Message Boards

Topic : 01/24 "I Want Out!"

Number of Replies: 163
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 18, 2008, 02:26:08 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
When couples tie the knot, they vow to stay together "'til death do us part," but what happens when a marriage takes a few bad turns, and one partner desperately wants out? Dr. Phil's guests are at a crossroads in their marriages. Hector and Nicole have been married nine years, and Nicole says she's done with the marriage, no longer loves her husband and has a boyfriend to prove it! Hector says he loves his wife and is desperate to save his marriage. He's even paid thousands for Nicole to have plastic surgery! Can Dr. Phil convince Nicole to give up her lover and give her marriage another shot? And, Shaun wants to dump his wife, Nancy, for good because he says she stalks him and throws herself in front of the door to keep him from leaving. Nancy is convinced Shaun still loves her, and she's hoping they can resurrect their union. Is there hope for this couple, or should they walk away? Tell us what you think.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 5:06 pm PST

it's all so simple

Don't be in any relationship with anyone if you cannot accept them as they are.  If you want to change anything then it is not right.  Take a long look at both of his/her parents and ask yourself when you are 50 will you have a problem waking up next to him/her if they look like their parent.  If you cannot say you won't have a problem then they are not right for you. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 5:09 pm PST

Exactly!!

Quote From: dollface54

 90 days is not a good idea,....Nicole doesnt want it....she was bullied into it by both her husband and Dr. Phil, it wont work not for a minute........

He will not change his spots ...been there have a closet full of t-shirts....same situation didnt work...tried councelling tryed everything....leopard dont change theire spots....

Reread what I said.  She owes it to herself and her kids to end that relationship in a healthy way...if at all possible.  She needs to bring it to closure in a way that is good for the KIDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   THEY come first and when she does this in a way that is honest..................she can and will feel better aboiut herself and how she feels going forward.

 

90 days is a drop in the bucket.....her kids are worth the time to create a less hostile environment for them going forward!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

PERIOD!!!  They are NUMBER ONE!!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 5:18 pm PST

Children and name calling parents

Quote From: bobby_2007

Nancy, if you read these message boards, I want to give you some advice.  First of all, I totally agree with Dr. Phil, this marriage is over.  I see your marriage so much like mine was.  My first marriage was ended when our daughter was about the same age as your daughter.  He was an alcoholic and I am glad I got my daughter and myself out of that marriage.  My second marriage reminds me exactly of this marriage.  My second marriage lasted 24 years.  Most of the marriage was in severe conflict, which severely impacted our children.  If you will notice about Shaun - on the show he stated, "She got pregnant", which is a statement that Nancy got pregnant by herself, as if he had no part of it.  Shaun is in a lot of denial.  Nancy says she recently had an abortion, aborting their second child.  The same thing occurred in my first marriage, and my physician recommended an abortion because the marriage was impacting my health and our unborn fetus, and the doctor stated I had a daughter in the world and life was going to be difficult enough.  He was absolutely right.  I aborted that second baby, and it took nearly seven years to recover from that.  Nancy will know what I am talking about, as any woman who is faced with that horrible decision.  My issue here is:  Shaun does not care about Nancy, and he obviously has some serious issues.  In the video I noticed Shaun is sitting down while Nancy is standing, very upset.  Shaun keeps his voice down and appears very calm.  This is what I think is occurring.  My second marriage was identical to this behavior.  I was the one made out to be a lunatic, while my husband appeared to be the victim.  It took 24 years for me to realize he was pushing my buttons to get me to yell and act like a lunatic, while he appeared calm and the victim.  One day, toward the end of our marriage I decided to not react the way I had always before.  Instead of reacting to my husband, I picked up a book and went out to the deck, and sat down.  Almost instantly my husband began ranting and raving and pacing.  He lost control of me for the first time.  I did not react the way he had always gotten me to react and it threw him out of control.  That was the beginning of the end.  I tried discussing with him that our marriage was over.  He would agree and then the next day he would return home from work, and butter up to me and say he wanted to try at our marriage again.  NO kidding, this went on for many years.  I finally filed for divorce.  Men who conduct themselves as Shaun does, with the cool and calm approach is an attempt to make themselves look like the victim.  Nancy needs to get out of the marriage as soon as possible.  The marriage IS over!  For the sake of Nancy's sanity and for the well being of their daughter, one or the other needs to file for divorce and end this marriage.  Do NOT use this child as a pawn!  Many parents use their children to get back at the other partner.  DO NOT DO THAT!  It is not fair to the child(ren), ever.  Just get a divorce and end the marriage.  People should not ever end being a parent.  Children love their parents.

