Message Boards

Topic : 08/24 The Family Cult

Number of Replies: 262
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, September 30, 2005, 03:30:22 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/03/05) Imagine growing up in a cult where you are forced to have sex with strangers -- when you’re as young as 5. Dr. Phil talks to people who escaped the group known as the Children of God, and need help moving on. Meet a daughter who says she can’t forgive her father for the years of painful abuse she suffered at the hands of this cult. How can she reconnect with her dad and start trusting again? Plus, China and her husband, John, are building a new life after leaving the group, where they were forced to have sex with strangers when they were both underage. They’ve had a difficult time adjusting to the outside world, and China wonders if she should prosecute her parents for abuse. What does Dr. Phil think? Talk about the show here.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More August 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 6, 2005, 3:10 pm PDT

10/03 The Family Cult

Quote From: estrella

Hearing and reading about such slanderous outright lies is hard for me as a 24-year-old fulltime member of The Family International. I still can’t believe that people would stoop to such low measures and means to demonize and bring others against a group of individuals who have dedicated their lives to helping others and bringing the true Gospel to many who otherwise perhaps wouldn’t have the chance to learn about Jesus’ love.

  

Being a mother of two small children myself, and wanting the best for them as they grow up, I am thankful to be surrounded by loving and caring members of my community who have the same vision and goal in life as I do, and impart that to my kids in their daily interactions with them. If I, living day in and day out in our communal Home, saw that it was indeed a “den of alleged sexual molestation, prostitution and extreme physical abuse”, I would be out of here without second thought. Who in their right mind would allow their children to continue to live in such conditions? Nevertheless, there are thousands of similar parents in The Family, who know the truth, have seen it and lived it for years, and are very thankful for the opportunity to have such a peaceful, pure and charmed atmosphere for their children to spend their formative years in. 

  

Of course, living a life fully dedicated to others includes quite a bit of sacrifices and giving up of selfish desires, so I can understand why there are many who choose an easier, less sacrificial and more self-centered lifestyle. I respect that. That is their choice, such as the Scripture says: “Many are called, but few are chosen.” (Matthew 22:14) Few choose to give their lives to the benefit of others in this way. But this gives those who don’t no right or leeway to criticize or make up stories about those of us who do feel called and have chosen to dedicate our lives to something more worthwhile and long-lasting than selfish living. 

  

My prayer is that these former members can find the peace that they are looking for, not by inciting more anger and violence, but by leaving the past behind and deciding to go on with their lives in the way that they feel is best, and allowing us to do the same. Each of us is an individual and has the right to live our lives in the way that we wish. I’ve found a wonderful place to live mine, and for my children to live theirs as well, and I feel very fulfilled in the cause of spreading Jesus’ message to all who are interested. Why can’t you just leave us alone so that we can get the job done while there is still time?  

  

With regards, 

Estrella Sola 

You say that what you hear are “slanderous outright lies.”  Just so that we are on the same page with our definitions please let me know if you are aware of any of the following practices in the Family (although you a bit young, you should recall the following):

  

 

  

 

-         Children being exposed to sexually graphic material (e.g., Heaven’s Girl, True Komix, and other literature)

  

 

-         Sex encouraged and practiced regularly between children

  

 

-         Regular or occasional dances that involved all of the women in the home (including children) to dance and strip for all the men in the home.

  

 

-         In the mid 1980s, 12-years-old became the official age for adulthood (this is what constitutes the Family’s stringent no minor-adult sex policy), which meant children 12 and older could be put on a home’s sharing list (i.e., could be forced to have sex with adults).

  

 

-         Copious amounts of sex between the “adults” in the homes, much of which occurred in front of children (e.g., your mom having sex with a “brother” in your presence).

  

 

  

 

I have intentionally left out instances of direct child-adult fondling and/or sex since this usually occurred behind closed doors (except for 12-year-olds being on sharing lists).  Additionally, I have left out other abuses and neglectful behavior that occurred on a widespread basis (e.g., lack of adequate education beyond the 6th grade, child-labor, etc.).  I would like any Family member to address these points and honestly tell me that these sanctioned practices did not occur in a typical home in the 1980s and early 90s.

  

 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 6, 2005, 3:14 pm PDT

With respect

Quote From: estrella

Hearing and reading about such slanderous outright lies is hard for me as a 24-year-old fulltime member of The Family International. I still can’t believe that people would stoop to such low measures and means to demonize and bring others against a group of individuals who have dedicated their lives to helping others and bringing the true Gospel to many who otherwise perhaps wouldn’t have the chance to learn about Jesus’ love.

