Message Boards

Topic : 07/17 Living on a Prayer

Number of Replies: 987
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 08, 2008, 12:25:06 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 02/15/08) What happens when a parent’s agenda becomes so extreme that his or her children are forced to live a harsh, stoic existence? Dan and Janna are a college-educated couple married for 15 years with seven children, ages ranging from 2 weeks to 14. They have no income, no heat, no running water and are about to lose their house. Dan and Janna believe that their primitive lifestyle is God’s will, and that they are being led by the Lord. Janna’s mom, Carol, and stepdad, Rich, are worried about the health of their grandchildren. Are they eating enough? Are they warm enough? They say because the children are home schooled, they live in a cult-like home environment, and are not exposed to the outside world. Carol and Rich are willing to bail this family out one last time, but why are Dan and Janna refusing the help? After eight failed businesses, why won’t Dan get a job to support his family? Where will they go when they are forced out of their home? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 7:57 am PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: bjkaes

How could these people put their children through a life like this?!? Two college graduates sitting around watching their kids sleep on cold hard floors with no running water or food! Apply for state help or something! He could be a substitute teacher and make a $100 a day or she could waitress at night ! I would dig ditches before I would let my kids go hungry! Please give these people some birth control! what kind of quality of life for the kids is this!?! I am so infuriated by these lazy, selfish people!

In most states you have to have your teaching credential to substitute teach, but I totally agree with you, I would dig ditches before my kids would live in those deplorable conditions. If that was my husband and he wasn't willing to work, I would tell him to take care of the children and the house and I'll work. A couple days of watching all those kids and scrubbing the kitchen floor may be an incentive for him to get out and support his family.

 

I think how many children a person has is certainly there choice. My husband and I purposely stopped at two, although we both love kids, but we looked down the road and knew two was about all we could afford.  I know money isn't everything but raising kids is not cheap and the cost just rises with their age.  It is just something people should think about when they are doing their family planning.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 8:56 am PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: jewelsf

   Are you kidding me?! I don't understand how you can so easily defend this man. He is not a lost little lamb, but a scammer who is too lazy to hold down a job. He's very good at getting every last penny of his wife's parents that was put away for their retirement, to the tune of over $50,000.00! That was hard earned money the he certainly didn't work for. And yet, with that "hand up" and a college degree he still couldn't get his act together? I take offense when you implied that "he has already done way more in his life than most of these people ever have". Again, are you kidding me? What exactly has this man done? Make more babies than he can afford to support? Yes, he is good at that! And they still continue to bring even more into this world while they cannot provide a roof over their heads, running water, heat in the winter time, and no telling what else.

   My husband is a responsible man. He is 60 years old and has worked full time since the age of 15. In the last 40 years he has worked between 110 to 140 hours per week, 7 days a week for 6 months out of the year, and 6 days a week for the other 6 months. Yet you dare to compare this man to someone like my husband? I don't think so! He has health problems at this point and needs to retire out, but he can't because I became disabled 7 years ago. We need to keep our health insurance going, even though I qualify for Medicare, we need a good prescription coverage plan for the both of us. So he doesn't have the luxury of deciding to "just not work". And BTW, we don't expect anyone to give us a handout, we take care of ourselves!

   You say that there has been no crime committed by the parents? I disagree! What about child endangerment or neglect? I believe that those are crimes. People get arrested for treating their pets in this manner. Why does the Dr. Phil show or anyone else for that matter need to help this man find a job? He has a college degree! He can get off of his butt and get out there and find a job just like everyone else has to do. What makes him better than anyone else? Nothing. How did you find your job? Did you look for yourself or did someone find it for you? When I was able to work, I had to find jobs on my own, that's pretty much the way it works.

   It's because of people like you that a man (and I use that term loosely) such as him expect to be able to get away with this type of behavior and refuse to take any responsibility for themselves. That would be fine if it was just him and his wife, they are adults and if they prefer to sleep under a bridge, that is their prerogative. But they have 7 children at home who didn't sign on for this type of life. Since when did the word "Responsibility" become a four letter word?

