Topic : 07/01 A Secret Inside: Extreme Hoarding

Number of Replies: 343
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 25, 2008, 02:58:59 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/28/08) Imagine being forced to dwell in a space that is so cluttered with junk, food and trash, you can barely walk. Nancy and her boyfriend, Bob, live this nightmare every day. In their two homes, flies and plastic containers fill the kitchen, moldy food is stuffed in four refrigerators, and boxes and plastic bags litter the house. The two youngest children sleep on the same couch in the living room, because one's bedroom is cluttered, and the other child doesn't even have a bedroom! Nancy, a former nurse, admits to being an extreme hoarder, but how did she and Bob, a former corporate attorney, allow their lives to degenerate to this chaotic clutter? Their home is trashed, and they're in debt $100,000. Could other issues be contributing to the chaos in the house as well? Hear from the three children, 16, 11 and 9, who are trapped in this mess. Are Nancy and Bob finally ready to rescue their family from the rubble before the kids' lives are ruined forever? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
April 29, 2008, 8:24 am PDT

A selfish, self-pitying nightmare

How dare this woman justify her living conditions by saying "no one should be slapped down over and over again". She brought every bit of that on herself; stealing drugs, losing her license. She endangers the other condo residents (connected building) with that filth, and resents them for trying to stop it. I can't even imagine what that unknown woman she "cared" for suffered before she was committed. How dare Nancy move in on someone's situation and bring that disgusting condition into it? What did that woman suffer? Nancy should have been jailed for abuse in that case, but she's complaining that she didn't get paid, and had to pay the estate back? She should have been charged for neglect and abuse.

Many people have been slapped over and over, through no fault of their own. They've lost children, and suffered accidents and attacks. Yet this creature is feeling so so sorry for herself. Do you know how many hungry people 7 freezers of wholesome food could feed? There are elderly women trying to boil water over a sterno can, and Nancy gets a new kitchen? She doesn't deserve it. I understand the psychological ramifications of the OCD and depression and so on, but this woman is self-pitying for everything she caused. Those children and pets should be taken away from her and her drunken boyfriend, and housed somewhere safe together, not have to wait until she makes a change and then gets a new kitchen. And in all that horror, she was obviously able to find the photos of herself in her glory days. She probably has no idea of where her children's baby pictures are, though.

People with OCD and hoarder problems are not bad people. They have a glitch in their thinking, which is obvious, but this case is something else. This woman has a vicious twist that would enable her to pretend to be a caregiver and subject an innocent woman with cancer to this filth. She should never be allowed a nursing license again. She's upset because of how the other parents treat her? Doesn't she think children talk and then talk to their parents? She doesn't have a moment to think about the humiliation her children must be suffering at school.

Go on, Nancy, Keep being proud of yourself and smiling when you talk about "being in charge of the estate" and "changing the towel in a couple of weeks" for the untrained dogs. Glad you have that amazing sense of smell. I hope that's a consolation when you are all alone and someone like you is taking care of you. Enjoy it.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 8:33 am PDT

RE: Show on hording/4/28/08

Dr. Phil!  YOU ARE A BIG TIME ENABLER!!!!!  The couple on your show need to stop drinking and doing whatever else they do to not face reality!!!!!   Those children need to be taken away from them.  They are not safe.  MERELY CLEANING UP THE HOME IS NOT THE ANSWER!!!!!   The couple need to dry up, dry out and find GOD!!!  I was really disappointed in Dr. Phil's response to this situation.  He is denying the severity of it and just enabling in a superficial way!!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 8:48 am PDT

