Message Boards

Topic : 01/21 Real Life Gossip Girls

Number of Replies: 277
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 18, 2008, 02:22:49 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Some teens are catty, mean and love to spread lies, but what happens when gossip goes too far? Kim says her daughter, Kailey, was the victim of a prank. Two of Kailey's cheer squad friends took a picture of her while she was in the shower, and the image supposedly made its way around the football team. Now, in the aftermath, the whole town is buzzing. You won't believe what the fathers of the alleged perpetrators have to say about the incident. Another girl claims she was also a victim when one of the girls took an unwanted photo of her as a joke. Hear from this alleged victim. And, Mandie and Nikki threatened the life of a classmate on MySpace after they thought she was going to steal Nikki's boyfriend. They were convicted in a court of law three years ago, and now both families say they face losing their homes because of this teen gossip. What do the girls say about their actions? And, Elizabeth started a Web site that allows anyone to gossip about anything. When a victim of lies posted on her site tells her story, will Elizabeth change her view? Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 3:46 pm PST

01/21 Real Life Gossip Girls

We all know that our kids are not perfect and impossible to know everything they are up to. So for the harsh comments to the parents of the girl's that may lose their homes are really not called for, the parent's should not have to suffer such great loss. Should the girl's be held accountable ? YES! You could just see the the regret in those girls they are truly hurting and are sorry. No this shouldn't be taken lightly but I am sure For the people who posted comments that were  targeting the parents- I bet they don't always know what their kids are up to at all times and are not perfect parent's either. Children need to make mistakes to learn by them and I am sure at least these two girls did. I do think restitution should be paid by the GIRL"S NOT the PARENT'S!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
January 21, 2008, 3:51 pm PST

Parents do their children a great disservice.

Mauricio, you are teaching your daughter that their are no repercussions for what she does. Thank you for leaving the world in such disgrace. Your daughter is a reflection of your morals. Shame on you! Your daughter has learned to play you against the system. You must be trying to make up for your lack of parenting and she knows it! You should have insisted that your daughter remain off the cheer team and do some community service to offset her actions. That would have made all the difference. Your daughter was mean and wrong. Saying sorry sometimes is just not enough!
 

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 3:56 pm PST

Oh, Elizabeth - Slaming Website

Elzabeth, Elizabeth, Elizabeth.."slamming website" - isn't that what it is afterall?

 

Such focus on negative with your website - and you know the focus of posts on your website is mostly negative don't you?

 

What you are offering on your webiste is nothing short of "slam books" that were happening when I was in Grade Shool (1962-1968) - nothing new and novel at all.

 

Remember, what you put out - you get back - many fold.

  • Elizabeth, have you considered a  website on how parents can help guide their children regarding "slamming" on the website.
  • Also, you could offer your services to schools...(as you know about "slamming" first hand...since you are nothing short of a "slam book" that goes way back in time.).

On the above bulleted:

You would have to do a ton of research and be credible to make it happen - strap your ankles.

 

You might get a more profitable support and help many children and families in return.

 

It would be the right thing to do.

 

Think about it.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
January 21, 2008, 3:59 pm PST

Revenge Bullying/Gossiping

Okay, watching this episode on “Real Life Gossip Girls” and reading these message boards had me thinking, and I want all the parents on here to put on their “reminiscing caps” and think back to their high school/middle school days.

 

Who here has been a victim of bullying?  What all happened to you?  Were you gossiped about, and if so, what did they say?  And who here has been a bully?  Did you pick on many people?  What did you do?

 

Now, to the bullied, getting back to the present and you have two children of your own.  By some coincidence, you happen to run into several of your used-to-be tormentors and everything comes flooding back to you, and you feel uncomfortable all of a sudden.  As you talk, you learn that your tormentors also have children, around the same age as yours, or perhaps a little younger.  Would the thought of perhaps encouraging your children to bully your former bully’s children ever cross your mind, as a way of getting revenge?  And to the former bullies, how would you react if you knew your former victim(s)’s child(ren) were tormenting your children as you tormented THEIR PARENTS in school?

 

Again, this was something I was thinking about during the duration of this show.

 

PS: I had to use a "chillin" emote.  For times like this, we could use a “curious” emote.... LOL!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
January 21, 2008, 4:04 pm PST

I Am Disgusted by Elizabeth and Gossipreport.com

I watched today's show and felt many emotions.  I felt empathy for the teenage girl who had her picture taken with a cell phone and shared with other people.  I felt anger towards the two girls who were so very malicious towards another girl for "attempting to steal a boyfriend."  AND, I am really angry that our world has come to our allowing someone like Elizabeth to create a website where you can gossip about other people.  Does she and her cohorts realize that people can spread serious falsehoods?  The teenage population actually has enough problems with self esteem, popularity, self respect...and now this!  She is making money at the expense of other people and I find this terribly disgusting.   Suicide is rampant among teenage and college aged females and males, and this website will definitely increase depression and possible suicide in very vulnerable people.  Our government(s) should have legislation in place to stop these kind of "stupid and self-serving" entrepeneurs.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 4:08 pm PST

Really??

Quote From: sleiffer

I believe the parents should be held accountable, these girls are obviously minors and just because they did something stupid doesn't mean they should pay the price for their actions.  A prank is a prank, shouldn't happen,  these young adults know right from wrong, they did something bad and think they shouldn't be responsible, NOT!   Having fun and laughs at someone else's expense isn't  appropriate and consequences should be administered, why slap them on the hands and say  WARNING, it doesn't teach them anything except, I got away with it, not ok in my book.  One way of stopping things like this is not to allow cell phones at school, it can be done, or only use at breaks or lunchtime, grab hold and prevent this from happening again....