  

Being a mother of two small children myself, and wanting the best for them as they grow up, I am thankful to be surrounded by loving and caring members of my community who have the same vision and goal in life as I do, and impart that to my kids in their daily interactions with them. If I, living day in and day out in our communal Home, saw that it was indeed a “den of alleged sexual molestation, prostitution and extreme physical abuse”, I would be out of here without second thought. Who in their right mind would allow their children to continue to live in such conditions? Nevertheless, there are thousands of similar parents in The Family, who know the truth, have seen it and lived it for years, and are very thankful for the opportunity to have such a peaceful, pure and charmed atmosphere for their children to spend their formative years in. 

  

Of course, living a life fully dedicated to others includes quite a bit of sacrifices and giving up of selfish desires, so I can understand why there are many who choose an easier, less sacrificial and more self-centered lifestyle. I respect that. That is their choice, such as the Scripture says: “Many are called, but few are chosen.” (Matthew 22:14) Few choose to give their lives to the benefit of others in this way. But this gives those who don’t no right or leeway to criticize or make up stories about those of us who do feel called and have chosen to dedicate our lives to something more worthwhile and long-lasting than selfish living. 

  

My prayer is that these former members can find the peace that they are looking for, not by inciting more anger and violence, but by leaving the past behind and deciding to go on with their lives in the way that they feel is best, and allowing us to do the same. Each of us is an individual and has the right to live our lives in the way that we wish. I’ve found a wonderful place to live mine, and for my children to live theirs as well, and I feel very fulfilled in the cause of spreading Jesus’ message to all who are interested. Why can’t you just leave us alone so that we can get the job done while there is still time?  

  

With regards, 

Estrella Sola 

This is not intended as a slam, I am curious.  You indicacted that the people in the Family have dedicated their lives to helping others.   What exactly do the members of this group do that helps others?
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 6, 2005, 3:34 pm PDT

Picking my Battles

Tina said in her letter to China: "if you want to feel better about your lot in life come to Africa and see for yourself what abuse, neglect, mistreatment and defilement mean.

  

I don't need to go to Africa (regardless of  the fact, of course, that I spent 5 years of my life there) to know that I have a better life than others. 

  

The fact is, no matter what your lifestyle is, there will always be someone who had it worse than you. The poor beggar on the streets of one african city has it better than the man being slowly tortured to death in another african city. So where does that leave us? 

  

Abuse is abuse just as a crime is a crime. Is the man who robbed a bank not a criminal because another man is a serial killer? If I beat a child, am I less of an abuser than the man who rapes a child? While the degrees of punishment may vary the fact that I have commited a crime against a child is undeniable. 

  

But let us play with the "people are abused worse in Africa" scenario. What am I supposed to do about it short of flying over to an unknown country personally and making sure unknown and corrupt politicians pass and enforce laws so that these forms of abuses commited by total strangers against total strangers cease? 

  

My time and money are far better spent bringing to justice the abusers I know who abused people I know in places I know. Does that make sense to you? 

  

There are many battles to fight. That is obvious. I pick the battles I have a chance of winning and this is one of them. 

  

  

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 6, 2005, 3:54 pm PDT

10/03 The Family Cult

Estrella wrote: "My prayer is that these former members can find the peace that they are looking for, not by inciting more anger and violence, but by leaving the past behind and deciding to go on with their lives in the way that they feel is best, and allowing us to do the same.

  

When you say "leaving the past behind and deciding to go on with their lives", do you mean I should forget that I was abused? Do you mean I should forget the inappropriate sexual contact with an adult I had as a child? Do you mean I should forget the hours I spent as a child out on the streets begging and busking so that the Home could pay its $4,000 rent? Do you mean I should forget the time I was in the Victor Camp and had to watch an 11 year old boy be held down while being beaten with a long rod and screaming for mercy? 

  

The only way that I will be able to allow you to live your life in peace is if you get out of the way of justice. Your comment can be likend to a law-abiding person who is housing a criminal and says, "Why won't the police leave me alone? I didn't do anything. I wish they would they stop bothering me." 

  

To use a quote from an anectode you should be familiar with, "I would do the no harm for the world, but thee standest where I am about to shoot." (Not literally, of course.) 

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
October 6, 2005, 4:01 pm PDT

A very snotty "christian" indeed!

