Message Boards

Topic : 12/22 Little Mean Girls

Number of Replies: 161
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, September 16, 2005, 04:29:18 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 09/20/05) They kick, they spit, they punch, they even cuss. Parents say their precious daughters have turned into "little mean girls." Mark and Heather are divorced and can't agree on how to parent their 6-year-old daughter, Montanna. Is Mark's macho personality making Montanna more aggressive? Or is it because Heather doesn't believe in spanking? Then, Jana and Cory are worn out by their 4-year-old daughter, Alyssa, and her bullying behavior. She bullies, name calls and screams at the top of her lungs. What are they doing wrong, and how can they make her behave? And Michelle says she has created a spoiled brat and giving in has become easier than fighting her "princess." Do you have any advice for these guests? Tell us.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 23, 2005, 6:08 pm PST

Thanks.............

Quote From: mandamom4

Thank you so much. It's nice to see that someone will listen to me. ANd thank you for the advice. It is  much needed at this point.

....................to both of you.  The more I read the more I find on this board can make sense of the discipline problem in this world.  Start young.  We are so concerned about teaching kids the ABCs, numbers, how to read, and to make sure we put them into the right school at the right time.  Well doesn't dicsipline at a young age make the same sense?   

  

Well it does -  to most intelligent and reasonable people.  I applaud you both. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 23, 2005, 6:22 pm PST

Me..............

Quote From: catoo2

How the heck does any child act like that?  I am a single mom of two boys - 11 mos apart!  I am a NO tolerant mom - NO misbehavior....it is not acceptable.....I was raised as an air force brat - I didn't like how I was raised but it turned out to be awesome!!  My boys do not do drugs, drink, smoke, etc.  They are awesome!  AGAIN why would anyone put up with misbehavior??? 

......................too.  It's about time someone is "horrified".  Bravo for you.  More people should be horrified - but this is the age of moral decay where children are not taught to have a sense of shame, but rather to pass the buck, cheat, lie, then deny, or simply blame someone else.   

  

I see it everyday - way too often if you ask me.   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 23, 2005, 6:54 pm PST

12/22 Little Mean Girls

Quote From: tbeeman

I am not trying to be nasty, but some of you are very judgemental.  I have 4 children 18,15 and twins 9(major handful).  I have parented the younger two under totally different circumstances due many reasons.  Needless to say I made mistakes with them all, but more with the younger ones.  I am currently trying to correct those mistakes and teach them the proper way to behave.  I do assume responsibility for where they are and how they are to some degree.  Although the older ones were boys and the younger girls.  They are nothing alike.  My point is this, I made most of my mistakes because of some circumstances that were out of my control, or so I thought at the time.  I was not intentionally being a bad parent, I was confused as to how go about some things, and also in a major depression.  What these parents need is someone to understand them, and help them.  Not put them down and beat them up, believe me they beat themselves up enough.  When your child is kicking screaming and having a fit that is totally out of control, you know you have a problem, and you know you need help.  Unfortunately, most people who are supposed to help you just want to put them in hospital and sedate them.  I know this because that's how they wanted to "Help" my family.  Stop judging people when you do not know their circumstances.  Instead, meet them where they are and help them see what's really going on.  We can change ourselves and our children but it takes time patience and a really good support system around you. 
Don't YOU beat yourself up either.  You can't turn back the clock or unring a bell.  It's done, whatever it is and you can move on now - only this time in another direction.  It will be all right - just believe.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 24, 2005, 6:16 am PST

BRAVO TO YOU ALSO!!!

Quote From: suesfive

...........................my hero.  But don't expect anything from this one.  All this discussion is most likely the most attention she's ever had in her life.  Anything of any substance that makes sense in the real world is far removed from her realm of reality.   

  

I love your perspective on the show though.  And I wish I had thought of the police anaolgy - bravo!  But again your good efforts fall on deaf ears - or blind eyes - loonylady that is. 

  

But maybe someone else will get the point. 

