Message Boards

Topic : 06/04 Too Big, Too Young

Number of Replies: 477
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Tuesday, November 20, 2007, 06:08:03 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/29/07) Obesity is a huge problem for adults in this country, but now it’s becoming an epidemic among young children. Barbra says her 3-year-old daughter started gaining weight at six months old and now weighs 80 pounds. Barbra and her aunt, Dana, are baffled by what they believe is a medical mystery because they say the little girl doesn't overeat. Dr. Phil brings in two medical experts to get to the bottom of this issue. Is Barbra contributing to her child's weight gain? Then, Tammy says she can’t change her family's eating habits. She's obese, her 11-year-old is 175 pounds and her 9-year-old is 136 pounds. Her sister, Debbie, says the boys portion sizes are too big and the family is just lazy. Can Dr. Phil get Tammy to stick to a nutrition plan? You won’t believe the surprise he has for her! Plus, Jessica says her mom, Angie, is blind to the health issues of her 351-pound sister, Jaleisa, who is only 15. Jessica says her mom never buys healthy food, and she fears her mom has Munchausen’s syndrome. Angie says she can’t monitor Jaleisa’s eating habits all day. Can Angie turn this situation around and save her daughter’s life, or is it too late? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 30, 2007, 6:52 pm PST

umm no

Quote From: anon_slc

Xylitol is a natural occurring sweetener found in many fruits like strawberries, pears and plums.  Pure Xylitol is a white crystalline substance that looks and tastes like sugar. On food labels, Xylitol is classified broadly as a carbohydrate and more narrowly as a polyol. Because Xylitol is only slowly absorbed and partially utilized, a reduced calorie claim is allowed: 2.4 calories per gram or 40% less than other carbohydrates.   

 

Xylitol has 40% fewer calories and 75% fewer carbohydrates than sugar and is slowly absorbed and metabolized, resulting in very negligible changes in insulin. About one-third of the Xylitol that is consumed is absorbed in the liver. The other two-thirds travels to the intestinal tract, where it is broken down by gut bacteria into short-chain fatty acids. 

 

Chemically speaking, Xylitol is not actually a sugar, but a sugar alcohol. It differs from other sweeteners such as sorbitol, fructose and glucose because the Xylitol molecule has five, instead of six, carbon atoms. Most bacteria in mouth are unable to make use of such sugars. This is one reason why Xylitol helps prevent cavities.  

 

Xylitol tastes and pours like regular sugar, but provides 40% fewer calories.  Xylitol mixes and dissolves readily and is heat stable, making it the ideal sweetener for hot beverages, baking and other cooking applications unlike artificial sweeteners. 

 

Xylitol looks, feels, and tastes exactly like sugar, and leaves no unpleasant aftertaste. It is available in bulk and many forms.  It can be purchased at health food stores and over the internet.  Xylitol was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 1963. 

 

 

Hope it helps!  

 

 Do not use chemically altered sugar at any time for any reason. Try raw sugar, honey and pure maple syrup. You need to stop injesting garbage, this is what makes our country fat, Cakes and pies are garbage. Finding a way to bake them with slightly less calories is not the solution. Processed foods are bad, it doesn't matter how few calories. I'm sick of the excuses people come up with, injesting crap and not moving your body makes you fat. PERIOD. Three year olds shouldn't even know what soda is yet, diet or otherwise. To say people don't understand nutrition is another cop out. Fresh fruits and veggies, good. Snack cakes and chips, bad. Lean meats and real cheeses, good. Burgers and processed cheeses, bad. Whole grains good, starchy foods bad. It's not rocket science, it's common sense.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 30, 2007, 9:51 pm PST

Walking a tightrope

It seems like feeding children a healthy diet these days is becoming a lost art.  I have a 22-month old, and on tv I see commercials for toddler tv dinners (or near enough), and have you seen the commercial where the line is bringing dinner back to the kitchen table?  Mom and dad are downstairs with a bucket of fried chicken, and they call up, "Kids, dinner!"  Next you see the kids running outside and jumping into the car to go eat, and mom and dad shrug, smile at each other, and say, "They'll figure it out!"

 

This show hits home with me, but in a different way.  My side of the family is naturally more slender, and the eating habits I grew up with, I'm working to keep up.  Which, since I do most of the cooking, isn't really that hard.  I love to cook, so we eat a lot of veggies, baked foods, etc.  I've been really lucky with my daughter so far, whose favorite foods are broccoli, carrots, apples, tomatoes, etc..

