Message Boards

Topic : 08/04 Daddy Drama

Number of Replies: 1404
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 25, 2008, 03:00:17 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/29/08) Christina, 21, and her younger sister, Carlie, 13, say they had a close relationship with their father, Michael, until two years ago when he decided to transition to a female. Michael was a police officer, soldier and loving parent who lived his life as a male for 40 years. Now, he wants his daughters to call him Mom, because he says Dad is gone, but they refuse. Michael, who prefers to be called Kayla, says she wants to explain to her daughters why she's living as a woman, but they've never given her the chance. The last time Christina saw her father was two years ago when he showed up at her work in lace and blue jeans to break the news that he's transgendered. When she sees Kayla onstage, does she greet her with open arms? Next, Carlie joins her sister and father. She says she wants her old dad back, but will she feel the same after seeing Kayla? Can the father-daughter bond be turned into a mother-daughter one? Be prepared for an emotional journey as two daughters  struggle to understand how someone they say loved so much could hurt them so badly. Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 6:22 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: karynm8621

Yup it does, it causes them to commit suicide. Sad isn't it Penny.

 

I walked away from this discussion some time ago because some get it some don't. People think everything is back and white in this earth and yet all throughout nature variations happen. Because we are human being, apparently we are immune to the same mutations that are seen in nature. We see dozens of issues with Gender and sexuality beyond just this one, including women who have XY men who have xx and some even have variations like XXY

 

It's easy to say this is wrong or that's wrong and pass judgment on someone else's life. It's easier than looking within ourselves and fixing our own problems. I lived this and I still am, I've had gender dysphoria since my earliest memories. It's done so much emotional damage trying to live the way society built the box I'm supposed to fit into. To the point that if I had to live the way a lot of you have deemed me to then I might as well just have killed myself like my original intent. But that wasn't the right answer for me.

I took the hard route, I chose life but I chose to get help for this, In getting help the path was set in front of me by my Dr's and that is what I have to abide by for treatment to live. That doesn't mean living in one gender part time to appease some because that violates the standards of care put forth by the medical community.

 

I've heard we need therapy not surgery. I've had 3 years of therapy and the only known cure is transition. Dr's are the gatekeepers of transition and to get there means living full time and doing hormone therapy.

 

It does damage to the mind to have such a conflict of opinion. Dr's tell us that transition is the only known sure, society tells us to stay the sex we were born as. So do I take medical advice from my neighbor or my Dr?

 

The truth in this show is simple. Dr Phil dropped the ball and most of all Kayla dropped the ball.

 

Dr Phil should have explained the hows, whys and what's of this condition and why it is medically necessary and YES it is NECESSARY!

 

Kayla has dropped the ball in so many ways. Not financially supporting her girls, Not getting them invovled with therapy so they understood what was going on and help them deal. Working to stay in their life.

 

We get the word tselfish thrown at us all to often in transition. It is selfish to expect someone to live miserable because they don't undertstand their feelings and emotions about who they are. Transisition is not selfish it is simply survival... .

 

Selfish is not supporting your children and getting your nails done. Selfish is not getting your children help because yours is more important to you. Please don't lump all TG people into one big ball because of a few bad ones...

 

Lastly I've read that I'm not supposed to have had children because of my Gender Dysporia. How sad people must be if they assume all families end up in tattered ruins because of this. I have a beautiful wife who has taken the time to talk to my Dr's and learn about why I need this and she stands beside me, she is my best friend and my soulmate. I have a 23 yr old daughter that not only supports me, she likes me much better the way I am now. She also likes the fact that her dad is still alive instead of dead. Lastly I have a beautiful granddaughter I am watching grow, that would have never happened if I followed the jugemental people . I love everyone in my family dearly and I know I'm loved. I would have nevber found that out if I lived the narrow path that some people expect .....

 

 

 

 

 

 

Is that a pic of you btw? You are very pretty. I actually had no idea you were personally dealing with this...wow. Coulda fooled me! LOL
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 6:47 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: PennyLane78

Is that a pic of you btw? You are very pretty. I actually had no idea you were personally dealing with this...wow. Coulda fooled me! LOL

Yes that's me in the photo and thank you that was very sweet of you to say.

 

I was in on this discussion back in April and told you that I wished there werer more open minded people like you. I walked away from the conversation at that point because it was hitting me personally and becoming hard to be objective in my posts.

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 6:54 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: PennyLane78

Is that a pic of you btw? You are very pretty. I actually had no idea you were personally dealing with this...wow. Coulda fooled me! LOL

BTW and I know you said this unintentionally so I'm pointing this out in a general way and not directly at you.

 

I'm not out to fool people, I'm out to educate them so I try to be as honest as I can about this subject. I think a lot of mainstream societies fear revolves around the idea that trans people are trying to "fool" them and I assure people this isn't the case. We are just trying to get from point A to point B happy and healthy. Mosty of all we want to be productive contributing members of society. In order to do that we need to be comfortable with who we are after al, its our lives and we only have 1 chance.

