Message Boards

Topic : 06/17 A Daughter in Danger? Part 2

Number of Replies: 956
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, November 08, 2007, 07:39:52 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/15/07) Dr. Phil continues the story of a young woman who made international headlines when she ran away to Palestine to be with a man she met on the Internet when she was just 16. Katherine was stopped by the FBI and brought back home, but two years later and now an adult, she’s left the United States again to be with Abdullah, the man she says she loves and wants to marry. Katherine’s terrified family thinks she is being brainwashed, and may never be allowed to return home. They say they’ve witnessed Abdullah’s violent temper when he’s verbally abused her over the phone. Now, in an exclusive interview via satellite, Dr. Phil speaks with Katherine and Abdullah together. Is Abdullah lying about letting Katherine return home? Is this couple already married? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 7:46 pm PST

daughter in pali

Quote From: cristo

 I've tried to give Abdullah and his family the benefit of the doubt. I have a number of Palestinian and other Arabic friends, great people. And all except one of my married male friends in this demographic are doting husbands, unlike the stereotype. I thought the whole bit about code-words and brainwashing stuff seemed a little over the top for fear-mongering - as if she was some American hostage in Iran in 1979. Is she brainwashed? No - she's just an immature, impressionable and impulsive girl, who jumped in over her head and was too proud to admit it is a mistake. Is Abdullah some insidious terrorist seeking a green card? No, i think he's just an insecure punk "bad boy" loser, and Katherine could have just as easily latched on to a Mr Wrong just like him lurking in any bar in America.

The really bizarre and fishy thing in all this though, is that Abdullah's dad made the arrangements for her to fly to the Middle East in the first place. For the first thing, it's highly unusual for such a dad to be supportive of his son marrying outside the faith - "why can't you find a nice Muslim girl?", or "Forget her, my business associate has a great daughter i'd like you to meet" etc. But the real clincher, with the strict cultural value of a young woman's propriety, is Abdullah's dad  sending Katharine alone overseas. If he did that with his o own daughter, in his culture that would taint his family honor with shame, and brand her as un-marryable , at best. Why would Abdullah's father invite this "shame" on his family? That makes this really fishy.
wow you said it best............ sorry i get to emotional about things like this and dont think before i write. I to have many friends from the middle east and really they are nothing like him. god bless
 
User Mood
Bored

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 7:46 pm PST

If

Quote From: sheenie

Being a practicing muslim as well as coming from a long line of men who practice islam properly, they know that in islam a woman's divine right is to be treated with respect and kindness.

Every woman no matter what religion needs to be taught that they should ALWAYS be talked to with kindness and respect, this is a basic human right (and God given right). Unfortunatley women don't always know that or arent' raised with those teachings. Some ddin't have an example of a man treating them kindly. Maybe this girl had an abusive father or maybe she doens't know how a man is supposed to treat her. Maybe her mom dates countless men who beat her as well? Unfortunately you only know what you have seen and learned. Some women who come from abusive upbringings think that's how a man is supposed to treat them. They don't know otherwise.

If she is being abused, I hope she realizes she NEVER needs to live lke that and DOES NOT deserve it. No woman does!

What you are saying is true then how come it is legal in most Islamic countries for a man to beat his wife?
 
User Mood
Bored

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 7:48 pm PST

This is Why

Quote From: savednow

1.  I have read the Koran (Quran).  Any translation of the Koran is considered to be corrupted  - it is a fasinating read.  I can post a few of their scriptures, but they are very vile and hateful towards Jews and Christians.

 

2.  You have had your children baptised (Catholics), but are raising them as Muslims.  Dod you let your Preist in on that little tidbit before they were allowed to participate in the sacrement?

 

3.  You are incorrect - Muslims are commanded to convert all to Islam and if someone refuses, they have permission (and are doing Allah a service) by killing them. This is where the 70 virgins in Heaven is promised.   Also, Muslims are allowed to "lie" to everyone EXCEPT other Muslims.

I do not trust them. Come on people.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
angry
November 15, 2007, 7:51 pm PST

Stupid girl

 This dude is bad news. If she had an ounce of a brain in her head she'd get out of there fast. Once she gets home she needs to cut all ties and never hear from that dude again.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 7:56 pm PST

Another hurting mother

I am also a hurting, worried mother.  I caught my daughter talking to guys in other countries when she was 15.  I took the computer and phone away,  called  the phone co. to make sure that she could not call out internationally, called the local library and told them she was not allowed to sign up for computer time...I covered everything.  I found notes she would have her friends write to these guys for her.   The communication cont. when she was at school.  She somehow got phone cards.  There is always a way to get what you want. 

My daughter left for Lebanon secretly a month after she turned 18.  I worry about terrorists and extremists  over there just like I worry about rapists and murderers here.  But I worry more because I don't know the people she is with, and because she had to be so secretive.  I did not know where she was, or if she was dead or alive.  Just b/c she is 18 does not mean I am not going to be concerned, worried, loving,etc...Once you are a parent, you are always a parent, no matter how old they are.

 

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 7:57 pm PST

11/15 A Daughter in Danger? Part 2

Quote From: sheenie

Being a practicing muslim as well as coming from a long line of men who practice islam properly, they know that in islam a woman's divine right is to be treated with respect and kindness.

Every woman no matter what religion needs to be taught that they should ALWAYS be talked to with kindness and respect, this is a basic human right (and God given right). Unfortunatley women don't always know that or arent' raised with those teachings. Some ddin't have an example of a man treating them kindly. Maybe this girl had an abusive father or maybe she doens't know how a man is supposed to treat her. Maybe her mom dates countless men who beat her as well? Unfortunately you only know what you have seen and learned. Some women who come from abusive upbringings think that's how a man is supposed to treat them. They don't know otherwise.

