Message Boards

Topic : 07/17 Living on a Prayer

Number of Replies: 987
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 08, 2008, 12:25:06 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 02/15/08) What happens when a parent’s agenda becomes so extreme that his or her children are forced to live a harsh, stoic existence? Dan and Janna are a college-educated couple married for 15 years with seven children, ages ranging from 2 weeks to 14. They have no income, no heat, no running water and are about to lose their house. Dan and Janna believe that their primitive lifestyle is God’s will, and that they are being led by the Lord. Janna’s mom, Carol, and stepdad, Rich, are worried about the health of their grandchildren. Are they eating enough? Are they warm enough? They say because the children are home schooled, they live in a cult-like home environment, and are not exposed to the outside world. Carol and Rich are willing to bail this family out one last time, but why are Dan and Janna refusing the help? After eight failed businesses, why won’t Dan get a job to support his family? Where will they go when they are forced out of their home? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.


Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 9:38 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: dawneen

How are they purchasing groceries and clothes? The Picture that is displayed shows them very well dressed. How can parents not work and support their family? Are they living on an inheritance?

 

 

Exactly!!!  How did the parents know to give the exact amount $7???? to purchase a van and other items if someone had now asked them for the money?  I have a college degree with honors and was out of work for two years---  I sure sent out more than 5 resumes to Pet Shops -- in fact I sure sent out more than 5 resumes per day.  I hope someone from the child protective services steps in and forces these parents to step up or place those kids in homes where someone can help them.  It was APPALLING for the wife to sit  there at the end of the show rubbing his neck like a wounded animal while her children are being forced to live in a third-world country under our flag!
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 9:42 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: ladyrybs

1 Timothy 5:8

But if any provide not for his own, and specially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel.

 

I am sorry, but if these people are being led, they are not being led by what God has said in his word.  I don't believe God leads people contrary to what the Bible says.

 

I didn't say this . . . God said it . . . this man (Dan) has denied the faith and is worse than an infidel.  I don't know how God judges the wife Janna, except . . . 

Romans 14:12

So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.

 

I am concerned for the children's sake.

Lady

 

 

I wonder, while Dan was reading about how worthless wealth will be in the end, did he ever head over to Proverbs where it often states that a man who won't work and support his family is a disgrace to his parents? Has Jana ever read Proverbs 31? Maybe while he's breeding fish in the swimming pool and turning the garage into a greenhouse he could watch the kids while she does something productive.

But more to the point, I see them going on their feelings and not much testing about where those feelings are coming from. I don't see them comparing their feelings to the scriptures to determine how they match up. Feelings are transient as evidenced by Dan's numerous ventures. If his feelings are really consistent with God's will wouldn't something have panned out by now?

Dr. Phil is right, they cherry-pick the scriptures that suit them and ignore the inconvenient ones.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
February 16, 2008, 10:22 am PST

mzsuzyq2u

Quote From: toniecw

Again, did you not hear that the wife stated that he has four or five job applications out there and is waiting for the call back?

 

I can't remember the name of one of the authors that Oprah had on her show that wrote a book about being in the interim of life...a time and place where nothing real was being manifested...sort of like sitting at the bottom of the hole one has dug for themselves, deciding that the only way out of that hole was up...he will get up and when he does, I do hope that Dr. Phil will be a bringing him back on the show with his lovely family for all things do happen for a reason...all things...

 

I have that much faith, trust and belief that God never allows His children to fall that far from Him...gentle, caring and loving Arms...

 

Some one will spot the needs of this man and his family...just like the person that wrote on this site about all the help that God sends us and how it is up to us to decide which is valuable and which is not...what is valuable to me is the fact that in the Bible...women are to follow the lead of their Christian lead spouse...this wife is not an enabler...she is doing what God has lead her to do...if that means into a hole for a while...so be it.

 

Personally to me, when I was in love with my significant other, I would have lived in a cave just to be with him...I believe that Dr. Phil's Robin...would agree.

 

Those are my thoughts for whatever they are worth...

Love, Light and Peace

May You Be Blessed

Tonie

So the man has four or five job applications that he has sent out?  Do you honestly believe that sending only that meager amount of applications out is going to land him a job?  I am only saying this because I do not know what state they live in( (it was probably mentioned but I forgot) anyway, I live in Michigan and I have been unemployed for the last year and have sent out, without exaggeration, about 400 to 500 resumes for jobs.  Four or five applications is NOTHING.  No wonder he isn't getting work.  He is not putting any effort into it.  A person has to put a lot more energy into a job search than that.  If he is waiting for a call back on his little four or five applications, GOOD LUCK with that!  Not going to happen.  People continue to amaze me, even at this late stage in life!
 

Message Emote
frustrated
February 16, 2008, 10:28 am PST

LIVING ON A PRAYER / NOT A JOB.