 

I do not condone or agree with Trans people that get into relationships and lie about who they are, it is not fair to the people they are invovled with.

 

I absolutely refuse to let closeminded people try and make me feel bad about myself anymore, I am proud of who I am ...

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 7:29 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: karynm8621

BTW and I know you said this unintentionally so I'm pointing this out in a general way and not directly at you.

 

I'm not out to fool people, I'm out to educate them so I try to be as honest as I can about this subject. I think a lot of mainstream societies fear revolves around the idea that trans people are trying to "fool" them and I assure people this isn't the case. We are just trying to get from point A to point B happy and healthy. Mosty of all we want to be productive contributing members of society. In order to do that we need to be comfortable with who we are after al, its our lives and we only have 1 chance.

 

I do not condone or agree with Trans people that get into relationships and lie about who they are, it is not fair to the people they are invovled with.

 

I absolutely refuse to let closeminded people try and make me feel bad about myself anymore, I am proud of who I am ...

No it was most definitely not an intentional hurt...but I don't mind you using my post to express this at all.

I am sure that you are open and honest when necessary and ethical.

All I meant was there is nothing "male" looking about your photo at all. I think that actually many people don't KNOW who was born what much of the time. They could be in daily contact a transsexual person and never know. (I think this is because many people confuse cross dressing with gender issues...and they aren't necessarily related....that's a whole other issue that irritates me! LOL)


 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
frustrated
August 5, 2008, 7:37 pm PDT

I hope you are real...

Quote From: angeleyes65

I know Mike personally I was married to him and he practically destroyed my life after I married him! He is very selfish and has many personalities! This must be number 5! You guys don't know him like I do, he is a dangrous man and will not get help because he said he would lose his PI license. He is gone way off this time. He changes his mind about something like being married he just gets rid of you like trash and expects it to be "OK" will now he has done his family this way. I really hope he gets some kind of serious help!

 

  I worry for those girls and you and the other X-wifes. I can't imagine

what your families must be going through.

 You are in my prayers deaply and I hope all of you can heal. The pain

in your hearts has got to be just simply unbearable, and yes me as

a man cried watching that show, I could never be so cold to my children.

 I wish you all the very best.

 John.

 MPLS, MN.

 

 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
angry
August 5, 2008, 7:44 pm PDT

Time to grow up?

Quote From: cyncritter

These children are being selfish. All their lives their father worked hard to provide for them and see to their every need. The very LEAST they can do to return all the love and devotion he gave them as a father figure is to accept him the way he has always accepted them--their quirks, their youthful indescretions--and love him no matter what.

It's not like gender changes aren't mainstream now. Thousands of people have made this change. It's time we all stop being selfish in what WE want, and start realizing that life doesn't revolve around each one of us... it just revolves, and we need to accept change when it happens. Why throw away a loving parent just because we have to look at them differently, and call him by MOM instead of DAD? The heart is still the same, and so is the love for the family.

Time to grow up.

 

 It's time for YOU to grow up! You or no-one can expect a 12 year old child to understand what this is about!

And you say she is selfish? That poor child will go through so many emotional rollercoasters over the next 10 years that you have no idea what this man has done to his child. You YES YOU need to grow up if you think that that baby is out of line, that child is in for deep trouble if her mother and sister don't keep a good eye on her, and people like you that are just plain dumb need to stay away from them.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 8:06 pm PDT

What about her rights?

Quote From: jewelsf

Are people actually giving this woman a hard time? I haven't read everything from her, just one post from someone that she was angered by and their response, but has there been even more? I feel that she has every right to her own feelings about her own father, who she really doesn't even have anymore. I can't understand the selfishness that a parent can heap upon their own children such as this.
Thank you for bringing up her rights!  I have a father that is transitioning, and I would never presume to tell him how to live his life, as his an adult.  All I ever asked of him was that he be guided by a professional. I think the most compassionate thing I could do for him is let him live his life, but it is still  my CHOICE as an ADULT to say that I want no part of this.  I am not obligated to follow him down this path- I have my own path. Brava, Christina. He has a right to change, you have a right to speak your mind.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 8:29 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: getrealtime

The children have not lived with or even thought that their father wanted to be a women for 30 + years like he has. it took him that long to make that change and to comes to grip with that kind of change, But the kids should just except something right now no time to come to grip with it and no help, and their just Bee-otches for doing so.WHO calls children that????? that was a sad sad statement made by a small mind.

 

he has responsilitys to himself, but also has responsibilitys to his children to help them to understand something that took him many years to understand. He above all should understand what they are going through, the douts of he really is, the stigma, and the loss of who he was.

 

Come off it. Psychological counseling is available in every community and every school- Tose girls had ample opportunity to avail themselves of professional help to understand what was going on They chose not to. They decided that making a public spectacle of their problems by going on a tv show was the best way to air their greivences.

