Message Boards

Topic : 06/02 Banned From the Wedding

Number of Replies: 2263
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 02, 2007, 11:50:57 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/08/07) A bride-to-be takes on her future mother-in-law in an ugly feud that has torn a family apart. The wedding day is fast approaching and the best man has resigned, the aunt has disowned the groom, and the wedding planner is on alert to call the police if the mother-in-law shows up -- which she’s threatened to do! Michelle says she cannot stand her future mother-in-law, Jane, whom she thinks has a sick and inappropriate relationship with her son, Jay. Jane thinks Michelle is a cold-hearted “you know what” who has stolen her only son. She says unless they hire a hit man, they can’t stop her from being at the wedding. Jay stands by his fiancée, which is why his whole family is saying they won’t attend the wedding. Has Michelle manipulated Jay? What happens when the mother of the bride and the soon-to-be mother-in-law come face to face for the first time in four months? Can Dr. Phil cut through the drama and heal this family feud? Tell us what you think.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 7:52 am PST

Banned from the wedding

Since this young lady likes computers and emails i'm sure she'll be tuning in to hear what people say and I'd like to give her some advice, my mother gave me when I started dating as a adult.

 

when you pick your future husband "WATCH HIM WITH MOTHER WATCH HOW HE TALKS AND TREATS HER, BECAUSE THIS IS HOW HE'LL TREAT YOU!!!! IF HE'S GENTLE AND LOVING AND KIND TO HIS MOTHER HE'LL BE WONDERFUL TO YOU FOREVER TOO!!!"

 

Now i'm going to get off the computer and call my wonderful Mother in Law and tell her how much I love her and again Thank her for the wonderful gift she gave me.................her son, my husband, the father of my children and my best friend.

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 7:55 am PST

Why can't this family get along

This family is way of line here she is banned from her son's wedding I don't understand it's almost Thanksgiving and Thanksgiving is a time to spend with your family I feel so so sorry for this family and this

mother-in-law is way off line she doesn't like her wife to be at all what's the matter with you I want to read my message really carefully and you at to be ashamed of your self and your famliy the holidays are coming up and you need to look at youself in the mirror and I mean take a good look one day your haterd toward

your your son and your family will cost you everything you have your family,home,and health STOP STOP STOP STOP this anger,hate excuses everthing toward your family right NOW!! and get along NOW!!          and GROW UP like an adult. I've been there done it. now it's your turn.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:00 am PST

11/08 Banned From the Wedding

Quote From: lorinnor

I have only one child, a son.  I would be horrified if he cut off communication with me.  He's my life.  The mother on today's show has EVERY right to feel the way she does. The son really shouldn't be so cold to his mother.

I'm not instigating or wanting to be disrespectful, but at what point does it start being HIS life and not yours?

 

Neither the bride nor the mother are much to speak of in this show. They're both selfish and bratty. The son needs to step up and start being the broker of peace in the family. The mother needs to step back and figure out WHY she's so angry that she's been calling the girl names.  The girl needs to loosen that butt of hers and realize that you don't have to CONTROL everything to be happy. In fact, it's better if you DON'T.

 

I'm a daughter in law to a woman I absolutely adore and I'd be devastated if she'd ever called me names like that. Mum in Law and I share a name too, so I guess that's something in our favor.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:04 am PST

11/08 Banned From the Wedding

Quote From: danceteacher

My mother in law picked out our wedding cake without my knowledge, planned the wedding with my husband without my knowledge, cooked and sent over food because I couldn't take care of her son like she could, gave my baby black coffee, rice and gravy, and god only knows what else, comes over when she wants, calls to check on the family all the time, and gets invited by my husband to everything we do!!!      Yet, I love her.  She gave me the most wonderful man in the world.  She picked out the cake and planned the wedding because I was too sick to do it.  She sent food because I couldn't cook, she treats my babies as her own ( look how good hers turned out to be-- I married him!!).  Comes over and checks to see if we need anything.

This did bother me at first, but she is not going to be here forever. 

Let them have their time,  you'll have plenty.  They raised the men YOU  love.  They made the man YOU love.  YOU picked him!!!  She must have done something right.  Believe me when you back off, so will she.   It's hard for them to let go and hard for you to learn to share.  But it'll get there.  Then you'll be on vacation and happy that MAWMAW is there so you and hubby can go off for a few hours.  It's worth it!!!!!!

Finally a sane person.  So many times these girls marry our sons and then all of a sudden the in-laws become the enemy.  In most cases we only want to be there to support our children.  Because we love our children we want them to be happy.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:06 am PST

11/08 Banned From the Wedding

Quote From: hotauntnc

im on with the bride. the same thing happened to me and everybody thought i was bananas. it was a situation where the mother thought bad of me but to all others she was normal. it was so confusing. and when i lashed back i was looked at as a trouble maker. we are not married yet but when we do, which is quickly approaching, i dont know if i want her to ruin MY day. because it is MY day.

you say:  'my day' ?