That sounds like a very difficult marraige to have been in for so long. I prayed that you will be very blessed in your future now that is is over.

 

Children do not always love both parents when they grow up though or as children. I have known some young people who did not love or care about their parents if there parents did not visit them, call them, write them, and if they called them racial names, acted racially superior, or bashed their mother. Mothers are special in children's eyes, especially girls and a man that bashes a young woman's mother after the girl grows up might very well lose the love of the child. Especially when she becomes a mother herself.

 

Shawn reminds me of the husband in a model's dangerous marraige. That man acted cool and calmed and even hailed Dr. Phil and joked with him while his wife sat there upset.

 

If Nancy reads this she should check out the book the verbally abusive relationship, quick thinking on your feet, and this other book that talks about divorce, but it is preventing divorce, it has a section about changing your habits and behaviors like what you spoke about above. The results in that book work very fast. I will have to look it up and post the information. 

 

Abusers try to make their victims lose their credibility through pushing their buttons so they are emotional.

 

I will be praying for Nancy regarding her abortion. There are some great resources out there to help people through abortion recovery.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
January 24, 2008, 5:35 pm PST

for Hector and Nicole

I wish Hector and Nicole the best.  That was my situation a few years ago...I did eventually get the divorce, but my relationship wasn't really finished.  I never gave it that honest "go" by getting rid of the other guy.  When I realized that new relationship wasn't going to work because it was "all wrong" from the beginning, I ended it.  My husband had enough insight to know we both made mistakes; we both had really hurt each other, but he loved me enough to still want to work on being a unit again.

We've remarried, and still have some issues we are working on.  Trust takes a long time to rebuild.  But we're conscience of it and discuss it.  Bottom line is he is the father of my children, neither of us want to be alone, and neither of us want to share them with any one else; we love each other.  And I always thought--even when I dispised him, that we are each other's better half. 

So I give Hector my support for still wanting and loving his wife...and my heart goes out to Nicole because it isn't easy to unwrap yourself from a potential new life.  (everyone but Nicole knows it wouldn't work)  Have faith and if you really want it to work, you can do it. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
January 24, 2008, 5:39 pm PST

Oh Pleeeese!

The ONLY reason she married him, personality flaws and all, was his money. Let's see; breast job, nose job, eye lift, Mercedes (!), and endless shopping sprees, no doubt. He's the typical not very good-looking guy who obviously has a very well paying job, who marries the pretty woman who takes  complete atvantage of it (this is not always the case, of course, but we all know women like this) Then she realizes what being married actually entails and decides to move on. I bet the next guy has some  money too. Who cares if he's a jackass? I guarantee you she won't lift a finger  to "work on the marriage", she'll simply keep moving on to the next guy. What's so suprising is how blatantly obvious this was!! Btw, I'm a woman ,not some bitter rich man, who, on the other hand, get what they deserve by flaunting their wealth or their willingness to try to "buy love".

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 5:45 pm PST

Hector has lost his chance period.

