Message Boards

Topic : 04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Number of Replies: 465
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 11, 2008, 08:16:44 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
You've heard the sayings, "Money can't buy happiness," and "Money is the root of all evil," and the newest family to move into The Dr. Phil House lives up to both of these adages! They’re engaged in a vicious war of finger-pointing and accusations over money, land and Mom's will. One daughter is slated to inherit everything while the other won’t get one red cent. How did a piece of land two family members purchased together become a royal battle ground? Family therapist Dr. Tara Fields, brings this family face to face for an emotional encounter. But will they participate? When sisters Lisa and Sara face off, who calls whom lazy and worthless, and will the siblings decide to put their grievances aside? Then, Dr. Phil makes a house call. Why is he fed up with this family? And, when Sonja's granddaughter makes a surprise visit with an emotional plea, you won't believe how Sonja responds. Can Dr. Phil get this family to focus on reuniting instead of dividing their land? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 18, 2008, 11:03 pm PDT

No one's business....

 

 

  Ok this will be short and sweet, regardless of what kind of woman Sonja is, its her money to do with as she pleases and it is no one's place to argue.

 

- If they bought the land together, then Lisa's name should be on the deed aswell....either mom dies and Lisa shares it with Sarah or they cut it in half and get 2 seperate deeds. Either way Lisa will still have her half of the land.

 

- whether its $1 or  One MILLION dollars, it is Sonja's money and unless she hires someone and pays them a salary NO ONE can earn that money or even a portion. Being a good child doesn't make you entitled.

 

Yes, there is drama, Yes, Sonja should have kept her mouth shut about the will but all that is MOOT b/c its her money and her will end of story. I can't believe Dr. Phil is even trying to help them! The answer is simple get 2 deeds for the land you bought together and then SHUT UP and you will get what you get.

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 19, 2008, 7:46 am PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: cuzican927

I think Lisa is just trying to fight her way back. Lisa is always PUT on the defensive do to sonja's words or actions. Daily life must be horrible for Lisa and Sara. Mom needs to go away--to a mental hospital.
how did you come to that conclusion?  Dr. Phil said he couldn't get none of them to talk about the root of the families problem, they just wanted to talk about the fence, what was it 100 and something time it was brought up by all of them. the only one who talked about family was Sara,
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 19, 2008, 7:57 am PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: vmaerz

I wonder if this is where editing of the show played a part and we don't know the whole story.  Lisa MAY have been referring to the land deal of which she is part owner when she used the term "earned". I never heard her say in the show that her mother owed her anything - besides Lisa's own portion of the land she supposedly owns. I'm anxious for the next episode to see if any of this gets cleared up.

They both own = in the land, the dividing of the land seams to be the issue, thats why they talk about the fence all the time, so we really don't know what Lisa means by earn yet, I guess we will have to what and see if they will get into it in the next show.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
April 19, 2008, 8:30 am PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: wytchie1

I know that Dr. Phil said the daughter and mother deserved each other - but let's remember something, the mother taught the daughter how to treat her, right Dr. Phil?  This mother reminds me of my own mother, though Sonya is not quite as bad as mine. If I were the daughter I would write her off and stop even trying to have a relationship with her -- have her buy me out of the land -- and walk away.  The woman is not worth it.

 

Sonya is mean spirited, hateful and does not deserve the love of her daughter.  I am sorry for the daughter - she has been mistreated by this woman her entire life, it is as obvious to me as the nose on Sonya's face.  It is totally understandable that the daughter wants her share of the money because that is the only way her mother has ever shown her any love, but for her own sanity and that of her children, she needs to walk away; shake the dirt off of her mother off her feet and never look back.

 

Debra Witchell

how is the 40 something daughter tring to have a relationship with the mother, TPing and throwing  cake batter, treats of calling the police, screaming nasty names across the fence?If thats tring maybe she should stop tring so hard. lol...................

 

If we where speaking of a young child and not a 40 something woman, hands down it would be all laied a the mothers feet, but where not, they are 40 and 60 something year old women, both doing and acting badly to eachother, they need help to grow up and act like they have the sence of what a full grown women acts like.

