Message Boards

Topic : 12/28 Wifestyles

Number of Replies: 2316
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 07, 2005, 03:34:18 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 10/10/05) What makes a good wife? Is it cooking, cleaning, raising the kids and having great sex? Dr. Phil says too few couples understand what it means to be a "Mrs." His first guest, Grant, says his wife, Kelly, is in desperate need of "wife lessons" when it comes to her cooking, cleaning and the way she dresses. Kelly says trying to be the perfect wife while raising three kids is overwhelming, and she fears she'll never be good enough. See what happens when she puts her hubby to the "wife test." Will he be able to do it all? Then, Diana says a good wife must serve her man instead of trying to balance a career and a family. Plus, a woman who thinks "wife" is a four-letter word! Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 9:52 am PDT

Here I go again.

Quote From: whyterose1

 Looks like you have some issues within inside your self,

Do you go to your husbands work and help him during the day? I think not. If it wasn't for your husband you would be taking care of your kids and working because I'm sure you’re the type of woman that would keep your kids from you husband for the sole purpose of receiving child support. So maybe you should get off your butt and stop watching TV and surfing the NET all day.

  If you are such a caring and loving person you would be able to look past all of this and accept your position in life. Remember your the Mommy, NOT the Daddy. So put on a nice dress and cook some muffins for your kids and you husband, and have them ready for him the next time he walks in the door.

Deb's comment:

Bill Jinkins, in response to your narrow minded comment, as Iitalisized above, where does it mandate that looking after children is solely a mother's job? Perhaps you picked up this information from "101 Ways On How To Loose Your Wife And Children And End Up Dishing Out Tons Of Money For Spousal And Child Support” or “Fathering for Dummies.”

Since you are, at least I am assuming you are a sperm donor, you have the same amount of resposnsibilty to rear your children, as does your wife.  This is a fact all fathers should be aware of when they have SEX with a woman - they CAN become fathers. Wow - what a concept, sex can lead to parenthood. Who would have thought of that? And parenthood leads to “fatherly” responsibilities. Not just financial either but physical, emotional, social, psychological, etc. Amazing!!!! Of course if you don’t want to be a father, keep your pants on.

IF you are such "a caring and loving person you would” realize that a father's job does not begin and end with a paycheck. You need to "accept your position in life" as a father and help raise your children. "Remember you are the Daddy." So put on a smile when you come home from work and bring home muffins from your local bakery and some take-out for dinner  "and have them ready" for her when she opens the door. When dinner is over, you read to your children and tuck them in for the night. I know your wife would be appreciative with such a positive action.

I wonder, how do YOU define the role of a father?

Well, the roll of my father was to raise two girls in 1975 alone after our mother was killed in the car accident we were all involved in. 

His roll was to stop giving us a night night hug when we were 7 because people might think he was molesting us.  

This led us to grow up unaffectionate, giving or recieving. 

He taught us how to pitch a tent, to change a tire, how not to cry, how not to talk about anything that may upset someone, how not to ask for help, how to push people away.  

  

The one thing we needed him to teach us that NO dad is able to teach his daughters is how to be a well balanced wife and mother. 

As the tears well up in my eyes I am admitting for the first time that I am angry that my mother was taken from us, and no one stepped up to teach us any little things to take with us through life. 

DAMN YOU ! 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 9:57 am PDT

Why does it matter?

Everyone seems to be an extremist?  If a woman is happy being the stereotypical housewife and feels respected why criticize her?  If your the woman who is happy running in the bathroom to freshen up for your hubby, why not just do that without insisting every other woman do the same?  It is so arrogant to say that a woman can't have a career besides being a Mom. And there is no need to criticize a woman who chooses to stay home with her kids and keep house full time.  People make full time careers working as nannies and merry maids and no one is criticizing them, so why can't a woman make a full time career out of doing both with their own household?  Hey, how about we all choose the career path that makes us happy and let others do the same.  Now there's an idea...
 

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 9:57 am PDT

Good for you!

Quote From: gulfotagen

Hey ya'll I believe that a real man is a husband who takes care of his wife and honors her. Our society has become that way it is because of the power trip most women in our society are on. I believe that it is natural for a woman to be in the home. It is unnatural for her to care more about her career goals that her family. Yet this is how most American females are raised. A wife is a vital partner to her husband. Marriage is all about teamwork and her husband is suppose to be the head of the household. This means it is his responsiblity to worry about finances and other major life decisions. Ladies I have a Bachlors degree and could have a great job but I choose to honor my husband by staying at home. It's not because I am forced to but becasue I choose to. And eversince my marriage has been blessed.