Nicole should leave him now.  He has proved that he is sadistic, cruel and he could harm Nicole and her little girl.  Once they have been abusive it is easier each time to do so again.  Yes, the ill-fated affair she is having should stop immediately; however, he should be restrained with being with Nicole at all.  He is an abuser.  Does Dr. Phil want to give him another chance to do so again, and possibly killing her?  Men who are abusers will never change in a million years.  Take it from me.   I tried seven times to make it work.  My children deserved better than what they saw happened to their mom.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
January 24, 2008, 6:33 pm PST

msuzyq2u

Quote From: man4christ

Hector sowed cheating by cheating first. (I am not condoning Nicoles behavior - just pointing out what he planted and what he harvested).

 

Hector sowed cheating by treating her like she cheated before she did.

 

Hector sowed cheating by tearing her down with his mean words and actions.

 

Hector sowed cheating by cheating before marriage and after marriage FIRST.

 

It is a silly thing for a man to think that he can cheat on his wife and thus SOW cheating and NOT REAP CHEATING.

 

Just because someone does not believe in biblical principles does not mean that they are not real. Just because somebody does not believe in gravity does not change the fact that they will bust open their head if they jump from a 10 story window because gravity does indeed exist.

 

Many times when a man thinks a woman is going to cheat, especially a macho man, then he cheats first as he does not want to be mad the fool and he is so busy projecting what is in himself onto her. It was revealed that he treated like she cheated when she did not.

 

You can have the smartest child or pet in the world but if you treat it like it is stupid, it will be stupid. You can have the most alive plant in the world, but if you treat it like it is dead by neglecting to water it and fertilize it, then it will sure enough die.

 

If both parties do not have a strong relationship with Jesus - not religion but relationship - then once the cheating poisoned one unsaved heart it will poision the victim to become a cheat as well. I have only seen woman chose not to cheat after they have been cheated on when they have a STRONG relationship with Christ.

 

Why? Because a strong relationhip with Christ means that obeying Jesus (do not commit adultery) is more important than reacting emotionally to what their husband has done to them. Without Christ, it is very easy as a human to ride the emotions and get revenge.

 

With Christ and a deep relationship where you abide in Christ, he enables people to wait to have sex until marriage, not have an affair if you are cheated on, and to not get involved with someone while you are still married. It is out of respect for 1st Christ and then yourself.

 

Christ bought us at a great price and he loves us dearly. And if Nicole understood how much Christ loved her, really loved her than this would give her the strength to stop having sex with the lover and to decide what to do with her marriage. Since they commited adultery on each other, they can divorce in God's eyes.

 

I will be praying for salvation for both Hector and Nicole as well as Shaun and Nancy. I hope that any Christian who read my post will join with me in praying for salvation for all 4 of these people and that the blinders that the prince of the world has put on their eyes will be taken off of them.

 

If Nicole, Nancy, Shaun, and Hector read this:

 

To the ladies - go to Joyce Meyer's website and look into buying her book set, dvd, workbook (used at Amazon for just a few bucks) or new on her site called Beauty for Ashes it is all about dealing with abuse and getting true healing and freedom as Joyce has been through a lot at the hands of her father and then her first husband.

 

To the men - see if Creflo Dollar, Td Jakes, or Jimmy and Karen Evan's resources online are of interest to you.

 

To all: Joyce Meyer, Jimmy and Karen Evans, and the Copelands offer free monthly magazine if you sign up on their website that address relationship stuff as well as all kinds of other areas.

 

One biblical promise is that you will lose all your wealth if you spend your time with harlots (or are a harlot) so even if you are not a believer, this spiritual law will apply. Men usually care about success and wealth so the bible promises that if you believe and obey and search after wisdom (lots can be found in Proverbs) than you have long life, wealth, riches, and abundance (since Jesus died to give us abundance and freedom).

 

We will reap what we sow. It is a very simple spiritual law. If you plant apples, you get apples. If you plant infidelity in a relationship, then you get infidelity back. In the case of Hector, he planted it, he got it back.

