Topic : 07/23 Ask the Doctors

Number of Replies: 199
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 04, 2008, 02:09:08 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/08/08) Imagine having your doctor on speed dial to answer your questions 24/7. Here's your chance, because The Doctors (link to: /shows/page/TheDoctors)  are back! Dr. Phil welcomes OB/GYN Dr. Lisa Masterson, family therapist Dr. Tara Fields, pediatrician Dr. Jim Sears, plastic surgeon Dr. Andrew Ordon, and E.R. physician Dr. Travis Stork. Join their conversation and hear their valuable insights on the hottest medical topics of the day, including actor Heath Ledger's untimely death and the rise in breast augmentation surgery. Next, meet Jennifer, a wife and mother who's so afraid of her family getting sick and dying from germs, that she won't handle cash or mail, she wears three different pairs of shoes each day -- a pair for in the house, one for out of the house, and one for in the car -- and won't even greet family members from out of town until they've come in and showered! Is Jennifer's house as germ free as she thinks it is? Dr. Phil sends a microbiologist to find out. Then, meet a woman who got married and was ready to start a family only to find out that the man she fell in love with was making her physically ill. And, meet a couple who are at odds over a serious medical dilemma involving their 3-year-old son. Should they amputate his legs? Plus, is there a medical question you're dying to know the answer to but are too embarrassed to ask? Be there when The Doctors answer viewer questions on topics ranging from breastfeeding to penis enlargement, and then talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.


User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
July 24, 2008, 6:14 am PDT

Jaya's legs

As I was watching the segment yesterday on little Jaya and the debate as the whether or not to amputate his legs, my heart dropped to my feet.  To see this handsome little boy say that he wanted those legs would be, as a mother myself, all I had to hear to understand that it is entirely too early to make that decision.  While I have a 3 year old as well, I am fortunate enough for him to not have a disability.  I can't imagine how hard it is on the parents, but can you imagine how traumatized this poor little boy would be when he woke up without legs?  You can't reason with a 3 year old as to why they cant have candy until after dinner, much less why the legs he had yesterday are gone today.  Once they are gone you cannot get them back.  You may tell him he will have "new legs" and get a postive answer from him, but does he know his new legs would now be made of metal and not attached to his body?   Just thinking of it makes me teary eyed.  Wait until he is old enough to make this decision where he can UNDERSTAND what you are saying and UNDERSTAND that his legs will  be gone FOREVER.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 24, 2008, 6:28 am PDT

re

Quote From: vickyliz7

I think that Jaya's mother is obsessed with the idea of having her son's legs amputated. That situation has got to be extremely scary for Jaya. If he brought up the idea later on then it would be a different story. He should make the decision and enjoy his childhood without having to hear mommy obsess how cutting off his legs. He is precious and innocent and she needs to keep him that way. This is child abuse. I think she needs counseling and her son is not safe with her. This talk can damage him psychologically.
i think its up to you but if its was me i wood yes if you do truely love him
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 24, 2008, 6:33 am PDT

re

Quote From: hebbysmom

I have an 18 year old with Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus. Heather is seen in the pic with some of her friends at her high school semi formal dance. She has had 47 + surgeries and procedures. Many of them orthopedic.

When I saw Jayas legs on the show it reminded me of how my daughters legs looked. However, I would strongly oppose such a surgery. It was never given as an option, nor was it ever thought of by myself.

The two disabilities are greatly different I do realize that. That being said, Jayas legs are part of who he is.

 

I wish there way a way that Jayas mother could meet my daughter Heather. She gives me hope and faith. She gives me courage and strentgh. I love her unconditionally for who she is. She is a very independant person, with a big heart. She is always smiling.

 

I feel that her legs have never been an issue, primarily because we have never made them an issue. She has had third degree burns on her feet, made worse by her not feeling the pain of it, which caused delay in treatment. She has constantly scraped up her legs and feet, from crawling. BUT considering the risk of any surgery, I would not change the scrapes and gouges. They are no different in my eyes then if my youngest fell off a bike and scraped her knee. The only difference is Heather cannot feel the pain.