  

It is a little sad I had to resort to an anaolgy just to make my point, but I agree that anyone with that view point is apparently not living in the real world. I also agree with your reply about parents trying  to be a friend to their children. I am a  mom in my 20's and I have no desire to be my child's friend. 

they have enough "friends" what they need is a parent. You made a good point - BRAVO!!! 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 24, 2005, 2:35 pm PST

It starts early!

I teach preschool, and already the parents want to be pals with their children.  They think sassy behavior is cute and they do not teach their children manners or to regard others'  feelings.  If their child is a bully the rationale is "kids will be kids".  But heaven forbid another child should call their precious child a name!  It is amazing how I can just give a child a certain look and that child will stop behaving obnoxiously, yet the parents already have so much trouble getting their children to listen to them.  I agree with all of you who say that parents should not be pals with their children.  The parents who behave as parents rather than friends to their children have the best behaved, well-mannered kids in my class. I would love to see some of those other parents and their kids ten years down the road.  Will the sassy behavior still be cute when these children are fourteen and fifteen???
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 27, 2005, 9:04 am PST

Children really don't want to be "In Charge"

That is a scary place to be for a child.  They don't know how to be a leader but at a very early age recognize that SOMEBODY has to take that role.  If the parents don't do it then they try - usually without sucess.  I say usually because there are circumstances where the child is forced to take care of themselves and younger children to simply survive.  (For instance those with drug addicted parents.)  Parents need to understand it is their responsibility to parent their children.  It isn't a parent's job to be their child's pal.  It works out that parents who are able to be their child's leader, behave responsiblly and lovingly turn out to be the best friend their child ever had.   

  

Of course we all make mistakes as parents.  We just need to recognize our mistakes, apologize when needed, and continue loving and parenting our children to the best of our ability.  Believe me, children are ALWAYS ready to forgive us.    

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 27, 2005, 12:56 pm PST

12/22 Little Mean Girls

Quote From: mistyc

I know that I am going to get creamed for saying this but..............  Sometimes a spanking is necssary.  When I was a child, not so long ago, I got the occasional butt whipping and when I did I knew what I had did there wasn't any question about why I was getting a spanking.  When your child does something that they know, that they know, that know is wrong the need to be disciplined. 

I am expecting a little girl in Feb. and when the time comes if she needs her fanny popped I'm going to do it. 

When I am out in public I can ALWAYS spot the children who are disciplined at home and the ones's who are just let do as they please.   

I think it is so stupid when I hear adults saying "Bobby stop that" over and and over again, it obviously isn't working lady!!!!!!!!!!!! 

Everyone is s worried about damaging there child's self esteem that we are raising a generation of spoiled little monsters that are going to be ill prepared for the real world. 

  

You are very right, and it annoys me when I read more posts with people saying that spanking is wrong. Beating your child is wrong, not spanking. Spanking could just be a little tap on the butt or hand. I was spanked when I was a child and now that i'm 18 i'm glad I got spankings when I was younger and I told my friends the other day that I wish I had received more spankings. The majority of parents these days seem to be blind to the fact that discipline is needed to keep order. Each situation has its own discipline. Time out for taking someone else's candy, taking toys away if they refuse to share, spanking for hitting someone, maybe even a spanking for telling your own mother to shut up. I just don't see how parents tolerate that. What has happened to the world?? The kids that aren't disciplined with some kind of "force" are the ones that grow up to be b*tches,bullies,punks, kids on drugs, etc...I seen it in high school even, the kids that were on drugs were the ones whose parents gave them what they wanted. I wish the parents of these kids could look through the eyes of everyone else having to put up with it.  

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2005, 11:13 am PST

12/22 Little Mean Girls

Quote From: mistyc

I know that I am going to get creamed for saying this but..............  Sometimes a spanking is necssary.  When I was a child, not so long ago, I got the occasional butt whipping and when I did I knew what I had did there wasn't any question about why I was getting a spanking.  When your child does something that they know, that they know, that know is wrong the need to be disciplined. 

I am expecting a little girl in Feb. and when the time comes if she needs her fanny popped I'm going to do it. 

When I am out in public I can ALWAYS spot the children who are disciplined at home and the ones's who are just let do as they please.   