 

Of course, nasty things like infidelity happen to people who are faithful and this is not their fault. We live in a fallen world and will face trials and tribulations that will test our maturity and emotions.

 

So with that said:

 

If you cheat, don't be surprised or act like a hypocrite if your spouse does it back especially if they are not saved or a really strong Christian. It is not easy to stay faithful for a lifetime to someone who cheated on your first.

 

If you have been an innocent victim of infidelity, then it was a nasy thing [from Satan allowed into your life to tempt you to harbor hate and unforgiveness because that puts you in a bondage. The devil uses people closest to us to hurt us - a Judas experience. Even Jesus, has a Judas (betrayer) and a Peter (denied him 3 times) among his closest discipiles.

 

Get strong with Jesus so that you are not reduced to the lower level of retaliation and seek resources that will not only address symptoms and habits but that will address the spiritual aspect of you as well. I knew a pyschologist and professor who said that no modern psychology that he had as his disposal could change a character defect. Only a true relationship with Jesus can change that permanently.

 

God bless all who read this.

I just want to say that I realize a lot of people on this board are making very valid points, BUT...does the messages (or a lot of them) have to be more like reading a book, instead of just stating your point and be done with it?   Just wonderin......
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 6:42 pm PST

The Looney Bin

I can't stand when couples complain about each other constantly...These 2 deserve each other...They are both playing games with each other & therefore I hold no pity for either of them...If this guy is so abusive..then why has she been there so long???I think these 2 like the fighting...& more than likely they now live for it...That's the ugly nature of domestic abuse...Sometimes people get so used to it..They crave it...
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
frustrated
January 24, 2008, 7:15 pm PST

I Concur

Quote From: dannette42

I think the first couple that you gave advice  to was not the best advice I have heard you give Dr. Phil. I think just because she had a boyfriend on the side you thought she needed to give her marriage another chance. It was obvious that her husband was a abuser in a big way and that she could be in real danger. I do not think it was right that she had another man involved but understandable. I think she should have dumped the husband and other man and just move on with her life alone for a while to figure out what she wants in a partner. It was obvious that she did not want to do the 90 days that you asked her to do and I am surpised she said yes when it was clear she wanted to say no to you. The marriage is dead her husband just wants her to control her because she has let him for so long. I think you should have offered her some counseling on how to have good relationships with a partner not her husband. I think the man is very sick and harmfull for her and there children. The second couple you gave in right away that they should get divorced and there was just a lot of yelling going on in there relationship and they got married for the wrong reason but the man was sure he wanted out so you thought it was best. I think just because the first couple had another person involved you thought that was the only reason she wanted to leave him. It was much more than just another man for her. I heard her say she had been in other bad relationships so she really needed help with seeking positve loving relationships and her husband was just another poor choice... I think you should call her back and get her out of that marriage and help her with some therapy... I have never replied to these kind of things before and I just had to say something for the first time in my life because it really touched me..... Thanks for your time... Dannette
Glad to know I wasn't the only one who thought Nicole was forced into giving her marriage 90 days!!! I had to go on the record and say Dr. Phil blew the call with Hector! Did you really advise a woman to go back to the man who admitted hitting his wife AND holding a pillow over her face? As the other writer said, Nicole said she didn't have a good track record with relationships and she felt she was forced to marry Hector...now she's being forced to give this man 90 days. Why? Because he's remorseful??? Hector has violated every aspect of trust in a relationship, to include physical violence and he realizes that he's pushed his wife too far. I agree that having another man is not the solution. Do you think she looks to the other man to protect her, should Hector lose it again? Not a reason to be unfaithful...call the police! I hope this 90 days will be with her and the children in a safe place and them both getting individual and marraige counseling.
 

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2008, 7:15 pm PST

couple split

I think you gave her the wrong advice,  I know my friend had an abusive husband, and they told her , once an abuser always an abuser.  You are sending her back to the lion!!!
 
First | Prev | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | Next | Last