 

I have been there and seen my daughter on life support, almost dying from septic shock caused by infection post-surgery. This was not even an elective surgery. I have also seen Heather have a grand mal seizure that almost killed her after a surgery. It is scary, to think that your child will not wake up, and more scary to watch the situation unfold. It is so much easier to deal with the legs, then the thought of what could happen. To put a child in that situation, I would not do it. It is NOT worth the risk. In my opinion it is almost considered child abuse. It is elective and in my opinion it is very unnecessary.

 

My daughter has grown into a beautiful young woman. I do not see disability when I look at my daughter, only ability.

 

This mother needs to stop looking at Jayas legs as an inconvienence to her.

My love to Sick Kids in Toronto as well. They have saved Heathers life many times! Thank you just doesn't seem to cut it.............I owe them so much more.

i agee with you i just make him un camable that his mom keeps looking at his legs
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
July 24, 2008, 6:48 am PDT

Mine, too!

Quote From: dlongga

Please tell me you aren't serious! Breastfed babies are SOO much healthier and thrive more than formula fed babies, not to mention they are mcuh earlier in development. My granddaughter just turned 5 mo old, she rolls over, she sleeps all nite (and has since she was 3 weeks old)...she is a very happy baby. She watches your mouth when you speak to her or make sounds and she imitates the sounds and has done that for 3 months. She is currently trying to say "MAMA" ...she also is the most content serene child I have ever seen. And she is never sick, her immune system is very strong.

My oldest son and his brother both did those same things.  In fact, my oldest is the top of his class despite being almost a year younger than most of his classmates.  I sense a huge amount of pride in your posts about your granddaughter and that's great.  However, great kids are made from more than one or two choices.  It is their whole environment that determines their overall  well being.   Oh, by the way, things like "serene" aren't really attributed to breastfeeding as my sons were not ever , nor ever will be "serene" but they are happy. 

 

Oh and I never breastfed!!!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
sad
July 24, 2008, 11:24 am PDT

Adive for someone who was on the show

Dr.Phil,

          I watched the Dr.Phil show yesterday (July 23,2008), and the mom with the 3 year old son really upset me. I haven't been able to stop thinking about this since the show. My friend has something called spina bifida, and its pretty much like what the little biy has. her spinal cord is messed up and she cant walk or even fell her legs either. She has had sergery since the day she was born. I talked to her about the mom on the show wanting to cut off her sons legs and she fells the same as me, we think that she should keep the legs and maybe later n life if she still feels this way then she can let him make the decsion of wheater or not he wants to. She said that it would be wrong if she did that because she wants her legs and would if her parents had cut them off! I think that she really should let her son make that decsion for his self, and hes only three hes too young for that right now.

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
July 24, 2008, 1:59 pm PDT

it sure isnt pimples

I was a regular, healthy, kick-butt, go-getter guy... until I got this stuff. I must only have the agrobacteria because I have every symptom except the colored fibres. Judith... thank you so very much for being on TV, I was begining to think it was just me. Just to have some idea of what is going on is sorta comforting.

 

I was also a farming and an outdoor guy, lotsa tick encounters, but I have not had one in many years.

 I somewhat suspect several sources: small nats could be the carriers, I have seen some species I have never seen in the Midwest before, the kind that are around dead fish on the bank of a river.
This whole thing for me started with what I thought was a sac spider or wolly centiped bite on the side of my head. My house had alot of them.
A Dr. also mentioned moldy houses and pollen from trees - there are more moldy houses than ever before, including mine, and the Elm trees had a massive pollen release this year... what eats tree pollen? What eats the stuff that eats tree pollen?

 

I only had one bump (that went away, by itself completely) on my armpits, so I figured there might be something to that. I used Right Guard Extreem covered by Caladryl as the best remedy before upgrading to the ultra-relieving wonderful drug Celephaxin.