I have worked in my profession for 19 years without taking any long breaks. It is natural for me to use my intellect and training as a lawyer to solve problems and smooth transactions for people.  I have never cared more about my career than my family.  My husband has never cared more about his career than his family.  We have both structured our workr to suit our family. 

  

I am a full partner and we make our decisions together.  We don't have a hierachy in our home. I'm not the "boss" nor is he. neither my husband or I have ever thought that he was supposed to be the head of the household.  We each use our gifts to the advantage of our family in the best way we can.  I really don't mind "worrying" about our major life decisions because I am an adult and it is my life too. 

  

Yet, in spite of all of this we have been very happily married for almost 22 years.  Our children are thriving and the school constantly praises their intelligence and their positve leadership role with their peers.   

  

Is it possible for you to could consider that the way you have succeeded (although right for you) is not the "way it is supposed to be" or "the natural way", but just one of the very many ways that families can succeed? 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:01 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: mkyourf8

I felt so sad and angry as I watched this show because it wasn't just about what makes a good wife, or what doesn't.  The bottom line is that Grant has broken Diana's spirit by making her feel worthless and not good enough day in and day out.  She sat on that stage and looked vacant the whole show and what broke my heart it that she seemed resigned to accept that this is her life! 

  

I wanted to grab her and hug her and tell her that she can do better.  I am not an advocate of divorce, but I am an advocate of happiness and this woman is NOT happy.  What is worse is that I believe you cannot truly be a good mom and rolemodel if you aren't a happy person.  I hope that with counseling they get real and do what is best for them and their kids.   

  

Bottom line is that life is too short to spend with someone that doesn't think you hung the moon.  If he doesn't feel that way, you can't change it, but you can pick yourself up by your bootstraps, call it a lesson and move on for the good of yourself and your children. 

  

My husband tells me every single day "Thanks for dinner Hun."  Last night I made macaroni and cheese and he still said it and meant it.  Please, please don't settle for an empty life.  Find your smile for yourself and your kids so that you can live the life you were meant to. 

Did you mean Kelly's spirit?  lol. 

  

I am Diana, and Grant didn't break anything of mine!!  :) 

  

Actually, Grant is a good guy,  just didn't express hinself fully. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:04 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: anothervio

Everyone seems to be an extremist?  If a woman is happy being the stereotypical housewife and feels respected why criticize her?  If your the woman who is happy running in the bathroom to freshen up for your hubby, why not just do that without insisting every other woman do the same?  It is so arrogant to say that a woman can't have a career besides being a Mom. And there is no need to criticize a woman who chooses to stay home with her kids and keep house full time.  People make full time careers working as nannies and merry maids and no one is criticizing them, so why can't a woman make a full time career out of doing both with their own household?  Hey, how about we all choose the career path that makes us happy and let others do the same.  Now there's an idea...

Because it's not about US.  It's about our kids. 

  

BTW, I don't run to the bathroom and freshen up everyday...and I don't push that on people.  The response I gave in the interview, (they only showed part of it - I guess for time constraints) was that hey, if that's what my husband wanted, then fine.  I want the mortgage paid, he wants to see me in makeup, then it's a fair trade.  He actually doesn't care, but he does like a good dinner! 

  

And he says thank you and he washed his own dish!  Last night, while I was on here, he played with the baby and put her to bed (which he actually does alot). 

  

  

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:08 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: leochic70

Actually I have helped my ass of a husband at work. I am from the city and married a grain farmer and have been thrown into a combine to get the crop off before it snows. My husband doesn't help me in the house or does he come to work with me. Yet he assumes more of the feminine roll in the house than I do. He overpowers his opinion of furnishings, decor, placement,etc. to the point where I have now interest after 15 years of marriage. He has taken the fun out of the wife roll for me.I truly think marriage should be on a lease basis. People are getting married for the wrong reasons these days and for those who married the wrong person for the right reasons, if they call it quits they are made to feel like one has to be the bad guy. A leased marriage would allow both involved to agree to the length and the possible renewal without being told they are bad people. I am 35 and just beginning to mourn the death of my mother 30 years ago. I have no feminine roll to follow. I seem to lack a feminine piece of my natural being that my husband wont allow me to develop. When Dr.Phil said Robin is his feminine side, I cried. I don't have a feminine side other than being able to have children which monkeys can also do. I have slept in bus shelters and my HUSBANDS house as he reminds me that it is. There isn't much difference between the the bus shack and this house right now for me. I am quite scattery with my thoughts right now I must apologize, I may have to post a message in every topic on this site once I figure out how to organize all my thoughts and experiences, and once my headache goes away. I have sat down in front of this site at least 100 times about to write something and my brain becomes overwhelmed with pain, lonliness, grief of losing my mother when I was 5, and a husband who doesn't have a clue who I am, and says I am the only one who needs help. He thinks he is fine. 

