Message Boards

Topic : 10/29 Gender Confused Children

Number of Replies: 1316
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 24, 2008, 02:51:47 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Dr. Phil tackles the sensitive topic of children who identify more with the opposite sex. What do you do if your son wants to wear dresses and play with dolls? Or if your daughter tells you she wants to be a boy? Should parents chock it up to being a phase that their children will grow out of, or should they intervene right away? Meet Melissa and Tim, whose 8-year-old son declared himself to be a girl when he was just 3 years old. Now, they allow their child to live as a girl and wonder if and when they should begin hormone therapy. Then, when Mary’s son was 8, he told her he felt like a girl, and Mary allowed him to experiment with dressing as a female. Now a teenager, her son is more comfortable living as a male -- but Mary wonders if she caused his confusion. Joining the discussion are experts with differing points of view: Dr. Dan Siegel, professor and clinical psychiatrist at UCLA School of Medicine, and Glenn Stanton, author and research fellow with the organization Focus on the Family. Is gender identity something we’re born with, or is it influenced by parents and environment? Don’t miss this heated discussion, then talk about the show here..

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 9:31 am PDT

Sandbox Psychology

Homosexuality starts in the sandbox, and the big funny guy that convinces other children to try things is the same one that says "Here. Eat this, it's just a tootsie roll."

In their adulthood they will then say "I was born that way" as an excuse for their guilty and morbid pleasures. Then we have these whacko professionals who say that it is scientifically so.

 

If they can bully your child into experimenting with them, then their social skills will be broken and melded back into a mentality that is corrupt and dangerous for their future, essentially becoming a slave to a group of very abusive and sadistic people with a flair for looking sweet and wonderful.

If your child has cross-gendered traits, they are a target for these abusers who tell them they have no choice but to become "gay", just like them.

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 9:34 am PDT

10/29 Gender Confused Children

Quote From: btabury

Growing up I wanted to be a boy, I wanted to be a boy so bad. I was angry that I had been born a girl. My mom would say to me well I can't help it you were born a girl. My parents did allow me to wear jeans most of the time, and I played football with the boys. I was a total "tom boy". Once I hit puberty I started being interested in boys and while I am still not real comfortable with dressing up. For me dressing up is a nice pair of jeans and a nice sweater. I enjoy being a woman now, I am married to a wonderful man, have great kids and I enjoy my life. AS A WOMAN! I think this family is really doing a disservice to this boy, this very well could be a stage that he will grow out of, and I think you draw the line with allowing him to act as a girl, call him she or her and cross dress. I think once he is an adult then he can do what he wants, but if he were my child, he would still be a he.

Exactly!

I think we need to stand our ground and say there are just some things we don't control!!

Why do we think we would know better than GOD?

 

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 9:44 am PDT

10/29 Gender Confused Children

It's really sad that parents today are just loving their children to DEATH.  LITERALLY!  PARENTS are the ones who are supposed to be in charge.  Parents are supposed to love and guide and teach.  Instead, many of them are the ones who are propagating much of the world's miseries.  Doting parents who believe children do not have to be DIRECTED.  I'm not questioning the LOVE they have, just the common sense they apparently do not have.  The line has been kicked so many times, each generation brings a new pitiful low.  It all started out with "I'm OK, You're OK"; live and let live, don't SPANK your child...  God, society, environment, therapists, teachers,etc. are all to blame when things don't go right.  Never mind the lack of parenting skills that started it all.  By the time the kids get to school, they KNOW they are the ones who make the rules.  They demand and they GET!  "You can't touch me, I know my rights!  What the HECK!!  This has come to a point where parents have to watch their children DIE, and I'm not just talking about the afterlife, I am talking about teens having the RIGHT to privacy.  Soon it will be at age 10!  Poor things don't even know what questions to ask when faced with bad situations.  HOW are they supposed to be able to cope?  WHERE are they supposed to be able to get help?  Pretty frightening to think about your child and their confusion when they don't feel like they can go home.  Rest assured, they WILL find help, from strangers and others who do NOT love them!  Now we are talking about giving credence to mere BABIES who think they are something they are not.  PARENTS- PLEASE!!  Your child should not even know the terminology at this point.  To the man who's parents "don't know" (and others):  If you had had the type of loving open relationship your parents should have provided in the first place, you would not now still be dealing with the temptations that you should have been able to conquer and put behind you so long ago that you would not even remember.  Kids do not need to know about the economy- or voting- or sexual behavior and misbehavior- or drugs, or evil and a whole plethora of other things- especially at the age of five- for cryin' out loud!  Adult conversations should be guarded.  Your children should love you AND fear you and TRUST you.  Start early and you will save many tears and much pain.