Quote From: estrella

Hearing and reading about such slanderous outright lies is hard for me as a 24-year-old fulltime member of The Family International. I still can’t believe that people would stoop to such low measures and means to demonize and bring others against a group of individuals who have dedicated their lives to helping others and bringing the true Gospel to many who otherwise perhaps wouldn’t have the chance to learn about Jesus’ love.

  

Being a mother of two small children myself, and wanting the best for them as they grow up, I am thankful to be surrounded by loving and caring members of my community who have the same vision and goal in life as I do, and impart that to my kids in their daily interactions with them. If I, living day in and day out in our communal Home, saw that it was indeed a “den of alleged sexual molestation, prostitution and extreme physical abuse”, I would be out of here without second thought. Who in their right mind would allow their children to continue to live in such conditions? Nevertheless, there are thousands of similar parents in The Family, who know the truth, have seen it and lived it for years, and are very thankful for the opportunity to have such a peaceful, pure and charmed atmosphere for their children to spend their formative years in. 

  

Of course, living a life fully dedicated to others includes quite a bit of sacrifices and giving up of selfish desires, so I can understand why there are many who choose an easier, less sacrificial and more self-centered lifestyle. I respect that. That is their choice, such as the Scripture says: “Many are called, but few are chosen.” (Matthew 22:14) Few choose to give their lives to the benefit of others in this way. But this gives those who don’t no right or leeway to criticize or make up stories about those of us who do feel called and have chosen to dedicate our lives to something more worthwhile and long-lasting than selfish living. 

  

My prayer is that these former members can find the peace that they are looking for, not by inciting more anger and violence, but by leaving the past behind and deciding to go on with their lives in the way that they feel is best, and allowing us to do the same. Each of us is an individual and has the right to live our lives in the way that we wish. I’ve found a wonderful place to live mine, and for my children to live theirs as well, and I feel very fulfilled in the cause of spreading Jesus’ message to all who are interested. Why can’t you just leave us alone so that we can get the job done while there is still time?  

  

With regards, 

Estrella Sola 

Why are calling people "liars" when they say what happened to them? Did you live with each of these people and shadow them all that time? 

  

Criticism in the media and justice through legal means are not violence.  Who is advocating violence?  I am advocating in the hopes of preventing more of the violence against children that I suffered as a child in the Family. 

  

Do you realize that you are posting on a board that is read mostly by people who live what you are calling "an easier, less sacrificial and more self-centered lifestyle" and "selfish living" (translated as believing in such "selfish" stuff as nuclear family, working for a living and private property)? How do you think insulting people who have not dropped out of society is going to make us look more kindly on your elitist group of "chosen" ones, the only ones who live for something "worthwhile and long-lasting"?  

  

Not to mention that many would laugh at the thought that "sacrifices and giving up of selfish desires" in regular English would apply much to a free-sex lifestyle! 

  

Finally, I don't understand why you would ruin your credibility by saying you "respect" something you are characterizing so pejoratively (that is, a life not having dropped out of society at large to joing your group). 

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
worried
October 6, 2005, 8:12 pm PDT

