Message Boards

Topic : 06/16 A Daughter in Danger?

Number of Replies: 454
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, November 08, 2007, 07:38:18 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/14/07) When Shawn’s daughter, Katherine, was only 16 years old, she made international headlines when she ran away to the Middle East to be with 20-year-old Abdullah, whom she met on MySpace -- a man she never met in person but was convinced she was in love with. The FBI intercepted her in Jordan and escorted her back to the United States. Unbeknownst to her family, Katherine secretly continued a relationship with Abdullah via the phone and the computer for two years. After turning 18, Katherine said goodbye to her family and left to be with Abdullah in the war-torn Gaza Strip. Katherine’s family is terrified that she’s never going to return. They think Abdullah is lying to Katherine and possibly even brainwashing her. They say when she calls, something doesn’t sound right. Is she afraid for her life, but unable to tell them? Is she being held against her will? Dr. Phil talks with Katherine via satellite from Palestine, and has some hard questions for Abdullah about his real intentions with Katherine. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 7:07 pm PST

What was she thinking?

Obviously this girl has not watched the news for the past 5 years. How many violations of female rights does someone have to witness to realize how the middle eastern men treat women. The fact that this boy is only 20 years old only solidifies the fact that it is ingrained so deeply, even the young are not immune to this archaic way of thinking. This is why western beliefs are severly critizied in the east. American women have battled these beliefs for decades.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 7:13 pm PST

dont forget the important point

Quote From: immalik05

when this girl was brought back why didn't her parents pay attention to her and what she was doing? why does it matter where the guy is from regardless it is wrong? i am from palestine originally but born in the us and i am from a very safe community. there are dangerous areas and safe ones just like any country in the world. it seems like it is so bad because he is palestinian and muslim. the parents need to focus on their daughter and opening the lines of communication. by the preview it seems like he is palestinian and muslim so he must be brainwashing her wish islam. but i am muslim and we do fall in love just like others. internet relationships are made everyday. obviously she saw something in him to go and see him. and if it doesn't work out she can just call the embassy and they'll pick her up and ship her back. what is he going to do to her? he  can't even get into this country without a visa and they don't give those out to young men anyway. so as a palestinian-american i wish they would focus on why she felt she had to be so secretive maybe its because her parents would have not accepted her relationship with a muslim man from palestine.

She was embarrased that she was being abused.

 

Lets remember that he was abusing her. That really is the bottom line here.

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 7:20 pm PST

let us not forget

Quote From: mactavish1

The young man Abdulah lit up like a Christmas tree when he saw his girlfriend in the final segment.  Truly a young love that was as real as Romeo's was for Juliet.  Dr. Phil threw him in front of the bus and acted like he'd done everyone a favor by embarrassing and humiliating the young man.  This kid was only 20 years old and had been involved with the girl for the past two years.  They'd been together in the best and worst of times and conditions.  How sad to end it this way and at the terrible expense of his feelings.  We are a biggoted nation and everyone should read the book Kite Runner to have a better understanding of how different it is in the Middle East but additionally how very much the same we really are no matter where with our needs, desires dreams and ambitions.  It all could have been handled a little more gently.  I'll bet she'll end up back with him.      

The bottom line here is that he was abusing her. I sure hope she doesnt go back to him, it is a possiblily though, isnt it?.

Lets hope she doesnt simply for her own safety. Abuse can never be tolerated.

 

I am sure he could use some help with his anger & insecurities but the damage is already done with Katherine.