If she is being abused, I hope she realizes she NEVER needs to live lke that and DOES NOT deserve it. No woman does!

i wasnt ever raised with a woman being disrespected or beat... ive just recently been rescued from that crap- from what katherines sister says, katherine acts like shes better than most- apparently there is a self esteem issue that needs to be cleared up.. so scared, naive, and young.. thats all there is to it. for her sake she better take the dr.s advice..

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
angry
November 15, 2007, 7:59 pm PST

Daughter in danger!!!!

I can NOT believe this!!! She is 18 and doesnt know anything. I am so ashamed of her and I am not even her mother! She is so brain-washed. This guy is so full of you know what. I am just watching it and I cant believe this guy. He doesnt love her at all. If he did, he would have come here! Where he lives is so dangerous and to put someone you are "so in love" with...I just dont get it. I feel so sorry for her family. They are such strong people to stick around and watch what this girl is doing with her life. I am not doubting to is in love but its not real...its puppy love. He is going to break her heart and she is one of those girls who has lost all common sense and she is just going to take him back and end up pregnant. WHY??? I dont understand why girl are this blinded by men!!! Does she not get that she could meet someone who doesnt call her names or put her life in danger? She is worth so much more then that!!!! It is so hard to watch this stuff. I just dont understand it. I know she is young but thats the problem...SHE IS YOUNG!! I met my boyfriend when I was 16 too but he lives in the same state I do. Its just so sad. Katherine, WAKE UP SWEETIE!!! You arent as in love as you think...trust me, you are going to find out so many things about him that you are not going to like and the longer you stay, the worse things are going to get!!!! GET OUT NOW!! Good job Dr. Phil. I am glad to see you are working hard to wake this girl up. One step at a time!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 8:09 pm PST

Brain Washed for Sure!

I think Katherine needs to be brought home and de-programmed.  Her life is definitely in danger...she is sleeping with the enemy.
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 8:18 pm PST

11/15 A Daughter in Danger? Part 2

Quote From: anita9456

 I have been to Israel 9 times since April 2000. I have been to Jericho - before the infitada. Jericho is located just slightly to the north and west of Jerusalem not far from the Jordan River. The Gaza Strip is Located down on the Egyptian Border. Been their as well. The West Bank & Gaza strip Belong to Israel. THERE IS NO COUNTRY OF PALASTINE! 
   In 1967  Israel fought a war with Egypt, Jordan and Syria. The active Arab states received aid from Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and Algeria. The war left Israel with the largest territorial gains from any of the wars the country had been involved in: Sinai and Gaza Strip were captured from Egypt, East Jerusalem and the West Bank from Jordan and the Golan Heights from Syria.
 
Israel also fought from October 6 to October 26, 1973 against a coalition of Arab states led by Egypt and Syria. The war began with a surprise joint attack by Egypt and Syria on the Jewish holiday of Yom Kippur. Egypt and Syria crossed the cease-fire lines in the Sinia and Golan Heights, which had been captured by Israel in 1967 during the Six-Day War.
 
So there is no Palestine (the land belonged to the nations listed)- it is Israel ! 


Yes, Katherine is in danger. She is the hands of a people who have no respect for woman and believe that Christians need to convert to Islam or die. I do not know what Katherine believes, but if she believes that Jesus is Lord, Jesus is the  Messiah and the son of God once they get married she will have to make a choice.  The Muslims are not friendly to woman, Christians and Jews. Their leaders (Yasser Arafat for one) wants to push the Jews into the sea and than go after Great Satan - American. First the saturday people than the Sunday people. Jericho was and I do believe still is where the headquarters of the PLO are, unless after Yasser Arafat they moved it to Ramallah (inswhich is straight North of Jerusalem).
 
I hope and pray you get her out of there!! Abdulla just wants to marry her to get into America. Look at Michigan they have a huge population of Muslims. Hmmmmmmmmmmm? Gee I wonder why he wants her?
 
Oh - one of my Israeli friends told me once that it is not Racial profiling when you look at a certian group of people, but it is "RISK PROFILING"! 
  

 

 I have a strong disagreement on your opinion  about how you view muslims in general. You have failed to understand that all religions have a blood on their hands period. Jews and Christians are no better than Muslims or Buddists.  All religions have killers, criminals, and abusers.  There is no proof that Muslims are more evil than Jews or Christians. In the Middle Ages, Catholic people killed tons of Jews in Spain and Jews had no chose but convert their religion to Christians. If they refused to convert, their punishment was death!   Don't be too gullible with the Media.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2007, 8:29 pm PST

hi

Quote From: anniekc

 

I met my husband on ther internet and he is from Paksitan. But I also didn't rush and meet him with in months. It took me 3 1/2 years before i agreed and went to paksitan to marry him. It is hard because we have two seperate cultures but i love him so much. This girl and everyone should wait and see because it might be just a crush. I took my time and tested him too

 

Hello from what i understood from the show is that she did know him for 2 years not months as you put it. Now im not saying what is did is right i just wanted to put that out there. Also I believe that the parents should have actually sat down with their daughter and talked to her and take her situation seriously. Given her a no right away made the situation much worse. They could of compromised and maybe if Katherine still wanted to go met him then someone from her family could have gone to palestine with her.
 
First | Prev | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | Next | Last