Message Boards

Topic : 04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Number of Replies: 465
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 11, 2008, 08:16:44 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
You've heard the sayings, "Money can't buy happiness," and "Money is the root of all evil," and the newest family to move into The Dr. Phil House lives up to both of these adages! They’re engaged in a vicious war of finger-pointing and accusations over money, land and Mom's will. One daughter is slated to inherit everything while the other won’t get one red cent. How did a piece of land two family members purchased together become a royal battle ground? Family therapist Dr. Tara Fields, brings this family face to face for an emotional encounter. But will they participate? When sisters Lisa and Sara face off, who calls whom lazy and worthless, and will the siblings decide to put their grievances aside? Then, Dr. Phil makes a house call. Why is he fed up with this family? And, when Sonja's granddaughter makes a surprise visit with an emotional plea, you won't believe how Sonja responds. Can Dr. Phil get this family to focus on reuniting instead of dividing their land? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 12:52 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: momakababe

ok I have to ask you now when you say you know a narcissist when you see or hear one and you know a borderline when you see/hear one too are you able to tell the difference between those 2 disorders too?  I can often spot the "narcissist" though they  can be very hard to pinpoint to start with because they can be good at deceptions.   Or they have a great way of making it "look a certain way".  

 

And I have to tell you I find it just fanscinating the ability to figure out the "diorder" from someone who was taught the behaviors.    I think I've known people like that where the behaviors were taught and again it's hard to know when they're genuine in their reason for doing something in that it's for concern for someone else or if they're using that as manipulation.   :)  For example someone on vacation using "My children have to have a balanced meal" as a means to go to a *nice restaurant* every day for all three meals rather than some times  just getting a deli sandwich and taking it on picnick or just getting a quick hot dog at a stand while at the amusement park.   When later in their regular life they're at Micky D's on a regular basis.   Now of course this is just 1 and a minor example of the person  but there are MANY.  And I think this was taught behavior because there is real empathy there for others at time.  Though I don't know if the person would ever *recognize* what he does.  i think this behavior often works for them and so it never occurs there's something wrong with them to get therapy....

 

I really do think it would be a great series to do for Dr. Phil

My best friend of fifteen years was a borderline. I didn’t realize how sick she was until she moved in with me and until I saw the way she interacted with her infant daughter, who by the way I took care of as if she was my own (sick people make bad parents). She was removed from my house after she cut herself up in my bathroom, which was of course my fault according to her. Borderlines are kind of like emotional black holes, no matter how much love you give them it is never enough and it is never their fault. They will also take away their affection from you as soon as they perceive a slight, you go from all good to all bad in an instant.  My last boyfriend was a narcissists and I was snowed by him for awhile until I came out of my denial phase and realized what he was. The two are very closely related but narcissists tend to be men and are less emotional or dramatic even though they cause most of the drama they claim to not like (at least for me). They both project, split, deny, and distort reality but a narcissist will talk more about their achievements (job, degrees ect) in a sort of superior manner to those around them and will also act as if they deserve all the credit because nobody helped them. They also seem to be more verbally and physically threatening. Borderlines are better at emotional manipulation are highly dramatic or hysterical. The one thing that stood out about Sonya was the evilness in her actions, they were on purpose. I have never seen that, but I have heard of it. They inflict huge amounts of pain but it usually seems to be unconscious because they are too busy protecting themselves, with immature defense mechanisms.  

 

Like I said I don’t know how I know. It’s just that when you are so entangled with someone who is sick like that you learn to spot the signs, in an almost automatic fashion. The best way is to see whether or not the person seems to be able to have empathy if you cry foul. A narcissist or a borderline will almost always deny your claim with some sort of ego defense mechanism. A narcissist or borderline (especially borderlines) have and do things that can almost look like empathy/kindness but when you take a closer look it is really selfish and about them. Pseudo empathy in my opinion is easier to spot in a narcissist, borderlines do a much better job at making it look like the real thing i.e. like giving her grandkids Christmas ordainments and making their reaction to them all about her and using it as an excuse to deny them love later when they cry out for it. The giving or the ordainment was meant to look like a kind gesture of giving them something to hold onto, but it wasn’t what they wanted (and she knows that) it was a set up.   A person who acts narcissistic like or borderline like maybe because of their childhood will still have the ability to see some sort of reason when you say “ouch that hurts,” they are also the ones who actually go to therapy to get help when they can’t manage their life.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 12:57 pm PDT

Pity party for Sonja?