 

Lets hope his next girlfiend isnt his next victim. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 7:35 pm PST

Mean to her

Quote From: stavalis

I watched this show yesterday and had no sympathy for Katherine whatsoever. Everyone painted Abdullah with the bad brush and it was sad to watch. Katherine went of her own free will, even after being turned back the first time. Abdullah didn't go to the US with guns blazing and steel her away, she went to be with him. When Katherine was trying to make up things he had done to her it was obvious she was lying. When she told Abdullah she was through with him and he walked off I thought the remark by Dr. Phil of that's mature or something of that nature was clearly not called for. Anyone who watched that and couldn't see that he loved her must be blind. He walked off due to emotions not maturity or bad manners. She stayed with him for all that time, refused to go home even after promising Dr. Phil she would and now she says he was mean to her. I don't buy that for one second. Then we have her loving family who couldn't even bother to pick her up at the airport, and the first person she called when no one was there to get her, Abdullah, the guy who was so mean to her. Katherine is one spoiled brat that needs to grow up and take responsibility for her own life. I watched in total disgust as the audience clapped when she told Abdullah they were through. You could see he was heartbroken. He called her names because he was hurting and wouldn't talk to him, most of us have done the same thing and I don't believe we would be called a terrorist. He said his parents treated her well and I don't doubt that for one second. Probably much better than the reception she recieved when she got home. Abdullah got the bad rap here, that's clear, and sad.

Katherine obviously liked this young man. but the big BUT... He was abusing her-- she has hopefully realized that no one can accept abuse. EVER

That really is the bottom line here. The relationship was abusive!!

 

It was unhealthy for both of them. Dr. Phil just doesnt accept abusers and I have to agree with him. He was tough but in the right. 

 

I did feel a tinge of sadness for abdullah because he does care for her but he doesnt have the skills to know how treat another human.  

 

Hope he can get some help for his anger & insecurities and have a healthy relationshiip some day.

But the damage has already been done to Katherine.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 8:56 pm PST

11/14 A Daughter in Danger?

I think Katherine is seriously confused and doesn't know what she wants. She obviously felt strong about wanting to leave everything she knows and all the comforts of home to meet a stranger overseas. Was she being adventurous/daring/rebellious/attention-seeking?

Whatever the reason, she seems to have fallen in love; then she accused Ab. of abuse. Why would she abandon her promise to Dr.Phil and return to Ab? She said she loved his parents and they treat her like a daughter...did she ever discuss his anger/abuse with them?

I think she found someone to pamper her and treat her different than some of the "ordinary boys" from back home. There she had a vacation, shopping, no one to really answer to, someone else to pay for her ticket and show her a great time.

Maybe she sounded weird over the phone because she was worried her family would lash out on her and she didn't know how to respond to their anger? I think her family had every right to feel the way they did, but ultimately I think they brainwashed her in to "oh my god, he's from a war zone area and he's not right for you". So what? Don't people from those areas fall in love? Are they all bad people with bad intentions? Give me a break

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 9:02 pm PST

11/14 A Daughter in Danger?

Quote From: lisa_burns

The bottom line here is that he was abusing her. I sure hope she doesnt go back to him, it is a possiblily though, isnt it?.

Lets hope she doesnt simply for her own safety. Abuse can never be tolerated.

 

I am sure he could use some help with his anger & insecurities but the damage is already done with Katherine.

 

Lets hope his next girlfiend isnt his next victim. 

That's true. Abdullah looked so happy to see Katherine, it was really beautiful to watch. I almost believed the things she said about him, but his eyes/smile/total concentration on her was so intense, I believe what he is saying .

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2007, 9:51 pm PST

11/14 A Daughter in Danger?

Quote From: sonia3

I think Katherine is seriously confused and doesn't know what she wants. She obviously felt strong about wanting to leave everything she knows and all the comforts of home to meet a stranger overseas. Was she being adventurous/daring/rebellious/attention-seeking?

Whatever the reason, she seems to have fallen in love; then she accused Ab. of abuse. Why would she abandon her promise to Dr.Phil and return to Ab? She said she loved his parents and they treat her like a daughter...did she ever discuss his anger/abuse with them?

I think she found someone to pamper her and treat her different than some of the "ordinary boys" from back home. There she had a vacation, shopping, no one to really answer to, someone else to pay for her ticket and show her a great time.