   Put an arm around this guy and guide him with love? Ugh! He needs to grow up!

Dan is a very well-rehearsed scammer.   He postures behind religion that manages to befuddle and fool people.  And this pariah on society, with his selective religious reasoning will never change.  You can sit and try to dissect it from a religious, psychological or any other perspective--but this man will not change until the pay off for him being this way changes.  His current pay off is the saccharine sentimentality and/or adulation of "Christians" who aid and abet his self-invoked victimhood status.  He's a proven moocher on his enabling in-laws.  And his "attempts at business"  that he claims failed, are obviously only get-rich-quick-schemes of the most questionable ilk.  Now, if had started a lawn service, humbly with a mower and willingness to work for instance,  and stuck with it...  But, he doesn't want to work.  

 

If nobody steps in to give him money, his next step will be to send his wife out to earn a living.  I guarantee that. Eventually even losers get hungry enough.   

 

He is a hopeless user and loser.  a real man isn't happy wallowing in "victimhood."   His kids will grow up to hate him.  I guarantee that as well.  And they will hate their mother as well unless she gets a clue and starts doing right by them and jettisoning this SOB of humanity that she keeps spawning children with as her only significant contribution to the world.  Big deal.  Most women with the right biology can birth children.  The greater significance is in providing them with a real life.  And this family is being denied their childhood.  There is no greater abuse that a parent can heap on a child than denying him or her a childhood.  If she gets a clue soon enough, she can give them back the childhood this derelict of a husband has stolen from them. 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 9:39 am PDT

Cognitive Dissonance

Quote From: ladyrybs

1 Timothy 5:8

But if any provide not for his own, and specially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel.

 

I am sorry, but if these people are being led, they are not being led by what God has said in his word.  I don't believe God leads people contrary to what the Bible says.

 

I didn't say this . . . God said it . . . this man (Dan) has denied the faith and is worse than an infidel.  I don't know how God judges the wife Janna, except . . . 

Romans 14:12

So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.

 

I am concerned for the children's sake.

Lady

 

 

I'm not saying that this man shouldn't get a job, because he should. And I'm not saying the bible doesn't say that a man is not required to provide for his family, because it does; but just not a 1 Timothy 5:8. This is without question the first and foremost verse that people use to support such a view. But if you read the context, it's not talking about a husband's responsibility at all. It's talking about provision for widows AFTER the husband is dead for goodness sakes ! The person or persons this passage is talking about are the widow's children and/or grandchildren who do not provide for their widowed mother and/or grandmother. THEY are the ones who are worse than infidels if they do not provide for their widowed mother and/or grandmother. And certainly not the deceased husband. Because afterall he's dead already. So how can he be worse than an infidel for not providing for his family from beyond the grave ?  The context is clear as the difference between night and day. And anyone who disagrees is obviously suffering from cognitive dissonance.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 12:55 pm PDT

I disagree!

Quote From: fascinate

My hit was that this man probably  has Aspergers. He manifested the characteristics. He has had many jobs all relating to his special interest at the moment. I am sure some people make a living selling tropical fish, golfing, or growing trees but it requires a lot of skill, planning, and training to do so. He is very willing to work and does so frequently just very poorly. I saw this man as someone pretty clueless as to what is required to get and maintain a job. I also saw him as pretty clueless as to how to maintain marital and parental relationships and expectations. Most people with untreated AS attempt self-employment because they lack the skills to work for others. Many people with AS have college degrees, sometimes up to PhD's but often with No successful employment due to poor communication, poor social relating, rigid thinking, and poor cause and effect.