Quote From: getrealtime

If where going to assume what could of happen, well maybe she out of the will because she called the police on her mother, and all the other things said on the show that Lisa did, got her thrown out of the will. it works both ways. we could assume that Lisa has been a troubled person all her life and caused nothing but grief to her mother, that would explain alot. Maybe thats why she didn't want her at hospital? she didn't want trouble on such a good day.

 

Assuming works both way, either is right, until proven,

and if Sonja turned Lisa that way? then who turned Sonja that way, and shouldn't you give her as much understanding? Damaged is damaged, one is 40 something and one is 60 something, whats the difference? I hold them to the same standing, both are = in their bad action, and both should be held accountable for them....................... 

 Are you saying that the child, in this case, Lisa, is just as reponsible for how she was raised, how she learned to behave, as her mother?  She was troubled her whole life?  Ummmm............how did that happen?  Perhaps by having a mother who never loved her?  So mommie dearest Sonja also deserves a pity party? 

Nope.  Sorry.  No can do.  Sonja was the mother who never loved her child.  To what ever degree Lisa is messed up, that can be laid at the feet of her Mommie Dearest, the witch who didn't even want her to visit the hospital when Lisa's sister was born.  Who the hell waits of invitation to visit a new baby and mother in the hospital?  Like most people, I had at least 10 family members and numerous friends arrive at the hospital when my son was born.  NONE of the received invitations from me!  They just showed up to see the baby, bring flowers, and share in our happiness.  You know, like the rest of the world does it when a precious new being has come into this world.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 12:59 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

I wonder what got these two women to this point in their relationship. It isn't about the land and it isn't about the money. Both appear to be behaving poorly towards one another. The daughter is not entitled to her mothers things but the mother is not innocent if the daughter knows and seems to use it against her. It is a stick to beat the kid with and the kid keeps asking for it. Hmmmm! Interesting choice for both of them.

 

People can discuss wills in a healthy manner and it is usually encouraged. In my opinion, at least the mother gets to answer for her decisions while she is alive. Had this been a surprise, it could be worse.

 

Our family talks openly about inheritance and we actually had a reading of my in-laws will 17 years ago. We went to the funeral home and picked out caskets, head stone is in place, service has been discussed. No problems.

 

It would be a good idea for the entire family to look at their intentions. This is where the real story lives.

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 1:29 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: suebonnetsue

 I can't find the post now but GetRealTime (aka Sonja) said that Sonja gave the ornaments so that her grandkids would remember HER.  Once again, as always, IT'S ALL ABOUT SONJA.  The poster child for narcissism, Sonja!  A disgusting example of a human being.

Sonja, you need help.  I know that you won't get it since borderlines/narcissists always think that everyone else in the world is at fault.  But as our dear Doctor would say "How's that workin' for ya'?  Does being right trump EVERYTHING in your little, angry, world?  If so, carry on in your misery.
Lisa you need help.   lol................................................lol........................................................
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 1:31 pm PDT

Very unattractive

I found Sonya's behavior to be very unattractive.

Why she has been delegated the "Matriarch" is beyond me.

I think her daughter should sell her four acres and move on.

Or, better still donate the land for a school for underprivileged children, or a battered women's shelter.

The younger daughter seems sweet and well intentioned.

I suspect that one day she will wise up, and see that she has been used by her mother to hurt another, and that she was in fact just as 'unloved' as her sister.

Love is love... for everyone.

