Message Boards

Topic : 12/28 Wifestyles

Number of Replies: 2316
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 07, 2005, 03:34:18 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 10/10/05) What makes a good wife? Is it cooking, cleaning, raising the kids and having great sex? Dr. Phil says too few couples understand what it means to be a "Mrs." His first guest, Grant, says his wife, Kelly, is in desperate need of "wife lessons" when it comes to her cooking, cleaning and the way she dresses. Kelly says trying to be the perfect wife while raising three kids is overwhelming, and she fears she'll never be good enough. See what happens when she puts her hubby to the "wife test." Will he be able to do it all? Then, Diana says a good wife must serve her man instead of trying to balance a career and a family. Plus, a woman who thinks "wife" is a four-letter word! Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:35 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: km7574

I read the things that everyone was saying and I must say it has added to the growing sadness in my life.  I feel trapped and alone in my marriage.  I have no one to talk to about this so I hope that someone could add something to help me out.  My husband works full time (midnight shift) then attends college full time (finishing a degree he started 10 years ago).  Three months ago I gave birth to a wonderful baby boy that is the light of my life.  My husband does NOTHING to help me.  He never has.  He kept making excuses.  First it was my job to take care of him, the house, the land, the dogs and the bills because I was a college student and had nothing else to worry about.  Then he couldn't help once I got a job because I worked part time.  Then when I got a full time job he said that he made more money so I could make up for the difference by taking care of everything.  Now I am a housewife.  Now it is my job to do everything.  He has no idea what I do all day.  The house is never clean enough for him.  I do the best I can considering he is a slob.  Plus, since he works nights, he sleeps most of the day.  I have to be as quiet as a mouse and keep the baby quiet so he can sleep.  I am at his beck and call in bed.  I have to put the baby down and have sex whenever he sees fit.  I feel dead inside.  I haven't been kissed in a year.  He never says I love you or even hugs me.  I feel like a servant.  If I wouldn't have had my son I probably would have left him but I am afraid to.  My husband isn't the nicest man ever.  Does anyone know what I can do?  I really do try to have all my chores done.  Is there a way I can reorganize myself?  I guess I am just fooling myself.  If I bust my butt to get everything done and perfect (which we all know it never will be) it will not cause him to love me.  Love, compassion, understanding.  These words are a mystery to my husband.  Will I ever be happy?

(((BigHugs))) for you. Your post brought tears to my eyes. The reason why is because about six months ago I could have written your post. First I was a SAHM to our two boys. So, EVERYTHING was my responsibility, he wouldn't even help with the kids by just playing with them after work. He'd put them in front of the TV and he'd sleep or play on the computer. Nothing was done right and there was only ONE right way to do it. I didn't do the laundry right , I didn't do the grocery shopping right, I didn't pay the bills the right way. Then,  I started back to school. I was in school full-time and he said I didn't get paid for it, it didn't benefit our home so everything was still my responsibility. He said that all I did was sit on my butt in class all day so there was no reason I couldn't handle everything else. Then, I got pregnant with our third. We knew we would need more money, so I got a job. Before this anytime I said we needed something his response was, "Get a job!". So, I got a part-time job and was still a full-time student. I was also very sick with this pregnancy all day and all night long. Well, my job wasn't good enough. I was a part-time bank teller, but, that didn't qualify as a 'real' job so, the house and kids were STILL my complete responsibility! I was so sick that in the evenings all I could do was just feed the kids and lie down b/c I was vomitting 10-20 times a day and had been hospitalized several times. Once, I had just come from the bathroom from once again puking my guts out...well, mostly just dry heaves b/c there was nothing to come up. I sat down on the couch trying to recollect myself. The house was a bit messy and dinner hadn't been made. This idiot had the nerve to say to me, "You know, the kids deserve to live in a tidy home."  

  

Well, to avoid making this reply longer than it already is, my husband is now my soon-to-be-ex-husband. Back in March when I was still pregnant and very sick, I packed up my children and went to a women's shelter. No, my idiot husband wasn't hitting me, but, my therapist helped me realize that what he was doing was emotional abuse and was just as bad, if not worse than physical abuse. Your husband is abusing you just as mine was. Oh, and the sex-on-demand is sexual abuse, my ex did the same thing. If I wouldn't have sex with him he'd hold me down and masturbate. I too felt like a servent or a possession and was tired of it. I just couldn't do it anymore. I finally realized that I deserved so much better. What's even more important is I realized what it was doing to my children. If things stayed the way they were my boys would have grown up to believe that women were merely servents put on this earth to please the men in their lives. Either that or they would have allowed other people to treat them as their father treated me. Do you want this for your son? 