My son who has autism, mental retardation, bipolar disorder and Fetal Alcohol Syndrome has had a very difficult time with employment. (He's adopted for all of you who are getting ready to cast stones at me.) He quit one job because one supervisor told him he could plug in the vacuum cleaner in one spot and another told him he had to plug it in another spot which kept coming unplugged. His psychiatrist of 10 years said, Of course he would not be able to deal with that kind of discrepancy of expectations because he has autism! Check with anyone who has experience with adults who have Aspergers and I am sure you will find that my opinion is not off base. I did not diagnose him but strongly suggested that he be evaluated for Aspergers and he and his family be given appropriate resources to understand and support each other.
This man is NOT willing to work and does NOT do it frequently! Why doesn't he at the very least get a job at 7-11 so he can pay the water bill? Your sympathy for this man is misplaced. I agree with the message that was posted in response to you by Feisty. (I think that's who it was!) And BTW, if he managed to get a college degree, that happens to take a lot of concentration and hard work, then why can't he also hold down a job. Even if he doesn't have very good people skills, there are thousands of jobs that include coming into contact with the public. I just completely disagree with your point here. You are trying to hard to look for answers as to why this man is the way that he is, face it, it's just because he is selfish and lazy. That's all there is to it!
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
chillin'
July 25, 2008, 2:07 pm PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: jewelsf

This man is NOT willing to work and does NOT do it frequently! Why doesn't he at the very least get a job at 7-11 so he can pay the water bill? Your sympathy for this man is misplaced. I agree with the message that was posted in response to you by Feisty. (I think that's who it was!) And BTW, if he managed to get a college degree, that happens to take a lot of concentration and hard work, then why can't he also hold down a job. Even if he doesn't have very good people skills, there are thousands of jobs that include coming into contact with the public. I just completely disagree with your point here. You are trying to hard to look for answers as to why this man is the way that he is, face it, it's just because he is selfish and lazy. That's all there is to it!

You go girl!!

Why is it  so easy for people to 'diagnose' someone instead of calling it like it is?

Yes, I know their are medical/psychiatric conditions that exist and proper diagnosis is necessary. I also know that laziness, selfishness, stupidity, lack of responsibility, lack of self control etc etc also exist and a proper 'wake-up call' is necessary!

It is time for people to be made responsible for their actions... not find excuses for them!

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
July 28, 2008, 1:45 pm PDT

You are so Feisty!

Quote From: feistyd

You go girl!!

Why is it  so easy for people to 'diagnose' someone instead of calling it like it is?

Yes, I know their are medical/psychiatric conditions that exist and proper diagnosis is necessary. I also know that laziness, selfishness, stupidity, lack of responsibility, lack of self control etc etc also exist and a proper 'wake-up call' is necessary!

It is time for people to be made responsible for their actions... not find excuses for them!

I am so happy that someone else can see things the same way as I do! There have been others of course, and I appreciate them too. I am so sick of the people who are trying to find every excuse in the book to justify what this man is dong and for his irresponsibility. I get especially irate when others have said that he has done more than most people will ever do in their lives! That one really gets me. It is such a slap in the face when I think about the hours my own husband has had to put in over the years. He certainly hasn't enjoyed the fast pace and long hours that goes along with the business that he is in. But, it is his job, he's a little old to go back to college now and just has to take it and ride it out until he can retire. For over 43 years he has worked the equivalent of 2 full time jobs and one part time job. That is the hours for his ONE job! He tries to take off early occasionally but the minute he leaves everything starts to fall apart and his phone starts ringing non stop. It's just not worth it. He's in produce and when the produce is ready in the field, it's ready. You can't just leave it there for the next day, it won't be worth anything the next day. It's a weird business! And very hard to explain. There is so much more to it than the field hands picking it in the field and it showing up on the grocery store shelves. Yep, I do get irate! My husband is very smart and inventive and could sit at home and doodle with things and call it his "business" but it sure won't get the mortgage paid. And something else I just thought about? They have 7 children? And one is just an infant? They can't possibly have health insurance! So for all of his admirer's here on the board, who do they think is paying for all of her pre-natal care and hospital bills when she gives birth? They don't have the cash to do it. So I guess it falls to the state. Oh yes, I'm so proud of them! We pay $800.00 per month, out of our own pocket for our health insurance. And how do we pay for that? Because my husband works and I get a disability check that I worked and paid into. I don't even use my Medicare, although they take out over $100.00 a month for it. I'm forced into laziness due to my disability and I would LOVE to be able to go back to work. For me, it would be a privilege. And how about all of the single mothers out there with deadbeat dads who refuse to help provide for their children? They hold down jobs and take responsibility for their lives. They should receive the applause that this man is receiving. And even the field workers, that is a back breaking job with very little pay. Seriously, you will never find us "white" people doing that kind of work. If it weren't for them, we would have no more produce! I have more respect for them! Yes, I could go on, I have already been on quite a tangent here haven't I?