hoarding

I grew up with a mother who still continues to hoard.  She has actually become worse now that my father has passed and my sister and I do not live at home.  I have not been inside her house in 11 years.  My sister was last in about 4 or 5 years ago.  When I was growing up it was just "stuff" she collected, mail, piles of clothes, etc.  She rarely cleaned or washed dishes.  We ate almost every meal at my Grandparents house who lived 4 houses away.  I could never have friends over and when I did, it was at my Grandparents.  As we got older and had friends pick us up we would watch and run outside so that they didn't have to come to the door.  My sister tells me that my mother now has her kitchen packed with garbage-- empty pepsi and food containers.  We also know that the kitchen sink does not work, nor does the stove or refrigerator.  I think the bathroom sink is broken but the faucet still works and I believe there is something wrong with the toilet.  She did buy a small dorm size refrigerator but has no freezer.  Her car is packed full of stuff-- there is only space for her to sit.  I dread having to deal with that mess if and when something happens to her.  Thank God that her dog died about 5 years ago b/c I can't even imagine  what that poor dog dealt with.  She does get her grass cut b/c the neighbor does it for $20.  No one should have to live this way.  I now struggle b/c I feel like everything has to be spotless and germ-free.  It has taken me years to realize that I can relax and have a clean home without driving my self crazy thinking that I will end up like her.  And with a husband, 2 kids and a dog, I was completely worn out.  I do not know what my mother's problem is but she has always held down a decent job and has friends but this is ridiculous.  She has no idea what she has done to us not only b/c of the hoarding but I think she has other mental issues as well,  I am glad that people are starting to talk about this and I feel like I can start to deal with this.  I truly understand what these children are going through,  and it is just not right.       
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 8:49 am PDT

04/28 A Secret Inside: Extreme Hoarding

Quote From: jerrycat1

Why has there been no comment re: child protective services made by Dr. Phil or his staff??  In my jurisdiction, those children would have been apprehended immediately, given the concerns identified:  FILTHY living conditions which present a health and safety concern (neglect); ongoing drug/alcohol abuse by one or both of the adults in the home; exposure to domestic violence; failure to provide the necessities of life. 

 

The children would not have been returned to that home until it was cleaned up completely (verified by a caseworker), and both adults had at least started counselling and shown some form of progress.  Both adults need substance abuse counselling, and counselling re: domestic violence.

 

Children who witness domestic violence are victims of child abuse.  The mother admitted that she has been held in a choke hold, with a hammer held to her head by her intoxicated partner.  Mother states that police have been to the home over 30 times.  GIVE ME A BREAK!  Mother can choose to live in this situation, but she CANNOT make that choice for her children. 

 

If Dr. Phil and have staff have not reported this to child protection, and provided them with a tape of the show, they are being grossly negligent of their responsibility to report child abuse. 

 

So,....what is it?  Have the authorities been notified or not??

 

Waiting for a reply.

 

I completely agree!!  The kids (a boy and a girl) have to sleep together on a small dirty couch....  That right there should be enough to warrant an investigation
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 9:04 am PDT

Seriously-I grew up like them

Quote From: oletrucker764

Give me a break!  Those kids are fine. They aren't living as bad as you think. They sounded to me like

very intelligent and sympathetic children, capable of taking care of themselves and Mom. All families are

not alike, and this family is just different.

Wow, I think you’re a one man/woman army with that one. I can tell you first hand that no those kids aren’t fine!! I used to have a life MUCH like that one. I was told the house was messy because of me and my brother. I was also threatened to be sent to foster care because I was so ungrateful. I was told that it didn’t matter if the floor was mopped once a week or once every ten years the germs would still be there. My parents were addicted to substances. I have spent six years in therapy and have had several bad and abusive relationships all of which are now my problems, my responsibility but I am not the one who put them there. You sound like my mother who likes to tell me she did just fine because I turned out okay (she says that because I have a college degree and am not working in some dead end job like she is). She doesn’t see how the PTSD or the mild to severe depression ect has anything to do with her. Our family was just “different” and as a result I spent time in houses with other “different” families, my best friends mother used to sit on her and slap her in the face till she cried…. daily.. but oh well they were “different” so it was okay. You have no idea how those kids are being set up to adapt poorly when they become adults, if they are successful it will be because they are precious, amazing and smart and will have nothing to do with their whinny poor me I am the victim/child abuser mother.  My mother is just as pathetic as that woman was. I love my mother but I also pity her as well.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 9:17 am PDT

ME TOO!