  

My husband works 8-11 hours a day out of the home.  He has a lunch break, sometimes there are slow times and sometimes there are busy times.  I work at home, sometimes I am just being present while out kids play, but I'm still on duty . They can't be left alone. Sometimes it's mad rush to get things done and some days I skip lunch and work through my "break".  When my husband gets home we both end first shift and start work on the second shift together. Maybe one of us will do dishes and one will take the kids on a walk. Or maybe I have a headache and I want a nap so he'll feed them while I rest.  Or maybe he had a really stressful day and he will just surf the net for a while and unwind. We're friends and partners, we don't keep score.  We don't bother discussing who needs to change what or who works more because frankly if we had time to that, there are too many other fun ways to spend the time. 

  

And WHAT may I ask is wrong with expecting great sex from your partner?  I do!!!  I thought that was one of the many perks to getting married?   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:11 am PDT

Not a typical view.

In response to all of the messages on this message board, and the episode on 10/10 Wifestyles... 

  

I need to state my point of view on this subject.  In order for there to be a particular "wifestyle", there needs to be that first initial decision to stay at home.  The old "How did this happen" idea.  I feel that this subject is just too broad and stereotyped in itself to be just one show. 

  

What perplexes me the most, is the overly used term... "housewife".  While watching this particular show, my mouth just hung open for it's entirety.  I know that Dr. Phil has a very clear and objective mind.  I just couldn't understand the bias that was envoked throughout.  There was a small part of the show that somewhat gave another point of view, of the single female that believes that becoming a wife was a lifestyle that is not meant for her.  I felt that it was good that Dr. Phil added this to the show... but, he refrained from talking about other points of view... as in one similar to my own.  At another point in the show, a female had talked about "when you make that decision to stay home..."  I almost sighed a relief, but no sooner was that part dropped. 

  

As a background for you to understand my viewpoint, I would like to explain to you my own particular situation.  I am a "Stay at Home" mother of three (soon to be 4) during the day, and an Afterschool Teacher at the school for grades 1-3 for three days a week/2 hours a day.  I have a Bachelor's degree in Elementary Education/Middle School Teaching with a minor in Social Studies emphasizing Sociology.  My husband is a High School Social Studies teacher and the Varsity Boy's Basketball Coach.   

  

When I married my husband (of 6+ years), I was still completing my college degree while he was already in a teaching position at his current employer.  We decided that we had wanted to start our own family after I finished college.  I became pregnant a month or so after we married, which was still a few years from graduating college.  I continued with college, and we had another child during the time it took to complete.  My husband and I had always talked about allowing him to stay at home with the kids while I took a teaching position.  Of course, I haven't been able to allow him to do this quite yet.  I enjoy being a part of our children's lives each day, and I don't mind the at home duties that go along with being the one who stays home.  I know one of these days I will have to surrender it to him.  (luckily, there aren't any readily available jobs in our area  :>)) 

  

This is where my own "Wifestyle" comes into play.  The mornings are rushed in our house, and with our eldest son, Camden, in kindergarten, I get up and make them lunches.  I do this because it is cheaper than hot lunch.  I then get Camden ready for school.  After my husband leaves for the day, I get the other kids ready, and pick up the house.  I get laundry done, and do anything else that might need to be done.  So by the time my husband gets home from school, I'm able to sit down and visit with him for a while.  We'll talk about our day, and play with the kids.  By then we both know if we had a hard day, and sometimes we'll just relax and read the paper.  My husband is an awful cook, although he makes a nice grilled cheese sandwich or PB&J sandwich when I don't feel like making anything.  I will sometimes do special things for him to surprise him, and he sometimes surprises me with foot rubs, etc.  I enjoy doing nice things for him and the children. 