Peace and Power to the non lazy hard working people in the world!

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2008, 8:49 am PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: meandmyfaith

I'm not saying that this man shouldn't get a job, because he should. And I'm not saying the bible doesn't say that a man is not required to provide for his family, because it does; but just not a 1 Timothy 5:8. This is without question the first and foremost verse that people use to support such a view. But if you read the context, it's not talking about a husband's responsibility at all. It's talking about provision for widows AFTER the husband is dead for goodness sakes ! The person or persons this passage is talking about are the widow's children and/or grandchildren who do not provide for their widowed mother and/or grandmother. THEY are the ones who are worse than infidels if they do not provide for their widowed mother and/or grandmother. And certainly not the deceased husband. Because afterall he's dead already. So how can he be worse than an infidel for not providing for his family from beyond the grave ?  The context is clear as the difference between night and day. And anyone who disagrees is obviously suffering from cognitive dissonance.

Silly arguments about what "Christian" scripture means or doesn't mean is a subterfuge, just as his Dan's blather about what "God told him."

 

In fact, the fact that professing Christians themselves argue among themselves over the nonsense in this collection of words.   The only benefits this book brings to humanity is the fact that it provides a living for seminary graduates and others who cannot function in the working world.   And it provides fodder for professing Christians to use in lieu of having their own opinions based on the actual facts of a matter.  It's a collection of writings of ancients whose mental state of mind we cannot even verify, and "approved" as "canon" by a bunch of power-hungry men who wanted to further their influence over people by incorporating this belief system into a state religion, at the Council of Nicea.   That's all it's been used for since--a body of writings used to control people and make some rich in the process. 

 

Some of the teachings contained therein have validity.  But even those basic tenets, such as "Doing unto others" can also be found in other equally as prolific and enduring religious writings from Eastern thought and elsewhere.  These basic teachings, most of which you won't find in "Christianity" today if you visit or try to get involved in a church, are not unique to Christianity.  They endure because they are true to the human condition and what's best for us.

 

So, bringing this into this discussion of this derelict is a waste of time.   Believing or not believing in "the bible" and trying to sort out its myriad of conflicting or vague words and teachings is for those who have nothing better to do.   And as we can see, Dan here has nothing better to do with his time or energy.

 

The discussion is about a grown man who will not go out and subject himself to working for someone else in order to provide for his children.  And the discussion is about a mindless woman who thinks this is okay for the children she has brought into this world.   There are plenty more like them of every persuasion and creed.  They have no defense.   They only have obligations to become productive members of society and take care of their family's needs.   They are not special, as they believe they are.  They are not entitled, as they believe they are.  They are not victims, as they want to project.   

 

I thank Dr. Phil for highlighting this type of situation for the incredible insanity that it is.  I hope that some woman watching gets the courage to leave this type of situation and take care of her kids.  Because,  this kind of man will not change.  I know whereof I speak. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2008, 7:12 pm PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: bjkaes

How could these people put their children through a life like this?!? Two college graduates sitting around watching their kids sleep on cold hard floors with no running water or food! Apply for state help or something! He could be a substitute teacher and make a $100 a day or she could waitress at night ! I would dig ditches before I would let my kids go hungry! Please give these people some birth control! what kind of quality of life for the kids is this!?! I am so infuriated by these lazy, selfish people!