  

Now, if you are determined to stay with him and try to make yourself perfect for him, you are setting yourself up for a huge failure and disappointment. This is not about you. It's about him. You ARE a good wife and mother, his attitude has nothing to do with your abilities. Now, to keep your own sanity there is a great system I use to keep myself together. I'm taking care of three boys under the age of four, I'm working and going to school. Have you heard of Flylady? Check out www.flylady.com. Its a wonderful home organization system that will help you. However, even if the house is perfect, the food is perfect, everything is perfect, don't expect your husband to suddenly start treating you like a human being.  

  

Sweeite, this man is mistreating you. He is abusing you. You deserve so much better and so does your son! Your son needs a happy mom, not one who feels pushed down and stepped on. Do you want your son to think that this is what a marriage is? A co-worker was in a similar situation. She finally left when her 8-year-old daughter said that she didn't want to have any babies b/c then she'd have a husband who made her sad and she would never have any fun again.  

  

My heart truly aches for you because I've been there. Right now I am tired, I am stressed, I don't know how I'm going to pay the rent and my car is falling apart. But, I'm happy, I'm finally happy and I finally like myself again and realize that I have worth and I am a good mother and a hard-working person! That alone is worth all the stress and work.  

  

If you EVER need to talk, vent, cry, or you need advice on something PLEASE feel free to email me at: momluvspunx@hotmail.com  I would love to hear from you and would love to help you in any way that I can. 

 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:36 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

I wanted to add one thing (or three) LOL  Since I was so used to doing things on my own - my h would tell me All you have to do is ask?  I say I shouldn't have to ask, but he doens't know what I am doing, and how many things I would like to accomplish before I go to bed, so yes I will ask if I need help.   

  

The other thing is do we really know that our h expects things from us, or do we just do them.  My b said to me the other day, I don't care if the house is clean.  It is me who likes the house clean not him.  I have stopped stressing about the house and realized it is not that important.  A lot of the things I do around the house or to myself I do it for me, not for him.  Maybe alot of you think you are doing them for your h's, I know in the back of my mind I used to think I was doing them for h, but I am realizing he doesn't care if the dishes aren't done, it is me who cares.  Never once has he said this house is  a mess.  I am not reallly too sure what I am trying to say here, I guess I am trying to say stop stressing yourself and stop trying to do everything because maybe those things don't matter to your husband.  Do they really notice the crumbs on the kitchen floor? 

 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
happy
October 10, 2005, 8:38 am PDT

I look up to Diana

I really enjoyed the show today. After I watched it I told my husband that what I heard on the show today made me realize that I need to look at my role in our marriage differently. 

I think that Diana is one Dr.Phil most intelligent guest. She spoke clearly and passionately about how she feels about her "career".  I also feel she wasn't portrayed fairly. She made excellent points about being a housewife. It is a job and it is a difficult job. Why not give it your all. When my husband goes to work at the office all day, he doesn't just do what has to be done to get by. He doesn't go to work in his PJ's. He gives it his all in a professional manner. What makes it wrong for Diana to give it her all and to take pride in what she does. This is what really caught my attention, and helped me in my daily struggles as a housewife. I need to start looking at my role as a career choice that should be taken seriously. I would give my 100% outside the home and I need to start doing that here. It is hard for me to put into words how Diana made me feel. But I know I want to start being more like her. She also made me feel like I do not need my husband to validate the job I do. I can validate myself. My job is an important part of my marriage. Marriage is a partnership. My husband does his part by providing for and protecting us. He is a father, a friend, a husband and a lover. He does all these things so well. Why should he get any less from me. 