  

I've just been lucky enough to have a husband that has the same belief system.  We have always agreed, and seen through our own students, the importance of a stay at home parent.  The stable foundation that these children get for at least their first five years of life cannot be compared to or regained later in life.   

  

I feel that it is a parent's duty to ensure that their children are equipped with morals, well-rounded personalities, and good attributes in order to survive in today's "society".  All of these are subject to the parent's own personal views and belief systems.  By choosing caregivers that share the same belief system, or by staying at home with your children, they will grow up with a more solid foundation.  I've just been fortunate to be able to stay at home, even though we do live paycheck to paycheck. 

  

Besides, there are other types of "Wifestyles", as in the working mom who does wonderful things for their husbands, or the feminist mom that has a husband that does most everything for her.... etc.  There are so many different ways you could flip this subject. 

  

In conclusion, the whole idea of a "Wifestyle" is not whole with just one episode.  I hope to see more of these shows with their counterparts.  I do understand that it is hard to include every view in the hour it takes to watch... I just hope that there could be a more open discussion.   

 

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:11 am PDT

I think you and Diane were talking about me

Quote From: mybabylex

I'm not sure who is "following" you...I was just reading this reply to the last persons quote......they said just because they chose to work they aren't putting their job first. If your financially able to stay home, but you chose to leave your kids with a sitter and go to work.....that to me IS putting your job first. Just remember Greed is one of the 7 deadly sins.
If it is your firm belief without knowing much about a person that if they are working then they are greedy and puts their career ahead of family, have either of you told your husband that he is greedy and not putting you and your children first?
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
quiet
October 12, 2005, 10:20 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles...

Just my point of view: 

  

What amazed me as much as anything is that the woman who *didn't* want to get married had the most realistic view of what marriage should be like.  Marriage is a state of inter-dependence.  Does this mean that you completely surrender your 'self'?  No, but that 'self' has to take into account the needs of the other. 

  

I found the woman giving out "stay at home advice" disturbing.  The plain truth is that each marriage is unique.  The level of interdependence necessary and the manner in which that is displayed needs to be worked out by the individuals involved.   

  

When I come home from work, I know there will be a hot meal that night - I know that because I cook it. 

  

My wife looks forward to my coming home, because my arrival means that she's off diaper duty. 

  

We each pull extra weight so that the other can have a couple hours each day to themselves.  It's not the easiest way to live; but it works for us, and I doubt that anyone can offer suggestions that would make our situation *that* much better. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 10:34 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: tadailey

I Think her name was Diane on the show saying something to the fact that you can't have a happy home life if the mom works outside the home. Let me tell her that I am a single mom for 9 years with very very little support that even the back child support is in the thousands of dollars and I work 40 hours or over and  my kids are not suffering at all. We have fun together, They play all kinds of sports, and yes they have chores. Don't tell me that the women has to stay home to have a successful  family - You can make it work what ever situation you are in. Maybe you just can't multi task as well as others.

I was like the lady who didn't want to marry until I met my husband, who is truly special, and married at the age of 28.  When we had children I stayed home until they started school/preschool.  I'm glad I could (for my own sake more than for the children's!  I loved the time with them.), but I know many mothers cannot do this.  When they went to school, I was fortunate to be able to go back to my career.  My husband has always "helped."  I now have two daughters-in-law.  One works outside the home.  The other stays at home, although she is taking some college classes online.  Both are fine mothers, and I'm so fortunate my sons had the good judgment to marry them.  I think it must be harder for the single mother who must work.  My son's job is closer to home, so he starts dinner before his working wife gets home.  I'm proud of the many ways he makes himself a partner.  A single mom has to do this herself.  It requires more effort, but I've seen it done successfully. 

My other son doesn't help as much, mainly because his wife is such a perfectionist that she gets things done before he gets home.  I tell her to begin to train him to help, because if she goes to work when the kids are in school she will want him to pitch in. 

In short, don't get married just to be married.  As a single mom, consider your children before you consider marriage.  If you marry, do what's best for you and your marriage and children.  God knows my heart (I'm a pastor's wife, in fact.) and He knows what I need and what I can do.  I know a number of single mothers who have managed to provide a happy home for their children and to be happy themselves.  Most of them do try to provide a masculine influence, maybe a grandfather or a good man who is willing to be involved, to show the children what to expect from a good man who cares for them.  There is no Biblical law about working or not working (See Proverbs 31). 

 
First | Prev | 94 | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | 99 | 100 | 101 | 102 | 103 | Next | Last