 

I have been bitten by almost every bug in the Midwest - this aint like nuthin' I ever had before.
Without the stupid Dr. Phil show I would have been hookin' up batteries or something next. I await what you find Dr.(s). ...and your show is no longer stupid.


I took Celephaxin a few years ago for this, I thought I was cured too. Then it came back, and Im on it again.
This sucks, girls can tell too, they dont smile at me anymore.
Gas station attendants put the money on the counter, not in your hand.
Talk about the road to ailenation.
 I would not wish this on my worst enemy... ever.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 8:39 am PDT

Breast Implants

Quote From: fluffyfat

I'm glad the doctors are going to talk about this subject. I think the growing poularity of breast augmentation is shocking. How is it different from the foot-binding Chinese women had done in the 19th Century or the African tribal women with lip plates and neck rings? Unless women are getting implants for medical reasons after mastectomys, it's exactly the same!

[bThese women are volunteering to have their chests cut open and foreign devices implanted -- for the sole reason of pleasing the sexual fetishes of men. [/b


They will tell you that they're doing it for themselves but that's obviously untrue. Would they be getting implants if they lived on a deserted island? Men once considered large breasts unattractive, as evidenced by the old paintings in which women were plump but had apple sized breasts. Somewhere along the line big breasts became fashionable in the world of pornography and now the average high-school girl considers herself unworthy as a lust object until she goes through this surgery.

It's not in the same area as make-up and hair coloring because those things are inexpensive and neither permanent nor dangerous. Have some pride, women! If you can't get a man to like you without having surgical alterations to your body then he isn't worth having!

I guess you women who have actual breasts are the ones who are judging--even the "doctor" on the panel.  I got breast implants almost a year and a half ago and it wasn't for ANY man whatsoever!!  It was for ME.  Do you know what it is like to never have develpoed breasts--even after having 5 babies?  I felt deformed and so unfeminine.   I couldn't even find any bras to fit or clothes to fit me right since they are made for women with breasts to fill them out.  How about swimsuits--do you know what that is like not being able to fill out a swimsuit?  I could easliy have been mistaken for a male if the lights were off (or even just a breast shot) --actually i was by my own husband!!  I was lying on my stomach trying to sleep and he came in and touched me in the dark thinking he was touching my "breasts" and it was my shoulder blades!!!!

How about being made fun of -- I have heard all the jokes all my life and have been made fun of--even as an adult!!  I have been embarrassed and humiliated and degraded for having no breasts!!!  I am not for porn whatsoever and am soooo against it!!  I think women thinking they have to get naked and show their breasts in movies is ridiculous--there is no purpose for it!!!  Now talk about wanting attention!!!  Those women are the ones who are out to please men and doing it for men!!  THEY are the ones degrading themselves!! 

 

Now with implants/breasts I feel like a woman--look like a woman---and feel so much better in my own skin.   I didn't do it for any man's attention.  I got my share of it to begin with.  And if I do find men staring at my chest it bothers me bc that isn't why I got them.  I want to be talked to in the eye and be respected and if that is all a man wants to do is look at me or talk to me bc all he sees are a pair of breasts then he isn't worth talking to and he is a pig!! 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 1:37 pm PDT

GIVEN A CHANCE

Quote From: marianparoo

As a woman who was born with a serious orthodpedic birth defect, I went through more operations than even my mother remembers (I started with the whole business at 9 months old when I fell shortly after I started walking - the  bone didn't heal and the condition was diagnosed).

 

My condition is different than Jaya's, and now the treatment is more efficient (although essentially the same, I was just one of the first children to have the op that got me walking in the right direction).

 

But my gut feeling is that Jaya might well have have a happier childhood if his legs are amputated than if he has to go through years of surgeries. And, from what I noticed from my own childhood is that scars and limps make a bigger target for the cruelty of children than prostheses.

 

Many, many hugs and hope to this child and the family.

 

By the way, the first major op I had that got me walking was at Sick Kids in Toronto. I lived in the USA at that time, and they still weren't doing that kind of op anywhere in the United States.