Darma queens? Of course, most tennage girls are but excusing bad selfish behavior due to the perpetrator's age is useless and decietful
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 9:04 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: auroralaura83

 I sat in front of my television yesterday crying with these two girls and hating a man I've never met in my life. I've lived this kind of sick perversion and anyone who thinks that this man was in the right is dead wrong. This lifestyle change- man to women- is not cheap and it takes away from your family. He cannot emotionally, mentally, or even financially put anyone but himself first- I know this because I live it every day. These girls aren't just mad because they are losing their father, they are mad on so many levels, for so many different reasons. I can't fathom how anyone on this board can stick up for this man when he is neglecting his basic responsibilities to his children. We should all be advocating for these young women, not condemning them or telling them to grow up or accept it because they love him. There is a 13 year old CHILD here that is going through HELL. People, society doesn't need to be more open to transgender issues but I think we need to take a good look at ourselves individually and as a mass and just think about the message we are sending our children.

 

GIRLS- Be strong. I'm 24 and I've lived with a crossdressing father all my life. My dad has never gone so far as to make a complete transformation but he's got the horomones and pills.  What he has done has been devestating to me and it's a never-ending battle for me. I know about the hormones and the clothing and the absolute loss you feel. He's taken something away from you-chipped straight into your being and removed a piece of you. I have never gotten over it- how can I when I deal with it every day?- but I've found ways to cope and so will you. Your father- I say father because someone who sits in front of a national audience and acts like YOU''VE victimized HIM, is nothing more than a sperm donor- will never be able to put anyone but himself first. You'll have to do that for yourself and each other. I have younger siblings and the one thing that I wrap myself in is something my grandma told me from the time I was a little girl until the time she died- in the end, your siblings are all you'll have. If you have each other, you'll make it. Hold on tight where you need to and let go when it doesn't do you any good anymore. You are in my thoughts and prayers and I know you will pull through this and be stronger for it.

Last week i was watching an interview with RandyPpausch (conducted before he died)

he reminded us that when you fly on a plane, the instructional video will always tell you to place the oxygen mask ,on yourself befre aidng your child.

Why/ because if you can't breathe it does no good to your children - The idea of a parent who always puts their children fist is a fantasy that has little to do with the reality of day to day living.

You are bitter becuse your father did not put you befr4ore himself- The person that you should be angry at is the liar who told you that that is what a parent is suppossed to do. if your father's chose was to transition to female or to commit suicide, aren't you grateful that he chose the former? That certainly would have scarred you emotionally far more than accepting him as a woman ever would.

You are angry at your father because he didn't fulfill your image of what a father should be and what his role is.

the person you should be angry with is the one who sold you the bill of goods that all fathers must behave the same and have the same sexual identity or something is rotten.

Directing your anger at the forces of intolerance and rigid unrealistic thinking will serve you - and ultimately the world much better.

Your father may have hurt you, but still you should thank him for giving you the gift of being able to see beyond the limited roles and mores of society
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 9:16 pm PDT

08/04 Daddy Drama

Quote From: jewelsf

   I happened to lose my father when I was 18 years old! He had a massive heart attack that none of us saw coming! On top of that, he was buried on my 19th birthday! So how dare you say "Boo-friggin-hoo? I DO know what I am talking about! But at least I am grateful that I only lost my father to death, it would have been much worse for me and my other 4 siblings, plus my mother, for him to have turned into a woman. I don't need two mothers and these girls don't either! How can you call them Bi#@h's? They are being honest and true, exactly like their father is. The only difference is that the father "CHOSE" to be a father in the first place. The daughter's did not ask for this!

   Yes, this family was destroyed, and why wouldn't it be? Obviously you read my post because you responded to it, yet you actually say that rather than for him to have lived his life on his own and to have NOT chosen to have children, that you're idea of acceptance is a better one? I don't think so! Prior to reading the lack of empathy for the girls of the he/she, I didn't have any problem with people doing as they see fit, as long as it does not hurt others. But after all of the reading that I have done here, and from all of the support that I am seeing for this father, I am changing my mind very quickly. The reason being is because trans-genders are apparently very selfish people that do not care who they hurt in order to get what they want. With that type of attitude, I refuse to support any of you trans-genders and will revert, quite happily, to my previous view on this topic and find this behavior to be unnatural and offensive at the same time!

  

first of all- I was not saying boo-hoo to those who have lost thier fathers- that is a real tragedy The boo hoo was directed at those who don't apprecaiteand accept the people in their livesand the love that they bring to it

You say that you prefer you father being dead then to being alive but a transexual?

Honey, loko up b!#@% in your Websters and you'll probably find that quote
 
First | Prev | 103 | 104 | 105 | 106 | 107 | 108 | 109 | 110 | 111 | 112 | Next | Last