Above the Law, Indifferent to Others

Quote From: raindancer

Dear China,    I had a hard time believing it was you when I heard the accusations made against us on the Dr. Phil show last Monday by members of your husband and his family. I didn't know them as well, but I know you. I grew up with you and I am still in the Family International. The reason I am still here is because I never saw any case of abuse in the Family except once, a man in our school had accosted you and the news shocked everyone. This man was immediately excommunicated and we felt stunned. This was and still is the only case that I in my 26 years in the Family have ever been close to.    We were friends, we had fun. We had over 40 students in our class, you were always popular in the 'singing group' which meant you were talented and got to perform at Christmas and other special occasions. You and I were in a children's television series which many other kids wished they could experience. I looked up to you and you taught me to harmonize which I still credit you for now that I sing professionally at hotels and functions.    You choreographed for dance groups with all the other 'cool' kids and when you became a teenager had a boyfriend before any of us. A great guy but then again you had many great guys after you and you finally picked one to marry. I was so happy for you when I heard. I hoped he would take care of you. I didn't think he and his family would be there with you saying those things and backing you when you said you were incompetent in society due to your upbringing! Girl, I don't know what you are trying to do in society but you knew at the very least how to cook, sing, dance and teach. Opening a bank account and writing a check was so easy I can't even remember the first time I had to do it.      I don't want to boast especially not to you who I've always looked up to and admire but I just can't understand what you're thinking and why you would forget friends like me and do and say things like this.     For the past five years, I have been Public Relations Manager for our Family missionary center in Africa, I've been teaching my 5 year old daughter Kaycee's class which happens to be 3rd grade as home schooling always developes advanced children due to her reading since the age of 2. I have participated in teaching several seminars for teachers and parents here on our methods of Early Learning with great success. I also host a weekly radio show for children and a counseling show for parents and teachers. I co-ordinate donations to homes for mentally and physically disabled children, orphanages in Uganda and Congo with children who have faced horrible atrocities, too gruesome to mention, if you want to feel better about your lot in life come to Africa and see for yourself what abuse, neglect, mistreatment and defilement mean.     We help reach near-forgotten tribes who constantly face starvation and civil war with medicine and Bible stories in their own language which we had to put on tape and distribute with hand crank tape-recorders because their written language is so newly developed they don't know it yet. I design and layout our project updates, newsletters, brochures and send out an inspirational, "Thought for the Day" e-mail to over 400 business friends and associates. I choreograph and dance for benefit concerts and national functions including Miss Uganda and AIDS or IDP charities. As a hobby, I have joined the local amateur dramatics society and have performed at the National Theatre, holding lead roles in several musicals.     We don't just cope in society, we make a difference.     Don't throw away your talents and opportunities with excuses of your past. You chose another lifestyle and I admired you for it. It always takes guts to follow your dreams whatever they are. Many, many of my friends have done so with great success. You know because you hang out with them I saw a lot of them last year. You all are having a ball and I was very happy for you! You certainly did not need to escape The Family it's the opposite. It's not easy to join and it's even tougher to stay. It's the hard life of a missionary where you live to help others. Your parents are wonderful people, I can't imagine what pain they must be feeling with what you are saying to them. I miss the China of years ago. The one who held me up when I was down who didn't complain except maybe when too many guys were in love with her at once and she didn't know how to be nice to them all and let them down gently. You were crazy and fun I just can't relate my memories to yours, they've changed so much.         Tina

Tina, 

  

Was the man who was excommunicated for accosting China reported to the proper authorities?  

  

If not, his next victim out in society has the Family to thank. 

  

If your group is so intent on helping others, why is it so averse to taking the preventive action of reporting abuse to the proper authorities? 

  

True to form, the Family has no regard for common standards of decency or for the well-being of those outside its group who do not donate, protect it, or provide it with a photo op. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 3:38 am PDT

what is your veiw doctor phill oprah said they can never change

 hi doctor Phill i watched the Oprah show the other day it was about child predators. On that show she said they can never change that there is no reforming them. She also said they should be locked up for life the first time because they could never change. I watched your shows on Mikai so i know you dont feel the same or you would have just tried to get him in jail and not help him. i wondered what your thoughts are on this and if you saw the show? Do you think these people are unforgivable? i read her baords after the show and the people were blood thirsty for justice as they saw it.  my question to them was why do these people have these atrations anyways? can it be stopped at a early stage? and what if somone admits to this attraction and seeks help but hasnt abused anyone? doese he deserve to go to jail for life to because of his thoughts because under that veiw that that person is doomed to act. sorry if im rambleing but no one would listen on Oprah boards if anyone asks anything suggesting helping these people get better they are met with anger like they are evil for evan bringing up a salution other then Oprahs give them all life in jail idea. thanks for your time ide appreciate you talking about this as this is a very sensative area that needs help in some way.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 6:05 am PDT

Reply to you

Quote From: wasthere2

You say this is the kind of proof you are looking for: 

  

1)      Photo’s picturing the “abuse”  

http://www.xfamily.org/index.php/Image:My_flirty_fish_pg_3.jpg (I direct your attention especially at the photo in the bottom left-hand corner) 

2)      Video showing the “abuse”  

I point you to the numerous videos of children who did the nude dances for Berg. 

3)      Audio playing sounds of the “abuse”  

I refer you to the audio recording of The Last State which was transcribed and published 

4)      Literature/E-mail having to do with the “abuse” (a) As in a document written by the accused to someone else, telling of the “abusive” act. (b) Or a diary written by the accused stating the act of “abuse”    

Got that too. There are a number of FSMs and Q&A letters on that one. 

5)      Witnesses who physically witnessed the “abuse”  

Got plenty of those. Count me as one of them. 

6)      Physical marks on victim showing “abuse” and proof that the marks are indeed directly connected with the “abusive” behavior 

You really think those kinds of bruises last 20 years? 

