Dr. Phil
This was a perfect opporunity to help lots of people with problems we all face with stress, but I felt you left out a lot of information. I am a masters prepared RN with extensive personal and professional experience in helping people with chronic pain learn to deal with not only pain, but the causes of pain including stress. One of the things I thought you should have addressed in this show was the obvious depression which these people were all experiencing. The clinical signs - physical and emotional - were all very apparent and yet the only times the word depression was mentioned were in the nutrition segment and the pseudomention in the segment with Dr. Lawless when you mentioned the "depressive stress storm." I think it would have helped to have you explain more about depression as it relates to each of these cases and how their losses, lack of resources - financial, emotional, and support system - has brought them to where they are now. Yes, it is important to understand what is happening physically to them as a result of their stress, but they also need to have more information of the simple stress relievers you mentioned. For example, the blue man music, while very enjoyable was not what I would call relaxing or a stress reliever. I think I forgot to mention that I have an undergraduate degree in Music as well as several graduate hours in Music Therapy. When I worked with injured workers in the Chronic Pain Management Program it became very apparent that each individual had to choose precisely which music they responded to in a relaxing manner. Many people have emotional responses to certain music because of past history as well as the various elements of music - tempo, key, dynamics, instumentation, lyrics, genre, etc. It is important to become aware not only of your responses, but to identify why you might respond that way. Each individual must determine which music is best for them and their own physical and physiological makeup. Some people responded better to country western better than classical and that is due to their own makeup including experience. It's very individual and they taught me that. I know time constraints prevent you from going into great detail in a one hour show, but there was so much left unsaid that I felt confusion trying to follow everything.
I am very interested in reading Dr. Lawless's book and maybe that will help to clarify the points you were trying to make. I suspect you were trying to make some very complex issues regarding stress understandable to the layperson, but only found it more confusing.
Stress is universal and unavoidable in our human lives. Increasing eustress and decreasing distress is a great concept, but many of us no matter how educated must have it broken down in order to become aware of what's actually happening to us. I think this is what you were trying to do, but it didn't quite come off as being cohesive and making sense as presented. It was like jumping from one building to another and not knowing where you were or why you were going there.
I have had multiple stresses in my life including an adulterous ex-husband as well as loss of my career and financial security due to multiple back surgeries from an on the job injury. I was fortunate enough to find a workman's comp program which helped me tremendously. It is called a Chronic Pain Management Program. I was fortunate enough to not only be in the program as a patient for 40 days but also transitioned my way back into the workforce by teaching and managing the program for my treating doctor. I worked with people who were injured on the job who could relate to someone who had gone through similar situations because their support system could not understand what they were going through and was failing them. Unfortunately, the codes assigned to this type of program are limited to reimbursement through Workman's Comp Insurance ONLY. No other insurance prgram will cover it. I can't tell you the number of people with chronic illnesses - Crons disease, Celiac disease, Diabetics, COPD, Arthritis, etc. who would love to have learned what the program offered, but couldn't afford the $1000 per day out of pocket expenses it took for a multidisciplinary team of Physcian, Physical Therapist, Counselor/Social Worker, and Educators to operate such a program. Our basic program was 20 days long (I was fortunate that due to the multiple heavy narcotics I was being taken off of, I was able to continue an additional 20 days. Yes, you could also say I'm a slow learner too. Probably my stubborn Irish sense of being able to take care of it all!) and most patients really didn't start "getting" it until about day 17 when you could visually see them having lightbulb moments right and left. I'd love to see such a program out there for everyone because this basic type of information doesn't just apply to those in physical pain, but could also make people's lives much better no matter who they were or what their problems. I don't know how to get it going. Any ideas?
Don't get me wrong Dr. Phill, I liked what you presented. I just know that some of what was presented might not work for some people and there is SOOOOOO much more to it than what you presented. I'd like to see you provide more detail in a future program.
Thanks for listening! and have a great day!
Marty Land