I would really love if I could email Diana and ask her for some advice on what to do so that I can be as successful at what I do as she is. And I am proud to share the same job title as her, "housewife"! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
October 10, 2005, 8:38 am PDT

I disagree

Quote From: watacutie

                         I am a full time mom, I have been married for 16 years, I have 3 kids and my husband is in the US army. we travel alot and he is gone alot. so most of the time its just me and the kids, but when he  is here he works from 5:30am until 5:00 pm and some time later. I clean and get everything ready for him to come home, dinner is usually  cooking when he gets home except soccer night, which all 3 of my kids play. I home school all 3 of my kids, I have no one who can help me, since we are stationed in germany, and our families are all in the state. I feel being a full time mom is hard but very rewarding. I see alot of wives here who are in the milatary who never have time with their kids because of their careers, I see moms who cant stand being home all day with their kids so they go get a job and have no idea what their childs been up to all day. 

                      I am very thankful for having a husband who lets me stay home to raise our kids, and I love it when he has a day off and I can spend a day with him , without worrying about having to go to work, and not getting to see him. The days I dont get everything done  he comes home and helps. He goes out and makes the money, I get to spend it!!!!   Im not saying women shouldn't have a job, but I am saying you cant give  a 100% to your family and a 100% to your career, and still have time for yourself. Even as a full time mom its hard to find me time. my husband takes me out every saturday night he is here, to get me out for  awhile. 

                      We have a very close family, my husband and I work at this family together.  Being a house wife is hard but so isnt the infantry. so we both keep the home fires burning, in two differnt ways. 

I disagree with you statement that you cannot give 100% to your family and to your career...I think that is a bold statement to make when in truth I beleive this is not true for everyone...it may be true for you but you shouldn't make the generalization that it applies to all...I give 100% to my children, my husband and my job...I look at it this way...my job is just that  A JOB...when I am there I give my all...then when the day is over I pick up my daughter and son from their grandmothers and we discuss their day...and then we go home and look over her activities that she did that day (my mother has a preschool type setting for her in the morning) and we look at her homework ( a paper my mother has prepared so that we can do an activity together before dinner or bedtime so she feels like a big girl)...we then feed the baby his dinner and get our dinner started so it is ready when daddy gets home...my other son then gets off the bus and we go over what he has done for the day...we review his lessons he has brought home and I help with any homework(if he needs it) and then we all listen as he practices his guitar...I am involved in every aspect of my childrens lives...I am there for evey gymnastics practice and every guitar lesson and know all about my sons afterschool activities (per mediation and choir)...short of going to school with him I don't think I could be much more involved...the children then attack daddy when he gets home and we all eat dinner and then is play time and bath time and story time and the kids are in bed by 7:00 silently reading to themselves until 7:30 then lights out...it is all very peaceful after that and my husband and I get a few hours of quality time together...I couldn't ask for more..I think it is all a matter of WHAT WORKS FOR YOU AND YOUR FAMILY  and between you and your husband...I don't think there is a right or a wrong...
 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:39 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: gunforhire

I have no idea what makes a good wife.  I am married but I don't have what I consider a wife, I have my best friend.  She is a stay at home mom, and runs our property.  When I say she runs my property, I mean she RUNS it.  She cooks, cleans, handles the finances, teaches our sun, tutors our daughter, mows the grass, runs a chainsaw, and any other power tool she wants, and does it all without whining and complaining.  She and I don't make demands on each other, nor do we have defined "house chores".  I work 3rd shift and come home @ 8am.  I am dog tired but if she were to ask me to do the dishes, vacuum, or any other "chore" I do it.  Why?  Because she ASKED.  She didn't cry, whine, complain or demand, she simply asks.  If I ask her to bring me a glass of tea, take off my boots, etc. she does because I ASK.  We learned that asking gets more done than rules, chores, or demands.  She wanted to learn to use a skill saw, I taught her.  Then I got out of the way as she remodeled our dining room.  Funny thing is she is shy and quiet.  No one suspects her to be so strong.  I they expect to be the big "manly man" since I am 6'3" and 210lbs.  I also am an 8 year Army Vet at 32.  I was used to giving orders and having them followed but that stops when I got home.  Without yelling, screaming, or divorcing me she gently and subtly helped me realize I only had to ask.  I believe that if other couples picked up on this concept that married life would be more heaven and less hell
I believe you are right, everyone needs to ASK!  If you don't ask how do we know what others need or want.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:41 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: plscows

I LOVE MY HUSBAND AND WOULD DO ANYTHING FOR HIM, BUT-- I'M NOT GOING TO CHANGE MY SHIRT, PUT ON MAKEUP JUST CAUSE HE'S ON HIS WAY HOME FROM A LONG AT WORK, I'VE BEEN WORKING,TOO. THIS WOMAN IS IN A DREAM WORLD, SHE SOUNDS LIKE SHE'S BOWING DOWN TO HIM, DOES HE REALLY DESERVE THAT MUCH ATTENTION. WHAT DOES HE DO FOR HER, IN THAT RESPECT. THAT CRAP WOULDN'T FLY AT THIS HOUSE.