Maybe she sounded weird over the phone because she was worried her family would lash out on her and she didn't know how to respond to their anger? I think her family had every right to feel the way they did, but ultimately I think they brainwashed her in to "oh my god, he's from a war zone area and he's not right for you". So what? Don't people from those areas fall in love? Are they all bad people with bad intentions? Give me a break

i agree. The thing i didn't like was that they jumped to conclusions so fast and insulted online dating. I met my husband online 5 years ago, through a family friendly site, and i was responsible in doing so. When we first met face to face, i had my aunt with me. people, online dating is not bad, i'm not saying what Katherine did was responsible, but I just want to clear up that online dating can be good and safe. Katherine's mom and family made it sound as though Katherine did not know Abdullah, but when you talk with 2 years with someone, you USUALLY know them pretty well, not as much as you know someone in person, but its true. Their relationship looked very real, and i'm sure it was not for wrong intentions. The only problem was, like Dr Phil said, that there were probably cultural differences. In USA it is considered horrible to call someone a slut, whore or anything  else of that nature. Maybe where Abdullah is from, as he said in his video clip, its "normal". I dont think Abdullah's treatment to katherine was right, it was abusive, and becauseof this, Katherine made the right choice to put an end to this relationship.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2007, 9:30 pm PST

Actually You are a Very Disrespectful Person!

Quote From: shisha4

What you're saying is very ignorent, especially when I read "And besides if the Middle Easterners weren't so cruel to their women perhaps there wouldn't be a stigma" I realized so.  I am a Muslim American who has been all over the Middle East. I have never been treated badly by any Muslim man, and with complete kindness and respect from my husband. When I read people assuming that Middle Eastern guys and/or Muslim guys treat their women badly I know for a fact those people making those claims haven't travelled very much. On the news the worse kind of Arabs are shown. Uneducated, poor, and uncivilized people living in villages are being represented as the norm, those that take their poor circumstance out on their wife. But the truth is, that ISN'T the norm. Try travelling to Beirut, Cairo, Sharm el Sheikh, Alexandria, Amman, Dubai and see how women are treated. Women have freedoms that women anywhere else in the world would have. Also classifying all Muslims as the same is extremely bigotted. We are all people and individuals act as individuals. Would you want American men to be potrayed as all being poor, uneducated white trailor trash guys who beat thier wives? Sure they exist, but they are not the norm. Same with guys beating their wives in the Arab or Muslim world. In Islam a woman has the right to divorce her husband for any reason she sees. Women who live in cities in the Middle East often live in wealth and with a good education, most women in Lebanon for instance speak Arabic, French, and English! So to sum an entire group as all being the same is not only inaccurate and uneducated, it's ignorent.

 Shisha4: I have read many  of your posts and you really  have no respect for others!


You are very aloof, and actually  portraying inaccurate information for others on this board!
Those that have little or no experience with  the arab culture, and countries, you are a poor example!

I even reread some of your responses, I couldn't believe you actually posted such information.

You claim to be a muslim-american as you worded it, with such extensive experience, in the middle east,
then" WHY are you not living overseas if it is so safe and life is so great"??
You are giving a complete misrepresentation to others here, and actually you are the "ignorant one"!!

You put yourself so high above others and clain you are "moslem'??

Well a true moslem, following her Holy Qur'an, would be in a "hijab" (veil) or scarf  covering your hair,
not posting a  provacative looking picture, because only your husband, brothers, immediate family members can see you without the "hijab"!!

I personally have lived in  Egypt, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, and worked in others! I am fluent in Arabic also.