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:06 am PST

Thank God for great MILs!

Poor Michelle - she's got a hard life ahead of her with this MIL.

Makes me even more grateful to have a wonderful, caring, Christian MIL who I am proud to call "Mom".

Hope the joint counseling works...

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:10 am PST

Bride thats been there

I just had a small piece of advice for this young couple. I met my husband when i was 15 and his mom never really liked me, i was raised to take the high road and be respectful to adults... thats exactly what i did. No matter what she did or said i brushed it off, until 4 yrs later it was still happening, i became angry and began speaking the things i had been thinking for a very long time..I took it upon myself to tell my future mother-in-law exactly how her son and i felt about her!  Big mistake when you speak for your other half about their parents it is never a good thing because you become the horrible person who just wants to destroy the relationship. At some point you as the wife or husband have to step out of the equation and allow the parent and child speak for them selves. If your husband has a problem with something his mom is doing, allow him to be the one that lets her know...she is not going to be as defensive as if it were coming from you.  Trust me, once i started making my husband answer the phone when his mother called or returning her messages things were alot easier on me.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:11 am PST

Simple solution

There is a simple answer to the dilema of the relationship between those two women.

The mother must remember that she is her son's past and his wife will be his future.  One would hope he chose wisely, but in any case, the choice is his.  His mother must accept this fact.  I too have a daughter-in-law.  As moms we all think no one is quite good enough for our children.

 

The wife needs to accept that this woman is the mother of the man she is going to marry.  If he is good enough to become her husband, then the mother can't be all bad.  After all, she raised him.  Also any children of the isssue should not be denied the unconditional love and dotage that only a grandparent can give. 

 

So go to your corner and think about this.  Remember, you both love the same man.  Do what is going to make him feel good.  It must hurt him terribly to see the two most important women in his life behaving thus.  If you love him, why would you intentionally hurt him?

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:11 am PST

Topic : 11/08 Banned From the Wedding

Quote From: barefootartist

You know what?  Life is too short for all of this.  It sounds like the bride and groom wanted to plan their own wedding.  The most important thing is your son is happy, right?  Let it go before it's too late.
You know what? Life is too short for all of this.  But just for the record we only wanted to contribute money to help toward the wedding just like most grooms parents and to watch him take someones hand in marriage someone  that he loved and someone that would love him,  we don't have to love her but we wanted too.  We are not the ones that won't let it go, the ball is in their court and has been since the beginning. It is out of our hands whether our "supposed to be Daughter in law"  wants to come to us and make things right  or not, our door is open.  I am telling you there are some people who thrive on drama.  Your right  I hope  it all works out before it's too late too, because we have already lost 11 months of our grand-daughters life and our son's life over this, which she lived with us for the previous three years of her life when her father had her and I know this has been hard on her the most, and this not even my "daughter in laws child" and  I hate that she has been put in the middle of something she has absolutely nothing to do with. And we don't have any access to her to let her know that we still love her and miss her.  Our son has no balls when it comes to taking up for his blood family that has been there for him his entire life.  All we want is for him to be happy and if it means that we are no longer  in his life for this to happen I guess this is the way it has to be.  But our hearts are broken. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 8, 2007, 8:15 am PST

No Excuse

THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THIS on either party's part!  I can find few reasons why adults in these roles (In-law/parent/child) should have these problems.  I was taught as a child that you show respect REGARDLESS of what is done or said to you when it comes to your elders.  There are some things you JUST DON'T SAY!!!  If you are raised this way then when you become the parent you don't do it to the child!  This also carries over into other relationships like a marriage.  There are things you just don't say to another person regardless of what they say or do.

 

On behalf of the Bride's Mom and the Groom's Aunt - they should be the peace makers regardless and to the end and beyond! They certainly don't need to be showing up on national television voicing their opinion that doesn't belong.

 

I have a MIL and we get along very well.  We even lived together in our house for several months while she was having a home built.

 

The key to our relationship is that we respect each other.  She is my husband's mother and my children's grandmother.  It is because of her that I have the wonderful man that I am married to (so she can't be all bad anyway).  We all benefit from this relationship and would be lost without one of the elements.  I am the wife and mother and she respects that.  I have things I am good at and she respects that, gives me credit and stays out of my role.  She has talents that I don't have, she cares for my children well and does not permit things that I say no to, I have the utmost respect for her (in her presence and away from her) and I stay out of her role and allow her to be his Mom and their grandmother.

 

We laugh and say the bottom line is it could have been so much worse.  I look at those I dated prior to my husband and say a word of thanks and she looks at those he dated prior to me and does the same! :)

 

 
First | Prev | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next | Last