I'm not sure I'm using these boards correctly... they are a little different from other forums I've posted on in that I can't just start a thread on a new topic. I've posted 3 messages in the past here and never rec'd a single response on any of them, although they were 3 different topics. I'll try this again!
I really need help/advice.
We are animal lovers, please believe that. I am a happily-married SAHM w/3 school-aged children at home. We have a wonderful housecat, many fish, 2 birds (cockatiels), and a standard American Eskimo (dog). Our dog wasn't right from the time we got her 3 years ago as a little puppy. When I say "wasn't right", I mean - she is excessively nervous, throws up the instant she gets in a car, pees all over our house at every insecurity, fear, bit of anger, disappointment, etc... and once even bit my husband (broke skin) because she didn't want to do what he wanted her to do (go outside). She is USUALLY okay w/going out on the leash, but not always... and we can't pick up a pattern of when/how/why she sometimes just decides she's not going to. We can't take her anywhere - not the pet store, not the park, not on a visit to family or friend's houses... first because she'll throw up the minute we pull out of the driveway, second because she'll bark endlessly in a new situation, and third because she'll pee no matter where she is - supposedly it's a nervous reaction to any strong emotion (fear, excitement, etc...). Yes, we've been through crate-training - she understands that she's supposed to "go" outside. Yes, we've obedience-trained her. She obeys most commands, but has a mind of her own. We can't go anywhere more than 24 hours w/out putting her in a kennel because she'll pee everywhere and we can't take her anywhere with us.
And now we'd like to re-do our home (carpets, etc...) but can't bear the thought of her continual "issues" on new carpeting. I know it sounds awful, but we're at the end of our ropes (my husband and I). We've talked to the vet... the general consensus is that sure, we can put her on meds, etc... that MIGHT help, but the bottom line is, she's an Eskie and while Eskies tend to have these nervous problems, hers seem a little worse, considering how much we've worked w/her. Please, this is hard enough w/out the animal-lovers' criticism of how she's supposed to be a family member, etc... so this is not where I'm going here in the Dr.Phil message board.
The reason I came here is to seek advice or guidance as to how to explain this to our kids... who obviously know our frustration, but love our dog. We know a family that we aren't exactly close to (like, we wouldn't be visiting)... but they have a small farm-like home, a huge fenced-in area, they have 5 dogs already that roam in and out of their house, and she is a registered animal-rescue person (the mom). They have kids, and plenty of experience with dogs. They are great people - and I'm starting to think our dog might just be happier there... and maybe her issues will then tone down a bit... or maybe it won't bother them as much, IDK. But they've volunteered to take her (gosh, she's beautiful) if we decide we can't do it anymore.
It's just our 9-yr-old son, a self-chosen vegetarian, animal-lover, naturalist, etc... is insistent that he'll never get over it, never forgive us, etc... if we "get rid of" her. The youngest (6) we're confident will adapt although likely be upset at first... Our oldest often agrees that she wreaks havoc on our home more days than not... but our 9-yr-old thinks that we should just "deal with it" - she's ours. And God love him for that. So for the past 3 years that we've been tossing up the idea of letting her go somewhere she might be happier, we've never carried through due to our middle son's feelings.
I just feel like I can't do this anymore, and neither can my husband. It's so much stress on our home, and we've tried EVERYTHING - except medication, and I REALLY don't want to go that route. How can we help our son to understand what is happening and why we might do this?