I think it is so stupid when I hear adults saying "Bobby stop that" over and and over again, it obviously isn't working lady!!!!!!!!!!!! 

Everyone is s worried about damaging there child's self esteem that we are raising a generation of spoiled little monsters that are going to be ill prepared for the real world. 

  

I couldn't agree with you more... however, one needs to be careful.  If you have an ex spouse like my fiancé does, they can use that to take children away from you! 

  

 

He had custody of his children up until April of 2004.  He hasn't seen them since.  She manipulated the system to make him out to be some horrible monster when in fact; he is the most wonderful dad that I have ever seen. 

  

 

The courts agreed that spanking is child abuse and that it just should not be done.  Not only can you not spank your children, you cannot talk to them about the punishment.  They do say it is ok to mentally abuse your child and go out and get drunk and then pass out so they are running all over the street!  They do say it is ok to let them be out of school all the time because they are sick all the time (all of a sudden), they do say it is ok that mom abuses alcohol and drugs because she is entitled. 

  

 

I was spanked and thank god I was, I can't and don't want to imagine what his kids are going to be like in a couple of years.  They get no discipline.  They are only taught that music and friends are important, oh, and how to get away with murder by manipulating! 

  

 

 

  

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2005, 2:29 pm PST

Great information!

Quote From: lh2000

If in 5 months your current psychologist has not improved things you need to go elsewhere.  There are several books that all apply Dr. Phil's technique in different ways but the main theme is the same.  If I were in your shoes I would go to extremes with behavior modification now before she is big enough to do real damage and prior to trying medication.   This will be difficult for the first few weeks but should pay off.  If you can afford it hire some help or recruit family or friends to provide support during the initial period.

  

 

  

 

Strip her world of everything but what she needs (3 healthy meals and water(no juice or milk)) , mattress pillow and blanket and one outfit per day plus pjs and undies.  No snacks, No Juice.  Meals should be a form of protein and some veggies.  Stay clear of refined carbohydrates and sugar in any form including fruit for a while.  She should have a bare room that just contains her bedding and a big clock or a timer.  She should be restricted to that room and your attention to her should only be when she is in a clam pleasant state.  You should be able to focus a great deal of your time with her during this time.   Your attention (or attention of any calm adult) is her first payoff for being good.  While she is good she should not be left alone for more then 5 minutes except when she is a sleep.   Bringing in a book or game or a single toy to play with her at a time is fine but it should be removed when you leave.  Any misbehavior means you leave the room (withdraw your attention) and she is left alone for 5 minutes of her being in a calm pleasant state.  Never enter the room if she is not in a calm pleasant state unless you fear for safety.   Get a baby cam so you can monitor without giving her attention.   If she is good for a specific amount of time (say 1 hour) then she can leave the room but must remain with you at all times.  Any negative behavior should return her to her room.  This room remains bare until she is living in the house with out problem behaviors for a period of 1 week.  She does not leave the house until she has been good for a month.  Any bad behaviors you step back room restriction and let her work her way back.  Then you slowly return things to her.  The first thing she earns is freedom from the room and then freedom from being at your side then her stuff back and then treats and goodies like TV.  You will need lots of help during this first period because you need to be calm and not react to any of her behavior.

  

 

  

 

You need to be very clear with her what good behavior is and but is negative behavior. 

  

 

You should monitor and record bad behavior so you know your starting point. 

  

 

  

 

To make this work you have to not yell or punish or show anger in any way other then to return her to the room in a calm way.  If necessary put a chain lock at a high point on the outside of the door so she can’t reach it but can still open the door.  Ensure the room is safe. 

  

 

  

 

If after 3 days you don’t see improvement in her behavior (expect it to get worse for the first day or two) then get a preschool behaviorist to work with you.  Don’t continue without help if you are not seeing improvement within 1 week.  Once you are in a more normal state with her then you will need to chart her progress and ensure she stays on track. 

  

 

  

 

I would recommend once she is on track following How to behave so your Preschooler will too or the book for older kids.