 

My love to Sick Kids and Toronto, Canada forever!!!!!!!

Dear Dr.Phil,

 

After watching your show ask the doctors. I was brought to tears concerning Jay and his parents inability to make a decison on whether or not to amputate his legs.

 

I am 50 years old,born with a condition called spina bifad.I too am parapalegic.I have had numerous surgerical procedures throughout my life,and many scars

 

.At age 8 my mother on the advice of a doctor decided to have my legs amputated.At  this age i did not understand the impact that might have played throught the rest of my life.

 

The reasoning for the amputation was my legs were scared,bent and basically useless.My father intervened on this decision.and refused to consent to the surgery.Thank God he did.

 

I today still have my legs.the ones i was born with.They are still in the condition they were when my mother decided to have them removed.They are a part of me.and have been useful to me.

 

People do not understand what they are doing when they make or attempt to make decisions in the best interest of someone who is so called less fortunate

 

I understand the love of a mother and wanting only to do the best and right things for their children.I too am a mother of 2 children.and grandmother of 2 .

 

When a person has something that doesn't work they learn to compensate .That i believe is a gift from God and a natural survival instinct we all as human beings have.

 

Sometimes people want to dismiss or remove something they can't imagine themselves being with.We can not truly,happily,completely replace the things we were given at birth.If jay's legs are not a direct threat to his health why remove them?

why give him a lifetime of possible medically related problems with ulcers and infections?

 

 I know myself  as a mother.I would rather have to tell my son later on in his life.we opted to keep your legs because they are your legs.A part of the son we love,cherish,and are very proud of.Rather then to try to explain to him that we  had your legs removed because we were worried about the social impact,the stares,and comments from rude uncaring people.

 

My advice to jay's parents.let your son be a normal active child.Don't look to him as if he were any different then any of your other children.let him try anything and everything that any other normal child would do.let him find his own limits in life.

Don't burden yourself by looking at him with pity,or restirctions.I promise you if you accept his condition as normal for him,he will also accept his condition as normal.and thrive through his life as a normal productive active adult.

 

Jay's mother mentioned she was concenred that he could not feel anything ,and by this he had a tendency to hurt his legs and feet by dragging them on the ground and causing the skin to wear through.She needs to protect his legs and feet with clothing and shoes.and teach him to do the same as he gets older.That will help eliminate damage.

 

I do not believe that God gives us anything we can't handle.he doesn't punish us with birth defects.I do believe however that God makes everyone different and some of us he gives physical limitations, maybe as a learning tool for others.

 

I am very passionate about this subject.and the idea that people don't really stop and think beyond the social aspect of things I will pray that you stop worrying about removing his legs and focus on enjoying a child that is going to astonish you with acomplishments through his life.

 

Attitude makes a person a cripple.not physical limitations.There is not one person on this planet that can do everything.So who is to say we aren't all disabled to some extent?

 

Because people can't imagine themselves in a situation doesn't mean that situation is a bad thing.

I realize you want to do the best for your child.Truly the best you can do for him is love him be proud of him and accept him just the way he is.

I did not walk until i was 4 years old.and through my life i have used my arms as  the means to support my body.walking with crutches.

 

Thank God for my dad.I was given  the chance i needed.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 11:46 pm PDT

It's a shame that you felt that way!

Quote From: darlenedawn

I guess you women who have actual breasts are the ones who are judging--even the "doctor" on the panel.  I got breast implants almost a year and a half ago and it wasn't for ANY man whatsoever!!  It was for ME.  Do you know what it is like to never have develpoed breasts--even after having 5 babies?  I felt deformed and so unfeminine.   I couldn't even find any bras to fit or clothes to fit me right since they are made for women with breasts to fill them out.  How about swimsuits--do you know what that is like not being able to fill out a swimsuit?  I could easliy have been mistaken for a male if the lights were off (or even just a breast shot) --actually i was by my own husband!!  I was lying on my stomach trying to sleep and he came in and touched me in the dark thinking he was touching my "breasts" and it was my shoulder blades!!!!