He could substitute teach?   OMG.  I wouldn't want someone with his issues or lack of values anywhere near my child, or anyone's child.  Come to think of it, I don't even like thinking about him and his influence on his own children.   Perish that thought!

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
happy
July 30, 2008, 8:15 am PDT

They don't deserve it!

Quote From: bjkaes

How could these people put their children through a life like this?!? Two college graduates sitting around watching their kids sleep on cold hard floors with no running water or food! Apply for state help or something! He could be a substitute teacher and make a $100 a day or she could waitress at night ! I would dig ditches before I would let my kids go hungry! Please give these people some birth control! what kind of quality of life for the kids is this!?! I am so infuriated by these lazy, selfish people!
This adult couple with 2 college degrees between them do not deserve government help. They are not disabled in any way, they are not capable of getting jobs, they are just too lazy to work. Government funds are for the people who are truly needy. But I do agree that digging ditches or even working at a fast food place would be better than nothing. It doesn't matter what type of work that you do, honest pay for an honest days work is admirable no matter the type of job. If my husband lost his job and couldn't find another within his current level, he would do anything to keep money coming in, even if it was 7-11 or any mini mart and I would have total respect for him because of it. He would never allow for us to go hungry, be homeless, or to have no running water or beds to sleep in, no matter what he had to do. I would work but I can't, I am permanently disabled. It's people like me that deserve government assistance, in my case in the form of Social Security Disability. I worked for over 20 years and paid into it during the whole time, I have earned it!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
July 31, 2008, 3:43 pm PDT

07/17 Living on a Prayer

Quote From: meme22

Silly arguments about what "Christian" scripture means or doesn't mean is a subterfuge, just as his Dan's blather about what "God told him."

 

In fact, the fact that professing Christians themselves argue among themselves over the nonsense in this collection of words.   The only benefits this book brings to humanity is the fact that it provides a living for seminary graduates and others who cannot function in the working world.   And it provides fodder for professing Christians to use in lieu of having their own opinions based on the actual facts of a matter.  It's a collection of writings of ancients whose mental state of mind we cannot even verify, and "approved" as "canon" by a bunch of power-hungry men who wanted to further their influence over people by incorporating this belief system into a state religion, at the Council of Nicea.   That's all it's been used for since--a body of writings used to control people and make some rich in the process. 

 

Some of the teachings contained therein have validity.  But even those basic tenets, such as "Doing unto others" can also be found in other equally as prolific and enduring religious writings from Eastern thought and elsewhere.  These basic teachings, most of which you won't find in "Christianity" today if you visit or try to get involved in a church, are not unique to Christianity.  They endure because they are true to the human condition and what's best for us.

 

So, bringing this into this discussion of this derelict is a waste of time.   Believing or not believing in "the bible" and trying to sort out its myriad of conflicting or vague words and teachings is for those who have nothing better to do.   And as we can see, Dan here has nothing better to do with his time or energy.

 

The discussion is about a grown man who will not go out and subject himself to working for someone else in order to provide for his children.  And the discussion is about a mindless woman who thinks this is okay for the children she has brought into this world.   There are plenty more like them of every persuasion and creed.  They have no defense.   They only have obligations to become productive members of society and take care of their family's needs.   They are not special, as they believe they are.  They are not entitled, as they believe they are.  They are not victims, as they want to project.   

 

I thank Dr. Phil for highlighting this type of situation for the incredible insanity that it is.  I hope that some woman watching gets the courage to leave this type of situation and take care of her kids.  Because,  this kind of man will not change.  I know whereof I speak. 

We obviously view the Bible differently. To you, it's men's words. To me, it's God's Word. But, on this, we agree. Bible verses, taken out-of-context, are often used to justify some totally  bazaar, off-the-wall, out-there behaviors. And, in this case, it's biblical hair-splitting used as a subterfuge to justify Dan's lifestyle. A man's family is his wife and children.
 
First | Prev | 93 | 94 | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | Next | Last