Too funny.  I don't bow down to my husband, I respect him, and he respects me.  If you had your day organized, you would have plenty of time to change your shirt or whatever to show your husband when he gets home that you're till his wife.  But you keep up the old "that crap wouldn't fly", and the next time you want him to pay the mortgage or the electricity remember that maybe he deserves something in return. 

  

BTW, the whole make up thing was just to prove a point, that if your husband works hard all day then why not do something for him.  Yes, I work hard all day but I clearly have more down time than he does.  it's a give and take, you want the mortgage paid, he wants to see you in makeup....fair trade?  If you have your own self-esteem, it would not be an issue at all. 


Diana 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
October 10, 2005, 8:46 am PDT

BRAVO!

Quote From: gunforhire

I have no idea what makes a good wife.  I am married but I don't have what I consider a wife, I have my best friend.  She is a stay at home mom, and runs our property.  When I say she runs my property, I mean she RUNS it.  She cooks, cleans, handles the finances, teaches our sun, tutors our daughter, mows the grass, runs a chainsaw, and any other power tool she wants, and does it all without whining and complaining.  She and I don't make demands on each other, nor do we have defined "house chores".  I work 3rd shift and come home @ 8am.  I am dog tired but if she were to ask me to do the dishes, vacuum, or any other "chore" I do it.  Why?  Because she ASKED.  She didn't cry, whine, complain or demand, she simply asks.  If I ask her to bring me a glass of tea, take off my boots, etc. she does because I ASK.  We learned that asking gets more done than rules, chores, or demands.  She wanted to learn to use a skill saw, I taught her.  Then I got out of the way as she remodeled our dining room.  Funny thing is she is shy and quiet.  No one suspects her to be so strong.  I they expect to be the big "manly man" since I am 6'3" and 210lbs.  I also am an 8 year Army Vet at 32.  I was used to giving orders and having them followed but that stops when I got home.  Without yelling, screaming, or divorcing me she gently and subtly helped me realize I only had to ask.  I believe that if other couples picked up on this concept that married life would be more heaven and less hell

BRAVO!!!  What a wonderful man you are! My husband is like you but so many of my friends whine and moan everyday about how lazy and useless their husbands are and I count myself lucky that my husband and I have a loving and respectful relationship...not to say we don't have our moments...we ask don't demand and we give kisses and I love you's every morning and night (and a lot in between)...I don't think we would make it if not for each other...like you stated he is my best friend... 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:53 am PDT

10/10 Wifestyles

Quote From: striple

That being a 'good wife' or a 'good husband' is something that one is supposed to learn watching their parents.  So what about those of us who grew up without their real father, and alcoholic step-father, and a mother, who had the best intentions, but didn't set a wonderful example?  I am almost 29 and have been married six years now.  I have two beautiful children and one on the way.  I grew up learning how to be selfish, controlling, and manipulative.  I made a choice (very bad one) at the age of 19 that drastically reinforced those charactertraits.  I have had one example in my life of what a 'good wife' is, but it was fleeting.  I am currently saving up the money to get Relationship Rescue for my husband and I for Christmas.   And when I saw the preview to the show that this topic was started for, I thought, "Finally!"  While it is great that y'all have loving husbands, and seem to have a good grasp on who a 'good wife' is supposed to be, what she is supposed to do, and all of that, some of us don't.  You would be surprised how many women out there don't know.    And to start the first post in this topic with : 
good grief! who came up with this subject?!!
seems really judgemental to me.   I'm not trying to start an arguement or anything, that was just my first reaction to that question.  I understand that  you probably were not intdening it that  way.  But I am definately coming back here in hopes that those of us who don't know, or aren't sure, about being a good wife can come together and talk to other women, like yourself, who do.  We can talk to each other and learn from each other. 
I couldn't agree with you more. I grew up in a VERY disfunctional home and I had no idea what a good wife/mother was or what a good marriage was. I thought my abusive ex-husband was normal, that it's just the way things were in marriage. Thank goodness for a great therpaist who let me know what the real world is like, otherwise, I'd still be with that moron and he'd probably be teaching my sons that this is how you treat a woman, as a servent.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:55 am PDT

