anyone think of that?  I could tell my husband to go find some unsuspecting woman with a bit of money and on our way we would be.  Watch out that this doesn't  come back to bite you in rear!!!

Excuse me while I go spill some hot coffee on my lap and sue for millions. 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
June 6, 2008, 12:07 pm PDT

Sueing a Lost Love

I strongly believe when a man wastes years of a woman's life making her believe he loves only her and there is a future for them then starts cheating behind her back, sue him for whatever you can, just as if you were married to him.  Some relationships last longer than married ones so therefore deserve some sort of retrobution for all the time he took from her life.  Go get him - GOOD
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
June 6, 2008, 1:00 pm PDT

I just don't get it

I just don't understand how any court of law could find this woman at  fault.  She had no idea that he was still married...HE lied to HER so why should she have to pay for his cheating?  When she found out that he was still married, she wilingly  backed out so how could this mans wife sue??  If my husband cheated on me, I wouldn't sue the other woman...I'd go after who was really guilty...MY HUSBAND!!!  I swear, this country has really lost its mind.  We can sue for the most absurd things. 
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
confused
June 6, 2008, 1:03 pm PDT

Sueing for Love

The woman who filed a lawsuit against her husband's lover, sued the wrong person. She should have sued her husband. He's the one who entered into a contract with her and broke it, not the other woman.

 

David S.

Bklyn, NY

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 6, 2008, 1:08 pm PDT

The Redhead Husband stealer

I am a male, and referring to the second guest on the show, the gal with the red hair. I actually found it funny that she got sued and lost everything....and she is a total "sleaze" (the term some use to describe a promiscuous woman...such as she)....She should quit whining about how much of a victim SHE was and all SHE lost....she totally busted up a family and feels ZERO remorse for it...blames it all on him and his wife. Maybe if she stopped sleeping with everyone's husbands the karma police wouldnt always be coming to haul her homewrecking butt off to jail
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
June 6, 2008, 1:25 pm PDT

06/06 Suing for Love

Quote From: labella226

I strongly believe when a man wastes years of a woman's life making her believe he loves only her and there is a future for them then starts cheating behind her back, sue him for whatever you can, just as if you were married to him.  Some relationships last longer than married ones so therefore deserve some sort of retrobution for all the time he took from her life.  Go get him - GOOD
Women have sued. And won "palimony" settlements. I think it should work both ways. Someiimes, it's the woman at fault.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 6, 2008, 1:34 pm PDT

06/06 Suing for Love

I am bi-polar, but medicated and under control. I think this man is bi-polar and really needs meds. She should have left and never looked back.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
June 6, 2008, 1:48 pm PDT

what a dumb law!

     Alienation of Affection is a ridiculous, time consuming and money wasting law.  This law has expanded to seven states and I hope it does not continue to go on to further states.  This law is ridiculous because it is a law that I can not believe it is a law.  Take the first guest whose ex boyfriend was threatening her, instead of using Alienation of Affection law to sue the ex boyfriend, why not have court orders to make the ex boyfriend stay 1000 feet away from her?  Why not sue him for harassment?  Why not sue him for making threats?!  There are other alternatives to sue the ex boyfriend. 

The second show was about a woman who did not know she was seeing a married man even though the man claimed he was separated from his wife.  The wife sues this woman under the Alienation of Affection law claiming the woman had ruined their marriage and that is why they are going through a divorce.  I believe the Alienation of Affection law shouldn't have been use against the woman, it was the wife's husband fault.  So, blame the man, not the woman.  The woman did not know he was still married, why is she to blame? 

The law is time consuming as well.  Going to the court, hiring an attorney or a lawyer, going through legal papers, this is what i called wasting time.  Instead of doing that, why not enjoy life by putting the things into the past and moving forward.  What's happened, happened already.  Instead of wasting your money to get revenge by going to the courts, go take a vacation.  Live life happy.  Give up the grudge.

 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
frustrated
June 6, 2008, 1:49 pm PDT

Ignorant and Sexist Law - Needs to go!

Quote From: ramair

This "lady" broke a commitment, too. To her spouse. Seperated? That means still married, folks. They were  both seperated during their affair. And, both to blame. As far "alienation of affection" laws, I'm undecided.

I'm decided...It's an ignorant law, and needs to come off the books.  It's also a sexist law, most probably created by men to take all blame off their shoulders.  This law basically says that a person can't help themselves when they cheat.  They have absolutely no power over their emotions or actions.  Was this thing written during the Salem witch hunts, or what?  Why can't you sue the spouse instead of the other person involved. What if he or she didn't know the person was married? 

 

I've been in that situation.  In my mind, I was in a very committed, monogomous, long-term relationship with who I thought to be the love of my life.  When we met, I asked if he was in a committed relationship.  I never asked if he was married, because he wasn't wearing a ring.  He said, "no."  He lived in Washington D.C., which created a long distance relationship.  His career had him traveling everywhere.  At first we could only see eachother twice a month.  After four months, he arranged something at work, where he could come more often.  A year later, we were living together.  We lived together for several months.  Of course, he traveled, but the majority of the time he was with me.  Never in my wildest dreams would I have thought he was married.  Then, he asked me to marry him.  He began introducing me to his friends and family.  I think it was at this point that his family told him he had to be honest, or else they would say something.  His brother stood there and watched when Ben finally said, "I love you so much Olivia, but I can't marry you.  I can't marry you right now, because I'm already married.  I'm going to see a lawyer tomorrow morning.  I'm getting a divorce."  I just gave back the ring right there.  What was the point in going on.  My heart would never be the same.  I would never feel the same way about him.  I never spoke to him again.  He tried to get back into my life.  A year later, when he heard I was engaged to be married, he actually had a physical altercation with my now husband.  I was soooo embarrassed!  If his wife would have sued me, I probably would have shot him.  I would have truly lost it! 

 

If the state in question just has to keep their precious "alienation of affection" law, then it should just be for the people residing in that state.  How many people really know about this law?  I didn't know about this law.  Now that I know, I can honestly say I would never have need for it.  If my husband cheated on me, he broke HIS promise.  I would be more upset with HIM than the other woman.  If it wasn't her, I'm sure it would have been someone else. 

 

I know of women who focus on the other woman's actions.  To me, they're just making excuses for their husbands.  They don't want to believe their husand made a conscious decision to lie and cheat.  It's so much easier to blame the other woman.  I've actually heard one close friend call the other woman a WITCH.  No, she's not a witch, she's a human being, and even if she was the first one to make a move, he could have walked away.  People walk away every day. 

 

 

 
First | Prev | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | Next | Last