 

My husband's side of the family is kind of the polar opposite: heavily overweight, eat a lot of snacks throughout the day, and don't really cook much.  I'm struggling with my MIL, who I've caught sneaking to my daughter potato chips, ice cream, chocolate, cookies, etc.  This is pretty frustrating to me when my daughter was going through a finicky eating stage, and it was tough to get her to eat a full meal to begin with, without filling her up on junk food.  Especially since I had already pointed out to her not to feed her junk food.  AArgh!

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2007, 10:32 am PST

11/29 Too Big, Too Young

Quote From: misstearyus

You know what, the truth - as much as we all don't like to hear it - can hurt.

The truth HURTS.. we all know that..

 

But I think to myself, what REALLY hurts more?

 

A parent having to listen to someone tell them what they're feeding their child is bad?

A parent having to listen to someone tell them they want to help?

A parent having resources made available to them to ensure their child heads down a healthy & happy path?

 

OR..

 

A parent having to deal with the DEATH of their child?

 

It's time to step up to the plate.

The time a parent spends in denial is time taken away from their child's life.

 

So think about what really matters.

 

 

To start with, it is interesting to note, that a MORBIDLY obese woman,
with a BMI of over 35, will generally outlive a normal weight man. 
That is not what you would believe reading the paper.  You would assume
that anyone morbidly obese would be lucky to see 50.  Not so. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2007, 10:04 pm PST

These kids need help before its too late

I am really worried about the weight problem affecting our society today.  I grew up with a lot of abuse and have had problems with my weight for many years.  I've been able to quit smoking and have never had any other addiction but food. 

I am 40 years old, am an insulin dependent diabetic, High blood pressure, high cholesterol, high tryglycerides as well as Rheumatoid Arthritis and I feel that 99% of this is caused by my unhealthy eating habits I battle this every day and hope one day I will win.  I do feel that I am running out of time though.

My point is though that I have not carried this on to my children.  We do not allow junk food in the house.  They eat fresh fruit and veggies and mainly white meat.  They are also involved in many different athletic programs from Tap Dancing to Basketball and Hockey.  My problem is that I eat way too much and am a closet eater when it cames to potato chips and other junk. 

The children seen on this show need intervention now.  If their parents can't do it somebody needs to step up to the plate in these families and help these children.

 

Raven

 

 

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2007, 3:13 pm PST

Calories

Quote From: monkeymilk

The mother and aunt of the 3yo little girl both seemed to feel very strongly that 600 calories a day (I think that's what one doctor had recommended?) was way to low for a child, that she needed more calories.  I've been doing some research online, but can only seem to find daily calorie guidelines for adults.  600 for a yo seems reasonable to me, considering that an adult woman needs about 1500-1800, depending on activity levels.  What *is* an appropriate caloric intake for a kid?

Thanks!

I got this information from peds calorie caluculator

 

Age: 2-3 years old

Gender: Female

Activity Level: Sedentary

Estimated Calorie Requirements: 1,000 calories per day

 

Age: 19-30 years old

Gender: Female

Activity Level: Sedentary

Estimated Calorie Requirements: 2,000 calories per day

 

I hope this helped



 

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2007, 3:16 pm PST

Force feeding is abuse

Quote From: karlaj022396

 I have two teenagers who are of normal weight.  Myself I weigh 100lbs. My problem with this is Dr. Phil is going to call child protective services--What?  Will I be next because I smoke in front of my kids?  Where does the line get crossed.  I do believe the girl needs help and I am so happy with Dr. Phils decsion but threating CPS-really-DR. Phil you know and I know in Texas lets work on issues like baby grace.  And if anyone can help me stop smoking, including sending me to jail (like one mother tried in Houston) I am gain, but don't threaten CPS.
And if you smoked inside your house, I call you stupid, and a bad mother sorry its true. I understand craving for a smoke, my husband is a smoker, and has tried to quit every which way. But he doesn't smoke in front of our son, not in the house. I would call CPS, in a woman that smoke indoors at close range to her young child.
 

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2007, 3:35 pm PST

Death

Quote From: wasafannot

To start with, it is interesting to note, that a MORBIDLY obese woman,
with a BMI of over 35, will generally outlive a normal weight man. 
That is not what you would believe reading the paper.  You would assume
that anyone morbidly obese would be lucky to see 50.  Not so. 
Where are your information on a obese woman out living a normal healthy weight man?
 