 

you don't treat your daughter that way and you don't treat your mother that way, that is lost to them.

and according to the pre-veiws to come, they still don't get it. the only one who seams to want peace is Sara, I hope the the two of them don't gang up on her, but it wouldn't surprise me!!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2008, 3:15 pm PDT

I understand

Quote From: queenzenta

Of course they didn"t want you there!  You"re 30 years younger than him!!  You said one key thing:  "I am in charge now!".  If you"re going around with that attitude, I hope they recover ALL their dad"s money from you.  You earn respect, you don't expect respect.  By taking care of their father, you'll earn that.  But you need to adjust your attitude.

My dad's woman, whom I didn't meet until I was 20, is doing this to me.  My child was diagnosed with autism, and she's holding the purse strings in some sort of stupid power struggle to show me and him who's "boss" (never mind she's never worked).  All the while, I need to get my son into early treatment.  Now.  My mom is just as bad.  She drove my step-sister to the point that she tried to kill herself to escape my mother's physical and psychological abuse.  She's holding our half-sister as hostage just like the witch in the story.

I'm so sick of these selfish step-women!   If you want to be a horrible B, you should go work in a crowded office of mostly women, that way no children have to be caught up in it.  There's a reason fairtales potray step-mothers the way they do.  They are the anti-thesis to what a mother is.

I understand exactly what you mean. I am not doing a power struggle with them, I don't think so anyway! They have done so many rotten things to me, I always treated them with respect. I have given them my time, cleaned rooms when they came to visit, put up with doors being slammed in my face for no reason. It was over going to a therapy session with all of them so we could work on things to help my husband through his beginning depression before diagnosis of alzheimers. The children sat there for an hour pointing fingers at every thing their father did wrong all the years they grew up! I kindly interupted and asked them if they knew how much their father loved them? I know all this! Seeing them sit their and degrade him this badly they he stayed in his room for 3 days and would not get out of bed to eat or anything. What a mess that was to clean up!

 

Their father has supplied his four children with money, home and cars for the last 40 years, none of them have jobs. Daddy has always given them anything they needed. I think it is time for them to stand on their own feet and get a job. They have not seen their father in 2 years. They only call him when they need money! It is really sad to see him treated this way. They all have trust funds, etc. but the worst part of it is when he passes away, the money he has given them to live on are all signed contracts, notorized and such that there is almost 1 million dollars that has to be paid back into the estate before it can be settled.

 

I never asked to be their mother, I only asked for respect! I wanted to get to know them! But they never let me in. They call and tell me what to do, not ask! Even when I have called them in the past when my husband has had a heart attack I would be respectful and give them all the information. They are his children, but I feel I have been abused long enough.  The children I am sure could be nice, but they have pushed me to far! I have really tried to be nice to them. I think about their father! On his birthday or any holiday, he sits and cries all day becasue they have not called him, I finally pick up the phone and dial their numbers so he can be happy! I don't know what else I can do to be a part of this family. My children treat my husband with the utmost respect! They visit him at the nursing home often, they call, my grandchildren send him cards. His family does not send anything at all. Not even at Christmas, no gifts, I even sent them all a list of things he could use. After Christmas he said to me, I guess my kids don't care for me, I also sent them all (family tradition) a $1,000) for each of them. I have tried to be nice. Thanks

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
April 22, 2008, 5:25 am PDT

Leave it all to your husband

I don't understand Sylvia's thinking. Isn't her current husband Sarah's father?? Or did I miss something?  The mother ought to be leaving everything to her husband unless he predeceases her.  Otherwise, why doesn't she leave a percentage to each daughter, like 60% to the younger daughter and 40% to the older daughter?  After she is dead, let the lawyer sort it out when she is gone.  The teenage daughter needs a larger share to be able to continue her education.            We haven't discussed our WILL with our daughters; but that is how it is arranged.  The spouse who survives ought to have everything left to him. Then he can set up his will that way also. If his wife, Sylvia, survives him she would inherit everything her spouse owns.  In our family we don't discuss wills, except with our spouse.   
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 24, 2008, 11:37 am PDT

Still greedy

I watched the show. How does Dr. Phil think that he helped these people? If he didn't have enough time to work with this family then he didn't need to start what he could not finish. Like the son-in-law said at the end. What could be done in a couple of hours. Dr.Phil clean your plate before you ask for more! You did nothing for that family. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 24, 2008, 4:10 pm PDT

No one owes anyone anything

I have a hard time understanding this topic.  Nobody owes me anything.  My parents can leave their money however they want, it is theirs.