How about being made fun of -- I have heard all the jokes all my life and have been made fun of--even as an adult!!  I have been embarrassed and humiliated and degraded for having no breasts!!!  I am not for porn whatsoever and am soooo against it!!  I think women thinking they have to get naked and show their breasts in movies is ridiculous--there is no purpose for it!!!  Now talk about wanting attention!!!  Those women are the ones who are out to please men and doing it for men!!  THEY are the ones degrading themselves!! 

 

Now with implants/breasts I feel like a woman--look like a woman---and feel so much better in my own skin.   I didn't do it for any man's attention.  I got my share of it to begin with.  And if I do find men staring at my chest it bothers me bc that isn't why I got them.  I want to be talked to in the eye and be respected and if that is all a man wants to do is look at me or talk to me bc all he sees are a pair of breasts then he isn't worth talking to and he is a pig!! 

 

I have two sisters who are very flat chested, one doesn't need a bra at all and the other one barely does. The one who barely needs one uses the bra's from Victoria Secret that give you cleavage where God didn't. My other sister who has nothing? She just screams sex appeal! Men have always dropped at her feet. Her bust size has never mattered to her or any of the MANY men that have been attracted to her over the years. Breast size and a beautiful face really have nothing to do with sex appeal, I wish that more women knew this. I was the only daughter out of 4 of us girls who was given "plenty". But I will tell you that every one of my sisters have never lacked for confidence. And they have never been jealous over the fact that I was given more than enough. We are all different and all beautiful in our own way. We haven taken our own sexuality and embraced it, I wish more women could do that without the stereotype of Hollywood, where nothing is real. Believe me, a woman is NOT her breasts!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
July 25, 2008, 11:57 pm PDT

I forgot to add................

Quote From: darlenedawn

I guess you women who have actual breasts are the ones who are judging--even the "doctor" on the panel.  I got breast implants almost a year and a half ago and it wasn't for ANY man whatsoever!!  It was for ME.  Do you know what it is like to never have develpoed breasts--even after having 5 babies?  I felt deformed and so unfeminine.   I couldn't even find any bras to fit or clothes to fit me right since they are made for women with breasts to fill them out.  How about swimsuits--do you know what that is like not being able to fill out a swimsuit?  I could easliy have been mistaken for a male if the lights were off (or even just a breast shot) --actually i was by my own husband!!  I was lying on my stomach trying to sleep and he came in and touched me in the dark thinking he was touching my "breasts" and it was my shoulder blades!!!!

How about being made fun of -- I have heard all the jokes all my life and have been made fun of--even as an adult!!  I have been embarrassed and humiliated and degraded for having no breasts!!!  I am not for porn whatsoever and am soooo against it!!  I think women thinking they have to get naked and show their breasts in movies is ridiculous--there is no purpose for it!!!  Now talk about wanting attention!!!  Those women are the ones who are out to please men and doing it for men!!  THEY are the ones degrading themselves!! 

 

Now with implants/breasts I feel like a woman--look like a woman---and feel so much better in my own skin.   I didn't do it for any man's attention.  I got my share of it to begin with.  And if I do find men staring at my chest it bothers me bc that isn't why I got them.  I want to be talked to in the eye and be respected and if that is all a man wants to do is look at me or talk to me bc all he sees are a pair of breasts then he isn't worth talking to and he is a pig!! 

 

As I mentioned, two of my sisters have nothing in the breast dept. either. But they have NEVER felt that they are not feminine. They are extremely feminine. I'll give an example, Kate Hudson. Is she not beautiful and feminine? And the fact that having smaller breasts allow you to wear blouses that women who have much more can never wear, we would look like sluts. Then there is your last paragraph where you mention being uncomfortable if a man looks at your chest instead of your eyes. What do you expect? That is exactly what happens, us women who have them already know this. So if it bothers you, then maybe you should have put more thought into it or have gotten smaller ones that weren't quite so noticeable. That comment is a little hypocritical.
 

First | Prev | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | Next | Last