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2007, 3:45 pm PST

Sugar

Quote From: juliastarr

 Do not use chemically altered sugar at any time for any reason. Try raw sugar, honey and pure maple syrup. You need to stop injesting garbage, this is what makes our country fat, Cakes and pies are garbage. Finding a way to bake them with slightly less calories is not the solution. Processed foods are bad, it doesn't matter how few calories. I'm sick of the excuses people come up with, injesting crap and not moving your body makes you fat. PERIOD. Three year olds shouldn't even know what soda is yet, diet or otherwise. To say people don't understand nutrition is another cop out. Fresh fruits and veggies, good. Snack cakes and chips, bad. Lean meats and real cheeses, good. Burgers and processed cheeses, bad. Whole grains good, starchy foods bad. It's not rocket science, it's common sense.

I do agree with you, but what the PP was talking about is Xylitol, which is what I have been told to use cause I have tooth decay, from my oral meds. And this sugar wouldn't continue to do harm and is actually healthy for the teeth. And its healthy for the body. Its a naturl sugar our body already makes from other foods we eat.

 

Oh but I totally agree with you, it is a cop out when people say, I don't know really what I should feed my kids, well lets see you have your choice of cheese, meat, any veggie and fruit your eye can see, you have whole wheat bread, whole wheat pasta, you can make your own pasta sauce and have it full of veggies you like. There are so many options you just have to be willing to make them. I know cooking can be hard when your busy, but once you start getting into those hard recipes you see become easy and you don't even have to look at them again. I use to be a big time eating out person, but once I became pregnant, I hated leaving my home. Plus I knew i wasn't going to let my kid eat fast food everyday. So went through magazines, books, and websites looking for food that just simply looked good, printed them out, and tried a new meal once a week (cooking the rest of the time easy/fast meals) I can now cook a bunch of different things and find I get them on the table then pre-made frozen dinners, and faster then getting ready and going out to a place. Its better thats all thats important right.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
December 2, 2007, 6:48 pm PST

I can not stand judgental people

Quote From: conniesechman

I have always beleive that if the child does not have a medical condition that is causing the weight gain of that child then the parent is 100% responsible for that child.  It is common sense that the child is unhealthy and overweight.  The parent needs to get this child active and take video games, computer and start limiting the food intake.  When that child passes away due to neglect then that parent needs to be charged with the childs death.  THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THIS.  Do whatever it takes to get this child to lose weight and get healthy.  The PARENT is the one that children depend on.  The PARENT is the one that is in control of their life for 18 years.  The PARENT is the one responsible for the children. The PARENT is the one that takes full responsibility for the children actions.  The PARENT must take action with help thru medical doctors,to see that these children that are morbidly obese get the help they need to get these children healthy.  The PARENT should take full responsibility for the death of the child due to the PARENTS neglect that is just commen sense to anyone of how unhealthy this is. I feel that most parents will outlive their children because of this.   
I can't stomach when people make comments about obese children.  I have a 2 year old  is 80 pounds and is 42 inches tall.  Like the mother in this story I have had every test imaginble for my son.  So far there is nothing thatcan be found medically.  I have taken my son down to 900 calories a day and he is very active.  He gains between 2 an 3 pounds a month that started at about 6 months.  How can a child start gaining weight this young and people blame it on what the child eats.  I have 2 other children and they never had this problem.  To the poster that says it is the parents fault shame on you.  If you have not walked in this parents shoes as I have then do not judge.  There is a genetics specialist at the Univerity of Florida in Gainesville that specializes in children like ours. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
naughty
December 2, 2007, 9:38 pm PST

11/29 Too Big, Too Young

Quote From: mr_cheer

I am 19 years old. I eat pizza, chicken, all kinds of tasty treats. I havent gained a pound in the last 3 years, and my cholestrol and all that other stuff is normal

 

  I smiled when i read you're post. You sounded just like me when i was 19. However it caught up with me and it will with you also. As we age metabolism slows down and on goes the pounds and the cholesterol number rise. Keeping my weight in check  and cholesterol normal now is a constant battle....enjoy you're treats now because there comes a time when if you want to remain  a healthy weight  or healthy.... period..... you have to watch what you eat. mmm to have pizza would be nice ..... but oh well Ive had my day of eating pizza.......enjoy yours too. Thanks for the memories.

 
First | Prev | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | Next | Last