Your strong statements are inaccurate, you seem to put down the lower class arab people, and always stress the wealthy!!
Sharm el Sheikh is a very wealthy district known for heavy tourism , and male gigolos, circling trying to pick up any foreign women, preying especially on older women, hoping to catch a wealthy financially stable woman. Trying to get their freedom out, and gain status , green card, freedom to the USA!!
Egypt unfortunately with all the beuaty, is a very poor country, economy suffering greatly!
Most egyptian men have wives, and still are trying to marry an american, or European women!
Some of the British women, will actually agree to be a "co-wife", which is utterly ridiculous and demeaning to any woman that puts herself in that situation!'
The ones that have come to the states on visiting visas, trying to find american women to marry, leave their egyptian wife alone with their children, visit them every 2 yrs. for about 2 month period.
The egyptian women think they are working here, they have wife in the states, and are committing fraud!
Egypt is on the top list right now for illegal marriages in the states, deceptions.
Hunting women on the internet, or in person, while they have a wife sitting their in Egypt! Then they use the american womans credit, send money back home if they get a work permit& green card, of course the money sent back home is worth 5x as much when converted!
You say they are living clean heart in this country .........think again! Illegal activity& causing a lot of pain and heartache for both women, when discovered! This is something to be proud of, let me inform you, we don't allow multiple marriage in this country Shisha!!
Shame on you.......You are a Hypocrite!!
You call people "white trailor trash", you think domestic violence is only from poor areas, rural areas, uneducated, think again!!
Kuwait, Dubai, Saudi, being very wealthy, I have seen first hand women, abused physically, from the upper class, Literally stuck in that country, scared to leave because, husband will not allow the children to go!
Excuse me divorce is still difficult for the arab women, many are ordered by the court to go back to their husbands!! Most are scared to lose their children, they cannot travel without the husbands permission, you call that "freedom" for women, good equal treatment!!
You put others down and you are the insecure unhappy person, but easy to call everyone on this board ignorant, unless they agree with your expertise!
The Holy Qur'an allows  the moslem man to discipline the women if she does not obey or behave as he sees fit& correct! That is why you do not reside overseas, the authorities are not going to help you if you call them!"
You make fun and mock others on this board in regards to the film"NOT Without My Daughter", well I have news for you, that kind of activity is still going on in the middle east my dear!! It is not fantasy, or a joke, when you cannot get out of a country with your own children!
YOU NEED A REALITY CHECK!!
So before you call the next person "uneducated, inaccurate, ignorant, etc."
Take a look in the mirror! You are suffering low-self esteem& in a very unhappy marriage, because you are trying so hard to convince others of your great marriage, the best life overseas in the arab world, but you are here???
You are a very cold heart& unsympathetic to others, who are suffering at the hands of these predators
who are lying and using american women to gain financial ,&green card status ,in this country, anyway
they can, even to destroy others lives and families,being torn apart! Even tearing their own family apart overseas with these lies and deceptions!
Just remember to these women never give up ,their is help available and support!
"By God What Goes Around Comes Around!!"
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
surprised
November 29, 2007, 6:44 pm PST

11/14 A Daughter in Danger?

Why didn't Abdullah come to the US, if he claims to love Katherine, instead of expecting her to drop everything to visit a foreign country where she doesn't know anyone?   I agree with Dr Phil - Abdullah went about it the wrong way.   Somehow, I don't think Abdullah really loves Katherine if he calls her offensive names. [One brother-in-law called my sister a "b----" so she left the mongrel!]   A man shouldn't expect a woman he claims to love to run after him, when he won't run after her - regardless of race, religion, etc.   Katherine is too young to understand what real love is. She should return to her family and let Abdullah visit her and run after her for a change. He claims he has money, so he can afford it.   I hope Katherine does come home to her family. She doesn't deserve verbal abuse, especially from someone who claims he loves her and can't live without her.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
angry
November 30, 2007, 1:32 am PST

It Happens To Aussie Women Too

Quote From: lite_the_way


 Shisha4: I have read many  of your posts and you really  have no respect for others!


You are very aloof, and actually  portraying inaccurate information for others on this board!
Those that have little or no experience with  the arab culture, and countries, you are a poor example!

I even reread some of your responses, I couldn't believe you actually posted such information.

You claim to be a muslim-american as you worded it, with such extensive experience, in the middle east,
then" WHY are you not living overseas if it is so safe and life is so great"??
You are giving a complete misrepresentation to others here, and actually you are the "ignorant one"!!

You put yourself so high above others and clain you are "moslem'??

Well a true moslem, following her Holy Qur'an, would be in a "hijab" (veil) or scarf  covering your hair,
not posting a  provacative looking picture, because only your husband, brothers, immediate family members can see you without the "hijab"!!