It is a working family NOT WIFE>

The word is marriage.  I am a full time working mother.  I have been in a very bad marriage.  Where nothing was equal.  I was expected to be a full time mother.  Clean the house head to toe. Everything had to be in a specific spot and place. The house was to be a museum and it was not to be lived in. It was a cold atmosphere.  He was abusive and controlling.  I am now remarried and have a wonderful husband.  But due to expenses of the last marriage I do have to work full time.  

  

 

What I know about a good marriage is that it is compromise on both parts.  We have to be there for each other.  You always have to have I love you and I care about you.  You have to look at each other with love and not spite.  You have to know each other weaknesses and embrace them and not use them against each other. We both have a job.  We both work full time.  But at the same time we BOTH are full time parents (of a combined family of past marriages).  This means that he can not come home and just sit down.  I can not come home and just sit down.  Because as a working mother I can not do it all on my own. And we work together.  We do not put each other down.  We do the chores together.  And in front of the children all we do is show support for each other. 

  

 

But there are times when I am out of work.  And during that time my full time job is at home.  I put in the time in cleaning, and having dinner on the table. You never get away from the eight hour job.  If it might be at an office or at home. Then the full time parent job is both of ours together and we have time with family and each other.  We always make time for each other.  A hug when we see each other.  We never fight in front of the children.  We always make up and work everything out.  I have times I am so exhausted and so is he.  Things just don’t get done.  But we do not put each other down for it.  The key is understanding.  He never comes home from work, eating dinner and ignoring me.  The work of the family is still going and we sit down and rest together.  I did my eight hour job at the house; he did his eight hour job at the office. Then comes the time of our job of   FAMILY…. 

  

 

I have seen so many mothers that stay at home and don’t do anything.  They just get up and expect everything to do all on its own.  And leave the husband to put in the hours at work. When the husband gets upset they just don’t understand.  He just sits at a desk doing nothing I just don’t get it.  I will tell you what.  I have done that job at the desk and it can be just as draining as a physical job. 

  

 

Then I have been and have seen women that have killed themselves doing it all.  While the husband just sits on his tail. All he does is complain.   

  

 

I am marriage with children, which means a full time job.  It may be at work on a job or at home.  But if I had the choice I would be at home cleaning and having the dinner on the table every night.  And letting him just work on the job.  The children suffer when you have to do both.  They need the stability.  The job of staying at home is not easy.  Despite what many men may think.  Working a full time job and raising children is even harder.  When you are married and have a good husband and he works with you it is so wonderful.  When I am tired, he worries about me.  When he is tired, I worry about him.  We take the load to help the other person.   There is always praise.  Or it would not work.  I have been in a marriage where I was put down all the time and almost killed.  And now I have someone that all he does is treat me and my children with full respect and love.  That is what a marriage is in my oppinion.   

 

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 8:56 am PDT

Awesome!!!

Quote From: vafriend

Just be a good person. Have self respect because it will show in your relationships. Listen more than Talk.  A mistake is not a mistake when it's corrected. Be truthful, be honest. Don't be self bostful. Give compliments. Don't always be right-but don't always be wrong either. Communicate from the heart. Always use "good words" with your "inside tone". take TIME OUT. Love unconditionally.  I have been in a growing marriage for 32 years. WE are growing at seperate rates . we hold hands-sometimes being pulled along and somethimes pulling- most often side-by-side. We have made alot of lemonaid from the lemons in our foot path. Don't dwell on the sour times, just add some "sugar" or "honey". We educate each other.  The more you know about someone the more you grown closer.  After 32 years, i am still being educated....and I do still take Time outs...for understanding and growth. 

Thank you!!  Your words are so true .  Life is a balance and we must each find our own!!!
 
First | Prev | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | Next | Last