 

Babies don't know hot things can hurt them, they don't know that poison can kill them.  They don't know even about FOOD.  These things and many others have to be taught to them (and they ARE taught to them- whether parents admit it or not.)  You cannot hold them at arm's length and hope that wisdom and training is going to fall out of the sky on them.  And yet, that is what many are doing.  Their lives are formed and their futures DEPEND on wise parenting from day 1.

 

Three things that I think are contributing to this mess:  1.  People are no longer honoring their VOWS.  (Just words to be said like some robo-tron) and divorce is more often the rule rather than the exception.  2.  Judges almost always 'give' the children to the mother to raise.  Certainly not all, but MOST of the people having identity crises have been raised by a single parent and this parent is usually the Mom.  DADS need to raise their sons!!  3.  As a nation, we are "Fat and Happy" so we allow our rights to be trampled without so much as raising a question.  Our children and our children's children - and theirs- will most certainly suffer for this.  Just like the Bible says.

 

Homosexuality is NOT normal.  Trans-gendering is NOT normal.  Parents who allow and encourage their young children to entertain these things are NOT normal.

 

 

 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
hopeful
October 29, 2008, 9:58 am PDT

Gender confusion

We were blessed nearly 3 years ago with the most beautiful grandson anyone could ever have.  However, he had some genital anomalies that we knew were going to require minor (we thought) corrections as he grew.  However, after 6 months and delayed growth (but not development) we had genetic studies done, discovering he has a condition called "XY-XO Mosiac Sydrome."  Genetic tagging tells us that he is very lightly affected--he's had 2 surgeries to repair hypospadias and 1 to remove tissue in the abdomen that started out as an ovary, but did not fully develop.  Some of these children are much more severely affected, and it can be difficult to tell gender at the time of birth.  It is a complex syndrome, and the effects are far-reaching. Some of the children have mental delays, particularly in the area of mathmatics and spatial reasoning, most will be very short without the early administration of growth hormones, and some of them are sterile.  The condition occurs very, very early in gestation-we were told during the first 92 hours following conception, and, simply put, means that not all of his XY (male) chromosomes are complete.  As they grow up, some of these folks identify female, even if they look male or have had reconstructive surgery to appear male, and a significant number of them choose transgender surgery in their late teens and early 20's  Our grandson appears, at this point, to identify completely male, but should that change, we, with his wonderful parents, will love and support him, and provide whatever he needs to become the most complete, productive human being he can be.  Because isn't that the real goal of a loving family and a truly tolerant and educated society--to make its members complete, contributing and productive?  What they have inside their underclothing is just nobody else's business.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 10:14 am PDT

Give your worry's to God

I pray that all of these parents struggling with this issue would give their problems to the one who created their child. God makes no mistakes and is there to help you and give to comfort. More comfort than these doctors and scientist can give you. Satan is here to kill, steal, and destroy these precious little children's lives and will do it in any way that he can. Please give you problems to God. He is the only true one that can help these families.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 10:26 am PDT

Only God Can Help

Quote From: brubaker

i really can not believe what I'm hearing, I'm married to a man who want to be a women!!!! and the thought of not having him in my life really scares me!!!!!!  these children need to be supported, not told that they can not be who they need to be. my husband started dressing at a very young age he was trying to figure out who he was. well he kept it hidden for years well guess what it came out full blowen and with a vengeance!!!! he has been out for over a year now. most of his friends as a male now except him as a female including my family!!!!! the only one who doesn't except him is his own mother. this whole issue has even brought his 3 childern closer to him. 

God can help you. God can give you comfort during this difficult time in your life. He loves you can wants to help him be the man he was put here to be. Please pray about this and see how God can change your life and your husbands life.

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 10:28 am PDT

SEXUAL DESIRES

I just wonder how many of you that are saying "You're born that way" would let your child - however young they may be when the "desire" hits... to go out and have sex anytime and with anyone because they are "born with a high sexual drive"?  I know this may sound crazy, but it's the same thing... you are letting "worldly things" rule the lives of our children.  You are parents, protect your children.  Satan puts bad thoughts and desires in minds, if he didn't, wouldn't this be a perfect world?
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 10:31 am PDT

Don't you see?