Quote From: luvncheers

Yeah this family needs alot of prayers. I am sure their self pride is preventing them from getting the financial help they need from extended family members (and they should not have to be in the position to have to help). Their pride has closed their heart and mind to wise and sensible living.  

 

The first thought that went through my mind is that is alot of kids to provide for. Businesses fail alot and that is no excuse to continue to have more kids. They definately need a better plan then the one they have!

 

It really is troublesome when people throw the term "God's Will" around like they have! It is their wrong definition of "God's Will" and it has also been their excuse for continuing to live the way they have!  

 

My understanding of God's will is it means the same for everyone who chooses to follow God. God's plan does not lead families in the ditch, humans do that on their own will!

 

This is really something.

 (7) children that will grow up thinking hand out from (GOD) is the way to live.

We teach our children by example, Now tell me What kind of EXAMPLE is it when they have No running water, NO heat, No food, etc, etc, Why, Because their waiting for 'GOD' to come through for them.

Well i hate to be the one to tell them that they'll be waiting a long time.

You have to take the bull by the horn and do it yourselves, How irresponsible our these Parents? To really believe he's going to come down and turn on there POWER & WATER and  put FOOD on their TABLE.

SOMEONE NEEDS TO GET THESE CHILDREN OUT OF THIS HOUSE AND GIVE THEM A CHANCE OF LIFE. LIFE IN THE REAL WORLD WHERE PEOPLE WORK FOR WHAT THEY HAVE AND DON'T DEPEND ON HANDOUTS FROM OTHERS.

Which I'm sure their wishing they've hit GOLD because they get the chance to get help from DR Phil. (( How would it be)) Most of us work our fingers to the bone to Keep the FOOD on the table, The LIGHTS ON TO see the beauty of what we've worked for each and everyday, AND to have a HOT shower before we go to work.

I'm sorry but I don't feel sorry for the PARENTS at all. They shouldn't be Parents of (7) KIDS C'mon.

They have Neglected and abused their rights and should be made to "NEVER MAKE ANOTHER BABY".

This Subject requires help from the LAW, Not DR Phil.

 

WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT ROLE OF A PARENT-- PROTECT & PROVIDE, Which they do Either, WHY -- Because Mr. FATHER & MOTHER doesn't want to work for someone else BUT THEMSELVES.

((HOW MANY TIMES HAS HE FAILED)) EIGHT, SOMETHING ISN'T WORKING.

WHATEVER-- Take a Hint..

IT'S NOT WORKING, DO YOUR FAMILY  ((KIDS)) THE BEST THING YOU'VE DONE SENSE HAVING THEM, GIVE THEM TO SOMEONE WHO CAN PROVIDE UNTIL YOU CAN. "Plain and Simple"  WHY MAKE THEM SUFFER?

My Prayers goes out to each one of those Kids. And for the kids to have Faith IN themselves and Not to depend on God  BUT TO DEPEND ON ONE SELF.

 

PRAY TO GOD, PRAYERS ARE ALWAYS THE BEST WAY TO FEEL GOOD ABOUT ONES SELF, HAVE FAITH IN GOD. AND MOST OF ALL HAVE YOUR OWN HOPES & DREAMS. AND IF YOU WANT IT BAD ENOUGH IT WILL HAPPENED, IT ALWAYS DOES.  YOU JUST HAVE TO WORK HARD AND HAVE FAITH.

GOOD LUCK TO THE KIDS. YOU ALL ARE BEAUTIFUL. "CHILDREN OF GOD"

 

Pray to GOD, Have faith in GOD. ask GOD for the strength and love to see you through life, GOD does listen, but he doesn't turn on lights and give you food and water.

Amen.

God Bless each one of those neglected Kids.♥

Bella

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 10:30 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

This guy is not a father...he is a sperm donor.  There is a big differance.  He is hiding behind his relition.  When his family gives him money to feed his family and provide for them...he spends the money on himself and his hair-brained schemes.   To me this is just total selfishness at tbe expense of his children  His wife is just as stupid as he is.  Both of them are college-educated "idiots".

 

If I was the grandmother I would start proceedings in getting these children out of this environment.  Living without heat is bad....but living without running water is horrible.  This breeds all kinds of diseases.

 

I am a very devout Christian and without prayer I could not have made it in my life.  God has provided doors for me....but it is up to me to walk through those doors.   The truest statement on earth is GOD HELPS THOSE WHO HELP THEMSELVES.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 10:53 am PST

It is all about the enablers

There is a difference between a disaster (a hurraine destroyng your home) and a mess of your own creation.  Helping others in a time of crises is honorable, but it ceases to have any impact on those who insist on making life choices that are at its core - entirely selfish.  
Dan and Jana live ths way because they CAN. 