 

I get frustrated that people feel an entitlement.

 

My Grandmother left a fairly large amount of money to my mother and her children, (me and three siblings)  She did not designate how much should go to whom.  My mother kept most of it.  I got less than 5%.  I felt a twinge of, that is not what Grandma's intentions were.  However, she also left my mom as the executor of the will, and my mom did what she thought was right.  Anything I got was "wind fall" money, meaning money I did not earn.  So, what is there to be upset about.

 

I take pride in being responsible for me.  Anything I have, it is because I earned it.  Nobody gave me anything.    Nobody owes me anything.  That way I can never fight about money.

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
April 24, 2008, 4:40 pm PDT

04/14 The Dr. Phil House: House of Greed

Quote From: momakababe

"I sure don't remember any of them by an object.

Be it a quilt, or anything. 

How ridiculous."

 

My father passed away over 20 years ago now. but

 

When I pick up my father's pocket watch and my fingers smooth over it I'm right back in his lap with him letting me hold it and smooth my fingers over it.  Thanks for telling me I'm "ridiculous"?  Apparently the problem is that people don't understand the sentimental value of something that doesn't include a actual dollar amount? Who are YOU to judge anyone as ridiculas?  Perhaps the inability to understand this child is that you don't understand something that means more than money or is not of a practical use.....  

 

How sad that you used your husbands great grandmothers quilts so much that they were turned into shreds?   How about having put them away for future generations?   And now the one thing that could connect her great great grand children is all gone becaue you washed and dried them instead of preserving?  so sad.

I'm sorry I hurt your feelings. 

I wasn't referring to money or any item. 

In fact that was my whole point. 

Without any objects don't we all still remember those we love/loved or even disliked for that matter?:)

And just for the sake of a different opinion on keepsakes....we lived in cold country, worked outside, heated with wood and were poor.  So I couldn't begin to tell you the memories the boys have after using those quilts and knowing who made them for 25 years.  In their homes now they have heavy duty king size bedspreads I've crocheted for them since grown. 

 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
worried
April 25, 2008, 2:43 am PDT

Has anyone even noticed?

    I just watched the first episode of "House of Greed". I sat here physically and emotionaly unable to move.

   There is a beautiful woman in a picture frame that watches over the bed where I sleep. She helped shape who I am to this day.She was my bestfriend in the whole world, I could tell her anything and she would listen and never let me down. That woman is my grandmother. I know that there was a Will in place when my grandmother passed away, but other than final arragements it made no reference to money. She left us her memories to charish and pass along to our own children and grandchildren. I remember sitting in the hospital with her after her first major stroke and holding her hand tracing the vains with my finger telling her I loved her. I dont have those vains to trace anymore, I have a frame with a picture of a beautiful woman who was and is my grandmother.

   When the grandaughter was entering the livingroom she had tears streaming down her cheeks and nobody even moved to hug her and hold her. I can not be the only person who noticed this! This is not about money, I dont believe it ever was. This child wants memories to hold and touch, a picture, a note stuffed in the family bible something tangable and why cant this family get it together long enough to realize that they are all suffering. The grandmother not only put up a stupid fence to divide her property from her daughters she put one up around her heart. The memories this family will be left with are not ones I would wish on my worst enemy. I hope for the sake of the children all the "fences" are torn down and someone hugs and holds those precious children without prompting, without being forced to by guilt, but with love.

  Before I fall asleep tonight I'll be looking into the face of my beloved grandmother and thanking her for the memories she created for us to hold in our hearts and hands forever. Take care all, be safe.

 
First | Prev | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | Next | Last