When a parent singles out one child as 'the better' or the more loved, and behaves outrageously to the other, sooner or later the 'golden child' will come to realize that what they experienced as Love, was not in fact love, but abuse.
Abuse of power and authority. And imagine how much fear must be buried in her heart...
Wow, if mom can turn on one daughter, what is stopping her from turning on ME when she perceives that I am not toeing the line.
I would be terrified.
I feel sorry for this family.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 1:44 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: suebonnetsue

 Are you saying that the child, in this case, Lisa, is just as reponsible for how she was raised, how she learned to behave, as her mother?  She was troubled her whole life?  Ummmm............how did that happen?  Perhaps by having a mother who never loved her?  So mommie dearest Sonja also deserves a pity party? 

Nope.  Sorry.  No can do.  Sonja was the mother who never loved her child.  To what ever degree Lisa is messed up, that can be laid at the feet of her Mommie Dearest, the witch who didn't even want her to visit the hospital when Lisa's sister was born.  Who the hell waits of invitation to visit a new baby and mother in the hospital?  Like most people, I had at least 10 family members and numerous friends arrive at the hospital when my son was born.  NONE of the received invitations from me!  They just showed up to see the baby, bring flowers, and share in our happiness.  You know, like the rest of the world does it when a precious new being has come into this world.

Read the post line for line not just what you think it says, What i said was if you lay all the blame at Sonja feet for Lisa bad action, then you have to do the same for Sonja, and lay all her actions on her mother, and keep going  generation after next until you have the person you can blame ( so your the one who screwed up your off springs so much) 

 

Grown ups take resonsibility for there actions, Lisa is a adult just as much as her mother, both need to take on their responsiblitiy, both are ugly and nasty people, both are the spawns of satan malicious and wicked,  lol........................we have found who is responsible, THE DEVIL MADE THEM DO IT!!!

 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 1:56 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: getrealtime

You speak of lisa as if she is a troubled child, Lisa is 40 something, She act's like a troubled child, but she is not a child she is a adult, and should be responsible for her actions she took in this familys troubles, I know its hard to get passed what the mother said, she really didn't help herself in the first part of the show, but why is she so angery, with her daughter?  and how much is a mother to take from a middle age daughter, should she huge and kiss her for threating to call the police? screaming and cussing that happens across the fence, verbal abuse from daughters hubby, the TPing of her house and cake batter, verbal abuse to the younger teenage sister, What middle age adult daughter does that to her mother? would you, I hope not. You should act like a adult, walk away, we don't act like a child.

 

The Ornaments, how sad of a statement by you, the ornaments she said was to remember her by, My children use to get quilts from their great grandmother for X-mas something to remember her by, would they wanted a PSP instead, yes, but as I told them one day you will cherish them,  as I do.

Christmas is about giving not getting, To bad Lisa couldn't teach her children that, but I guess if you can't understand that yourself, how can she teach it.

here you go, you said you where looking for it,

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 2:06 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: karensb

I wonder what got these two women to this point in their relationship. It isn't about the land and it isn't about the money. Both appear to be behaving poorly towards one another. The daughter is not entitled to her mothers things but the mother is not innocent if the daughter knows and seems to use it against her. It is a stick to beat the kid with and the kid keeps asking for it. Hmmmm! Interesting choice for both of them.

 

People can discuss wills in a healthy manner and it is usually encouraged. In my opinion, at least the mother gets to answer for her decisions while she is alive. Had this been a surprise, it could be worse.

 

Our family talks openly about inheritance and we actually had a reading of my in-laws will 17 years ago. We went to the funeral home and picked out caskets, head stone is in place, service has been discussed. No problems.

 

It would be a good idea for the entire family to look at their intentions. This is where the real story lives.

The only reason they are there is to prove themself  right, The Dr. Phil Show is their big stand, They think that The Doc. will point at one of them and tell them they are right and the other is wrong.

because either can see they are both wrong, one no better then the other, The only one I feel sorry for is the youngest daughter, a nut for a mother and and a evil stepsister.

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
chillin'
April 16, 2008, 2:09 pm PDT

I need the make/model of Lisa's glasses. I love them.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 16, 2008, 2:28 pm PDT

Getrealtime

Is there any particular reason why your posts are always in red?  Granted, it makes them stand out and easy to find, but it also seems a tad attention getting, one might even say narcissitic..................lol
 
First | Prev | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | Next | Last