 

If those around them STOP giving $, etc....  Jana or Dan or both will have to provide for themselves.  Jana's parents should call social services if they have concerns about the children. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 10:57 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

this is not about religion at all.  this is about control, pure and simple.  when Dan says the lord is leading him to sell red light blockers or whatever, what it means is "i don't want to work for someone because that means i am not in control and i don't have the power".  Dan wants control and power, even at the expense of his children and wife.  which only proves that faith isn't the problem, it's the faithful. 

 

Dan wants to call the shots in every aspect of his life and not have anyone tell him what to do.  why did his father-in-law fire him?  why was that not discussed?  the answer might have been very revealing.  and what was his upbringing like?  why was that not brought up?

 

as someone else remarked, he may well be suffering from depression, which is a very selfish, very self-centered disease.  it is anger turned inward, and judging by his appearance on Dr. Phil, Dan is a very angry man, and he is using religion as an excuse for his behavior, which is totally bogus.

 

one more time, this isn't about religious faith.  this is about a control freak, and no amount of prayers and scriptures will change THAT.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 10:59 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: polarburg

I think Dr. Phil missed the boat on this one, for a couple reasons. Here are my observations:

1. Dr. Phil was off-base by saying that we should't "cherry pick" when it comes to the Bible. The fact is, the Bible is filled with so many nutty things (instructing how to beat your slaves, death to all non-believers, not having sex because the world will end soon, leave your wife and kids for Jesus, etc. etc.), you pretty much have to pick some things from the Good Book, and forget about the rest.

2. It looked like the kids were home-schooled (that may have been mentioned). Dr. P. should have insisted that the children go to school, if for no other other reason than to get them at least one, and probably two hot meals a day. It also would be good to get the kids away from these two kooks for at least a few hours every day.

3. As for providing for his family, that won't happen -- not with seven kids. He's not going to find a job that pulls down that kind of money. That boat sailed a long time ago. But getting a job to get heath coverage would be a good idea.

4. The family has to start getting food stamps and welfare.

5. Despite their bizarre -- and maybe creepy -- lifestyle, I have to admit that this is a loving family, and their children, although intellectually, medically and nutritionally deprived, do seem amazingly happy and healthy. Not the worst family I've seen on the show, by a long shot.

6. He should have told the parents something like: "You might want to consider that God sent you to me for some advice, so you might want to take it."




No offense but based on your comments in # 1 you haven't read the Bible.

-Bryan
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 11:05 am PST

02/15 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: natalielynn

The Amish who are some of the most God Fearing, hard working people I know,  have a saying.  "If you want a helping hand, look at the end of your Arm."  These two are two hosts short of a Eucharist, him bordering I feel on Psychotic, and I believe both parents are a danger to themselves and these kids.  Both parents need a psychiatric tune-up, and the children need to be removed from this home and placed in a healthy and safe environment.  To put your children through this in the name of God, is not only offensive Dr. Phil...it's abusive. I hope to God you did not leave this family where I think you did. 
Splitting up a loving family is not the solution here. Love trumps living conditions, every time out.

But obviously, as Phil said, Dan needs to go find work and stop seeking "the next big thing" as far as the attempts at his own business ventures go. It may be something as simple as a burning passion and desire to succeed at his own business, but Dan needs to put that aside (or ON the side) and go find steady work asap. That's the solution here.

Splitting up the family would be an incredibly foolish thing to do.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
February 16, 2008, 11:08 am PST

OH PLEASE!!!!

  I was not raised in a christian home but have decided to live my life for the Lord and am raising my kids the same way. I have a hard time believing that any parent no matter what their faith would purposely put their children in harms way. I'm a divorced mother of two working two jobs just a tad over minimum wage and I find it hard to make it. We get by the bills are always paid and I'm buying my home but still just with what I make and two kids I don't see how they can live with themselves knowing that they can do better. I believe in the power of prayer and I know that God will provide but....he only provides us with the resources we need to make it on our own...he will not pay the bills or put food on the table, he points us in the direction we need to go to make that happen. 1 Timothy 5:8 says...But those who won't care for their relatives, ESPECIALLY those in their own household, have denied the true faith.Such people are worse than unbelievers.  I know when my daughter was diagnosed with Epilepsy we laid hands on and prayed every sunday service and every day at home but I also knew meds would be the only way to stop her  anguish. God gave us the resources to make a trip to Minnesota and see a specialist God gave us the resources to get the Meds we needed but he did not heal her the meds did...God gives direction and resources not the actual means, praying for those resources is great but we have to use what God gives us and put it to use. I think that this family is lost to the true meaning of  what God actually does for us and I also think that  maybe they need some Pastoral Enlightening.
 
First | Prev | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | Next | Last