Quote From: efffy_

I don't have to break my arm to know that it hurts. I don't have this particular issue in my life, but I can tell you what I would do. I would love my child and support them no matter what. When I was 16, my best friend killed himself because he was outed. His parents where bible thumping born again monsters. They didn't have the first clue about what love means. Love is unconditional or its not love.

He came to my house to tell me what happened. His mother had peeled his arms from around her neck, pushed him away like he was something slimy and distasteful. She said he was going to hell and that he made her sick. His bags were on the front step. He was not to come back until he found god... their version of god of course. He was in shock. I told him not to do anything crazy (like run away). He was always so crazy and fun. He was beautiful inside and out. We always joked that you could see his flame from space. I loved him just the way he was. I digress... the memories are bittersweet. Anyway, I asked my parents if we could take him in. I explained all the whys and wherefores truthfully. My parents agreed. My parents are pretty old fashioned and don't understand homosexuals, but they understand love, and his parents disgusted them.

He said he had to get his things from home. I told him I'd come as soon as I talked to my parents. When I got there, emergency vehicles were just pulling away. He was dead. He broke into his home and hanged himself in the basement. His parents had him cremated and never picked up his ashes. His sister finally took them when she was 18.

Kindness impresses me. Acceptance impresses me. Understanding impresses me. Love impresses me. This is one of many events that have shaped my life and my attitudes. Im not saying it is always easy, but it is something to strive for. No one has the right to define you, control you, or determine your future.  
Don't you see that Satan has come to Kill, Steal, and Destroy these peoples lives? That is exactly what he wanted is for that young man to kill himself. We have to come to these people with a heart of compassion and let them know that God understands what they are going through and wants to help them and comfort them. Without him we are all lost.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2008, 10:38 am PDT

I will pray for you.

Quote From: clvrgrl29

Dr Phil your show has sure it a nerve today.I have never been so upset at all the people who think that the parent is causing this.I have a question for everyone would you deny your child of anything you know will not hurt them.Who cares if boys are feeling and acting as if they are girls and vice versa.My 7 yr old has done it since he was 2.He goes to school everyday with a purse and a necklace on.He has been made fun of.He has told me this, but I tell him that is how people are and you have to learn to ignore them if this is really what you want.I told him the other day we were going to have him try boy toys and take away the girl clothes and he gave me a face like I killed his best friend.It is too painful to shun him from the things he enjoys or because of the way he acts.I could honestly take away all girl things and his actions alone are more girlie than the girliest girl in the world.I can say I am usually in better mood after I vent, but your show with what the non-believers were saying has me still upset.
Satan has come to kill ,steal and destroy your sons life. From a early age he has a hold on him and your family. God is the only one who can release your son and help him be the man that God put him on this earth to be. God loves you and is just waiting for you to call upon him. Please give your problems to him.
 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
hopeful
October 29, 2008, 10:45 am PDT

10/29 Gender Confused Children

Quote From: bhm1rn

We were blessed nearly 3 years ago with the most beautiful grandson anyone could ever have.  However, he had some genital anomalies that we knew were going to require minor (we thought) corrections as he grew.  However, after 6 months and delayed growth (but not development) we had genetic studies done, discovering he has a condition called "XY-XO Mosiac Sydrome."  Genetic tagging tells us that he is very lightly affected--he's had 2 surgeries to repair hypospadias and 1 to remove tissue in the abdomen that started out as an ovary, but did not fully develop.  Some of these children are much more severely affected, and it can be difficult to tell gender at the time of birth.  It is a complex syndrome, and the effects are far-reaching. Some of the children have mental delays, particularly in the area of mathmatics and spatial reasoning, most will be very short without the early administration of growth hormones, and some of them are sterile.  The condition occurs very, very early in gestation-we were told during the first 92 hours following conception, and, simply put, means that not all of his XY (male) chromosomes are complete.  As they grow up, some of these folks identify female, even if they look male or have had reconstructive surgery to appear male, and a significant number of them choose transgender surgery in their late teens and early 20's  Our grandson appears, at this point, to identify completely male, but should that change, we, with his wonderful parents, will love and support him, and provide whatever he needs to become the most complete, productive human being he can be.  Because isn't that the real goal of a loving family and a truly tolerant and educated society--to make its members complete, contributing and productive?  What they have inside their underclothing is just nobody else's business.
This is truly a fortunate child.
 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Next | Last