Quote From: cdp1973

I grew up with a mother who still continues to hoard.  She has actually become worse now that my father has passed and my sister and I do not live at home.  I have not been inside her house in 11 years.  My sister was last in about 4 or 5 years ago.  When I was growing up it was just "stuff" she collected, mail, piles of clothes, etc.  She rarely cleaned or washed dishes.  We ate almost every meal at my Grandparents house who lived 4 houses away.  I could never have friends over and when I did, it was at my Grandparents.  As we got older and had friends pick us up we would watch and run outside so that they didn't have to come to the door.  My sister tells me that my mother now has her kitchen packed with garbage-- empty pepsi and food containers.  We also know that the kitchen sink does not work, nor does the stove or refrigerator.  I think the bathroom sink is broken but the faucet still works and I believe there is something wrong with the toilet.  She did buy a small dorm size refrigerator but has no freezer.  Her car is packed full of stuff-- there is only space for her to sit.  I dread having to deal with that mess if and when something happens to her.  Thank God that her dog died about 5 years ago b/c I can't even imagine  what that poor dog dealt with.  She does get her grass cut b/c the neighbor does it for $20.  No one should have to live this way.  I now struggle b/c I feel like everything has to be spotless and germ-free.  It has taken me years to realize that I can relax and have a clean home without driving my self crazy thinking that I will end up like her.  And with a husband, 2 kids and a dog, I was completely worn out.  I do not know what my mother's problem is but she has always held down a decent job and has friends but this is ridiculous.  She has no idea what she has done to us not only b/c of the hoarding but I think she has other mental issues as well,  I am glad that people are starting to talk about this and I feel like I can start to deal with this.  I truly understand what these children are going through,  and it is just not right.       
I hear ya! I think when my parents die I am just going to burn down the house... its absolutely disgusting. Sometimes I wonder if they just don't know how to throw stuff away. I remember one time I cleaned the two-three foot tall mound of crap of off the coffe table and washed it and my mom blamed me for months because I threw away stuff she "needed," like the bills, even though I kept all of those.  I am forever at war with clutter in my own home, much like you are.  It isn't just about hording my mom has other problems too and it has been a struggle for me to get out from under them. I am glad to see someone else in here... good luck to you. I just try and remember to put one foot in front of the other and that I need to be patient with myself.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 9:44 am PDT

To Makezmuzic

Your post really touched me. I'm also a youngest of three who tried to help my parent with hoarding and dementia. In my case it was my father. He would actually hit me for trying to throw things away -- things like used envelopes and filthy old rags covered with dog hair. I'm not sure that it was a case of loving the stuff more than he loved me, so much as an overwhelming fear of getting old and helpless and being without things. Even though my father had plenty of money, if he thought I had thrown out something he, "might need someday," he would tell me he, wasn't made of money! He was so afraid of getting old and losing control and, sadly, in the end he did have to leave his possessions and his dog, and go to a nursing home where he was miserable. I feel guilty for not letting him live out his final years with me but his anger at me and criticism of everything I did made me feel I just couldn't live with him full time.



I'm sorry this awful hoarding thing touched your life in such a sad way, and I'm also very sorry about your disease. Best of luck and prayers for healing,
Fluffyfat
 

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 9:48 am PDT

04/28 A Secret Inside: Extreme Hoarding

Quote From: yougtbk

 Try   flylady.net.   She's the best and can help you organize.
While there are members of Fly Lady who are hoarders, a person with this severity needs professional psychological help and that can't be accomplished with the 15 minutes a day that Fly Lady teaches.  As a leader of a local chapter, I have tried on many occasions to help members like this and it has never worked...they're mentally ill, not just "messy".  I hope that Dr. Phil can find the professional help for her that she so obviously needs.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 9:48 am PDT

04/28 A Secret Inside: Extreme Hoarding

Quote From: kittin

Good idea! The anger and hatred you are showing isnt helpful to anyone, let alone those poor kids!
in all honesty i dont think these posts will be seen by her nor her children, from what i saw thear aint a chance in hell of any one in that home finding the computer let alone being able to logg in on it.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 29, 2008, 10:13 am PDT

04/28 A Secret Inside: Extreme Hoarding

Quote From: noblemuse

Dr. Phil!  YOU ARE A BIG TIME ENABLER!!!!!  The couple on your show need to stop drinking and doing whatever else they do to not face reality!!!!!   Those children need to be taken away from them.  They are not safe.  MERELY CLEANING UP THE HOME IS NOT THE ANSWER!!!!!   The couple need to dry up, dry out and find GOD!!!  I was really disappointed in Dr. Phil's response to this situation.  He is denying the severity of it and just enabling in a superficial way!!!!

wow its a good thing your not on dr phils staff he would have to fire you  thinking about him that way, i think dr phil did a wonderful thing, hell hes getting those children a clean house to live in, something i bet they havent seen in many years.
 
First | Prev | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | Next | Last