  

 

  

 

Don’t even consider medication until you've done some form of extreme behavior modification. 

  

 

  

 

To do this you will need a second adult in the house at all times for the first week at least to support you.  You need buy in from that adult and you need other assistance for at least a month if not two because she won’t be leaving the house until she is under complete control.  It takes 3 months to form a habit so you should have 3 months of proper behavior before you put it to the test in a situation where you do not have complete control and can’t just pick her up and leave as soon as you see a problem.   

Hi 

Now that is some real information that a parent can use. My 3-1/2 year old is in pre-school but is on the verg of being asked to leave. Last week she was suspended for a day. We met with her teacher and staff including the principal of the school. Now my wife and i have issues with the turn over of the staff at the school but for the most part are happy with it. My daugher has a strong teacher now and she is less likely to run her over. My daugher has been biting other studeant about once a month, scatching,hitting and being mean to her friends. She has also kicked at the teacher and spit at them over the course of the last year and a half. Now this is not all the time. She is very smart and social. It seems sometimes she just lashes out with no regaurd to consiquence.  I have 2 older sons from a previous marrige 17 and 19 and had none of these signs or problems I have with my daugher.  We also have a 1- 1/2 yr old son and he is about the same temperment as my older sons.  So I thought she would grow out of it and things have gotten better but not to the extent to which she can remain in school at her current pace of notices from the school.  So in closing I would like to thank you for the information as it does seem extreme but I feel its necessary to start over with her. To let her know good behavior will be rewarded and bad will not be acceptible and has a consequence. soap, spanking and getting angry have only incouraged and reinfoced the behavior. Its time to take another direction. 

Thank you 

  

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
happy
January 3, 2006, 10:57 pm PST

Behaviour modification can work wonders

Quote From: allanah

You know there are things called autistic spectrum disorder, add, childhood schizophrenia, etc... 

Those things can't be treated just by yelling at your kids and putting them in time out. Sometimes you need to take things a step further and put your children on medications and then take it even further and do behavior modification with them. And that can take even the best experts time to do. 

  

Here's a tip: Instead of just punishing your children, try some positive reinforcement. Reward the absence of the bad behavior and reward the good behavior with things your children enjoy.  And use verbal reinforcement too, saying stuff like "Good using your words," "thank you for not screaming", etc.. But also use the time out system when this misbehave.. 

I just had to pipe up on this one because I am the mother of an 11-year-old autistic son.  There have been occasions a few years ago when I had to pick him at school because his behavior was out of control.  There are moments when you can't control a child that has a special problem.   His worker's at school have been wonderful and have worked with my husband and myself  through the years.    

  

I would like to caution any parent before putting their child on any drugs.  This should not be the first thing you do with any child without exercising careful consideration.  ABA therapy has benefited many autistic children without the use of meds.  I do realize that sometimes medications are necessary.  It was not necessary to put my son on medications for his autism.  Consistency and structure has worked wonders for him.   

  

If he keeps doing something he is not supposed to he is told not to do that behavior and if the behavior persists then some form of punishment does follow (ie: he loves to play on the computer, but if he doesn't listen or stop the behavior the computer is off limits to him for the rest of the day) 

  

I use these techniques on my son when I need him to listen or behave and these techniques are taught in a lot of parenting classes: 

  

  • Make sure he is looking directly into my eyes (and yes I do bend down to his eye level)
  • Use as few words as possible to tell him what he can or can't do (ie: "No running" or "Stay next to Mom" when we are shopping) (Most small children will respond better to short sentences as opposed to a long dragged out "mini" lecture)
  • Give him one instruction/task at a time and let him respond before giving him another instruction/task
  • If he is behaving then I remember to praise several times

The fact is I can take my son shopping or to a restaurant with him because we have taught him what is proper behavior and what is not.  BTW he loves "shopping" and it is used as a reward when he behaves or he is "punished" for misbehaving when I go shopping without him. 

  

Your Tip is 100% right on.  Good behavior needs to be acknowledge just as much (or more than) bad behavior with all children. 

 
First | Prev | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | Next | Last