  

In number 5 you indicate that oral testimony counts as evidence. Why do you think this does not apply to the victim of abuse? Did you know that in a court of law oral evidence IS evidence? Many of the ex-SGAs are lawyers you could run circles around you when it comes to the law. Trust me, you don't want to get into that with them. 

  

You say The Family has always been found "not guilty". It seems abvious that you have not read the Judgement of Lord Justice Ward in its entirety. http://www.xfamily.org/index.php/Complete_Judgment_of_Lord_Justice_Ward 

  

In it He give the most comprehensive outline of The Family's History to date. His judgement: "I accept the generality of the evidence presented to me that there was widespread activity of that kind (sex with minors) to an extent significantly greater than would take place between children and between teenagers outside The Family. "
 

The are also at least 2 courtcases that I know of (one in France, the other in the US) in which Family members were found guilty. But Maria and Peter don't publish that kind of news to their Members. 

  

I'm not sure if you think I'm stupid, but all the stuff you reccomemnded we do when it comes to forgiveness and getting rid of our bitterness: I've done that. Now I'm in the final stage in which I seek justice for myself and those of my peers who were abused. 

  

You may not realize this but you are doing some serious projecting onto the ex-members. Are you familiar with that concept? 

  

You seem very disconnected with the feelings of the victims of abuse. You seem to think that they have not considered all of the things you mention. But don't worry about it. I used to be as naive as you. I used to wonder why on earth anyone would say abuse occured in the Family. I used to reason with myself that the experiences I had were not abusive. In fact, were I still in The Family, I can see myself writing a post similar to your own. I have hope that you'll see it differently some day. I never thought I would. I swore I would stay in the Family for the rest of my life. And yet, here I am. 

  

Loecon, here's where what you write just doesn't add up. You say that you are truly sorry for the pain that the vicitms of abuse feel, and yet you place all of your references to abuse in quotes, as if you don't really consider them abused. You act as if you don't believe a word of what the abuse victims say. Your post is blatantly two-faced. So which is it? Do you believe they were abused or do you not? 

 Well, if you got all the proof  than what are you waiting for?

What exactly does it help for you and all those like you to spread your hate and pain?
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 7:17 am PDT

What hate? What pain?

Quote From: leocon

 Well, if you got all the proof  than what are you waiting for?

What exactly does it help for you and all those like you to spread your hate and pain?

Clearly, leocon, you have no idea of how the law works. I can have all the evidence I want, if I can't get the legal name and location of the person I'm accusing, then I don't have much of a chance of subpoenaing him or her, do I? Thus far, The Family has refused to help provide that information. 

  

Furthermore, if I am in the US and my abuser is in some country in Africa and I was abused in Switzerland, how easy do you think it is to get a date in court? 

  

You have no idea how much power you and your Family peers have in your hands to bring closure to your peers outside of the group. Stop and think about that one for a minute. 

  

You ask, "What exactly does it help for you and all those like you to spread your hate and pain?" 

  

What hate? I hate no one. It's not my style. I do, however, wish to see justice served. I do not have to hate a person to know that their actions are criminal. 

  

Secondly, what pain am I spreading? Show me one person that I have personally hurt in my quest for justice and I will immediately do my best to make amends to the best of my ability. Show me one person that was abused through my personal actions in this matter. 

  

I think you forget completely that I used to be just like you not very long ago. I used to be just as arrogant towards ex-members. I used to be just as callous to their pain. I used to defend the Family's past in the exact same way you are doing now. In time I found out I was wrong. Believe me, that was not an easy thing to admit. 

  

I dare you, leocon, to sit down with any one of the people that the Family has called "vitriolic apostates" (pick one) and listen--no talking, just listening--to the stories of their experiences. After they are done, I want you to look them in the eye and tell them they are lying, exaggerating and/or dellusional--that they sound convincing, but are just trying to destroy your faith and cause you doubts. 

  

I bet you that you will not be able to. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 7:19 am PDT

Just a guess.....

Quote From: leocon

 Well, if you got all the proof  than what are you waiting for?

What exactly does it help for you and all those like you to spread your hate and pain?

But I think what they are waiting for is the legal names and current locations of those accused, so they can be faced with their crimes and the whole matter dealt with fairly and finally.  

  

And what does it help? Seems to me they are just bringing the "hate and pain" as you call it,  back to where it originated.  Requiring the perpetrators to see the fallout of thier experiments, and be held responsible for it. That is very healing to victims. So I'd encourage all current family youth who have no recollection of this past horror to encourage their elders to step forward and take the heat for the "hate and pain"  they created.  

 
First | Prev | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | Next | Last