Do you really think that schools allow the phones in the schools.  They do not allow phones in any schools during class time my child can only use theirs once school is over and that is it.  What you say and what they do is 2 totally different things.

 

We can't keep GUNS & WAEPONS from our schools why do you think they can control the cell phone thing! 

As parents we need to make sure our kids understand right from wrong and know if you don't want it done to you then don't do it to someone else and at the same time remember when they leave your home they are on their own to make their own decisions and you can only hope that all you have taught them stays with them and they practice it. 

 

My mom always said to me growing up..."you made your bed...you have to lie in it" and I feel these girls and their families have a high price to pay but it is far from what the other families have gone through. 

No pitty from me that is for sure!  Girls are way too comfortable destroying other girls over mere jealousy and they can't even admit it is jealousy!  My neice has done this same thing to another girl except the pic is different but the result the same and she doesn't see anything wrong with what she has done and it actually disgusts me at the thought that she can be that evil and he mom and dad think she is so wonderful and great and would never do any wrong!  I love my neice but she is very disappointing and I cannot do anything about what she has done because my inlaws feel its all harmless!

 

What goes around comes around!! Sorry girls hard price to pay but it has to be paid!

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 4:29 pm PST

Kailey's school ought to be sued

It is disgraceful that Kailey's school opted not to follow their own rules and kick those two girls off the cheerleader sqaud like they SAID they would do.  Is there a school administration ANYWHERE that doesn't bend over when faced with parental pressure?  What nonsense.  I think they should be sued right away.  What a horrible example to set - making rules and then not enforcing them!  They need to set an example.  Basically, nothing happened to those two little twits except they got 3 days off from school - which teenagers LOVE. 

 

And shame on that father of one of those girls for giving her a free pass. Grow a spine, Mister!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 4:46 pm PST

Elizabeth needs to grow up!

As a parent of a 13-yr-old and one younger (and also as a high school teacher), I can say I would be very embarassed if Elizabeth were my daughter. The fact that she's SUPPOSED to be bright yet she tries to justify her website is just plain dumb.

 

Yes, we all gossip. But it's NOT something we should be proud of... As a Christian, I like to stop and ask myself what Jesus would say about my words or actions if he were standing in front of me. Somehow I know what he would say about a website based on gossip.

 

It's EASY to be a coward and post when nobody knows you. It's easy to lie. To cheat. To bash, etc. What's apparently difficult is for these young people to be MATURE and kind. Remember the old saying about not saying something if you don't have something nice to see?

 

Yes, we all have the RIGHT to say what we want, even behind a screen where there are no consequences to our actions/speech. However, just because we CAN do something doesn't mean we SHOULD do it.

 

Disrespecting others is disrespecting oneself. When we go down in the gutter, it says more about OURSELVES than it does about our victim/target.

 

Grow up, Elizabeth (and others like you). Have some self-respect, maturity and compassion. One would think your parents would have raised you better!  There is NO justifying your immature website. Once you become the target of a mean liar, I KNOW you'll change your tune....

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 4:48 pm PST

01/21 Real Life Gossip Girls

Quote From: walden420

Very true. This is a big deal about nothing. The two girls who took the photo got suspended from school, were dropped from the cheerleading team, and have apologized repeatedly. It was wrong, and the girls did deserve to be punished but it's also time to MOVE ON. What else does the family want? A multimillion dollar lawsuit settlement? This nonsense that a picture of someone's naked butt is going to ruin their entire life is ridiculous. It's an insult to those out there who are violently raped, beaten, or molested and have to TRULY suffer the rest of their life.

You are so right!!! Too many poeple are on here judging without really knowing the entire story from ALL sides. I can tell you for a fact that these people bringing their children on tv just want attention and to cause more and more drama. Some people just thrive on it!!! The alleged "victims" lied and totally fabricated the story for attention. This is why "no adult has ever seen the alleged photo". People, get a life!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2008, 4:49 pm PST

Dr. Phil was right on!

Quote From: barbs11

I cannot believe Dr. Phil's response to these girls! Their actions go beyond gossip to criminal. Since when is it ok to take pictures of a naked teenager and distribute them? If this was a boy or a man that had taken the picture would Dr. Phil have had a different response? With the speed and ease of technology those pictures could easily have been posted on the internet and accessed by pedophiles world wide! This is sexual harrassement of the worst kind and should be held to prosecution by the law. And the other two girls that threatened to kill another girl???? I personally don't want to live in a society  where people are allowed to walk around and threaten others lives. Schools cannot allow this kind of bullying. Schools should be a place where children feel safe to attend. There is too much emotional damage that is caused by bullying to just dismiss these actions as simple "girl gossip". Again, this was more than just bullying though, it was criminal. Schools nationwide are wising up to the damages caused by online sites such as MySpace and are dishing out consequences at school (as they should!) If what is said online causes the victim to fear attending school then it is well within the rights of the school to hand out consequences.

 

*Dr. Phil- you are slowly losing viewers. Wise up!!!

Dr. Phil WAS CORRECT. The girls were charged, faced their accuser in a court of law and finished their punishments. They have also apologized and seemed sincere.

 

If Dr. Phil didn't think they were, he would have slammed them.

 

The girls paid their debt to the victim and society; they cannot take back what they did. All they can do is move forward and become better individuals. The victim must learn to move forward as well. God bless ALL of them. What a bad situation all around....

 
First | Prev | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | Next | Last