I personally have lived in  Egypt, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, and worked in others! I am fluent in Arabic also.

Your strong statements are inaccurate, you seem to put down the lower class arab people, and always stress the wealthy!!
Sharm el Sheikh is a very wealthy district known for heavy tourism , and male gigolos, circling trying to pick up any foreign women, preying especially on older women, hoping to catch a wealthy financially stable woman. Trying to get their freedom out, and gain status , green card, freedom to the USA!!
Egypt unfortunately with all the beuaty, is a very poor country, economy suffering greatly!
Most egyptian men have wives, and still are trying to marry an american, or European women!
Some of the British women, will actually agree to be a "co-wife", which is utterly ridiculous and demeaning to any woman that puts herself in that situation!'
The ones that have come to the states on visiting visas, trying to find american women to marry, leave their egyptian wife alone with their children, visit them every 2 yrs. for about 2 month period.
The egyptian women think they are working here, they have wife in the states, and are committing fraud!
Egypt is on the top list right now for illegal marriages in the states, deceptions.
Hunting women on the internet, or in person, while they have a wife sitting their in Egypt! Then they use the american womans credit, send money back home if they get a work permit& green card, of course the money sent back home is worth 5x as much when converted!
You say they are living clean heart in this country .........think again! Illegal activity& causing a lot of pain and heartache for both women, when discovered! This is something to be proud of, let me inform you, we don't allow multiple marriage in this country Shisha!!
Shame on you.......You are a Hypocrite!!
You call people "white trailor trash", you think domestic violence is only from poor areas, rural areas, uneducated, think again!!
Kuwait, Dubai, Saudi, being very wealthy, I have seen first hand women, abused physically, from the upper class, Literally stuck in that country, scared to leave because, husband will not allow the children to go!
Excuse me divorce is still difficult for the arab women, many are ordered by the court to go back to their husbands!! Most are scared to lose their children, they cannot travel without the husbands permission, you call that "freedom" for women, good equal treatment!!
You put others down and you are the insecure unhappy person, but easy to call everyone on this board ignorant, unless they agree with your expertise!
The Holy Qur'an allows  the moslem man to discipline the women if she does not obey or behave as he sees fit& correct! That is why you do not reside overseas, the authorities are not going to help you if you call them!"
You make fun and mock others on this board in regards to the film"NOT Without My Daughter", well I have news for you, that kind of activity is still going on in the middle east my dear!! It is not fantasy, or a joke, when you cannot get out of a country with your own children!
YOU NEED A REALITY CHECK!!
So before you call the next person "uneducated, inaccurate, ignorant, etc."
Take a look in the mirror! You are suffering low-self esteem& in a very unhappy marriage, because you are trying so hard to convince others of your great marriage, the best life overseas in the arab world, but you are here???
You are a very cold heart& unsympathetic to others, who are suffering at the hands of these predators
who are lying and using american women to gain financial ,&green card status ,in this country, anyway
they can, even to destroy others lives and families,being torn apart! Even tearing their own family apart overseas with these lies and deceptions!
Just remember to these women never give up ,their is help available and support!
"By God What Goes Around Comes Around!!"
I had an Egyptian man trying to hit on me whilst using ICQ a few years ago. He wanted to know whether I was single or married. When he admitted he was married, I asked why  he was talking to me when he should be paying more attention to his wife! I then hit the 'Ignore' button so he couldn't contact me again.   Many Middle Easten men have contacted me by ICQ, but I wasn't interested in having a 'romantic' relationship with any of them. For all I knew, they could have half a dozen wives in their home countries they weren't planning to tell me about ... until it was way too late.   One current affairs programme ran a story how a Turkish bloke had a relationship with an Australian woman via the Internet. He tricked her into marriage. Then he abandoned her once he got what he wanted - entry into Australia. She was devastated.   There are probably many more women who got sucked in by these men on the Internet and ended up unhappily married, but we don't hear about them in the media.
 
First | Prev | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | Next | Last